While I agree in principle, does facing a significant pay cut from an already low-paying job not worry you? While everybody talks about being top heavy, the reality is that f/o's are going to get blasted on this. Captains getting capped at year 12 pay might be the difference to wait one more year to buy the wife a new car or Maybe telling their high schooler to fill out more scholarship applications. An f/o capped at year 4 pay with no iai, no upgrade sight, and barely anything in his 401k has more lose financially. And perhaps that's why it seems that we actually stand to lose LESS if a comair scenario were to unfold. As is pointed out in very thread, an f/o can replace his salary by working at home depot or the cell phone store. .
If I was running place, mind you, I'd do the same thing management is currently doing. I've run some businesses-I get it. The bottom line is the bottom line. Consumers don't care if the plane which says "American eagle" on the side isn't actually American eagle. They only care about the ticket being $5 cheaper than the next guy's.
A yes vote here accomplishes little. AAG puts its regional feed in a cost box lower than where currently sits. F/o's voting yes are ensuring their own financial pain for years to come. Anybody voting yes also agrees to accept what I see as a dangerous
Precedent. What's to stop them from coming back in another 12 months and saying "sorry, eagle. You're still too expensive. We're giving the jets to rah?" AMR and AAG have already proven to have no problem lying straight to our collective face. Or, heaven forbid 9/11 reoccurs or fuel goes to $150 and your savings account is nil? Accepting a pay cut and hoping you'll be gone before you max out is a risky bet. Are willing to risk your kid's college fund on it?
I should add that I fully believe management's threat to shut us down.
Shut the place down - my first stop will be Orange. Would I rather fly? Of course. But there comes a point when you have to weigh the damage you're doing to your brain, body, and family against the meager income you bring in and decide it's worth it.