A co-worker went on vacation with his family to GPT via MSY via WN, this week, he's a student pilot. He called me the following day and very excitedly told me all about the flight. He said that he had a lil' chat with the pilots at the gate about their speed on approach and the very hard landing in MSY. He told me that they had some very nasty weather coming into MSY.
I was like... at 40 hr. a pre-solo student pilot lectured two ATP rated pilots about their landing? I told him you didn't even know what was going on up there. He then informed me that he was listening to live ATC the entire flight from PHX. He said and I quote:
"This student pilot paid $1600.00 and had my two kids on the flight, that approach was unsafe. Brian (his kid) was scared and shaking and crying."
Reading your post to
@Cherokee_Cruiser made me think of that laughable conversation.