Azerbaijan Airlines Crash

@MikeD
"The vast majority of successful Surface-to-Air Missile (SAM) hits are achieved using a proximity fuse because it significantly increases the kill probability by detonating the warhead near the target, even if it doesn't directly impact it, making it highly effective against fast-moving aircraft and other elusive targets"

Oh most definitely. As one who has had MANPADs shot at me, I can well appreciate prox fuzing, or in my cases, the lack of effective ones on the early models. The prox is mainly for a maneuvering target, so the SAM can get an effective kill if it’s in danger of being outmaneuvered by its target. For a big non-maneuvering target, the prox would still fuse, but usually as the missile is or shortly about, to skewer the target like a shish kabob. Just interesting the non maneuvering airliner wasn’t skewered. Or maybe it was. Hasn’t been completely clear in reporting.

SA-22 then. Yeah, the double digit SAM club, a club that is difficult to avoid if you’re a fighter, much less a transport. SA-17 for MH17, ironically. These systems, from the SA-10 upward, were systems we would have a very difficult time evading. Multiple leaves of SAM avoidance maneuvering, if you even get that chance, will likely be ineffective on these systems once they are airborne. Defeating them pre-launch, whether electronically or kinetically, is about the only chance of not getting tagged by them.
 
I'm not sure why two users who do nothing but incite arguments and parrot narratives that are harmful to western society continue to be permitted to post on this site. It's truly embarrassing the things they say.

Just take the garbage out. You banned me for much less :)

Agreed.

Here we have a thread about an airliner shot down by Russia. Instead of talking about the crew and the lives they saved, this thread spiraled into a clown show by two Putin/Trump bootlickers and probably needs to be flushed to the lav.
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure why two users who do nothing but incite arguments and parrot narratives that are harmful to western society continue to be permitted to post on this site. It's truly embarrassing the things they say.

Just take the garbage out. You banned me for much less :)
I think the ayes have it. The ayes have it.
 
I'm not sure why two users who do nothing but incite arguments and parrot narratives that are harmful to western society continue to be permitted to post on this site. It's truly embarrassing the things they say.

Just take the garbage out. You banned me for much less :)

I did, didn’t I? :)
 
Happens all the time.
I'm not sure why two users who do nothing but incite arguments and parrot narratives that are harmful to western society continue to be permitted to post on this site. It's truly embarrassing the things they say.

Just take the garbage out. You banned me for much less :)

Agreed.
Happens all the time.

Here we have a thread about an airliner shot down by Russia. Instead of talking about the crew and the lives they saved, this thread spiraled into a clown show by two Putin/Trump bootlickers and probably needs to be flushed to the lav.

Yup. They’re ruining every thread.
I made some adjustments to user permissions in this thread. Let me know how it goes.
 
I made some adjustments to user permissions in this thread. Let me know how it goes.
1735340559792.jpeg
 
Judging by the pictures I've seen, the damage was mostly on the empennage.

If this happened the way it looks like it happened the flight crew are absolute heroes.

One could argue that being refused an emergency landing clearance should have been followed by “I’m sorry, you’re breaking up” but I’ve thought about this kind of situation a lot since learning about United 232, if I’m going to try to land a plane with major flight control issues, I’d like to spend some time figuring out the new characteristics before purposefully taking it anywhere near the ground.

It’s incredible that anyone survived.
 
Back
Top