PFT testimonials

Status
Not open for further replies.
"there are many who love to instruct, don't necessarily want to go to the airlines, and are quite content spreading the joy of flying while instructing at a Part 61 program."
Exactly - and that's fantastic - I was lucky enough to be taught by 2 outstanding instructors who did it not to build time and get out, but for their true love of teaching and they were fantastic at it!

"2)PFT hurts the industry in this manner. If a student is flying an aircraft requiring two crewmembers, he/she is paying a company to occupy a seat and log hours in which the company should be paying for a qualified crewmember"
I still don't see this point - you're NOT paying to fly!! You are paying for your training and IF SELECTED you are paid for your work.
banghead.gif


"If you poll the American public, I'm sure 99.5% of them want qualified crewmembers flying their aircraft, not training students and very-low time pilots who just paid to sit there"
What if people heard Gulfstream had lowtime pilots flying there??
 
[ QUOTE ]
I still don't see this point - you're NOT paying to fly!! You are paying for your training and IF SELECTED you are paid for your work.

[/ QUOTE ]

last time i checked the only FO's gulfstream hired were the ones that bent over and paid 30,000 bucks. So yes you are buying a job.
 
Maybe at Gulfstream that's true- I also notice they only pay $8/hr. for 250 hours in 6 months..
programs that pay you $45/hr for 60 hours/month make for a decent salary though
 
Actually, it falls to a misnomer. It should be PFJ (Pay for job) instead of PFT. Hell, I PFT all day long. It's not like my instructor is going to train me for free. Here's the deal with Gulfstream, TAB Airline, etc....

They charge you $30K for the pleasure of an FO position. In return, you get the turbine time in the left seat. NOT PIC time no matter how you cut it, unless you want to log it illegally. You also get paid $7-8/hr. Dude, RAMPERS make more than that. You're paying $30K for a job that the company should be paying someone else for. I have absolutely no problem with someone spending $30K to fly around in a King Air or B1900 all day long, the trick is getting that where they can legally log the time while not taking the job away from a qualified crew member. Why is Commutair flying essentially the same type routes on the same equipment as Continental Connection but they have minimums for their first officers instead of a $30K "buy in?"

There are several different ways to build time other than instruct. Instructing is just the easiest way to get hired to fly with low hours. Insurance companies are killing the low time pilot jobs. Banner towing operations (if you can find one left thanks to the wonderful new DoHS rules) are great. However, even some of those are going PFJ. Txpilot is flying with an aerial survey company, there's a few pipeline jobs out there, and traffic watch is still a good option (friend of mine was flying traffic watch in LIT until the company shut down). There's even a few VFR-135 gigs you can get at 500 hours. It's not that we're biased towards CFIing, that's just the choice most of us have made. I'm working towards my CFI right now, but I'm also keeping the other options open as well. If I can get a VFR 135 gig at 500 hours, I'll take it, same goes with pipeline or traffic watch. Hell, I'm even willing to move to Alaska for a bush pilot job. I don't have $30K to waste on buying time, though. That's one of the reasons I opted not to go to MAPD. I could spend $12K on a little bit of Baron time and some CRJ sim time and HOPE for a job, or I could spend $12K on my CFI ratings and be more marketable.

Flight training is all about the individual choices, and everyone has to make the decision for themselves, good or bad.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Maybe it's jealousy - if you all of a sudden had $30K in your hand, there's not one person here who wouldn't plunk it down on a program and fly for a Gulfstream or Great Lakes or a 727 freight company or whoever rather than teach S-turns for the 150th time.

[/ QUOTE ]John, that's a pretty BIG assumption there. And you know what Samuel Jackson says about assumptions - "they make an ass out of you and 'mption' "
smile.gif


I can honestly say if I had an extra 30 G's no way in heck would I plunk it down at any of the operators you mention. Proof of that is that I have 30 G's in VA bennies. Did I take that and waste Uncle Sam's $$ at Gulfstream like I could easily have done? No, I'm using that money at a small flight school in the FPR area that advertises on JC. Maybe I was raised differently, but I have peace of mind knowing I earned a job rather than paid for it.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Maybe it's jealousy - if you all of a sudden had $30K in your hand, there's not one person here who wouldn't plunk it down on a program and fly for a Gulfstream or Great Lakes or a 727 freight company or whoever rather than teach S-turns for the 150th time.

[/ QUOTE ]

Um, here's your one person right here. I've got better uses for $30K. I could pay off some loans, buy a new car, downpayment on a house, save for my kids college, etc. This coming from someone that's older than most of the guys just getting hired with Pinnacle and XJT. Sure I'd love to get the jump start, but I'd rather be smart with my money.

[ QUOTE ]
Of course not - risk of being flamed or thought of badly? But I don't care - I think PFT is great if that's the direction you want to go - I haven't decided if I want to go the CFI route or the FPT route yet...but I'm also not afraid to express what I think,

[/ QUOTE ]

First off, good for you for making your own decision. Second, don't make assumptions like that. Trust me, I've stood up to Doug, Mike, JT, flyover, and just about everyone else on this board when our opinions differ. Check out some of the posts on Mesa Airlines, etc. However, I also LISTEN to the otherside to see what they have to say. Sometimes they say something I haven't thought of, and sometimes it works the other way around.
 
ONCE AGAIN...
It is NOT NOT NOT **PAY FOR JOB** It is PAY FOR TRAINING...once again...pay for TRAINING!
If you flunk out, you do NOT get a JOB...you get NOTHING but a percentage of the cost refunded..Jesus!
banghead.gif
banghead.gif
banghead.gif


Some programs like Gulfstream are not financially lucrative - some that pay $45/hour ARE financially lucrative and experience-lucrative.
 
It IS pay for job. You pay them $30K, you get a job for $7 and hour. You don't pay them $30K, you don't get a job for $7 an hour. Hell, you can get a B1900 TYPE rating for less than that. Think Gulfstream would hire you with that? No, since you didn't write the check for $30K to THEM.

I'll say it again. How is it that Commutair is a mirror of Gulfstream, yet they have published experience mins for their FOs while Gulfstream has a "buy in" for their "training" program.
 
[ QUOTE ]
ONCE AGAIN...
It is NOT NOT NOT **PAY FOR JOB** It is PAY FOR TRAINING...once again...pay for TRAINING!
If you flunk out, you do NOT get a JOB...you get NOTHING but a percentage of the cost refunded..Jesus!
banghead.gif
banghead.gif
banghead.gif


Some programs like Gulfstream are not financially lucrative - some that pay $45/hour ARE financially lucrative and experience-lucrative.

[/ QUOTE ]

Here's the test... Can they fly the flight legally without a pilot in that seat?

If NO - then you are paying to take a required crewmember job for an appropriately rated and expirienced pilot who should be PAID to sit there.

If YES - then you are getting training. Logging is a different animal all together.. that's been discussed elsewhere on how to log that time, but... Essentially you have to be rated in cat and class and be the sole manipulator of the controls to log it as PIC time. BUT since the second crew member isn't required, you can't log it as SIC time...
So alot of the time you are just paying to sit in that seat and keep it warm.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Maybe it's jealousy - if you all of a sudden had $30K in your hand, there's not one person here who wouldn't plunk it down on a program and fly for a Gulfstream or Great Lakes or a 727 freight company or whoever rather than teach S-turns for the 150th time.


[/ QUOTE ]

Hahahaaaa, ROFL!

If I was Commercial-ME-instrument rated, with CFI-I-MEI qualifications, I'd spend the 30K on getting a fractional ownership of a multi engine plane, and fly over weekends with my family/friends.

Give it to Gulfstream so I can pay my way into the B1900? That's toooooo stupid.

I'd rather offer to be the target holder at my local archery club.



[ QUOTE ]
It IS pay for job. You pay them $30K, you get a job for $7 and hour. You don't pay them $30K, you don't get a job for $7 an hour. Hell, you can get a B1900 TYPE rating for less than that. Think Gulfstream would hire you with that? No, since you didn't write the check for $30K to THEM.

I'll say it again. How is it that Commutair is a mirror of Gulfstream, yet they have published experience mins for their FOs while Gulfstream has a "buy in" for their "training" program.



[/ QUOTE ]

yeahthat.gif
 
If I had $30G's, a commercial/instrument and some hours behind my belt, I'd have to be a fool to drop that type of loot to fly around a Beech 1900.

I'd put the money away in a growth-stock mutual fund and forget it was there.

I wouldn't be any more jealous of a person dropping $30G's for a job than I'd be jealous of a custodian in an adult bookstore in the pre-Gulliani Times Square.
 
It IS pay for job.

But it's NOT pay for job!
argue.gif

banghead.gif

At Gulfstream it's a ripoff, I agree...but to spend 30G and in the end make around 45G back PLUS have the experience...priceless!
NO it's not PIC time and I'd never log it as such...but at least you've got a much better shot at getting a job or staying on with them getting PIC time.

Here's a question: You're a Delta Captain, and while shooting the breeze w/your FO invariably your route to the cockpit surely comes up...the FO says "yada yada yada and then I flew w/ XYZ outfit - I paid 30G for the training but the experience got me where I wanted to be..." What's the Captain going to think? say? Probably nothing...like I said I've emailed/spoken w/several Chief Pilots and NONE see anything wrong w/FPT at all - it's got as many good pilots and bad pilots as the CFI's out there - some good ones and some who really should think about doing something else.
rawk.gif
 
Define 'contradiction:'

[ QUOTE ]
It IS pay for job.

But it's NOT pay for job!


[/ QUOTE ]

[ QUOTE ]
I've emailed/spoken w/several Chief Pilots and NONE see anything wrong w/FPT at all - it's got as many good pilots and bad pilots as the CFI's out there - some good ones and some who really should think about doing something else.


[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah! Gulfstream chief pilots...
 
NOT true at all. Anyone with a bunch of cash can sit in the right seat. But to have someone give you money to perform a service - flying airplanes - means a while lot more. People paid to fly are held to a higher standard because something is expected of them in return for their pay.

To dumb it down for you, take golf for example. Anyone can pay a few bucks to play a round of golf. But to be paid to golf you have to know what you're doing.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Maybe it's jealousy - if you all of a sudden had $30K in your hand, there's not one person here who wouldn't plunk it down on a program and fly for a Gulfstream or Great Lakes or a 727 freight company or whoever rather than teach S-turns for the 150th time.

[/ QUOTE ]

Bullcaca.

I can very easily raise that amount of capital if I want to.

I'm not going to Gulfstream.

The idea of paying someone for something they should be paying me for just pisses me off. Call me crazy.
 
Actually no I haven't spoken w/Gulfstream and I won't - I didn't even know about them until today but after what I see, I don't like it.

I just wish people didn't see as "ruining the industry" It's not doing that at all, just like people w/only a half-assed ability to climb a mountain and pay serious money to be guided aren't sneered at by those who've got the expereince and ability to guide them.
 
We probably go down the road about once a month, but it's like this.

Paying for a job absolutely unequivocably denigrates the industry.

Why on earth should a Beech 1900 operation pay a first officer a decent wage while his competition is keeping costs low and profits high by taking advantage of low time pilots by selling the job?

I know, I know, most of the forum regulars know it's a 'rhetorical question' because those that tolerate these type programs will normally avoid answering the question altogether.

Take it from an industry professional, it further erodes the profession.
 
Doug, I have the HIGHEST respect for you, first of all, but we don't see eye to eye on this.
Once again I'm not talking about the damn Beach1900 Gulfstream crap - that's a ripoff.
I"m talking about other programs that are worthwhile.
I see it as Pay For **TRAINING* which we've all done from day 1. If you pay an FBO to get your CFI licenses and then they hire you on after to work..voila! Same as paying a training outfit for training on a 727 or whatever and in return, you've got a job paying $45/hour.
banghead.gif

I wish I was drunk today after all this!
cwm27.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top