When do you speak up?

I agree with Todd.

Here's the qualification:

Before I sat left seat, I was very much like Firebird's perspective. I was working hard to learn how to be a Captain. In essence, I guess I was a "shadow" CA, and as I gained confidence in my skills, I saw my way as the "correct" method (not yet realizing the wide breadth of leadership styles that exist). I think every person goes through this in building their crew cockpit experience. You need to learn the bounds of your sphere of influence, and some of that is garnered through the much loved "experience" phrase.

In reality, until you've been in command of a crewed cockpit, most stuff you learn, file away and work on developing for your turn to Captain, is all theory. It might be some very good guesses, and lots of life experience dialed in as well. However, one finds out quickly that as a Captain, your style of leading the cockpit will go through some evolutions as your ideas on leading a cockpit are put to real world experiences.

Now, that I have had time to flush out how I like to run my show, as well as having real line experience in a myriad of situations, I'm quite set in my "comfort zone". As an FO, I make my suggestions. If what the CA wants to do doesn't get me violated, fine. Go with it. I spoke up. If it's going to get me in a heap of manure, and as is common practice at our airline, we break out Vol I or Vol II - because I'm as wrong as many times as I am correct. Have I seen guys be rude to ground staff? Yup. What do I do? Have a cup of coffee and when they're all done, I go back to work.

I have kicked gate agents off my jet before, not to be a tough guy, but at that exact time, they were exacerbating problems I was dealing with. I remember one night in IAD. I had a FA approach me and tell me she was having a problem with a passenger. I head back, and the lady was visibly upset. As I started to talk to her, it became apparent that she spoke very little English and had just gotten off Austrian. As I'm trying to communicate with her, the gate agent is standing behind me saying very loudly "Tell her she has to go, or get off! I don't have time for this!" At that point, it was late, we were parked at the "G" gates in the 170 (if you look up 'Boondoggle', it'll have a picture of that), and there is this gate agent yelling at me on a jet boarded full of folks. I asked him to leave. He said "Not until she makes up her mind!" I told him to get off the jet, and I'll let him know when I'm ready to move the jet. Was that the best solution? I don't know. I do know adding his hostility to the situation wasn't helping me communicate with a scared lady already. Turns out, she was travelling with some people who didn't make it through Customs as quick for whatever reason. I gave her my cell, she called some folks where she was going. That's all it took to resolve the situation, a little understanding and sympathy.

Now, who knows what else contributed to this guy's day. Just because the FO didn't say anything in front of the gate agent doesn't mean that nothing was said once the door was closed. There were so many issues going on, and perhaps there was the straw that broke the camel's back. Everyone's thinking there is a rogue CA when in fact there is just as great of a possibility that the dude just had all the buttons pushed at the same time. He's already convicted though.

There are people that are unfailingly Zen, and they are just as rare as people that are never, ever calm. The rest of us on the Bell Curve all have a breaking point. Help your buddies out, but there's a time and place to discuss. Just because the FO didn't jump in, doesn't mean anything wasn't said once the door was closed. Heck, maybe the CA got behind the door, sat for a second and looked at the FO and did a "Dude, I'm so sorry. I just F'd up. I really apologize. We square?"

I agree with you (see my first post). But, your style is your own style. I can't fault someone for being concerned enough to speak up. What I would do and what you would do is fine, but both of us are products of scheduled airline environments where pushing on-time is seen as more important than getting the people on. For example, if the FO had come from a 135 charter department, his outlook may be more customer-oriented, even if he sat left seat before coming to the airline.

I dunno, just thinking aloud. JMO, YMMV, etc.
 
Backing up your Captain does not mean you simple adapt to whatever style the Captain chooses to adopt. You run the risk of assuming that Captains are somehow infallible.

The captain is certainly not infallible, but he is, in fact, in command. It's his ship, and so long as he doesn't violate the rules, he gets to run things the way he wants to run them. He sets the tone in the cockpit, and you have to adapt to it. I'm worried that a lot of newer FOs aren't getting this, and they're misunderstanding CRM as an excuse to not let the captain really run his ship.

I don't care what the circumstances are beyond this particular Captain's behavior.

That's not really a realistic attitude. Human beings react to situations in normal human ways. In many cases, that means that they react with anger or frustration. To pretend that it can be suppressed and prevented is completely unrealistic. Understanding human behavior is part of CRM. Just expecting someone to act stoic under all circumstances is not reality, and it's not good CRM. Understand why he's reacting the way he is, and try to deal with it in a manner that will be productive. In this circumstance, I doubt there is anything that could be productive other than possibly offering to do the paperwork for him. If that doesn't work, then trying to talk to him about his behavior is only going to make him angrier, and only make the situation worse.

Whatever you say, Captain. ;)

Former captain. With this merger happening, you'll probably see the left seat of an airliner at a major before I do. :)
 
In reality, until you've been in command of a crewed cockpit, most stuff you learn, file away and work on developing for your turn to Captain, is all theory. It might be some very good guesses, and lots of life experience dialed in as well. However, one finds out quickly that as a Captain, your style of leading the cockpit will go through some evolutions as your ideas on leading a cockpit are put to real world experiences.

Great post overall, but I especially liked this part. Being an FO again when I came to AirTran, after spending a couple of years in the left seat at Pinnacle, has definitely been a far different experience. After you've sat in that left seat, your perspective changes, because it's not theory anymore, it's reality. You know what the guy is dealing with, and you know what it was like to fly with a wide range of FOs. When you're an FO for the first time in your career, you've only seen that one seat, and you don't have a full perspective on what things are like for the other guy.

This is why I've always liked AirTran's policy that they only hire pilots who have been airline captains or military aircraft commanders. It helps to have seen things from the other seat.
 
This is why I've always liked AirTran's policy that they only hire pilots who have been airline captains or military aircraft commanders. It helps to have seen things from the other seat.

I think it's a little unfair to those of us who've put in time learning the same lessons in a non-121 or military environment, personally. I have scheduled 135 PIC experience. It's the same stuff, but some 121 airlines don't see it that way. Too bad.
 
I think it's a little unfair to those of us who've put in time learning the same lessons in a non-121 or military environment, personally. I have scheduled 135 PIC experience. It's the same stuff, but some 121 airlines don't see it that way. Too bad.

The problem with giving credit for scheduled 135 is that some of them are really good operations that run like airlines (like AirNet for example), but others are really ratty operations that have little resemblance to airline operations. It sucks, and I haven't been able to get a friend of mine hired who has 2,000+ hours of part 135 Shorts 360 captain experience, but overall, I'd rather have the requirement than not.
 
I think it's a little unfair to those of us who've put in time learning the same lessons in a non-121 or military environment, personally. I have scheduled 135 PIC experience. It's the same stuff, but some 121 airlines don't see it that way. Too bad.

You're not the only one who sees issues with exclusions. The "you've never been an airline Captain card" has been played, so anybody without time in the left seat of a 121 airliner has no idea what they're talking about. ;)
 
The captain is certainly not infallible, but he is, in fact, in command. It's his ship, and so long as he doesn't violate the rules, he gets to run things the way he wants to run them. He sets the tone in the cockpit, and you have to adapt to it. I'm worried that a lot of newer FOs aren't getting this, and they're misunderstanding CRM as an excuse to not let the captain really run his ship.

That's not really a realistic attitude. Human beings react to situations in normal human ways. In many cases, that means that they react with anger or frustration. To pretend that it can be suppressed and prevented is completely unrealistic. Understanding human behavior is part of CRM. Just expecting someone to act stoic under all circumstances is not reality, and it's not good CRM. Understand why he's reacting the way he is, and try to deal with it in a manner that will be productive. In this circumstance, I doubt there is anything that could be productive other than possibly offering to do the paperwork for him. If that doesn't work, then trying to talk to him about his behavior is only going to make him angrier, and only make the situation worse.

CRM isn't license to tell a Captain how to run the airplane. Asking that a Captain not act like a petulant child or in a manner that raises questions of his mental state are not unreasonable and certainly in line with good CRM. I specifically had to call a Captain to task once for his attitudes. I told him that his attitudes and temper were making it hard to fly with him. I also had to tell him that I wasn't the only one saying that- I was the only one saying it to his face.

Candor is a surprisingly useful tool in dealing with superiors and subordinates alike in the chain of command. Sometimes you just have to say it like it is. If the Captain's acting like a mental patient, something needs to be said. Who feels good trusting the judgment of someone who acts like a candidate for a thorazine drip?

An unrealistic attitude? It's perfectly realistic. If the Skipper needs to take five to get his head together, so be it. That said, letting the world decide how you're going to act when things don't go as planned is ridiculous. Letting the Captain pitch a tantrum because that's "human nature" just reinforces the concept that a Captain has authority without the real responsibility. To be 'master and commander' of a vessel one must first be master and commander of one's self. If the situation such as the one illustrated has someone frothing at the mouth and barking like a rabid dog, they've failed. It's time to count to a hundred and start again, with a more focused intent towards a sense of overwatch for the situation.

As for the idea that there's no way someone could bring leadership experience to the flight deck with having been a Captain, I'm going to argue that the concept is a bit near-sighted.
There are plenty of ways to find one's self in the figurative 'hot seat'. The leadership principles that govern them are all the same.
 
Who cares about the passengers...I want to know why it was suddenly discovered that their was a sign off needed for mtx. and why there wasn't the proper fuel order on board if the plane and its operators were trying to get out at a certain time.
But at the same time you have to realize it's midnight and people that are either just coming on duty or are finishing their day are not a bunch of happy campers. I regularly go on duty at either 1 or 3 am and let me tell you its not a happy group. You can only accommodate before you realize that your lack of customer service by not letting on every stranded passenger is really the airline screwing itself for selling 80 seats on a 50 seat airplane.
So, you offer advice, Captain rejects it, forget about it. If its not about to bend metal, kill you or get you violated say something and then go with the flow. I work with guys that will get their blood pressure so high over spilled milk its scary funny. In the end its their call and you do what you have to do as per your job requirements.
Wow.

I'm surprised at some of the stuff I'm reading. Overselling airplanes? First off, that wasn't the case, second off, as a gate agent at a hub, I can tell you it is very rare to involuntarily deny a passenger boarding due to an oversale. Our airline got people in late so they "missed" their flight, they show up to the gate and, lucky them, the plane will be sitting here another half hour. We have a chance to make things right and turn their bad experience into something nice, but instead because of a CA with a bad attitude, they sleep on the dirty floor of the airport while their plane sits there with tons of open seats and the door wide open. They are OUR passengers. It's our metal, they're inside of it, it is our duty not only to get them from point A to point B, that is what a bus is for, but to give them the best service we can within our abilities. You can cry me a river about having working late and being grumpy, I was on my 2nd hour of overtime at the time and my 10th hour on the clock getting yelled at by stranded passengers that day AND we started our shifts finding out UA has canceled our ground handling contract due to the merger and we're all losing our jobs April 1st. But do you see me taking it out on the passengers? Hell no I don't, as long as I'm with the company I have a duty to take care of them. The flightcrews aren't the only ones getting screwed. We're an airline, I don't care what your position is, your job includes customer service. You have a commitment to your passengers, and any passenger who flies on our airline. You guys are professionals, act like it. If you don't feel this way, go fly freight. Otherwise, if you just want to play bus driver and have no interaction with your customers, then expect to be seen for what you are.

"Who cares about the passengers"...with attitudes like this, why should those passengers care about you and bringing dignity back into the profession? I for one would love to see great improvements in 121 pax flying, but it all starts with the image portrayed to the flying public, and then you may hope to gain some attention from the company and press. I know there are guys out there who go above and beyond to please their passengers regardless of how happy they are with the company, but a few people can only do so much.
 
Wow.

I'm surprised at some of the stuff I'm reading. Overselling airplanes? First off, that wasn't the case, second off, as a gate agent at a hub, I can tell you it is very rare to involuntarily deny a passenger boarding due to an oversale. Our airline got people in late so they "missed" their flight, they show up to the gate and, lucky them, the plane will be sitting here another half hour. We have a chance to make things right and turn their bad experience into something nice, but instead because of a CA with a bad attitude, they sleep on the dirty floor of the airport while their plane sits there with tons of open seats and the door wide open. They are OUR passengers. It's our metal, they're inside of it, it is our duty not only to get them from point A to point B, that is what a bus is for, but to give them the best service we can within our abilities. You can cry me a river about having working late and being grumpy, I was on my 2nd hour of overtime at the time and my 10th hour on the clock getting yelled at by stranded passengers that day AND we started our shifts finding out UA has canceled our ground handling contract due to the merger and we're all losing our jobs April 1st. But do you see me taking it out on the passengers? Hell no I don't, as long as I'm with the company I have a duty to take care of them. The flightcrews aren't the only ones getting screwed. We're an airline, I don't care what your position is, your job includes customer service. You have a commitment to your passengers, and any passenger who flies on our airline. You guys are professionals, act like it. If you don't feel this way, go fly freight. Otherwise, if you just want to play bus driver and have no interaction with your customers, then expect to be seen for what you are.

"Who cares about the passengers"...with attitudes like this, why should those passengers care about you and bringing dignity back into the profession? I for one would love to see great improvements in 121 pax flying, but it all starts with the image portrayed to the flying public, and then you may hope to gain some attention from the company and press. I know there are guys out there who go above and beyond to please their passengers regardless of how happy they are with the company, but a few people can only do so much.

Just an observation, but if certain airline pilots don't care about customer service or about the pax; then why should they expect the customers/pax to give a rats ass about their problems that they go do informational picketing at the terminal about?
 
Just an observation, but if certain airline pilots don't care about customer service or about the pax; then why should they expect the customers/pax to give a rats ass about their problems that they go do informational picketing at the terminal about?

Well, I think most of us DO care about the passengers, but in regard to your question, we DON'T care if the passengers care about our picketing. That's not the point of picketing. Picketing is really meant to garner media attention so the guys on Wall Street start to get nervous and make phone calls to management to finish up negotiations so their investment doesn't lose money.
 
Well, I think most of us DO care about the passengers, but in regard to your question, we DON'T care if the passengers care about our picketing. That's not the point of picketing. Picketing is really meant to garner media attention so the guys on Wall Street start to get nervous and make phone calls to management to finish up negotiations so their investment doesn't lose money.

I agree that most airline crews do care about the pax and its the few that don't. My point being that for those that don't and show it, then that is likely going to come back to them in terms of how pax view them. Completely unnecessary all around.
 
Who cares about the passengers...I want to know why it was suddenly discovered that their was a sign off needed for mtx. and why there wasn't the proper fuel order on board if the plane and its operators were trying to get out at a certain time.

:yeahthat: My guess is the CA was more upset about this then the pax's.

The flightcrews aren't the only ones getting screwed. We're an airline, I don't care what your position is, your job includes customer service. You have a commitment to your passengers, and any passenger who flies on our airline. You guys are professionals, act like it. If you don't feel this way, go fly freight. Otherwise, if you just want to play bus driver and have no interaction with your customers, then expect to be seen for what you are.

"Who cares about the passengers"...

I think you are miss reading what he is saying.

Baj is not say F the passengers, he is saying if the company cared about the customers the plane would have been long gone by the time the pax showed up.
My guess is the CA felt if the company doesn't care about the customers why should he.
 
I think you are miss reading what he is saying.

Baj is not say F the passengers, he is saying if the company cared about the customers the plane would have been long gone by the time the pax showed up.
My guess is the CA felt if the company doesn't care about the customers why should he.
Ah, I understand. I apologize for misreading, but what I said wasn't so much aimed at him as it was the people in the profession who really feel that way. A few bad apples spoils the bushel in an industry as publicly scrutinized as this one unfortunately.
 
You're not the only one who sees issues with exclusions. The "you've never been an airline Captain card" has been played, so anybody without time in the left seat of a 121 airliner has no idea what they're talking about. ;)

121 PIC time is like so many other discriminators.

Is it a magical cure all? Nope. As with most other parts of our jobs, the skills can be learned. Just like the skills of flying turbojets, or turbines, or glass, or FMCs, or even ATP skills.
 
Chasen try not to take it personally. Yeah it sucks but there isn't anything you can do. If the captain cancels the flight that is their prerogative and at that point it becomes between the captain and the company. As for the FO, well if it's not a safety issue there is only so much the FO can do. PIC is final authority. I'm not defending the captain's actions but on a professional level you have about as much power as the FO does at that point... and from the sound of things, had the FO somehow made a stand, CRM may have deteriorated and that IS a safety issue.
 
I have a real simple policy: the Captain is always right unless he's: A) about to kill people or break things; or B) about to get me violated or otherwise in trouble.

I love you man! (no homo, not that there's anything wrong with that :) )
 
There are a lot of people I've worked with that really do forget about customer service. Put me in the camp of thinking we aren't respected/compensated/etc nearly enough for what we do. Giving crappy service isn't going to change that. If anything, its going to make our company weaker and make it less likely we are going to "take it back"...(yeah...like that's going to happen). But more importantly, my life outside of this job is way important to me than what happens at work. I assume my passengers lives to them outside of the airport/airplane is much the same. Yes, doing the paperwork for the 4th time is a pain in the ass, but some of those people might be going to a wedding, funeral, job interview, or other event that is probably very important in their lives. One of the most rewarding days I've had at work was a day that started out with some MX at an outstation, then some more MX in the hub. There was a woman who was afraid she was going to miss a relatives funeral because of our delay. We were able to get the MX done quickly and got a couple shortcuts in the air and were able to make up a considerable amount of time, thus getting her to DTW. Could we have said "well, MX is on board, I'm heading into the terminal for a while" or "we're already late, I'm sticking with the filed route". But in my opinion that's losing the big picture.
 
Great thread! I agree that the Captain is in charge of his aircraft, but to leave those passengers off is totally wrong! It doesn't matter if he's having a bad day, he needs to stay professional and do his job, which is to bring his passengers to their destination safely. His job is ALL about customer service. You have to put on the mindset of "if my family were the ones who showed up at the gate, would I want them left off the flight for this Captain who doesn't want to do extra paperwork?" I would think not! The Captain would probably have thought the same if it were his family too. I know it's easier said than done in the heat of battle, but this one's for filing away in the "how NOT to be a Captain" folder for when the time comes for you to upgrade. If I were the Chief Pilot and heard about this, I would certainly have a word with this guy.
 
Often times we overlook some other underlying problems. In this case, long duty, stress of screwed up schedule for the day etc. None of these excuse this guy's behavior, however a sharp FO might recognize this. I would have responded ot the gate agents request in the following manner. "Cap'n, look I know you're tired and don't wanna put up with more BS, but lets get these people on and do the right thing here. I'll run grab you a starbucks or something, your choice, and I'll do the paperwork for you". If this doesn't help him, then he cannot be helped; and at the very least I have done my best to try and help the situation for him, the gate agents, and the passengers. (pax piss me off a lot too, but they are still the reason we have a job anyway)...
 
CRM isn't license to tell a Captain how to run the airplane. Asking that a Captain not act like a petulant child or in a manner that raises questions of his mental state are not unreasonable and certainly in line with good CRM. I specifically had to call a Captain to task once for his attitudes. I told him that his attitudes and temper were making it hard to fly with him. I also had to tell him that I wasn't the only one saying that- I was the only one saying it to his face.

Candor is a surprisingly useful tool in dealing with superiors and subordinates alike in the chain of command. Sometimes you just have to say it like it is. If the Captain's acting like a mental patient, something needs to be said. Who feels good trusting the judgment of someone who acts like a candidate for a thorazine drip?

An unrealistic attitude? It's perfectly realistic. If the Skipper needs to take five to get his head together, so be it. That said, letting the world decide how you're going to act when things don't go as planned is ridiculous. Letting the Captain pitch a tantrum because that's "human nature" just reinforces the concept that a Captain has authority without the real responsibility. To be 'master and commander' of a vessel one must first be master and commander of one's self. If the situation such as the one illustrated has someone frothing at the mouth and barking like a rabid dog, they've failed. It's time to count to a hundred and start again, with a more focused intent towards a sense of overwatch for the situation.

As for the idea that there's no way someone could bring leadership experience to the flight deck with having been a Captain, I'm going to argue that the concept is a bit near-sighted.
There are plenty of ways to find one's self in the figurative 'hot seat'. The leadership principles that govern them are all the same.

That's like letting my two year old get away with a tantrum and get what he wants just to avoid the real task of teaching him something, all for the sake of, "human nature". THat's just a little too liberal of an approach for me...

THis is a great post..:tmyk:
 
Back
Top