This topic is similar to religion in that most people are in capable of discussing it without getting emotional and illogical.
Man do I get sick of people preaching to others. 99% of you are Hippocrates!
If you didn't get your training through the military, you participated in PFT! Why is it ok for you to pay for all your initial training but if someone takes it a step further they are evil and to blame for the woes of the industry? Oh, I forgot, you drew the line there and anyone who pays for any more training that you did (ie a type or extra time building) should be crucified for destroying the industry. Why didn't you halt your training at the beginning and hold out for an airline to sponsor you and thus raise the bar. What's that? That wouldn't have worked out for you and your situation cause the industry at the time wasn't paying for ab initio training? Bingo. The only way for you to get that first job was to anty up and pay thousands of dollars for that initial training. But if someone else feels they want to pay for something more, somehow that is not ok.
What if a pilot feels he needs to pay for a type, or time, to get that job he needs? Oh, that is soooo wrong.
Can you see the double rules here? I'm sure some of you will reply with why YOUR situation was different. Baloney! You did what you had to do, so don't condemn someone else for doing what they need to do!
Furthermore...
If you work for a regional, you participated in lowering the bar! Get off your high horse. Why was it ok for you to work for 19K per year? Oh, that's right, 19K per year is ok because that is where you drew the line, but if someone undercuts some guy by charging 100 below market rate suddenly they are the devil and are to blame for the industry woes. Why is it ok for you and not for them? Oh I forgot, all of you are GV captains making 300K per year and working 10 days a month.
I understand the sentiment of the majority on this board. No one sets out to systematically reduce the pay and quality of life that a pilot career entails. But we live in a free market society. Your unions artificially alter this. In a non union world (hell lately even in a union world) pilots have to fend for themselves a career. You do what you need to do. That is the world we live in.
My career is mine. Not yours. It would be great if everyone could band together in some communal industry push to raise the bar but by and large THAT IS NOT HOW THE WORLD WORKS. (sorry for the caps but I don't know how to italicize).
Teachers, Policeman, and Firefighters should be paid more. Sports starts a heck of a lot less. PeaceCorps volunteers should be set for life.
But pull that blank-ee off yourself. Here is a little secret for you..
You are not paid by the intrinsic value of what you do.
Here it is one more time...
You are not paid by how much you SHOULD earn. You are paid by how much the market will allow (be that a completely free market or one that is manipulated via unions).
And before someone asks, I am not a gulfstream, free right seater, nor have I paid for a type (although if I thought it made financial sense I would!)
I paid for my basic ratings with a loan, flew skydivers for 3 years, single pilot freight for a year, KA350 PIC for a year, and now do overseas contract work.
There is nothing in my past that I would need to defend to most of you, but I don't get on my high horse if someone decides what is best for his/her and their family is to buy a type, time build, or sit right seat for free in a CJ1.
Also, for the record, I am completely pro union, against PFT (even paying for our own basic ratings) and all for raising salary and qol. But I can admit that unless EVERYONE in the industry will stand behind me, sometimes you got to do what you got to do, or you wont have job/career/food/roof over your head. You can't make a stand by yourself...thus unionization. But the beginning part of your carrier is unionless...so you work with the rules the market makes.
It's just that I, unlike most, am willing to publicly admit that I'm not willing to quit this career to make a point that will not change anything unless everyone does the same. You do what you have to do (be that paying for your basic ratings, working for 25K per year, paying for a 737 type, or slinging gear for free) and if you are honest you have done and will continue to do the same.
Some of you see your salary, qol, etc as some god given right. Its called business. If you treat your career as one, you might be more successful. Of course, you already do treat yours like one. That is why you rationalized paying for your initial ratings, taking the crappy regional job, or paying some other form of dues. The real truth is that now that you are past the point that you look down on, somehow you feel empowered to lecture up and coming pilots on why their similar choices should not be made. As though they are somehow able to overpower the rules of the way the industry works.
Dont' judge others lest you be judged!