All of the above Cazadores, and more. These guys are as good at their jobs (sometimes at least) as you are at yours. They play a game of multi-dimensional chess. Deception is their game. They train for it, like you train for your job. They have more than one tool in their tool bag. Spectacular screw ups sometimes? Apparently so. I think they may have gotten careless on the Flight 253 Operation and permitted the wrong passenger (Haskell - a former Gov't lawyer) to witness what they were doing. But I never write-off the potential and lethal competency of some small, tight knit unit, to pull off an effective Op, leaving little trace behind.
I agree, a small group with a common goal can pull off things, like the Portland JTTF scam. However you are now asking me to believe DHS, DOJ, DOS and CIA, in a much bigger wave of cooperation than just a few compatriots in Sana'a were suddenly able to get along with each other, find enough competent people willing to play along, and then get the Dutch and Israelis on board. This is one of the fundamental issues with US Federal Government conspiracy theories, I know them, they just aren't that organized, often do not see the need/benefit of playing nice with other agencies or even departments within their own, and well, often are not that smart either.
My Brother is a lawyer, and not a tax attorney, he sometimes works with the FBI, let me tell you, he is a pretty bright guy, but if I took him to the airport and asked who was doing what he wouldn't be able to tell the difference between a ticket agent and a special agent. Haskell's time as a "federal government lawyer" are not really impressive credentials, but I agree with him the 253 bomber was thrown to the media and abused in an opportunistic fashion, just probably not a plant, not enough evidence.
I'm inclined to believe that the Feds have an inventory of these knuckleheads lined up and ready to be rolled out when they need a DH$ funding photo op, on cue. Christmas seems to be a popular time of year. The Congress and public are easily controlled with the application of a little fear.
Ok, but these knuckleheads if they are being actually harvested, equipped, and put on airplanes, have to be funded, supplied and given visas, etc. Sort of like the fighters at Eglin, or people claiming the Toledo ANG shot down UA 93...at some point someone like MikeD is in the cockpit of the fighter, or counting AIM 9s, and raises questions or blurts out in pain of guilt "I shot down the jet! or in this case "I am facilitating terror for Chertoff's nudie machines!!!"
.
Terrorist Plots, Hatched by the F.B.I. - NY Times
Sure, and why not give dummy stingers to them and see if you catch a bigger bad guy....
.
Clarification Note: I'm not suggesting that these suspects are innocent angels. I'm just suggesting that most were harmless incompetents with big mouths....... but no money, skills or the required ambition until undercover Feds showed up with lots of cash and promises of glory. What the Feds are doing is great marketing for their budgets, and I think we should not be too naive about that when it comes to this DHS/TSA Theater. Sure, these wanna-be-terrorists should go to jail. But I'm not impressed with the types of people they are arresting in these sting operations. I'm just wondering if we should be racing to give up all our civil liberties just because the Feds have demonstrated that they can work these patsies into dramatic Arrest Photo Ops.
.
That is a little closer to where I am at, we don't need a conspiracy, we don't need to harvest, all DHS needs to do is make sure each event is well covered in the media. The 253 thing is really a great example, I mean, if it was truly meant to sell backscatter why would they plant a bomb experts say would not have been detectable by backscatter? Why take the risk of covert operations when it is so patently unnecessary, the sheeple have shown clearly they do not care, or are to stupid to analyze the risks and stand for their rights. I mean seriously, we, here in the land of the free and home of the brave, walked through airports listening to recorded messages reminding us of the current threat color, put our hands on our heads and cried "never forget" while we were being lied to all the while repeating the mantra "whatever, just keep us safe." This really became apparent years ago with the DUI enforcement craze but that is another discussion for another day....