Agreed.
Which is why when I was at Amflight we washed half the candidates out of training. Oh and that was after almost every trainee had blown multiple regional interviews and couldn't get hired anywhere else.
Freight MAKES the best pilots, but few start out that way.
EDIT: I'll also clarify this a little bit. Not too many people showed up as animals like @
JayAre, who not only had a great grasp of instrument flying fundamentals, but also showed no problems with making the transition to flying larger, faster aircraft in a structured environment.
Many folks were coming to Amflight to make themselves qualified to re-interview at those regionals where they couldn't get hired in the first place. Many people were successful in that. VERY FEW people showed up WANTING to fly freight. Their goal was to get into a good part 91 gig, or a good charter gig (if such a thing exists), or to make themselves qualified to get on with a regional.