dasleben
That's just, like, your opinion, man
I agree with Todd.
Here's the qualification:
Before I sat left seat, I was very much like Firebird's perspective. I was working hard to learn how to be a Captain. In essence, I guess I was a "shadow" CA, and as I gained confidence in my skills, I saw my way as the "correct" method (not yet realizing the wide breadth of leadership styles that exist). I think every person goes through this in building their crew cockpit experience. You need to learn the bounds of your sphere of influence, and some of that is garnered through the much loved "experience" phrase.
In reality, until you've been in command of a crewed cockpit, most stuff you learn, file away and work on developing for your turn to Captain, is all theory. It might be some very good guesses, and lots of life experience dialed in as well. However, one finds out quickly that as a Captain, your style of leading the cockpit will go through some evolutions as your ideas on leading a cockpit are put to real world experiences.
Now, that I have had time to flush out how I like to run my show, as well as having real line experience in a myriad of situations, I'm quite set in my "comfort zone". As an FO, I make my suggestions. If what the CA wants to do doesn't get me violated, fine. Go with it. I spoke up. If it's going to get me in a heap of manure, and as is common practice at our airline, we break out Vol I or Vol II - because I'm as wrong as many times as I am correct. Have I seen guys be rude to ground staff? Yup. What do I do? Have a cup of coffee and when they're all done, I go back to work.
I have kicked gate agents off my jet before, not to be a tough guy, but at that exact time, they were exacerbating problems I was dealing with. I remember one night in IAD. I had a FA approach me and tell me she was having a problem with a passenger. I head back, and the lady was visibly upset. As I started to talk to her, it became apparent that she spoke very little English and had just gotten off Austrian. As I'm trying to communicate with her, the gate agent is standing behind me saying very loudly "Tell her she has to go, or get off! I don't have time for this!" At that point, it was late, we were parked at the "G" gates in the 170 (if you look up 'Boondoggle', it'll have a picture of that), and there is this gate agent yelling at me on a jet boarded full of folks. I asked him to leave. He said "Not until she makes up her mind!" I told him to get off the jet, and I'll let him know when I'm ready to move the jet. Was that the best solution? I don't know. I do know adding his hostility to the situation wasn't helping me communicate with a scared lady already. Turns out, she was travelling with some people who didn't make it through Customs as quick for whatever reason. I gave her my cell, she called some folks where she was going. That's all it took to resolve the situation, a little understanding and sympathy.
Now, who knows what else contributed to this guy's day. Just because the FO didn't say anything in front of the gate agent doesn't mean that nothing was said once the door was closed. There were so many issues going on, and perhaps there was the straw that broke the camel's back. Everyone's thinking there is a rogue CA when in fact there is just as great of a possibility that the dude just had all the buttons pushed at the same time. He's already convicted though.
There are people that are unfailingly Zen, and they are just as rare as people that are never, ever calm. The rest of us on the Bell Curve all have a breaking point. Help your buddies out, but there's a time and place to discuss. Just because the FO didn't jump in, doesn't mean anything wasn't said once the door was closed. Heck, maybe the CA got behind the door, sat for a second and looked at the FO and did a "Dude, I'm so sorry. I just F'd up. I really apologize. We square?"
I agree with you (see my first post). But, your style is your own style. I can't fault someone for being concerned enough to speak up. What I would do and what you would do is fine, but both of us are products of scheduled airline environments where pushing on-time is seen as more important than getting the people on. For example, if the FO had come from a 135 charter department, his outlook may be more customer-oriented, even if he sat left seat before coming to the airline.
I dunno, just thinking aloud. JMO, YMMV, etc.