Just checking - are those quoting a multiple of Vso correctly using "calibrated" Vso to do the calculation?
Those numbers would be in his favor. Calibrated is faster than indicated at very slow speeds..I.E. 172R at 40 with full flaps it's 47 calibrated.
Though weight sure makes a big difference. Howdy Mark, been a while!
Der_Meister: Thank you for correcting those approach numbers, I just verified them. I'd been recalling an older model, I have an R model book here which agrees with yours. R model is S model - 20 horsepower and 100lb gross. Was 40 knots stall with full flaps calibrated, though? I have bottom of the white arc at 33.
That said I highly disagree with your method of fly it faster for safety. Teach incorrectly never benefits your students. 20 knots over stall is more than enough to react. Back to what Mark said because he makes a great point(feel free to adjust these #s): A/C = 1650 -- 2 pilots = 400 -- 240 lbs/40gal fuel = 2290.
Correcting for weight: sqrt(2290/2550)*40 puts you are at 37.9*1.3 puts you at 49. That's probably heavier than many will be. Or approach at 60 would be adjusted to 57 (62 with 10 knot gust factor).
The weight scenario, however, is of particular importance when solo, which, if your half tanks and under 200 pounds, puts stall at 35 knots approach at . In other words a solo student with half tanks flying this fast approach technique will meet the specs I posted earlier. They probably won't be up with more than a 5 or 6 knot gust factor either. So zipping along at 70, or since you said faster is safer, 75 to be extra safe. That will put them 10-20 knots fast -- impact forces (kinetic energy) 28-57 percent greater.
To summarize:
This technique used by unknowing students could lead to as much as FIFTY percent, or more, additional kinetic energy to be bled off in flare than what they should have to. That's safer?
I do hope the above makes my point without feeling like an attack. Like I said in my first post, this is by no means addressed solely at, or meant to attack, you. And was in fact my technique when I first started teaching. At least till I looked at the numbers, the situations I was putting my students in, and reflecting on my own solo situations coming in way too hot.
Whatever you, or anyone else, takes away from this. Make it this:
Flying faster approaches is not making pilots safer. A guy who used to post here once told me that doctors are expected to, "first, do no harm." He was using this idea to emphasis the importance of teaching accurately because to teach inaccurately does the student harm. Telling them, showing them, to approach faster to be safe is inaccurate and does harm. Tell them, show them, that they can fly the numbers published in the POH (even the low end ones like 60 instead of 70). That's how we do right by our students.