When do you speak up?

ChasenSFO

hen teaser
You're the F/O. Its a flow day at a certain West Coast hub and the entire 10PM bank of flights is leaving around 12AM. You board up, the realize you need MX to come sign something off. Now that the flight is going to miss the quick-turn anyway, customer service asks if you care if they send down a jumpseater who just ran up to the gate. CA agrees, but ACARS is down so you have to re-do the paperwork by hand. MX finishes up, but you request more fuel and the fuel truck says it won't even get there for another 5 minutes. All the other flights have since left anyway, so you're asked by a ramp agent if you can take 2 revenue pax who just got in since you'll be sitting a while. CA rips up the load sheet he was working on in the face of the ramp agent and expresses with profanity how pissed he is to re-do the math, but says send them down "but that's IT". With the new fuel load, you need a new release. Dispatch says since it is past 12AM and ACARS is down, its going to be a while, they estimate 20 minutes. The rest of your misconnects have all shown up, and watched the last 2 revenue pax board, and you are sitting there with 20 open seats and the cabin door wide open for at least 20 minutes. Agents ask again and the CA explodes and says he will cancel the leg if we ask again. You as the F/O look very shocked at this. Agents explain that the passengers have been told the plane will sit there for 20 minutes and if they aren't let on, they are stuck until 9AM and will sleep in the airport. The CA responds "And how the ____ is that my problem? You go tell them ____ happens. I'm not doing all that math a 4th time. Customer service is your trade, not mine". Again, you, as the F/O, are shocked at this and as the plane sits there idle ultimately for 35 more minutes with the door wide open, you feel so guilty you come upstairs and apologize to the gate agents. They urge you to have the balls to speak up and tell the CA it IS his duty to take care of his passengers. Do you do it?

I'll tell you what did happen. F/O said "that would be a mistake on my part" and left it at that. Passengers slept in the airport. I was disgusted with the PICs attitude and our supervisor filed a grievance on him. God forbid you have to change the numbers AGAIN instead of sitting there with your feet up for 35 minutes. I've never seen a CA behave like this, in these situations they always let misconnects on, most of our CAs are very CS oriented. But what was more alarming was the fact the F/O and F/As(so 3 of 4 crew members) were as disgusted as the CS agents but were afraid to speak up. It was obvious this CA was having a horrible day, who knows, he could have just gotten divorced, but CRM anyone? Seems a little dangerous to me when an entire crew feels the CA is unapproachable.

I'm curious how many F/Os on this board would have told the CA, "Look, we're stuck sitting here anyway, these people paid for a seat on this plane, if CS is willing to get them back on the flight, and the ramp is willing to grab a belt loader, go back into the pit, stack their bags, and fill out a new load sheet, we might as well let them on."? Or, do you guys think that it is better CRM to just let the CA chill out and have it his way to avoid an awkward trip from then on out?
 
"Look, we're stuck sitting here anyway, these people paid for a seat on this plane, if CS is willing to get them back on the flight, and the ramp is willing to grab a belt loader, go back into the pit, stack their bags, and fill out a new load sheet, we might as well let them on."

I'd say it pretty close to that. After that, you've said your peace, it's not a safety concern, and if he wants to still be a [feminine hygiene product] and go without the late passengers, well, it's on him. Can't save the world every day of the week.

The big thing is just not to be intimidated by the guy in the left seat. He's just a guy who got hired before you who happens to wear four bars. He's in charge, but don't think that you have to cower in your seat until you're spoken to.
 
Why not (as the FO) offer to fill out the sheet this time? If he's sick and tired of doing it, offer.
 
Honestly I would not get worked up about this unless I was an F/O at the actual company that the passengers bought a ticket on. If I was an outsourced employee then I could be up against some odds that are not in my favor and here's why.

I fly with people that do not see the passengers as their customers and I do see why. They don't work for the company that sold the pax their tickets, they might not have any intention of doing so, and this one's really interesting if you think about it, they might have a class date lined up at a competitor! i.e. a US Airways express captain with a class date at SWA not caring about USAir's not getting pax on just to pick two carrier names at random for the example.

I am not justifying the behavior nor am I advocating it, but I must say, the longer I am in this industry the more I can see where they do get this mentality. They work hard to get the job done and the parent mainline company kicks them in the head by slashing pass travel, health insurance, etc. Some changes do not even save money. So, we end up with this type of thing...employees that have lost interest.

This probably wasn't the type of answer you were expecting -- but, it wasn't the type of employee I was expecting to work with when I entered the industry either. They are the minority, but they are the 10% that cause 80% of the headaches. Frankly, I blame the parent mainline company for hiring a vendor to get a job done that they could do themselves just as well.

So, if that is the type of PIC that is in this scenario, as an FO I see it as a lost cause to even try and convince them what to do. The mainline company had the opportunity to put their own metal on the route on that flight, they chose not to, end of story.

I am becoming more interested in pursuing an MBA or similar higher education just so I can infuse some of these examples into a discussion and see what happens. It truly is boardroom vs. reality and it's shocking just how badly outsourcing can fail sometimes, yet go undetected by anyone other than those employees that are right there for a few minutes to witness it.


Now, shifting gears, if the guy was usually a good one to fly with and he's just having a really bad day and is ticked off in the heat of the moment, then I would take a different approach. Offering to do the paperwork myself, if allowed by company policy, would be my first step. It certainly can be frustrating doing that stuff a couple times as they add more bags or add a misconnecting passenger and you have to rip it up and start over again. No ACARS is a bummer for that!

If there is a minute or two, I might just close the cockpit door and let them know what I think about their angry response to the gate agent. 'Listen, you've always been a good guy to fly with before but I think you might owe the agent an apology for at least the outburst part. The rest of your decision is yours to reconsider and I urge you to do so...think about it...you've got several minutes to.'
 
They don't work for the company that sold the pax their tickets, they might not have any intention of doing so, and this one's really interesting if you think about it, they might have a class date lined up at a competitor! i.e. a US Airways express captain with a class date at SWA not caring about USAir's not getting pax on just to pick two carrier names at random for the example.

I think that is a highly unlikely scenario. That someone with a class date knowingly goes and sabatoges flights to stream customers away from said carrier. Sounds interesting, but most guys could give a rip about ticket sales.
 
I think that is a highly unlikely scenario. That someone with a class date knowingly goes and sabatoges flights to stream customers away from said carrier. Sounds interesting, but most guys could give a rip about ticket sales.

That particular instance is not likely but it does exist; I flew with a guy at my last company that specifically mentioned that he was no longer 'playing for this team' because he'd been hired at a competitor and saw it as a conflict of interest to go out of his way to help out what would, in the future, be his competition (even though he didn't have a class date at the new place! . . . and if I had to guess, still doesn't!).

It wasn't taken to the level you're referring to, sabotaging the operation or anything. Just the "not in my job description" mentality.
 
A Captain that's this riled up about things could possibly not be too focused on other things of import later on. Regardless of how the passenger situation is resolved, I'd do something to try to get the Captain to calm down. Perhaps commiserating a bit over how the day has gone to hell, etc.

"So yeah.. this has been a crappy day. We're really getting the run around with all these changes." Step one- find common ground. Turn "You and Me" into "We."

Once you've got him looking at your situation as common ground with common goals... maybe you say "Hey man, I know this sucks, but you're kinda worrying me a little. Can we tone it down a little?" If you can de-escalate the Skipper while showing that A) You're on his side and B) you need him to chill out to help you both out, maybe that attitude will C) spill over to other aspects of the operation.

I had an episode once where we were halfway to Mexico from DFW when one of the hydraulic systems overheated then failed. We took it back to DFW without incident. We changed aircraft and prepared to go again. The Captain had been wound way too tight for the whole trip, but this time he started swearing at the ramp agents via the intercom.

We had a chat about stress management and how things in other parts of his life were severely negatively influencing his work. I was gentle and respectful, though- I knew why. Not too long ago, his infant son had drowned in a swimming pool. His marriage had failed in dealing with that. Tragically rough time for the man.

That said, the Captain is the final authority for a reason. The FO is SIC for just the same reason- if the Captain's not quite holding it together, somebody needs to joggle his/her elbow and remind them why they're the Captain, and that you need them to be the Captain.
 
A Captain that's this riled up about things could possibly not be too focused on other things of import later on. Regardless of how the passenger situation is resolved, I'd do something to try to get the Captain to calm down. Perhaps commiserating a bit over how the day has gone to hell, etc.

"So yeah.. this has been a crappy day. We're really getting the run around with all these changes." Step one- find common ground. Turn "You and Me" into "We."

Once you've got him looking at your situation as common ground with common goals... maybe you say "Hey man, I know this sucks, but you're kinda worrying me a little. Can we tone it down a little?" If you can de-escalate the Skipper while showing that A) You're on his side and B) you need him to chill out to help you both out, maybe that attitude will C) spill over to other aspects of the operation.

I had an episode once where we were halfway to Mexico from DFW when one of the hydraulic systems overheated then failed. We took it back to DFW without incident. We changed aircraft and prepared to go again. The Captain had been wound way too tight for the whole trip, but this time he started swearing at the ramp agents via the intercom.

We had a chat about stress management and how things in other parts of his life were severely negatively influencing his work. I was gentle and respectful, though- I knew why. Not too long ago, his infant son had drowned in a swimming pool. His marriage had failed in dealing with that. Tragically rough time for the man.

That said, the Captain is the final authority for a reason. The FO is SIC for just the same reason- if the Captain's not quite holding it together, somebody needs to joggle his/her elbow and remind them why they're the Captain, and that you need them to be the Captain.

Very nice post!

If all else fails, just scream "CAPTAIN'S AUTHORITY" and wrestle the plane from him. Okay, just kidding. Don't do that. ;)
 
I have a real simple policy: the Captain is always right unless he's: A) about to kill people or break things; or B) about to get me violated or otherwise in trouble.
 
First off let me say I do not work in this type of operation. I would feel bad about leaving the pacs but you never know where you or that captain will be in a few years. He might have some other things going on and the comment might just be enough to solidify your name in his memory as the guy that talked back or whatever. That smoldering bridge could have a few years to cook but just be careful. I'd let it go.


Part of my life experience that makes me say let it go and they can wait is that THEY were late right? "Fifteen minutes early is on-time, on-time is late, and late is unacceptable." Now that I am back to civilian life I will accept just "on time" but if someone is late I usually don't feel too bad about leaving them behind.
 
I have a real simple policy: the Captain is always right unless he's: A) about to kill people or break things; or B) about to get me violated or otherwise in trouble.

So how do you know that the Captain's clearly unstable attitude and outbursts aren't about to precipitate situation A) or B)?
The key to accident prevention is to identify the attitudes and practices currently in place that later lead to accidents or violations later in the chain. Would a little prudence in this matter be in order? I think so.

A First Officer's duty is to support the Captain in performing his/her responsibilities. The Captain's first priority is safe management of aircraft and crew to ensure public safety. A Captain that cannot manage his own self and maintain emotional control is clearly not fully achieving that.

If a First Officer's duty is to support the Captain- which would be better in this situation? Is it better to give the Captain what they want- or what they need?
 
You're the F/O. Its a flow day at a certain West Coast hub and the entire 10PM bank of flights is leaving around 12AM. You board up, the realize you need MX to come sign something off. Now that the flight is going to miss the quick-turn anyway, customer service asks if you care if they send down a jumpseater who just ran up to the gate. CA agrees, but ACARS is down so you have to re-do the paperwork by hand. MX finishes up, but you request more fuel and the fuel truck says it won't even get there for another 5 minutes. All the other flights have since left anyway, so you're asked by a ramp agent if you can take 2 revenue pax who just got in since you'll be sitting a while. CA rips up the load sheet he was working on in the face of the ramp agent and expresses with profanity how pissed he is to re-do the math, but says send them down "but that's IT". With the new fuel load, you need a new release. Dispatch says since it is past 12AM and ACARS is down, its going to be a while, they estimate 20 minutes. The rest of your misconnects have all shown up, and watched the last 2 revenue pax board, and you are sitting there with 20 open seats and the cabin door wide open for at least 20 minutes. Agents ask again and the CA explodes and says he will cancel the leg if we ask again. You as the F/O look very shocked at this. Agents explain that the passengers have been told the plane will sit there for 20 minutes and if they aren't let on, they are stuck until 9AM and will sleep in the airport. The CA responds "And how the ____ is that my problem? You go tell them ____ happens. I'm not doing all that math a 4th time. Customer service is your trade, not mine". Again, you, as the F/O, are shocked at this and as the plane sits there idle ultimately for 35 more minutes with the door wide open, you feel so guilty you come upstairs and apologize to the gate agents. They urge you to have the balls to speak up and tell the CA it IS his duty to take care of his passengers. Do you do it?

I'll tell you what did happen. F/O said "that would be a mistake on my part" and left it at that. Passengers slept in the airport. I was disgusted with the PICs attitude and our supervisor filed a grievance on him. God forbid you have to change the numbers AGAIN instead of sitting there with your feet up for 35 minutes. I've never seen a CA behave like this, in these situations they always let misconnects on, most of our CAs are very CS oriented. But what was more alarming was the fact the F/O and F/As(so 3 of 4 crew members) were as disgusted as the CS agents but were afraid to speak up. It was obvious this CA was having a horrible day, who knows, he could have just gotten divorced, but CRM anyone? Seems a little dangerous to me when an entire crew feels the CA is unapproachable.

I'm curious how many F/Os on this board would have told the CA, "Look, we're stuck sitting here anyway, these people paid for a seat on this plane, if CS is willing to get them back on the flight, and the ramp is willing to grab a belt loader, go back into the pit, stack their bags, and fill out a new load sheet, we might as well let them on."? Or, do you guys think that it is better CRM to just let the CA chill out and have it his way to avoid an awkward trip from then on out?

Who cares about the passengers...I want to know why it was suddenly discovered that their was a sign off needed for mtx. and why there wasn't the proper fuel order on board if the plane and its operators were trying to get out at a certain time.
But at the same time you have to realize it's midnight and people that are either just coming on duty or are finishing their day are not a bunch of happy campers. I regularly go on duty at either 1 or 3 am and let me tell you its not a happy group. You can only accommodate before you realize that your lack of customer service by not letting on every stranded passenger is really the airline screwing itself for selling 80 seats on a 50 seat airplane.
So, you offer advice, Captain rejects it, forget about it. If its not about to bend metal, kill you or get you violated say something and then go with the flow. I work with guys that will get their blood pressure so high over spilled milk its scary funny. In the end its their call and you do what you have to do as per your job requirements.
 
So how do you know that the Captain's clearly unstable attitude and outbursts aren't about to precipitate situation A) or B)?

How would they do so? We're sitting at the gate, so he's not going to get anyone killed or hurt, and he's not going to break anything. And I don't see how "B" could be a problem, because no rules have broken that could get us violated or otherwise in trouble (unless there is a company policy that requires him to do the W&B a 4th time for this purpose, which I highly doubt).

A Captain that cannot manage his own self and maintain emotional control is clearly not fully achieving that.

Some guys are just excitable. Doesn't mean that they can't do their jobs effectively. I don't subscribe to your line of thought on this one. Yelling at a gate agent may not be very nice, but it doesn't mean that you can't do your job.

If a First Officer's duty is to support the Captain- which would be better in this situation? Is it better to give the Captain what they want- or what they need?

What does he need? A hug? Sorry, but I don't go for this touchy-feely stuff. He's the captain. If he wants to be a jerk, he can be a jerk. Just don't break any rules or hurt anybody.
 
How would they do so? We're sitting at the gate, so he's not going to get anyone killed or hurt, and he's not going to break anything. And I don't see how "B" could be a problem, because no rules have broken that could get us violated or otherwise in trouble (unless there is a company policy that requires him to do the W&B a 4th time for this purpose, which I highly doubt).



Some guys are just excitable. Doesn't mean that they can't do their jobs effectively. I don't subscribe to your line of thought on this one. Yelling at a gate agent may not be very nice, but it doesn't mean that you can't do your job.



What does he need? A hug? Sorry, but I don't go for this touchy-feely stuff. He's the captain. If he wants to be a jerk, he can be a jerk. Just don't break any rules or hurt anybody.

This is clearly a sign of differences in leadership styles. Your style seems to be a bit more authoritarian, which is fine, as you're certainly not failing in your career progress. Mine tends to be more of the "motivate others to succeed" stuff. It's not 'touchy-feely', either. It's realistic, and recognizes that creating conflict with ground personnel can just as easily spill over to creating conflict with the crew.

How do you know that someone on your crew is afraid to speak up- even about something potentially serious- when the Captain creates a hostile, stressful environment that makes speaking up about problems a negative event?

As for "some guys just being excitable".... really? I think you're evading the idea here. A Captain has to be able to make calm, clear and rational decisions based on accurate data and the ability to utilize the crew. How does being "excitable" not weigh in against that? It would seem to work against it, in my opinion.
 
This is clearly a sign of differences in leadership styles. Your style seems to be a bit more authoritarian, which is fine, as you're certainly not failing in your career progress.

I don't think "authoritarian" is correct, as that has a pejorative insinuation. I'm not authoritarian, but I do believe strongly in the chain of command, and the captain is in command. An old rEAL captain once told me "the cockpit is, at best, a benevolent dictatorship. It is NOT a democracy." I agree with that 100%.

What this is really about, though, isn't leadership styles, but followership styles. The FO needs to possess certain leadership qualities, but he isn't the leader. The FO should be a chameleon who adapts to the leadership style of the captain. There are times when he needs to step up and be a leader to stop the captain from doing something dangerous, illegal, against policy, etc., but the captain just being a jerk is not one of those times. That's the time for you to be the chameleon and let the captain run his ship the way he wants to run it.

How do you know that someone on your crew is afraid to speak up- even about something potentially serious- when the Captain creates a hostile, stressful environment that makes speaking up about problems a negative event?

As for "some guys just being excitable".... really? I think you're evading the idea here. A Captain has to be able to make calm, clear and rational decisions based on accurate data and the ability to utilize the crew. How does being "excitable" not weigh in against that? It would seem to work against it, in my opinion.

It sounds to me as though this was one thing after another, and the captain finally got fed up and lost his temper. It doesn't sound to me like he's always a jerk who creates a bad environment. He had a long day, a bunch of crap was happening at 1am that was slowing down the operation, and he got fed up and yelled. It's a normal human reaction, not an indication that he creates a hostile work environment for the crew. If the guy is always a CRM nightmare, then the FO should talk to Pro Standards and maybe they can get him some CRM training. If it was just the captain losing his temper in the wee hours of the morning after a long day, then I think there's no reason to get worked up about it.
 
I don't think "authoritarian" is correct, as that has a pejorative insinuation. I'm not authoritarian, but I do believe strongly in the chain of command, and the captain is in command. An old rEAL captain once told me "the cockpit is, at best, a benevolent dictatorship. It is NOT a democracy." I agree with that 100%.

What this is really about, though, isn't leadership styles, but followership styles. The FO needs to possess certain leadership qualities, but he isn't the leader. The FO should be a chameleon who adapts to the leadership style of the captain. There are times when he needs to step up and be a leader to stop the captain from doing something dangerous, illegal, against policy, etc., but the captain just being a jerk is not one of those times. That's the time for you to be the chameleon and let the captain run his ship the way he wants to run it.



It sounds to me as though this was one thing after another, and the captain finally got fed up and lost his temper. It doesn't sound to me like he's always a jerk who creates a bad environment. He had a long day, a bunch of crap was happening at 1am that was slowing down the operation, and he got fed up and yelled. It's a normal human reaction, not an indication that he creates a hostile work environment for the crew. If the guy is always a CRM nightmare, then the FO should talk to Pro Standards and maybe they can get him some CRM training. If it was just the captain losing his temper in the wee hours of the morning after a long day, then I think there's no reason to get worked up about it.


'Benevolent dictatorship'. A Captain has to be 'Master and Commander', etc. I understand the concept. That said, I'm not advocating that it's a democracy, nor would I expect it to be. And while an FO's support style must be fluid, to term them a chameleon implies that they're ever-changing based entirely on the Captain's whims and moods. Backing up your Captain does not mean you simple adapt to whatever style the Captain chooses to adopt. You run the risk of assuming that Captains are somehow infallible. Without concrete, external standards, you risk having a Captain who is in fact a chameleon- a volatile, situational-reactive person. That's not command- it's reaction. Captains are put in place to enforce standards that all are held accountable for- including the Captain. To assume that as a Captain you are somehow above scrutiny entirely misses the point.

The FO is not the leader, true, but does possess leadership ability. Understanding what leadership actually is just as important for a subordinate as it is the commander- how else is someone to truly act in a supportive role? Anything less is just a robot. That's the problem with the "Captain is *always* right" concept.

As Socrates said, "The unexamined life is not worth living." Therefore, an unexamined leader is not worth following. A leader, regardless of what title they hold, should stand up to scrutiny. A PIC pitching a tantrum and expecting the rest of his colleagues to find this acceptable and simply adapt to it is little more than a despot in the left seat with an attitude problem.

I don't care what the circumstances are beyond this particular Captain's behavior. Yes, we all make mistakes, and we shouldn't crucify him for it, but it certainly should be condoned, emulated, or excused. The real measure of a leader is demonstrated when under pressure in less than ideal circumstances.

... or we could just sweep it under the rug and act like its not worth noticing. Nothing to see here.. nothing to learn from.. nothing to say.

Whatever you say, Captain. ;)
 
I know for a fact I never yelled or lost my temper when I was a Captain. I was especially courteous to any FO who felt like doing things his way because he's the co-captain. I vacillat as much as possible so that I'm liked.

Of course, all the above, is sarcasm. Quite frankly, 95% of our FO's were great to fly with, and the other 5% got better as they gained time in the saddle.
 
I agree with Todd.

Here's the qualification:

Before I sat left seat, I was very much like Firebird's perspective. I was working hard to learn how to be a Captain. In essence, I guess I was a "shadow" CA, and as I gained confidence in my skills, I saw my way as the "correct" method (not yet realizing the wide breadth of leadership styles that exist). I think every person goes through this in building their crew cockpit experience. You need to learn the bounds of your sphere of influence, and some of that is garnered through the much loved "experience" phrase.

In reality, until you've been in command of a crewed cockpit, most stuff you learn, file away and work on developing for your turn to Captain, is all theory. It might be some very good guesses, and lots of life experience dialed in as well. However, one finds out quickly that as a Captain, your style of leading the cockpit will go through some evolutions as your ideas on leading a cockpit are put to real world experiences.

Now, that I have had time to flush out how I like to run my show, as well as having real line experience in a myriad of situations, I'm quite set in my "comfort zone". As an FO, I make my suggestions. If what the CA wants to do doesn't get me violated, fine. Go with it. I spoke up. If it's going to get me in a heap of manure, and as is common practice at our airline, we break out Vol I or Vol II - because I'm as wrong as many times as I am correct. Have I seen guys be rude to ground staff? Yup. What do I do? Have a cup of coffee and when they're all done, I go back to work.

I have kicked gate agents off my jet before, not to be a tough guy, but at that exact time, they were exacerbating problems I was dealing with. I remember one night in IAD. I had a FA approach me and tell me she was having a problem with a passenger. I head back, and the lady was visibly upset. As I started to talk to her, it became apparent that she spoke very little English and had just gotten off Austrian. As I'm trying to communicate with her, the gate agent is standing behind me saying very loudly "Tell her she has to go, or get off! I don't have time for this!" At that point, it was late, we were parked at the "G" gates in the 170 (if you look up 'Boondoggle', it'll have a picture of that), and there is this gate agent yelling at me on a jet boarded full of folks. I asked him to leave. He said "Not until she makes up her mind!" I told him to get off the jet, and I'll let him know when I'm ready to move the jet. Was that the best solution? I don't know. I do know adding his hostility to the situation wasn't helping me communicate with a scared lady already. Turns out, she was travelling with some people who didn't make it through Customs as quick for whatever reason. I gave her my cell, she called some folks where she was going. That's all it took to resolve the situation, a little understanding and sympathy.

Now, who knows what else contributed to this guy's day. Just because the FO didn't say anything in front of the gate agent doesn't mean that nothing was said once the door was closed. There were so many issues going on, and perhaps there was the straw that broke the camel's back. Everyone's thinking there is a rogue CA when in fact there is just as great of a possibility that the dude just had all the buttons pushed at the same time. He's already convicted though.

There are people that are unfailingly Zen, and they are just as rare as people that are never, ever calm. The rest of us on the Bell Curve all have a breaking point. Help your buddies out, but there's a time and place to discuss. Just because the FO didn't jump in, doesn't mean anything wasn't said once the door was closed. Heck, maybe the CA got behind the door, sat for a second and looked at the FO and did a "Dude, I'm so sorry. I just F'd up. I really apologize. We square?"
 
Back
Top