Legal ramifications of majors not hiring "connection" carrier pilots

I worked at AWAC in that time frame. I made around $35k IIRC second year. I'm sorry, that is not "OK" wages. That is piss poor wages. By comparison to my CFI days, I was better, and the job was better, but by no means was it an "OK" wage.

The entire regional industry is underpaid, by a significant margin. If ALPA really gave a shat, they would put all resources available to stop the continued outsourcing of scope, which is what drove that segment. Yes it's happening now, sort of, but only because of fuel prices and economies of scale making the 50 seaters not really needed by management. Management is voluntarily cutting 50 seat aircraft now that carriers have combined.

When United pilots got their ridiculous raises in 2000, they gave away an unlimited number of RJs in exchange. That is a failure from the ALPA leadership for allowing that to happen. ALPA could give two shats about the commuters.

ALPA is needed by the commuter guys because they can't fund their own stuff but it's the best of the worst options, kinda like your executioner asking if you want your head to be cut off or suffocated.
Scope was voted on or given away in bankruptcy, it has nothing to do with ALPA. Each airline pilot group made a choice that they saw benefitted them best, didn't matter if they were ALPA, SWAPA, APA or USAPA. If certain union members pushed it, it was because of a decision they made individually. You do realize that no matter how much ALPA national pushes to stop scope relaxation that if the majority of a mainline carrier votes yes then it's a done deal? How can ALPA persuade each member to vote a certain way without a possible illegal work action? I'm done now.
 
ALPA has no control over the "supply" it's up to each individual person to decide if they want to be a pilot and apply to the airlines, which starting out is the regionals. Once again when costs are fixed like they are at the regionals (contractors) there's not a whole lot a union can do to increase wages when the money isn't there. Just look at Republic, they are saying they already can't afford their new contract and expect Delta and United to pay them more. I suspect you're gonna see some contracts get canceled.
Then why even create programs such as "Cleared to Dream"?
 
Then why even create programs such as "Cleared to Dream"?
Because enough regional airlines have done polls in the last year wondering what is most important to their pilots and "career progression" has always came up as #1 and they benefit their mainline partners. Everyone's goal lately is get to a mainline carrier ASAP and obviously ALPA listened and helped secure some form of progression.
 
Last edited:
Most of the folks at XJT I knew were making $40,000 there second year. Same was true for ASA. Should it be more? Yes. But it isn't poverty wages.

So, your example of choice is a company that has been deemed too expensive and is slated for being shuttered in two years with the loss of some 3,000 jobs? Wow.

I can't speak for 'Merican but United and Delta's Scope Choke is working. Fuel prices have little to do with it as fuel closed below $40.00 a barrel yesterday. You are reaching for facts that aren't there.

Are the majors reducing their 70 seaters? No they are adding them in fact.

Why the reduction in 50 seaters? Back when fuel prices were high, it was because of that. Now, with the doubling up of feed, the majors are transitioning from 50 seaters to 70 seaters and reducing frequency. My own company is an example of that. 14 flights a day between two carriers on 50 seaters became seven flights on 70 seaters. This is happening across the board. Absent union bargaining, this would've happened regardless, yet you think ALPA deserves the credit.

That is characteristically false. I got all the resources I needed as Colgan MEC Chair.

Has nothing to do with the topic at hand.
 
Scope was voted on or given away in bankruptcy, it has nothing to do with ALPA. Each airline pilot group made a choice that they saw benefitted them best, didn't matter if they were ALPA, SWAPA, APA or USAPA. If certain union members pushed it, it was because of a decision they made individually. You do realize that no matter how much ALPA national pushes to stop scope relaxation that if the majority of a mainline carrier votes yes then it's a done deal? How can ALPA persuade each member to vote a certain way without a possible illegal work action? I'm done now.
Some scope was. The toe was under the tent by that point. See UAL contract 2000.

Yes, each pilot group made the decision themselves to benefit themselves. Piss poor excuse for a union, IMO.
 
Yes, each pilot group made the decision themselves to benefit themselves. Piss poor excuse for a union, IMO.
Show me a union that has control over all their members. If someone wants to do something they will do it unfortunately. Remember the old saying that everyone will tell you they voted "no" yet something still passes?
 
Show me a union that has control over all their members. If someone wants to do something they will do it unfortunately. Remember the old saying that everyone will tell you they voted "no" yet something still passes?
I think the more important point you're not mentioning is ALPA is not a union. It's an association. The union is the one on property at each carrier. ALPA can't make policy that can be adhered to on a large scale because they don't really have any power. It's an illusion.

ALPA allows a bunch of small(er) unions to pool resources. That is the benefit of it.
 
Yes.





There are plenty that are lifers at ARW, XJT, Envoy, ASA, even TSA. As stated, making $75,000 - $80,000 is ok for a lot of folks. However, these lifers can only blame themselves if/when the business model of their carrier catches up to them.

And, most of the "lifers" at ASA are making over 100k. The instructors routinely are in the $150,000 to $200,000 range. The line check airmen aren't far behind if they "work it." There are plenty of people that make a decent career at some of the regionals. It's all about personal choices, and priorities. Until the merger with XJT, I was well on my way to a career at ASA. I'm very happy that I didn't stay, but the ASA of 2005 is far different from the ASA/XJT of today. Back then, there were pure lines, and the trips were much better. (A pure line was a line that has the exact same pairing 4 weeks in a row.)

Anyway, my point is that there are plenty of non-aviation careers that never come close to $100,000, and it is important to remember that some people are quite happy flying their regional jet and going home in base. That's a perfectly valid choice. It may bite them, it may not. Hell my airline could merge with SWA next week and I'll be singing the blues...you just never know.
 
I think that's a huge cop out.

  • For one, it's obvious that not everyone can get a job at a major. There just aren't enough seats.
  • For two, it's completely missing the point. If a guy can fly a Delta/United/American passenger from Podunk-ville to XYZ Hub, and from XYZ Hub to Podunk-ville, but isn't "qualified" to fly him from XYZ Hub to "slightly less Po-dunk"-ville, that is a serious problem with the how airlines are legally on the hook for overseeing their subcontractors.
  • For Three, making the major carriers legally responsible for the actions of their subcontractors especially in regards to who is actually operating the equipment, might mean the gutting of the regional ranks altogether and placing the vast majority of those RJs on property at said property. It also might possibly further increase the pilot supply problem at that level, making returning flying to the major level even more obtainable. This is a huge win for guys already on property at that major. There would be no need to waste any sort of bargaining power on that part of the scope clause, and instead a broadsided volley could be delivered to where it is needed most - with the new joint ventures being established.
What we've been doing in the past isn't working. Yes, some RJs are being phased out (mostly 50 seaters) but there are still thousands in operation. Maybe a different plan of attack is needed.

Why on Earth would a mainline pilot want his company to take legal responsibility for a bottom feeding regionals decisions, much less lobby for legislation to make it so? Why would a United pilot want his job security underscored by some Mesa pilot who was potentially given his job over the phone?

And getting turned down by a major doesn't mean they 'aren't qualified'. It could have meant they had a rough day at the interview, or they could be a complete tool bag ( which is often obvious) that current mainline pilots wouldn't want to be stuck sitting next to for the next 30 years. They wouldn't have offered them an interview if they weren't qualified

It's the largest hiring wave ever in pilot hiring, right now, in front of your eyes. Quit worrying about the other guy and get out there!
 
Why on Earth would a mainline pilot want his company to take legal responsibility for a bottom feeding regionals decisions, much less lobby for legislation to make it so? Why would a United pilot want his job security underscored by some Mesa pilot who was potentially given his job over the phone?

And getting turned down by a major doesn't mean they 'aren't qualified'. It could have meant they had a rough day at the interview, or they could be a complete tool bag ( which is often obvious) that current mainline pilots wouldn't want to be stuck sitting next to for the next 30 years. They wouldn't have offered them an interview if they weren't qualified

It's the largest hiring wave ever in pilot hiring, right now, in front of your eyes. Quit worrying about the other guy and get out there!
Because it's an end-run around the outsourcing. It's a win-win you just need to get the bigger players to see it. See my bullet point list to Dough. It would result in mainline taking back the flying without having to expend negotiating capital doing so. Despite what you read, mainline is mostly trading 50's for 70's.

As a lawyer, I would shred the mainline carrier in front of a jury. "So you're telling me, you found pilot CA XYZ not eligible for hire at Delta but allowed them to flying Delta passengers on different airplane?".

It would be seen as complete negligence in the eyes of 12.

The jury would eat it up. Hell I would too. It's absolute BS.

I'm fine, I'm at a career destination (hopefully). I want the commuters to go away completely.
 
Are you a lawyer?

Again, there is a large distinction between qualified and competent to fly, and someone who will bring value to the company and won't be a problem child for 30 years. That's what the interview is supposed to determine.
 
Because it's an end-run around the outsourcing. It's a win-win you just need to get the bigger players to see it. See my bullet point list to Dough. It would result in mainline taking back the flying without having to expend negotiating capital doing so. Despite what you read, mainline is mostly trading 50's for 70's.

As a lawyer, I would shred the mainline carrier in front of a jury. "So you're telling me, you found pilot CA XYZ not eligible for hire at Delta but allowed them to flying Delta passengers on different airplane?".

It would be seen as complete negligence in the eyes of 12.

The jury would eat it up. Hell I would too. It's absolute BS.

I'm fine, I'm at a career destination (hopefully). I want the commuters to go away completely.

You're barking up the wrong tree here. Plenty of Legacy/LCC/ULCC interviews have zilch to do with your flying skills. It is generally assumed you possess the knowledge commensurate with your experience and the skill set to safely maneuver your flying contraption from A to B without undue risk to anyone on board. These interviews are about wether or not you can be tolerated for four days at a time for the next two or three decades. They're about determining how you interact with customers and how you will represent not only yourself but your fellow pilots, employees and the airline. They're about determining whether or not you fit the culture at that carrier. There are plenty of reasons why someone might not be hired at one airline or another and I'm guessing that company's hiring practices would stand up in a court of law despite the example you offer.
 
So, your example of choice is a company that has been deemed too expensive and is slated for being shuttered in two years with the loss of some 3,000 jobs? Wow.

In the dark days of aviation, folks at XJT were making close to six figures flying around a 50 seat jet. They got to expensive because the business model DOESN'T work today.



Are the majors reducing their 70 seaters? No they are adding them in fact.

Looking at it wrongly. The overall number of Fee For Departure Carriers seats available and fleet numbers are overall declining. While I would love to have a 70 seater at mainline, I will take available seats and a declining fleet number in the meantime.


Why the reduction in 50 seaters? Back when fuel prices were high, it was because of that. Now, with the doubling up of feed, the majors are transitioning from 50 seaters to 70 seaters and reducing frequency. My own company is an example of that. 14 flights a day between two carriers on 50 seaters became seven flights on 70 seaters. This is happening across the board. Absent union bargaining, this would've happened regardless, yet you think ALPA deserves the credit.

See above.



Has nothing to do with the topic at hand.

Yes it does.
 
or they could be a complete tool bag ( which is often obvious) that current mainline pilots wouldn't want to be stuck sitting next to for the next 30 years.

News flash:

Those guys exist at every carrier. For that matter, they exist in every industry. Just because the name on the plane matches the name on the check doesn't absolve the company of having any difference in it's workforce diversity. Getting hired at any shop just means you did well at the interview, nothing else.

Edit to add: Just look at the diversity here. I'm 100% sure some guys here think I'm a tool. And that's alright with me. After all, it's only 4 days out of my life.
 
News flash:

Those guys exist at every carrier. For that matter, they exist in every industry. Just because the name on the plane matches the name on the check doesn't absolve the company of having any difference in it's workforce diversity. Getting hired at any shop just means you did well at the interview, nothing else.

Edit to add: Just look at the diversity here. I'm 100% sure some guys here think I'm a tool. And that's alright with me. After all, it's only 4 days out of my life.

I dunno man, 4 days sharing a closet with a bunch of buttons can turn into a loooong time with the wrong dude.
 
I think that's a huge cop out.

  • For one, it's obvious that not everyone can get a job at a major. There just aren't enough seats.
  • For two, it's completely missing the point. If a guy can fly a Delta/United/American passenger from Podunk-ville to XYZ Hub, and from XYZ Hub to Podunk-ville, but isn't "qualified" to fly him from XYZ Hub to "slightly less Po-dunk"-ville, that is a serious problem with the how airlines are legally on the hook for overseeing their subcontractors.
  • For Three, making the major carriers legally responsible for the actions of their subcontractors especially in regards to who is actually operating the equipment, might mean the gutting of the regional ranks altogether and placing the vast majority of those RJs on property at said property. It also might possibly further increase the pilot supply problem at that level, making returning flying to the major level even more obtainable. This is a huge win for guys already on property at that major. There would be no need to waste any sort of bargaining power on that part of the scope clause, and instead a broadsided volley could be delivered to where it is needed most - with the new joint ventures being established.
What we've been doing in the past isn't working. Yes, some RJs are being phased out (mostly 50 seaters) but there are still thousands in operation. Maybe a different plan of attack is needed.

But we've got to cut the "emotion" out of the answer.

If The Sizzler purchases Kraft Foods, you can make cheese that ends up on the bacon cheeseburger that shows up on the lunch special, but there is no guarantee or "right" implied that since your product ends up on the lunch menu that you're fully eligible for hire at the restaurant.

Emotionally, sure. Realistically, nope.

The processed cheese food division can have a strike, but at the end of the day, The Sizzler will just create a new division to produce processed cheese food.
 
Mmmmm....processed cheese food...I think I'll have some with my potted meat food product. Much loved for its spreadable consistency.
 
But we've got to cut the "emotion" out of the answer.

If The Sizzler purchases Kraft Foods, you can make cheese that ends up on the bacon cheeseburger that shows up on the lunch special, but there is no guarantee or "right" implied that since your product ends up on the lunch menu that you're fully eligible for hire at the restaurant.

Emotionally, sure. Realistically, nope.

The processed cheese food division can have a strike, but at the end of the day, The Sizzler will just create a new division to produce processed cheese food.

I take major issue with this.





The insinuation that Sizzler uses processed cheese.
 
American cheese is barely cheese!

But I don't really understand the term "processed". Isn't everything non-whole "processed"? :)
 
Back
Top