PFT testimonials

Status
Not open for further replies.
[ QUOTE ]
Latest rumor on the Pinnacle crash is that they were doing airwork(!) and stalled the plane at 410. Somehow ended up with a dual flameout.

[/ QUOTE ]

One thing Ive learned in my short life is never trust rumor, all they do is create panic when 75% or more (thats being nice) are false or contain false information.

DE727 no disrespect man, but how do you know for sure that was a gulfstream graduate in the right seat? What is your source? Or are you just theorizing from Pinnacle hiring many of their graduates?
 
If someone were to go to the Mustang Ranch or the Bunny Ranch would that be considered PFT??
grin.gif
 
I wouldn't say it unless I had a good source. The Pinnacle post accident press release mentioned the date of hire of both crewmembers. I was told the rest by a PCL pilot who knew the Captain.
 
It's open to opinion. Do a search to form your own answer.

To me, PFJ (pay for job) is a better term for what people really disagree with. My defination is if the plane can't go without you (it requires you as a flight crewmember), and you are paying the airline to sit in that seat, it's PFJ.
 
Throw all this pay for training crap out...the big thing that has gotten everybody all bent out of shape is people working for free. And rightly so...there is an outfit in Canada where guys buy PPCs (pilot proficiency checks...essentially a checkride allowing a pilot to fly for a commercial (charter or airline) operator) and then work for free to build time. Obviously cutting down on overhead like this allows them to charge lower fares than the competition, and eventually allowed them to buy the competition. Now the f/os for the airline that got bought out had their salaries reduced from basically nothing (like most of us make starting out) to entirely nothing. How's that for a pay cut. So anyone that gets on here and says they can't understand how buying jobs and flying for free hurts the industry is clearly not worth debating. Now that is a pretty brutal situation which has guys buying a job AND working for free. To me working for free is absolutely the worst thing anyone can do...with paying for a rating to land a job that pays you in peanuts the lesser of two evils.

Anyways, the thing that worries me most is what type of pilots are these places turning out? Anyone who is looking for the quickest and easiest way to get into the cockpit is not going to be the greatest pilot down the road. And I am not talking about flying skills and ability to pass a ride. To me the good pilots are the ones that look at every flight, no matter if they are flying the heavy metal or a 30hp ultralight, as an opportunity to learn, and make every effort to ensure they are a better pilot when they block in than they were when they departed. Something tells me that if the only effort you make to get into the cockpit is to reach back and pull out your wallet...there is a chance you may not get anything more out of your investment than a nifty set of epaulets and lot of debt.

I think the people that truly love to fly will usually take the other routes and tow banners, instruct, take aerial pictures, count ducks on ponds etc...and they'll enjoy it because they are doing what they love...and when they do move onto the next level they'll appreciate it all the more because of the effort and sacrifices they made to get there. So you folks that are thinking about buying a job or working for free or whatever else so you can jump right into that coveted RJ or 1900...think about what you might be giving up.

Anyways, the shadier operators in question are usually pretty good salesmen and I am sure a lot of good people and good pilots are sucked into these traps with fancy speeches about future pilot shortages and lost senority if you don't jump on the fast track...and unfortunately that is not going to change.
I find it hard to get too worked about about this whole PFT thing because it makes me realize how fortunate I am to get paid to do something that others are lining up to pay tens of thousands of dollars to do.
 
[ QUOTE ]
If someone were to go to the Mustang Ranch or the Bunny Ranch would that be considered PFT??

[/ QUOTE ]

Sure! For our young guns on here, it would be initial training -- much like the Private certificate

For those of us who are married, it would be recurrent training ...
grin.gif


In the PFT, PFJ context, however, we're not exactly a required crewmember, so we're paying just to raise and lower the flaps
cool.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
If someone were to go to the Mustang Ranch or the Bunny Ranch would that be considered PFT??
grin.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah, man. That would be considered Pay For T**ts.
 
I don't like the idea of super low time guys in the right seat of jets. Checkride passing or not, they don't have the overall experience level to be in the seat.....just my opinion.

SO...you'd say someone who's flown F-16's and has 600 total hours would make you uncomfortable.
Most of the space shuttle pilots only have 3000 total hours or so...but their quality of training is superb...so as long as you have training, and know what you're doing, TT doesn't matter nearly as much,

NOW>...if anyone's going to talk about Everest...first of all, get your facts straight; it wasn't 17 people and it wasn't 1995.
It was 9 people and it was May 1996. If you ever get a chance to see "Everest" the IMAX film it's excellent.
Krakauer's book is generally considered misinformed about some critical details of what happened after the storm hit and trapped them above Camp IV, in the Death Zone (above 26,000). I've read his book, I've read "the Climb" by Anotoli Boukreev (excellent) and "Left for Dead" by Beck Weathers as well as countless other mountaineering books.
Yes Everest has become commercialized but the end result is the same: You pay the price for the CHANCE (no summit guarantee) and maybe you'll succeed or maybe you start as a guide in the USA and one day are a world-class guide being paid and sponsored to go to some places.
Or you pay for training for the CHANCE to advance your career like has been discussed.
This CFI thing is a uniquely American method and it's become the accepted way, like paying for cadetships in other countries has become the accepted way there.

Back to mountains...if anyone ever gets to read "Touching the Void" - it's the most amazing story of survival I've ever read - the movie by the same name is good, but the book is much more complete. In a nutshell, 2 friends climbing in the Andes - one takes a bad fall, breaks his leg and shatters his knee. The other tries to lower him over an icecliff, but it doesn't work - he has to cut the rope to save himself, sending his friend into a crevass below - this guy somehow gets himself out and crawls to camp days later w/true mental and physical determination. It's a great read.....
 
It is people like you that drive down wages for pilots that aren't willing to pay for a job.
It is people like you that have this way of thinking that hurts everyone else.
It is people like you that shouldn't be hired anywhere regardless how good you think you are.
 
It is people like you who are so closed-minded you can't see another perfectly good point of view.
It is people like you that are so clueless you think 700 hours of power-on stalls are more quality than 700 hours of real-time part 121 experience.
Still I wish you luck, mostly in prying open your tightly shut mind.
 
You can't compare 600 hour military pilot to 600 hr. civilian pilots. You just can't. It's comparing apples to freakin' eggplants, so don't even start with that little attempt at justification.

By the way, lruppert is right on. You're not. It's ok, you can tell me I'm full of it. I've heard it before.

Go ahead and PFT. Have a blast. In some way, shape, or form...Karma will bite you in the ass. What goes around comes around.

By the way, instructing is a lot more than just flying around doing power on stalls. Obviously, you are not an instructor. I learned more about flying in a few hundred hrs. of being an instructor in high performance singles giving instrument instruction than I did in a couple hundred flying charter in a King Air. No •!.
 
[ QUOTE ]
I don't like the idea of super low time guys in the right seat of jets. Checkride passing or not, they don't have the overall experience level to be in the seat.....just my opinion.

[/ QUOTE ]

So where do you think most of those PFT'ers are going? Pinnacle ain't go no turboprops, Lt Dan.
 
It's really a bitter pill for us civilians to swallow, but a 600-hour F-16 pilot and a 600-hour civilian pilot are, in most cases, worlds apart.

But we've already had the discussion two or three times in the last 30 days so I won't restart that debate.

I've been 'down this road' numerous times over the past 9 years (1996? Holy cow!) where experienced advice was discounted because it wasn't consistent with the person's aspirations.

But if you really want to drop $30G's on snake oil, by all means, go right ahead. But if you're ($n + $30,000) dollars in the hole complaining about a $15/hr job sometime in the future and angry because a good number of the entry level jobs have no benefits, low pay and you can't service your student loan debt, I'm not going to have much empathy -- especially after so much consistent advice we've given on the subject over the history of the website.
 
Doug, I think you should just delete every PFT thread that shows up from this point on. There are TONS of threads on it that people can dig up with the search function if they're interested in being a contestant in the race to the bottom.

I'm sick of these private pilot wannabes showing up monthly and telling me that I'm closed-minded, and my hours of flight instruction aren't worth their weight in dung (like they would have the slightest clue).
banghead.gif
 
IF I do, I won't have any regrets about it.
I'm not saying I will - I may well go the CFI route - it just boggles my mind people can be so closed-minded.
It's a perfectly good and logical route to take...you wanna land on aircraft carriers? Fly w/the Navy - don't fly 152's.
You wanna be a career CFI? Great - all pilots need you!
You wanna fly for the a commercial operation (freight or people haulers)? Do what you can to get there - if you have a chance to gain some real experience, fantastic.
600 hours military vs. civilian? You just proved my point - it's quality, not quantity. So while you 've got 700 hours of S-turns under your belt in a 152, a PFT guy has 1000 hours of valuable real experience - shooting a difficult approach in a 727 into a blizzard in Minneapolis; working in a crew environment.
Just because you work at a flight school that makes their CFI's wear airline-type uniforms (another ridiculous phony ploy) doesn't make you qualified to fly the big stuff after hundreds of hours in the little stuff.
So down the road and we meet...what are you going to do? I'm the Captain and you're the FO and we talk about our paths to the cockpit and you find out I PFTraining a few years back...you gonna request a new captain to fly with?
banghead.gif

rawk.gif
 
Then the 'powers that be' will smell conspiracy.

But seriously, the same thing happens in email every day.

People will write me a question, hoping to have a particular answer to justify decisions they're about to make. If my answer isn't consistent with their preconcieved views, they get bent out of shape.

Rinse. Repeat.

A typical discussion goes like this:

"Dear Doug, I'm going to do my training as cheaply as possible and use the money I saved to go to "XYZ" in Miami to purchase 100 hours of A-320 time so I can go to work for Northwest ASAP. I could be off probation by 22 years old and non-rev on all of my off days. Will I still need a degree with all of the A-320 time?"

You can imagine the fun I have with stuff like this.

And yes, that's based on an email which I actually received a few weeks ago.
 
[ QUOTE ]
So while you 've got 700 hours of S-turns under your belt in a 152, a PFT guy has 1000 hours of valuable real experience - shooting a difficult approach in a 727 into a blizzard in Minneapolis; working in a crew environment.
Just because you work at a flight school that makes their CFI's wear airline-type uniforms (another ridiculous phony ploy) doesn't make you qualified to fly the big stuff after hundreds of hours in the little stuff.

[/ QUOTE ]

You are a complete and utter • bag. I'm glad you think you know what I do. The only airline uniform I've ever worn, was one required BY AN AIRILNE.

By the way, I love the glasses in your avatar. They'll go nicely with your Gulfstream uniform.


Sorry Doug, I just had to say what everyone else was thinking. Adios, I'm done with this thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top