PFT testimonials

Status
Not open for further replies.
[ QUOTE ]
SO...you'd say someone who's flown F-16's and has 600 total hours would make you uncomfortable.

[/ QUOTE ]

Are you kidding me?

I know a guy who flew 16s. If you think for one second that the amount of training is even the slightest bit comparable to the training that you get from a PFT place -- well, just don't say it to his face, because it will get very ugly.

Do you know what the selection rate is for UPT? And the washout rate?

Let me tell you something, it takes a lot more to get selected for UPT, much less get through it, than the ability to write a check for $30K.

He came this close to washing out, and you know why? He had a stomach virus and did a couple of touch and goes during the summer in Oklahoma. Well, his stomach touched and went.

Dude was sick for a couple of days, and he almost washed out That is how tight they are.

Don't compare the ability to get through a program with standards that are that tough to the ability to write a $30K check.
 
Quote:
This CFI thing is a uniquely American method and it's become the accepted way, like paying for cadetships in other countries has become the accepted way there.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Thanks America for that!!. If hard work and "working your way through the ranks" wasn't the American way, many of us will NEVER get a shot to make it.
 
Nope, but I'm going to tell you to not talk with me for the rest of the trip. You tell me what checklist you want run and I'll run it. I don't want to be associated with people that are destroying the profession that I'm busting butt and sacraficing a lot to break in to.

Furthermore, when are you going to get it through your head that you're not being $30,000 worth of "training" and "experience" to be "evaluated for a job." IT'S BULL! And you bought it hook line and sinker. Maybe you realized that and you're just trying to cover for youself so you don't look like a complete fool, but what you are doing is paying a company for a position that is NORMALLY paid and REQUIRED BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT to be there. Don't you get it? By doing this, you are yanking a job out from under someone that has BUSTED BUTT to meet the minimum qualifications to get the same job at any other company. Let me point you in the direction of something.

http://www2.allatps.com/PilotJobs/default.lasso?page=airline&airline=33

You see that is the hiring information for Commutair, which is also a CAL Express carrier (which is who Gulfstream "works" for). You notice that the LOWEST NUMBER OF HOURS they'll think about hiring you on with is 900 hours? So let's look at this.

You have to have 250 hours at Gulfstream to even "fly" for them, then they give you another 250. That equals 500. So now you've got 500 hours and you don't meet Commutair's min hiring requirements, and you're nowhere near what is competitive. Congrats, you just got bent over and can't find a job. That is unless Pinnacle wants to hire you, and if they're not hiring then you're left flat on your butt extorted.

But let's say you do get a job; you've just ripped this job out from under me, and I don't like people that do that too much. Maybe you can see now why people would equate you to a scab (which you might be alright with too since you don't seem to care about anyone but yourself). Scabs steal jobs from people that rightfully earned them, and so do guys that buy their jobs. That dosen't make anyone that has EARNED their job by PAYING THEIR DUES in a horrible schedule and bad pay feel very good. That's why we're so emotional about this pay for job crap, because that could be the job that we want at least a chance to compete for, and we don't want some insignifigant rich boy to rip away from us when we're the ones that put the time in and didn't just drop $30,000 on some "training."

So there's my PFT rant for the month. Go ahead, steal my job; but don't expect me to do much more than run a checklist for you.
 
John2375 -- your point was no proven.

You cannot buy quality.

600 hours of F-16 time doesn't denote "quality" because the difference in the candidate isn't how fast their burning Jet-A, the difference in the cadidates is the screening.

A 600 hour F-16 pilot, off the bat, has a bachelors degree, passed a rigorous as hell selection phase, passed physical and cognitive tests, passed an astronaut physical, succeeded in Undergraduate Pilot Training (UPT) to the point where he was awarded a highly desirable F-16 slot, passed advanced pilot training, passed fighter lead-in school and was then was thrown 'the keys' to an F-16.

MikeD, correct me if I'm wrong, but that 600-hour pilot our young Jedis try to compare themselves to is probably part of that 40% that didn't wash out along the way.

[ QUOTE ]
I'm the Captain and you're the FO and we talk about our paths to the cockpit and you find out I PFTraining a few years back...you gonna request a new captain to fly with?

[/ QUOTE ]

Being a captain doesn't mean that you're good, it just means that you were senior enough to bid it and got by the checkride. Certainly don't look for instant respect from your peers when you add the fourth stripe because you're going to get your feelings hurt!
smile.gif
 
Speaking of military, can we give MikeD the "Drop a Bomb and Disappear" award?
smile.gif
First he targets my house on a training sortie now he drops a bomb in the forums!
smile.gif


Gotta love that kid!
 
He's practicing for his new airplane!

Nobody sees you come in, you drop your bomb, and then nobody sees you when you leave.
 
I just love how despite all the professionals on the board trying to impart some sort of wisdom...there are so many that just won't listen to the advise. If you are unwilling to take constructive critisism from those more experienced than yourself...what kind of pilot are you going to be down the road? The ones that 'have all the answers' are usually the ones that kill people down the road.

[ QUOTE ]
IF I do, I won't have any regrets about it.

[/ QUOTE ]

That's a bold statement...how do you know that? A day ago I thought to myself "If I read this PFT thread, I won't have any regrets about it"...
 
[ QUOTE ]
I just love how despite all the professionals on the board trying to impart some sort of wisdom...there are so many that just won't listen to the advise. If you are unwilling to take constructive critisism from those more experienced than yourself...what kind of pilot are you going to be down the road? The ones that 'have all the answers' are usually the ones that kill people down the road.

[/ QUOTE ]
Well said.
 
[ QUOTE ]
You see that is the hiring information for Commutair, which is also a CAL Express carrier (which is who Gulfstream "works" for). You notice that the LOWEST NUMBER OF HOURS they'll think about hiring you on with is 900 hours? So let's look at this.


[/ QUOTE ]

Ya know, John makes a very interesting point. Let's say Pinnacle stops hiring. Where are all these Gulfstream grads gonna go? They only have 500 TT. So what if it's turbine ME, most insurance companies underwrite based on TT. So, if Pinnacle (or "insert airline agreement company here") stops hiring, that 250 TT someone just shelled out cold hard cash for is about as useful as 152 time.
 
If you want to split hairs, yes it was 1996. But TWELVE people died in May 1996 as a direct result of Everest, not seventeen and not nine. Perhaps it is you who should get your facts straight.

A lot of what happened in the span of those two days is not known as the participants are now dead. A lot of what Krakauer and Boukreev published is based on conjecture and educated guesses. At least Krakaouer acknowledged this in his book, Boukreev devoted a large portion of his book to attacking Krakauer. It depends on whose spin on it you believe, I'm inclined to believe Krakauer because he seems a bit more honest about it and he's not going out of his way to discredit the now deceased Boukreev. I digress though, we could debate this all day.

Whatever the facts are, it doesn't change the fact that one of the leading causes to this disaster was the fact that there were inexperienced, unskilled people on that mountain that shouldn't have been up there. Everyone agrees on this. In a way, and the point I was trying to make, is that it is rather synonomous with PFT/PFJ, whatever you care to call it.
 
[ QUOTE ]
IF I do, I won't have any regrets about it.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes you will. I've worked with hundreds who have and they do one of 3 things:

1) They hide it (lie about it actually.)
2) They are always rationalizing it ("Well I didn't have a choice for <blah blah balh>)
3) They flaunt it and dare you to argue with them.

In any case they are never popular in the crew rooms - and YES - we KNOW who you ARE.
rolleyes.gif


I heard one Furloughed AA pilot describe PFT/PFJers (whatever initials you want to call them) as "one notch above scab in the food chain."
 
[ QUOTE ]


You have to have 250 hours at Gulfstream to even "fly" for them, then they give you another 250. That equals 500. So now you've got 500 hours and you don't meet Commutair's min hiring requirements, and you're nowhere near what is competitive. Congrats, you just got bent over and can't find a job. That is unless Pinnacle wants to hire you, and if they're not hiring then you're left flat on your butt extorted.



[/ QUOTE ]


This happened to a guy I met a few years ago. As soon as he got his 250 hrs in the 1900, he got the boot along with many others to make room for the next $30K "qualified" pilot. He was a 500 hour pilot that wasn't hireable by anyone. He finally nutted up more cash to get his CFI to build more hours to become hireable at an airline. Heard he finally got a job flying 1900's for someone. The longer you're around this biz, the more you will see that PFT companies and the such are not good for pilots long term. They are great for the companies involved bottom line, that's about it. It's short term satisfaction for a few that are willing to pay, but a long term detriment to the overall well being of your profession.

A little bit of advise John, until you are on the other end of the stick for awhile (long enough to make an informed decision from both sides of the fence), don't assume that there is nothing wrong with these types of programs. You'll know what I mean when you get there. It might even save your head. What is that old saying "Doc, my head hurts when I do this"-
banghead.gif

"Well, says the Doc, don't do that."

Learn a bit more (especially when you're actually flying for an airline), then you might not bang your head so much in these debates.
 
The places that require their CFI's to wear airline-type uniforms are PHONY BALONEY!
I've never wanted anything to do with a place that does that - I only want to use places where the CFI's wear jeans and a baseball cap.

ONCE AGAIN - I'm not minimizing CFI work - it's valuable and great - no one seems to understand that, but I'm not saying it's useless time. And I may indeed be doing it myself, so there.
HOWEVER, paying for training is not wrong bad or hurtful - if the industry didn't have such ridiculous prerequisites then people could have a fair shot.
There's hundreds maybe thousands of perfeclty good PILOTS out there who'll never get to live their dream and help companies fly their airplanes because they don't feel comfortable TEACHING and are blackballed because of it.
Eatsleep'n'fly - calling me a douchebag is uncalled for - again an example of how closed minded you and others are - I'm pro FPT and may not even do it!! I may go CFI and enjoy it and have a student who asks about it and I will NOT slam it infact I'd obviously say go-for-it if you think it's what YOU want to do.
Once again - other countries this is the accepted way - pay for your SPECIFIC training instead of spending $ and too much time mastering skills that aren't necessary unless it's what you want to do. Wanna be an aerobatic pilot? Then of course you better for sure master skills very different from flying an airliner or freightliner. Last time I checked though Delta didn't approve of doing Cuban-8's!
Point being...is being a CFI useless *** NNNNOOOO!!! ***
But is 700 hours of explaining FAR Rul # 61.23 or whatever useful when flying a 747 into LAX? Probably not.
rawk.gif
 
I saw it written somewhere else in this thread, but I'm gonna say the same thing again, cause it's true. I've got about 300 hrs dual given now, and I'm 3 times the pilot I was just 4 months ago when I started instructing. You get to see all the mistakes people make, and believe me, you learn more from that, than you do during any training for ratings. I went to an "academy" (if you want to call ATP that, I don't think it really is, but whatever), and felt like I walked out of there professionally trained, and hot-shiat. That changed in my first month of CFI'ing, I realized how much I really didn't know yet. The saying goes "you don't really learn something until you teach it". I believe that 100%, after seeing it firsthand. In large part, this is because if you don't know something offhand, you're sure to look it up so you don't look unprofessional to your student. How likely are you to do that, if you're sitting right seat and "have a captain there to make sure you don't do anything wrong"? Sure, you may have 250 hrs (or however much) of Part 121 operating experience if you PFT, but how well does that prepare you to make decisions when something goes wrong? Or to make decisions in general. Being a CFI teaches you more SA and decision making, I believe, than 500 hrs in the right seat ever could.

For those of you saying you're not "cut out" to teach, BS. I didn't think I would be either, really didn't think I could teach, really didn't want to teach, but I manned up, cause I knew the valuable experience I'd receive from it. Turns out, I can teach, and I enjoy it too! If you're truly the pilot you believe you are, then you should have no problems with it after the first month or so. I truly think people who say they "can't teach" are just taking the easy and cowards way out, rather than pushing themselves outside of their comfort zone, and giving it a shot.

And to reiterate another point that's been brought up numerous times, people telling you this stuff are PROFESSIONAL PILOTS, as in they're where you want to be. Why would you discount their advice??!!?? I know I listen very carefully to what these people say, granted I don't take it at face value, but after considering it, it usually makes good sense to me.

There's my $10 on this issue, take it for what it's worth, from someone who's "in the trenches" currently CFI'ing.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Once again - other countries this is the accepted way - pay for your SPECIFIC training instead of spending $ and too much time mastering skills that aren't necessary unless it's what you want to do. Wanna be an aerobatic pilot? Then of course you better for sure master skills very different from flying an airliner or freightliner. Last time I checked though Delta didn't approve of doing Cuban-8's!
Point being...is being a CFI useless *** NNNNOOOO!!! ***
But is 700 hours of explaining FAR Rul # 61.23 or whatever useful when flying a 747 into LAX? Probably not.
rawk.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

I don't think you totally understand the value of doing these "useless" maneuvers. No, they don't specifically relate to airline flying, but all planes fly the same. The more experience you get learning "the basics" and some of the advanced maneuvers, that teach the finer points of controlling an airplane and really flying it, the better pilot you are, which means the more equipped you are to handle the unexpected. If you do end up going the route of CFI, which I hope you do, you'll understand what I'm saying.
 
First...I'm sorry I misspoke on Everest - it was indeed 12; I was forgetting the Taiwanese team.
Anyway - Boukreev does not spend the entire book attacking Krakauer - maybe a few pages of disagreement but his story is in my opinion much more accurate and insightful than Krakauer who seems to just make assumptions and anyway - that's not for this board!
And yes commercialization of Everest has hurt it - if they didn't make the fee so outragoues you wouldn't get a majority being rich exclusive people w/no mountaineering experience trying to do it! Lower the fee and you'll get many more true mountaineers who want to do it but can't afford to shell out $60K or more.
W/flying -don't make the minimums so outrageous and you'll get perfectly good pilots coming through the ranks;

As far as American-way being hardwork - that's true - and you guys who think PFTraining is the easyway out are the sorely mistaken ones - that's why it's not PFJob. If it were, you'd get any ass w/a flying dream there. Because it's PFTraining, you get people who want to fly, going a specific route, paying money to get trained - if they wash out, too bad - it's on them that they're out 30grand and still have no job.
If you pass the checkrides and are qualified, then you're qualified.
And as far as F-16 pilots? Yes they're more qualified because of their training even w/lower time, but just because you have good cognitive skills and can pass a tough physical doesn't mean you'll be a great pilot...the quality of training once there makes them good, and the relevant training too.

Down the road, I'll hold my head up high whether I was a CFI for 2000 hours of PFTraining and that experienc got me a job somewhere building my PIC time that inturn led to a job w/FedEx or United or who-ever. If my crewmates are close-minded like you say you would be, believe me I don't want to talk to you anymore than you want to talk to me.
Truthfully I feel bad you think a different way is BAD or not right - I'm open to going either way and see pros and cons of both. And other countries aren't worse or less hard-working than us just because they train their pilots differently.
Do yourself a favor and open your mind to otherpoints of view - you can tell I disagree w/many points here but I read and think them over and consider them. I still see the different pros and cons of being a CFI and the pros and cons of PFTraining programs.
Have a great day
John

PS - that crack about my sunglasses was especially uncalled for since I think that was the one day in my life I've ever worn them! I hate glasses, especially how they make it so uncomfortable w/ a headset...............

http://www.everestnews.com
http://www.mounteverest.net

http://www.edviesturs.com
rawk.gif
 
If you build time in the right seat of a 121 operation, will you learn some useful skills? No doubt. More useful than if you built time instructing? I certainly wouldn't say that.

Experience is experience. How you gain that experience does not matter...what you do with that experience matters.
 
[ QUOTE ]
if the industry didn't have such ridiculous prerequisites then people could have a fair shot.


[/ QUOTE ]
Wow..... too many thoughts, not enough time to type them.
banghead.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top