PFT testimonials

Status
Not open for further replies.
[ QUOTE ]
while the "richboy" with 250 hours does just fine because he's got a natural gift

[/ QUOTE ]

Alright, alright ... you're on to us -- the gig's up!

We're not anti-PFT, we're anti-rich people ...


... I kid, I kid
grin.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
We're not anti-PFT, we're anti-rich people ...


... I kid, I kid

[/ QUOTE ]

Actually, I am anti-rich people. I fear those different than me.
smile.gif
 
sure that could happen too in which case the richboy would get a partial refund and re-evaluate his decisions.

It obviously could go either way...AGAIN - all comes down to quality of the pilot!
banghead.gif
 
I just realized MikeD hasn't replied to this thread ... he just dropped the bait to watch the fireworks.

Slow night Mike
grin.gif
?
 
[ QUOTE ]
I just realized MikeD hasn't replied to this thread ... he just dropped the bait to watch the fireworks.

Slow night Mike
grin.gif
?

[/ QUOTE ]

Nah. I haven't had a chance to reply. I'm here at KIKR for 2 weeks of advanced aircraft accident investigation course. I only posted this thread as pure entertainment, didn't figure I'd launch WW III
grin.gif


I'm likely gonna have to kill this one........
 
[ QUOTE ]
I'm here at KIKR for 2 weeks of advanced aircraft accident investigation course

[/ QUOTE ]

Hey, you wanna fly in and take my aircraft accident investigation final next Tues? Huh? Please?
smile.gif


[ QUOTE ]
I'm likely gonna have to kill this one........

[/ QUOTE ]

Looks like it's already run the standard stalemate course in record time.
 
[quoteHey John - ask the PEA Chief Pilot what airline he flew for.

Let us know the reply ...


[/ QUOTE ]


ooo Tenney drops the bomb and runs too. LOL.

OK John2375 you have had about 5 pro pilots who have made it tell you how evil and awful this yet you still think they are full of shat? Hmmm who are you gonna trust PEAs markting department or pro-pilots not associated with any training program who are here out of the goodness of their heart?


as much as you can "justify" this program too us. Methinks an airline interview board isnt gonna give you time to justify it for them.
 
Hey John I am not anti-PFT, PFJ, PMS, or EPMD. They are all money makin' schemes, except for EPMD, but I do respect what the more senior pilots have to say. I had the same questions a few months ago and MikeD said it best, he told me that you can go any route you want but it is all a risk. All depends on what risk you wanna take and don't go cryin' about it later.
Fits with my favorite phrase "You knew it was a dangerous job before you took it", meaning if you know of the consequences in what you're doing, no sobs if you get the short end of the stick.
If I were serious about making this a profession, I wouldn't do the PFT/PFJ thing, but if I had 30K to blow I might go for it, emphasis on might. Or find some other way to get my kicks flying some heavy metal
grin.gif
 
WOW - this topic is huge

Just wondering out of curiosity what the American opinion is of cadetships that offer a job after YOU pay for your training. Qantas offers it - after you drop $80 - $100k on training, you're pretty much guaranteed a job as a SO, or if they're not ready for you - they find you a job for a couple of years and bring you back later. A couple of friends that recently finished the program are off to fly A320's as FO's in Singapore for 2 years before then moving into SO positions with the QF longhaul fleet.

And then recently there was an ad in Flight International:

Quote (re: http://www.qatarairways.com/0.12.0.0.1.0.htm)
--------------------
Cadet Pilot / Second Officer (Ref: CP/SO/503/04)


Candidates must hold a valid ICAO Commercial Pilot’s License with Instrument Rating & frozen ATPL from a recognized flying school. Proficiency in both written and spoken English is essential and only candidates below 29 years of age will be considered. Preference will be given to candidates with tertiary education, especially in Science or Engineering.

Successful candidates will be provided training for a type rating on one of the Company’s fleets and be required to sign a training bond that will require them to serve Qatar Airways from joining until 5 years after their date of appointment as First Officer. In addition, the successful candidate will be required to repay a part of his training cost at the rate of QAR 1,800 (approx USD 494) a month for 5 years from his appointment as First Officer.

Successful applicants will be paid a salary of QAR 7000 (approx USD 1910) as a Cadet Pilot / Second Officer and be provided with Company housing, on a shared basis, or an allowance of QAR 3,500 per month in lieu of housing.

A First Officer in Qatar Airways will earn an all inclusive average monthly remuneration package of approximately QAR 24,800 (approx USD 6800) inclusive of housing and other allowances. Other benefits include meal allowances, school fee subsidy for children and Loss of Licence/Medical/Group Life Insurances. All remuneration is currently tax-free.
-------------------------

Whether it's $30k for a training bond or a full type rating - does it really make a difference in the view of the pilot community. $30k is $30k

I'm under the impression that European airlines have been doing this for ages but have heard that airlines like the BA cadetship scheme don't require you to pay any cash - correct me if I'm wrong thou.

-- whats the opinions??

-kyle
 
Well Im just a pion so I doubt my opion matters much, but I have a couple questions?

Do you need to be a good teacher to be a good airline pilot?

If its not, then please answer the next few:

Im going into my third career here. I was a computer tech for 3 years and a truck driver for another 3. Durring my days truck driving there were so many trainers out there just taking students to make more money by getting more miles and a "slave" to drive those miles. All the trainer would care about is miles(which would equate to the truck you see rolled over on the side of the road on the way to the airport) and not the quality of the instruction(I had one, but luckily I was smart enough to change trainers and get one that really cared to teach). With this in mind isn't it better to have guys who actually want to instruct instruct students and build there time that way and have another outlet if they are not military qualified so they can go for the PFT or PFJ route? I don't know about anyone else but the thought of having an instructor who is there just to build hours is more scarry to me than someone who is paying for a job. I mean come on these are the guys training everyone how to fly not only commercially but privately to. Do you really want to share the sky with a pilot who was trained by someone who was just teaching to pass the time and really could care less?


2nd when it comes to Gulfstream academy there is a guy who lists on www.willflyforfood.cc(which I assume is a pretty accurate site from what I read on the message boards here.) who got hired by Pinnacle with 400TT 150 multi turbine(Im assumeing SIC since he mentions Gulfstream in his interview report). Is this guy just an anomaly? Is there any other reason they would have hired him?

3rd 99.5% of the general public(non pilots or aviation enthusiasts) are affraid of flying and if they had it their way, no guy under 50 would be flying their airliner anyway so bringing in their oppinion on flight deck matters is like bringing in a Texas oil magnet with no aviation expirience to run a major airline. Its just stupid and a petty way to drive a point. While I am not a proffesional pilot yet, it tends to make me think low of proffessionals in any proffesion who bring in oppinions from people not in their field.

4th, Can anyone actually bring up a factual NTSB report of a PART 121 carrier having a fatal crash caused by one of these PFT/PFJ guys? They do have to go through the same training any FO goes through dont they?

Well sorry for the long post I dont mean for this to be adding fuel to a fire, but I was just wondering from my expierience and research Ive looked at.

On a personal note, I am not considering Gulfstream, Tab, etc.. because I am actually looking foward to being a flight instructor while building time since I love to teach and want to teach(If it wasnt for the low pay and no benefits, being an instructor would be my goal). Money is also a factor, but even if I had 30k, I probably wouldnt do it, besides polarbears hate Florida, lol
spin2.gif
 
my 2 cents....

No, CFI'ing isn't for everyone, but if you don't want to instruct that doesn't mean you have to PFT. I work with guys who started out doing aerial photog and box hauling as well as some who PFT'd. In my meager experience as a professional pilot I can already tell the difference. It's more evident in attitude and professionalism than flying ability.


That said, CFI'ing is probably your fastest and most economical route to success. I did it for less than 6 months and ended up with a paying job in the right seat of a regional airliner. Truth be known I had the financial resources to plunk down 30 grand to a PFT outfit if I wanted to. Trying not to sound too cliche, but the path of least resistance is not always the path that yeilds the greatest rewards. The CFI checkride is no picnic, especially if you take it outside the protective umbrella of a pipeline-type flight academy. People on interview boards realize this. Earning that certificate (and using it) is definitely something that will help you down the road.
 
"who got hired by Pinnacle with 400TT 150 multi turbine(Im assumeing SIC since he mentions Gulfstream in his interview report). Is this guy just an anomaly? Is there any other reason they would have hired him?"

Not an anomaly. Pinnacle sucks up Gstream guys. Don't know where they would go if it wasn't for Pinnacle. Don't know the "deal" between PCL and Gstream. Does this make PFJing right? A) I think PFJ is morally reprehensible and B) I don't like the idea of super low time guys in the right seat of jets. Checkride passing or not, they don't have the overall experience level to be in the seat.....just my opinion.

"PART 121 carrier having a fatal crash caused by one of these PFT/PFJ guys?"

"Caused"? are you kidding me. No report will ever say that. Accidents are a chain of events. You remove one link from the chain and the accident is prevented. Super low time jet F/O's only weaken a link with their lack of experience. They won't directly cause an accident, unless the Capt screws up big time.

The crew of the Pinnacle CRJ that went down after going to FL410 on a ferry flight consisted of a Capt who was new to the plane and an F/O who was from Gstream and had only been a PCL for a few months.
 
I have two comments:

1) Latest rumor on the Pinnacle crash is that they were doing airwork(!) and stalled the plane at 410. Somehow ended up with a dual flameout.

2) The title of this thread is "PFT Testimonials." I haven't been reading every word, but has there been one positive testimonial yet?

Enuff said.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Well here we go again...
This board is EXTREMELY biased towards the *only* way to make it this biz is to flight instruct. Well I hate to tell you but some of us our not comfortable being instructors - that always gets taken as "instructors are lower class pilots" or "instructing is a waste". Nothing could be more wrong - instructing is one of the greatest things anyone can do - sharing knowledge and skill to help others - that's great. But let's face it - some are better than others. Just because you can fly great, doesnt' make you a great instructor. Just because you can play the piano great, doestn' mean you can or should be an instructor.
I still don't see how paying for training is hurting the industry - is paying (renting aircraft) for time taken as an attack on the airplane-selling industry? You dont hear great outcry from airplane manufacturers that everyone should OWN their own individual plane and not rent others...that renting somehow ruins their business.
Paying for training doesn't hurt anyone - it simply means the company is not willing to take chance on you because of your lack of experience...SO - if you're willing and able to pay for the training, then they'll hire you IF you pass all necessary checkrides - I think there's an assumption around here that if you pay for your training, you're guaranteed the job of FO and even if you dont' know an aileron from an elevon you'll still get the job. NOT TRUE - you must pass just a stringent flight check as Doug himself would if he were seeking the job.
I've emailed with several companies and asked their opinions about PFT programs vs. CFI route. From what I've gotten in responses, they see pros and cons of both - a PFT guy will have much more VALUABLE REALWORLD experience. A CFI will be more authoritative since he's been the PIC w/his ticket on the line each time going up.

Let's say you want to climb Mt. Everest - you're a good mountain climber but not someone who's ever attempted anything above 22,000 feet let's say. Are you going to get a job as a mountain guide, and spend countless days leading people up Mt. Rainier and other lower peaks in the USA, thinking that one day you'll all of a sudden be guiding on Everest? Of course not - if you're going to do one of 2 things, more likely the first: You're going to PAY - you're going to shell out in the neighborhood of $60,000 to join a guided expedition to Everest - and the summit isn't even guaranteed - it all depends on your luck, conditioning, the weather, etc,etc. Is "PFC" (pay for climbing) wrong? Of course not...I don't hear great mountaineers like Ed Viesturs screaming foul that people are shelling out money while he's busy getting sponsors to pay for his expeditions. The other thing you could do is if you have some extensive experience, you could sign on as a guide - UNPAID though - the expedition will finance your trip but you won't be paid - if you do a good job then maybe you'll be asked to be a fulltime guide on the high-altitude peaks but even that's not guaranteed. My point is, people pay to get what they want all the time - it doesn't mean they think less of those who work hard as instructors. If you pay $60K to climb Everest - you achieved your goal and no one's going to think more or less of you. If you pay to get great training and gain valuable flight time, no one SHOULD think less of you..
Maybe it's jealousy - if you all of a sudden had $30K in your hand, there's not one person here who wouldn't plunk it down on a program and fly for a Gulfstream or Great Lakes or a 727 freight company or whoever rather than teach S-turns for the 150th time. Will anyone here admit it? Of course not - risk of being flamed or thought of badly? But I don't care - I think PFT is great if that's the direction you want to go - I haven't decided if I want to go the CFI route or the FPT route yet...but I'm also not afraid to express what I think,

[/ QUOTE ]

It's funny you mention that, in May 1995, 17 people died on Everest. The majority of these people were rich folk led up the mountain on guided tours.

The underlying cause of these deaths?

Inexperienced climbers attempting to do something they weren't qualified for. You should try reading "Into Thin Air", it's a good read.

And eight bucks an hour? You can barely call that a job, I get paid more to throw boxes into tractor trailers.
 
actually the PFTing of Everest has made Everest lose alot of respect in the mountain climbing community. Any John Doe can plop down money and get their ass led up Everest.

K2 now thats a different story. In one year alone K2 killed 50% of those who attempted it.
 
[ QUOTE ]
actually the PFTing of Everest has made Everest lose alot of respect in the mountain climbing community. Any John Doe can plop down money and get their ass led up Everest.

K2 now thats a different story. In one year alone K2 killed 50% of those who attempted it.

[/ QUOTE ]

Those are great odds 50/50 chance of living
confused.gif
Are people still signing up for this climb? I'm just a good ol' boy from Inglewood, California but my K2 is a kindergarden class on the 2nd trackof the semester.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top