Your FO is not wearing proper uniform...

This thread has caused my inner uniform gestapo to surface. Now i'm going to be hyper sensitive to the uniforms of the Pinnacle and Delta employees I see today during my travels. I will post the results of my non-official, non-scientific survey. First priority will be finding a good place for lunch in Memphis, then maybe policing the uniforms of airline pilots.

I know. I have no life.
 
No, it's still there. I opted for Larry's subs. Interstate barbecue called but I'm trying to lose a few pounds.

Anyhow, so far I've seen about a dozen flight crew. Only a handful of pilots wearing a hat though. I also have not seen a single backpack although I did see one red lunch box. Looks like Pinnacle crews are almost exclusively non-hat. ASA and Delta crews are wearing hats. Surprising number of pilots with sunglasses perched on their heads.
 
I would also bring it up in a non-confrontational way.....We have a Chief Pilot who has decided to make himself the uniform police/Gestapo. Casually bringing something up like "Hey, I saw RC lurking in the hallway. I think he's on uniform patrol" all the while wearing the proper uniform myself serves 2 purposes

1. Reinforces the idea of proper uniform standards and wearing it correctly or there could be consequences

2. Keeps the FO on MY side!!!! This will make/keep him a much more useful crew member. This is ultimately much more important than a hat....

If I immediately get on his case about the hat at first meeting, he/she will ultimately shut down and be on the defensive. Not a good way to foster a proper crew environment. By deflecting blame onto the CP it lets them know I got their back. You always want that other guy/girl to be on the same team. Anything I can do to foster that idea increases safety. Busting their chops about a hat and having them shut down from the start doesn't help the situation any.

While I would like to see them wearing the hat, it's the lesser of the evils...
 
I would also bring it up in a non-confrontational way.....We have a Chief Pilot who has decided to make himself the uniform police/Gestapo. Casually bringing something up like "Hey, I saw RC lurking in the hallway. I think he's on uniform patrol" all the while wearing the proper uniform myself serves 2 purposes

1. Reinforces the idea of proper uniform standards and wearing it correctly or there could be consequences

2. Keeps the FO on MY side!!!! This will make/keep him a much more useful crew member. This is ultimately much more important than a hat....

If I immediately get on his case about the hat at first meeting, he/she will ultimately shut down and be on the defensive. Not a good way to foster a proper crew environment. By deflecting blame onto the CP it lets them know I got their back. You always want that other guy/girl to be on the same team. Anything I can do to foster that idea increases safety. Busting their chops about a hat and having them shut down from the start doesn't help the situation any.

While I would like to see them wearing the hat, it's the lesser of the evils...

Agree. Hence my approach earlier. Great reasonings for it though and effective too.
 
I didn't read but the first post. I would tell the guy, "Hey man, put your hat on. If I am wearing a hat and you aren't, it makes us look funny. I don't want to take my hat off because you're not wearing one. I don't want to get busted for not being in uniform, and I don't want to see you get busted either."

I would see that as a polite way of saying get back in line with SOP's. If he still refused, well, it's not an issue of saftey, but something needs to be done about it, because I was hired to perform a task a certian way, and so was he. So something needs to be done. If I speak up and say something, I am the bad guy because I "ratted" them out. If I choose not to speak up and say nothing, then I am the bas guy because I let him get away with it and am not a "team player." It's a loose/loose situation in the end. But in this case, I'd rather be in the lesser of two evils and tell him to put it on. If he refused, I guess I'd have to put on the remarks section that "I'd rather not fly with this guy again" of my paper work. Let him dig his own grave.
 
I don't like the "Wear your hat because the chief pilot is a uniform Nazi" route. It's like telling troops you don't like a policy that your CO put out but they must follow it anyway.
Hats, no hats. Tie, no tie. You know when you're hired that the company has a uniform policy and you sure didn't say, "I'll only work for you if I don't have to wear a hat." If the subject even came up I'm sure the response was "I love hats. All kinds of hats. The dorkier the better. The more I resemble a bus driver the better." I never really liked the hats, but it was my airline uniform policy... so I wore one. Integrity is not doing the right thing when your boss is watching; it's doing the right thing when no one is watching.
So how would I handle it? "Hey bud, company policy is to wear a hat. Don't like the policy? Here's a Walmart application. Make sure you tell 'em you don't like wearing blue bibs." Well... maybe not like that. But I sure wouldn't throw management under the bus.
 
I agree with your CA that suggested you let it be. BeAAgle is a big airline, and there are about umpteen bazillion pilots. When you have such a large organization and you fly with such a broad number of folks, things are different than a small shop.

At the small shop, you know everyone, whether it's actually knowing them, a reputation or even just a name.

Let's bend it a little further. Say..er.. hypothetically.. that this was at a 'small shop' and there was no pro standards department because there was no union, etc.

What then? (I'm not being snarky- serious question. I do in fact let things be a good deal more at the Beagle. Too time consuming.)
 
Let's bend it a little further. Say..er.. hypothetically.. that this was at a 'small shop' and there was no pro standards department because there was no union, etc.

What then? (I'm not being snarky- serious question. I do in fact let things be a good deal more at the Beagle. Too time consuming.)

There is always a pro-standards function, whether it's formal or informal.

Obviously, at a large shop, there is a formal pro-standards system.

Sometimes at a small shop, such as my current employer, there is a formal pros-standards system.

In both cases there is an "informal" pro-standards. You and I both know guys that when their name is brought up, folks say positive things about. "hey, he's a great guy" for example. If you feel strongly enough, and there isn't a formal pro-standards, talking to a respected member of the line about your concern is a great way to address it.

I'm sure you already have a couple names in your mind at your organization that this applies to.
 
I didn't read but the first post. I would tell the guy, "Hey man, put your hat on. If I am wearing a hat and you aren't, it makes us look funny. I don't want to take my hat off because you're not wearing one. I don't want to get busted for not being in uniform, and I don't want to see you get busted either."

I would see that as a polite way of saying get back in line with SOP's. If he still refused, well, it's not an issue of saftey, but something needs to be done about it, because I was hired to perform a task a certian way, and so was he. So something needs to be done. If I speak up and say something, I am the bad guy because I "ratted" them out. If I choose not to speak up and say nothing, then I am the bas guy because I let him get away with it and am not a "team player." It's a loose/loose situation in the end. But in this case, I'd rather be in the lesser of two evils and tell him to put it on. If he refused, I guess I'd have to put on the remarks section that "I'd rather not fly with this guy again" of my paper work. Let him dig his own grave.

I don't like the "Wear your hat because the chief pilot is a uniform Nazi" route. It's like telling troops you don't like a policy that your CO put out but they must follow it anyway.
Hats, no hats. Tie, no tie. You know when you're hired that the company has a uniform policy and you sure didn't say, "I'll only work for you if I don't have to wear a hat." If the subject even came up I'm sure the response was "I love hats. All kinds of hats. The dorkier the better. The more I resemble a bus driver the better." I never really liked the hats, but it was my airline uniform policy... so I wore one. Integrity is not doing the right thing when your boss is watching; it's doing the right thing when no one is watching.
So how would I handle it? "Hey bud, company policy is to wear a hat. Don't like the policy? Here's a Walmart application. Make sure you tell 'em you don't like wearing blue bibs." Well... maybe not like that. But I sure wouldn't throw management under the bus.

On the contrary, I'm going to file this under "Who the hell cares." The guy knows what's in the FOM. If he chooses not to follow it, it's his problem. Of course, if the Captain is also made responsible in the FOM for the uniform appearance of the crew, something should be said if it's really out of order. I once saw a pilot walking around with a "Joe's Crab Shack" t-shirt easily visible under his pilot shirt. Yes, that looks ridiculous and should probably be brought to his attention. Not wearing the hat? Meh. I've probably got more important fires to put out. Then again, I've never worked for a "hats mandatory" company; every company I've worked for has been hats optional or no hats, period.

But I'll admit, sometimes my shoes aren't as shiny as they should be, and on reduced rest overnights sometimes I don't shave. I try to do my best, but very few people are 100% in compliance at all times. It has nothing to do with how the person is to fly with, and has nothing to do with how that person is as a person. And guys, marking down the person's name on the paperwork or making the Walmart comment is just going to make you "that guy" to the rest of the pilot group and would do very little to facilitate CRM in the cockpit.
 
On the contrary, I'm going to file this under "Who the hell cares." The guy knows what's in the FOM. If he chooses not to follow it, it's his problem. Of course, if the Captain is also made responsible in the FOM for the uniform appearance of the crew, something should be said if it's really out of order. I once saw a pilot walking around with a "Joe's Crab Shack" t-shirt easily visible under his pilot shirt. Yes, that looks ridiculous and should probably be brought to his attention. Not wearing the hat? Meh. I've probably got more important fires to put out. Then again, I've never worked for a "hats mandatory" company; every company I've worked for has been hats optional or no hats, period.

But I'll admit, sometimes my shoes aren't as shiny as they should be, and on reduced rest overnights sometimes I don't shave. I try to do my best, but very few people are 100% in compliance at all times. It has nothing to do with how the person is to fly with, and has nothing to do with how that person is as a person. And guys, marking down the person's name on the paperwork or making the Walmart comment is just going to make you "that guy" to the rest of the pilot group and would do very little to facilitate CRM in the cockpit.

You obviously did not read my entire post.
"Well... maybe not like that."
It was obviously a joke.
There is the misconception among pilots that we are in the "flying" business. Sorry, we are not. We are in the customer service industry. Very few pilot jobs are "flying" jobs. Even air show pilots are expected by their sponsors to present a certain image and if they don't their sponsors will drop them.
People pay airlines to be safely and comfortably moved from point A to point B on time. Yet there is also a certain level of appearance that customers expect. Much like a hotel. If you drive by two hotels, one looks shoddy the other has a pleasant appearance, which will you chose? In the airlines the level of appearance is set by management and employees are expected to follow those policies or move on to another company. As I've written and others have written, it was no surprise when you were hired that the airline had uniform policies and I'm sure in the interview the applicant never mentioned that they would refuse to wear the uniform properly. They probably showed up in a uniform for the interview... dark suit, red tie, white shirt.
Being a captain means more than just moving sticks. It means running a safe ship, taking care of your crew and taking care of the company. Sometimes this means doing things that are not popular- so be it. Popularity is not in your job description.
I ran things the same way as a PIC in the military. Initially I was unpopular with the crew chiefs as they thought I was a PITA- I made them wear their flight gloves with their sleeves rolled down when we flew missions. They had to wear their "chicken plates" even when it was 130 degrees. Other PICs would not enforce this. But when I left my unit the CEs took me to lunch and told me that they realized I was actually looking out for them. When the missions were over other PICs would look out for themselves first. Me? I made sure my crew was fed before I was. If they were turning wrenches I asked if they needed anything before I crawled into my spank sack. Maybe even cleaned their weapons for them.
As an airline captain maybe I could be a PITA. I made the FO who showed up with a goatee shave it. Did not have a tie? I had an extra one. No, I did not inspect their shoes for polish, but they had to meet the minimum standards. Did I have pilots who forgot their hat? Sure. I reminded them to bring it next time.
But I also took care of my crew. If we were behind and they had not eaten, I gave them the choice of running late and eating or I would go buy them a meal (at my expense) and bring it to them. I would not let them tip the van driver- that was my job. If we went out together I bought the first round. If something was messed up in the cabin with the pax I did not dump it on the FA's, but helped them as I could. If we were delayed I told the pax why so they would not keep harassing the FAs. If we canceled a flight I stood at the exit with the FAs as people got off to take the heat off them. Over the years I only had one FO who refused to fly with me again... but she was... interesting. It also had nothing to do with uniform.
Leadership is not doing the popular thing, leadership is doing the right thing.
 
You obviously did not read my entire post.
"Well... maybe not like that."
It was obviously a joke.
There is the misconception among pilots that we are in the "flying" business. Sorry, we are not. We are in the customer service industry. Very few pilot jobs are "flying" jobs. Even air show pilots are expected by their sponsors to present a certain image and if they don't their sponsors will drop them.
People pay airlines to be safely and comfortably moved from point A to point B on time. Yet there is also a certain level of appearance that customers expect. Much like a hotel. If you drive by two hotels, one looks shoddy the other has a pleasant appearance, which will you chose? In the airlines the level of appearance is set by management and employees are expected to follow those policies or move on to another company. As I've written and others have written, it was no surprise when you were hired that the airline had uniform policies and I'm sure in the interview the applicant never mentioned that they would refuse to wear the uniform properly. They probably showed up in a uniform for the interview... dark suit, red tie, white shirt.
Being a captain means more than just moving sticks. It means running a safe ship, taking care of your crew and taking care of the company. Sometimes this means doing things that are not popular- so be it. Popularity is not in your job description.
I ran things the same way as a PIC in the military. Initially I was unpopular with the crew chiefs as they thought I was a PITA- I made them wear their flight gloves with their sleeves rolled down when we flew missions. They had to wear their "chicken plates" even when it was 130 degrees. Other PICs would not enforce this. But when I left my unit the CEs took me to lunch and told me that they realized I was actually looking out for them. When the missions were over other PICs would look out for themselves first. Me? I made sure my crew was fed before I was. If they were turning wrenches I asked if they needed anything before I crawled into my spank sack. Maybe even cleaned their weapons for them.
As an airline captain maybe I could be a PITA. I made the FO who showed up with a goatee shave it. Did not have a tie? I had an extra one. No, I did not inspect their shoes for polish, but they had to meet the minimum standards. Did I have pilots who forgot their hat? Sure. I reminded them to bring it next time.
But I also took care of my crew. If we were behind and they had not eaten, I gave them the choice of running late and eating or I would go buy them a meal (at my expense) and bring it to them. I would not let them tip the van driver- that was my job. If we went out together I bought the first round. If something was messed up in the cabin with the pax I did not dump it on the FA's, but helped them as I could. If we were delayed I told the pax why so they would not keep harassing the FAs. If we canceled a flight I stood at the exit with the FAs as people got off to take the heat off them. Over the years I only had one FO who refused to fly with me again... but she was... interesting. It also had nothing to do with uniform.
Leadership is not doing the popular thing, leadership is doing the right thing.

I read your post (the comment I was responding to was at the very end of it!).

I agree with you in your other points, but I think one needs to pick battles. If you're nitpicking the FO's uniform as if he's in the military, well, you're not going to get a whole lot of respect in the cockpit. I'm certainly not saying that's how you were (I've never flown with you so I don't know), but I have flown with the guys who'd point out any small error or omission, even in other crews. Naturally, he wasn't 100% in compliance himself, which made the whole exercise absolutely ridiculous.

My point of view: If the guy looks like a complete and utter slob, yeah, speak up. Otherwise, pick your battles. Not wearing the hat? There are plenty of airlines that are "hats optional" these days, so it really shouldn't look out of place to not wear it. If you really feel strongly about it, I like the idea of letting the other guy know that the CP is roaming the hallways on hat patrol. It voices your concern without alienating your fellow crewmembers. And I'm sorry, if we flew together and you asked me to shave off my goatee, I'd throw the FOM right back at ya (I know, my airline is among the minority that allows it). ;)
 
I read your post (the comment I was responding to was at the very end of it!).

I agree with you in your other points, but I think one needs to pick battles. If you're nitpicking the FO's uniform as if he's in the military, well, you're not going to get a whole lot of respect in the cockpit. I'm certainly not saying that's how you were (I've never flown with you so I don't know), but I have flown with the guys who'd point out any small error or omission, even in other crews. Naturally, he wasn't 100% in compliance himself, which made the whole exercise absolutely ridiculous.

My point of view: If the guy looks like a complete and utter slob, yeah, speak up. Otherwise, pick your battles. Not wearing the hat? There are plenty of airlines that are "hats optional" these days, so it really shouldn't look out of place to not wear it. If you really feel strongly about it, I like the idea of letting the other guy know that the CP is roaming the hallways on hat patrol. It voices your concern without alienating your fellow crewmembers. And I'm sorry, if we flew together and you asked me to shave off my goatee, I'd throw the FOM right back at ya (I know, my airline is among the minority that allows it). ;)

My airline did not permit it, so you could throw the FOM at me and the next call would be to the CP who would pull you off the line and dock your pay. I did not nitpick uniforms, I was not the uniform police.
Letting a guy know the CP is roaming is a cheap out and throws the CP under the bus. Either enforce the policy because it's the right thing to do as a captain or take the easy way out and do nothing.
 
My airline did not permit it, so you could throw the FOM at me and the next call would be to the CP who would pull you off the line and dock your pay. I did not nitpick uniforms, I was not the uniform police.
Letting a guy know the CP is roaming is a cheap out and throws the CP under the bus. Either enforce the policy because it's the right thing to do as a captain or take the easy way out and do nothing.

Would you really call the CP on another pilot about a uniform standards issue?
 
Would you really call the CP on another pilot about a uniform standards issue?

No. I'd call the CP if the FO threw an FOM at me.
Now if an FO were to have an issue with me enforcing a uniform policy I would not report them to the CP. I'd tell the FO to call scheduling and ask to be removed from further trips due to my enforcement of the uniform policy. That or the FO could go to the CP and complain about my enforcement of the uniform policy.
 
No. I'd call the CP if the FO threw an FOM at me.
Now if an FO were to have an issue with me enforcing a uniform policy I would not report them to the CP. I'd tell the FO to call scheduling and asked to be removed from further trips due to my enforcement of the uniform policy. That or the FO could go to the CP and complain about my enforcement of the uniform policy.

Copy. No worries, just was wondering what your outlook was here. I'd handle it the same way.
 
Copy. No worries, just was wondering what your outlook was here. I'd handle it the same way.

Cooperate and graduate. If an FO took umbrage at me making a comment about his/her uniform, or even worse, told me to pack sand for doing so, there is a bigger issue with the FO than the uniform policy. This is easy stuff. If the FO has a problem with this... how will he/she react to the difficult stuff?
For the record, I had two real problem FO's in my time but I never remember having a problem with an FO over uniform. Usually a comment like "From now on when you fly with me bring your hat" or "Would you terribly mind wearing a clean shirt without coffee stains" was enough.
 
I didn't read but the first post. I would tell the guy, "Hey man, put your hat on. If I am wearing a hat and you aren't, it makes us look funny. I don't want to take my hat off because you're not wearing one. I don't want to get busted for not being in uniform, and I don't want to see you get busted either."

I would see that as a polite way of saying get back in line with SOP's. If he still refused, well, it's not an issue of saftey, but something needs to be done about it, because I was hired to perform a task a certian way, and so was he. So something needs to be done. If I speak up and say something, I am the bad guy because I "ratted" them out. If I choose not to speak up and say nothing, then I am the bas guy because I let him get away with it and am not a "team player." It's a loose/loose situation in the end. But in this case, I'd rather be in the lesser of two evils and tell him to put it on. If he refused, I guess I'd have to put on the remarks section that "I'd rather not fly with this guy again" of my paper work. Let him dig his own grave.

The worst captain I've ever flown with started by saying, "You're doing your control check wrong." I asked him why, and he said, "You checked your left aileron up first before you right one."

The guy turned out to be a micromanager, and I didn't do anything correctly for the entire 4 day trip in his eyes. Taking this same approach with the hat will do little more than cut a crew member off at the knees, making them uninterested in listening to what the skipper has to say, and more importantly, it will make the captain an ineffective leader because the folks he is leading won't have any interest in listening to what he has to say, because he's a giant bag.
 
The worst captain I've ever flown with started by saying, "You're doing your control check wrong." I asked him why, and he said, "You checked your left aileron up first before you right one."

The guy turned out to be a micromanager, and I didn't do anything correctly for the entire 4 day trip in his eyes. Taking this same approach with the hat will do little more than cut a crew member off at the knees, making them uninterested in listening to what the skipper has to say, and more importantly, it will make the captain an ineffective leader because the folks he is leading won't have any interest in listening to what he has to say, because he's a giant bag.

Yep, as I said, acting like that is a great way to alienate your crew. It's not the military; if anyone came in barking orders at me, we're going to have a discussion before we push. In the civilian world, we treat each other like coworkers, not soldiers of lesser-rank. Of course a captain must still be able to lead, but in order to do that effectively, he needs to create an environment that will ensure that his crew will back him up when necessary. Pick your battles, and most importantly, don't degrade your own ability to lead by being a jerk from the first moment you step foot on the airplane (we've all flown with those guys).
 
Back
Top