Windy days - flaps anyone?

18 knots isn't really that much in a 172, I only really messed around with lower flap settings once it got to 30-ish IIRC.
Lol, loved the 30kt crosswind landings in the 172, people would look at you like you're nuts at the fbo, but the plane is actually very capable. I mean it's tricycle gear after all.
 
I have them fly the approach speed for that flap setting 70kts.

First things first, I am by no means trying to single you out or point fingers. Because, in fact, many pilots I've come across teach and/or fly in this manner; and I used to myself. That said, allow me to present something for thought:

  • Most 172's stall at ~35 knots or less with full flaps.
  • Recommended approach speed is ~55 knots.
  • Stall speed * 1.3 for a minimum approach speed is ~46 knots.
  • Recommended gust correction is to increase approach speed by one half gust factor. And, as the article blackhawk linked points out, gust factor is the value of gust over the steady wind condition. So 25G35 = 10 knot gust factor.
Given the above we'd need a gust factor of 30 knots. :eek2: Something like 15 gusting 45, for 70 to be a viable approach speed.

For example, let's use the above information with a gust factor of 10 knots above the steady winds. I choose this gust factor because in my experience it's common to see about 10 as a high end gust factor. Our rule of thumb says we should increase approach by 5 knots, giving us the following speeds:
  • Approach: 55 + 5 = 60 knots
  • Approach 1.3Vso: 46 + 5 = 51 knots
I list both because I believe, and am comfortable demonstrating it myself, that it's reasonably safe to fly an aircraft at 1.3Vso + 1/2 gust factor.

Just one final thought, impact forces increase with the square of velocity. So 70 knots as opposed to 60 knots increases your impact forces by ~28%. Landing at 45 instead of 35 is an increase in any impact forces (sideways landings = impact force) by ~44%. Not even mentioning the still flying issue that the AVweb article discusses
 
The recommended approach speed for the 172Sp I fly is 65 and 61 when doing a short field. Hence my 70 kts, while I agree it is much above the stall speed Vso of 40 (x1.3= 52) for my 172. I personally would rather have more airspeed when I am having students land. It gives them more control-ability and me the instructor more time should I need to take the controls. I also do my flight training above 5000' with Da's regularly above 7000' which also need to be taken into account, in short more speed is better.
 
The recommended approach speed for the 172Sp I fly is 65 and 61 when doing a short field. Hence my 70 kts, while I agree it is much above the stall speed Vso of 40 (x1.3= 52) for my 172.
Just checking - are those quoting a multiple of Vso correctly using "calibrated" Vso to do the calculation?
I personally would rather have more airspeed when I am having students land. It gives them more control-ability and me the instructor more time should I need to take the controls. I also do my flight training above 5000' with Da's regularly above 7000' which also need to be taken into account, in short more speed is better.
I'll disagree with that. If you think so, why not teach landing at 100? Why limit it to 70?

Unnecessary excess airspeed can be as much of a control problem as not enough. Check the Nall report on lading accidents. I think you'll find too much speed being a bigger problem than the more-imagined-than real stall that a lot of CFIs are unfortunately worried about.

And remember that the 65 & 61 recommended in the POH are for max gross weight. So, unless you are carrying a full load you're starting with excess airspeed and then adding 5 kts to it.

And what the heck does the density altitude have to do with landing speeds, except translate your already too fast IAS into even faster TAS and GS?
 
Just checking - are those quoting a multiple of Vso correctly using "calibrated" Vso to do the calculation?
I'll disagree with that. If you think so, why not teach landing at 100? Why limit it to 70?

Unnecessary excess airspeed can be as much of a control problem as not enough. Check the Nall report on lading accidents. I think you'll find too much speed being a bigger problem than the more-imagined-than real stall that a lot of CFIs are unfortunately worried about.

And remember that the 65 & 61 recommended in the POH are for max gross weight. So, unless you are carrying a full load you're starting with excess airspeed and then adding 5 kts to it.

And what the heck does the density altitude have to do with landing speeds, except translate your already too fast IAS into even faster TAS and GS?

I hadn't used CAS, but if I remember correctly it increases a few kts 2-3.
Excessive airspeed is defiantly a problem, but 70tks is not excessive. It would be the approach speed as if you were doing a no flap landing. I am not worried about the stall, I am more worried about smacking the airplane on runway when the gust drops off. I do realize that those approach speeds are for max landing weight, but since Cessna does not publish anything other then that (for the 172's I fly) I go with what the book says instead of making up my own numbers. The DA does nothing to your indicated approach speed and does increase your TAS I agree, but it also decreases the performance of the aircraft so should a "go-around" be needed it would take more time for the aircraft to respond.
 
Just checking - are those quoting a multiple of Vso correctly using "calibrated" Vso to do the calculation?


Those numbers would be in his favor. Calibrated is faster than indicated at very slow speeds..I.E. 172R at 40 with full flaps it's 47 calibrated.

Though weight sure makes a big difference. Howdy Mark, been a while!


Der_Meister: Thank you for correcting those approach numbers, I just verified them. I'd been recalling an older model, I have an R model book here which agrees with yours. R model is S model - 20 horsepower and 100lb gross. Was 40 knots stall with full flaps calibrated, though? I have bottom of the white arc at 33.

That said I highly disagree with your method of fly it faster for safety. Teach incorrectly never benefits your students. 20 knots over stall is more than enough to react. Back to what Mark said because he makes a great point(feel free to adjust these #s): A/C = 1650 -- 2 pilots = 400 -- 240 lbs/40gal fuel = 2290.

Correcting for weight: sqrt(2290/2550)*40 puts you are at 37.9*1.3 puts you at 49. That's probably heavier than many will be. Or approach at 60 would be adjusted to 57 (62 with 10 knot gust factor).

The weight scenario, however, is of particular importance when solo, which, if your half tanks and under 200 pounds, puts stall at 35 knots approach at . In other words a solo student with half tanks flying this fast approach technique will meet the specs I posted earlier. They probably won't be up with more than a 5 or 6 knot gust factor either. So zipping along at 70, or since you said faster is safer, 75 to be extra safe. That will put them 10-20 knots fast -- impact forces (kinetic energy) 28-57 percent greater.

To summarize: This technique used by unknowing students could lead to as much as FIFTY percent, or more, additional kinetic energy to be bled off in flare than what they should have to. That's safer?

I do hope the above makes my point without feeling like an attack. Like I said in my first post, this is by no means addressed solely at, or meant to attack, you. And was in fact my technique when I first started teaching. At least till I looked at the numbers, the situations I was putting my students in, and reflecting on my own solo situations coming in way too hot.

Whatever you, or anyone else, takes away from this. Make it this: Flying faster approaches is not making pilots safer. A guy who used to post here once told me that doctors are expected to, "first, do no harm." He was using this idea to emphasis the importance of teaching accurately because to teach inaccurately does the student harm. Telling them, showing them, to approach faster to be safe is inaccurate and does harm. Tell them, show them, that they can fly the numbers published in the POH (even the low end ones like 60 instead of 70). That's how we do right by our students.
 
I don't take it as an attack merely a discussion. My faster is safer was referring to 70, not the 75 or 100 as has been previously suggested. Though not really touched on but most gusty landings are also a crosswind landing as well. One would also need to take into account the increase in stall speed due to the cross controlled condition (assuming you use wing low). While much of this discussion has been about stall speed. I teach 70 (or what ever half the gust factor is added to 65) because it adds to the controllability of the aircraft. The controllability of the aircraft is very important when you are landing with gusty winds. With that being said, you have more control of the aircraft with a higher airspeed.
 
My faster is safer was referring to 70, not the 75.

So long as you can be sure that your student won't ever hear you say "faster gives more control" and interpret that as: "Well let's see it's a bit windy today and I fly 70 with my instructor when it's windy. Guess I'll fly 75 knots just to be a little safer since I'm solo."

It's not about what you teach so much as how what you teach can be interpreted and unknowingly extrapolated to unfavorable, possibly dangerous, conditions. Add 5 knots while subtracting 200 pounds in that Cessna and you've got a ~25 percent increase in kinetic energy when entering flare without you there.
 
This, ladies and gentlemen, is why so many pilots think the 172 floats a lot.
And why UND's approach profile has us coming in on an ILS at 90 knots with 10 degrees of flaps. Flying that to DA pretty much guarantees that you'll use up at least half of our 7300' main runway :bang:
 
Teach them across the board. Had 35 knot crosswind at hillsboro one day so I taught my commercial student what it looks like at zero flap vs full flap in a c172. He got the idea that there's a HUGE difference and the fact that there are some things a C172 just can't do. I think with zero flaps we were still 25 deg off with the wing as far as I would let it go down. I appreciated 27R at KGFK that day.
 
Flaps. Flaps are an extremely versatile tool. We all can cite numbers and aerodynamics and long time old school techniques and personal experiences and philosophies on the use of flaps.

But the feel of it has as much to do with how much flaps you use as the science of it. You have to have the feel of various flaps settings, and different airplanes have different feelings with different flap settings.

So, I start off using, or teaching, the use of flaps at one half flaps. Yep, you can set a 152/172 flap lever at 1/2, just position the lever between the 10 and 20 indents. For the Cherokee, use the 2nd notch- not exactly 1/2, but you get the point.

After the student becomes somewhat accustomed to the approach, round-out/float, and touchdown at half flaps, we practice full flap and no flap and other in between positions, according to feel and conditions. The student learns by feel which is the best flap setting for the existing conditions as they occur. He develops the necessary judgement from personal experience.

I'm not talking about primary training, either. This is after solo use of flaps for extreme conditions that may be encountered during solo x/c or after PP training and beyond. For initial pre-solo, I keep it simple with, usually, just half flaps, but each student is an individual.
 
What? That we snuck out without telling them? Or that our CFIs are not comfortable with spins and unusual attitudes? Or both? (one of our older CFI's is not scared of them but he says the school doesn't want him doing them. it's the newer CFI's who shudder when we bring it up.).

Sorry to backtrack posts here, but the answer to your question is that you have CFI's at your facility that are not comfortable with spins and unusual attitudes. IMHO they shouldn't be teaching if that is, indeed, their mentality. Furthermore, the school is at fault for propagating the lack of comprehensive training.
 
So, I start off using, or teaching, the use of flaps at one half flaps.
I worked with two flight schools that taught no flaps until shortly before solo (it was a technique my CFI CFI used).

The concept there was in part giving the student a longer flare in order to help develop the sight picture for touchdown. But the real benefit was in terms of energy management*. One of the schools moved to it when, during the pre-solo phase check, a substantial number of students were unable to land with no flaps. No so much energy management on final, but because they used flaps as speed brakes and were simply unable to slow down on downwind without them.

- - - -

* - I agree with shdw's comments about kinetic energy. Excess energy in landing can lead to using too much runway, loss of control after touchdown (which is where crosswind landing accidents actually happen) and, of course, increased injury if you do end up going off a runway or hitting something. How flipping over, weathervaning, or hitting something at a faster speed is "safer" is beyond my comprehension skills.

Somewhere along the way, CFIs picked up this idea that, somehow, full flap landings in crosswinds were dangerous. It's not new; I was taught that 20 years ago and finally unlearned it when working on my CFI.
 
I see this all the time in the PC-12. For some reason the Pilatus engineers set the indexer to have you ludicrously fast if you follow it, especially at high flap settings. At flaps 30, following the indexer, it's almost impossible not to float 2000 ft down the runway before even getting the wheels on (provided you don't wheelbarrow it, as above). Another case of trial lawyers putting us all in danger, IMHO.
 
flight schools that taught no flaps until shortly before solo

The concept there was in part giving the student a longer flare in order to help develop the sight picture for touchdown.
Yep, I do that too, mainly for the same reason- longer flare time, and slightly quicker control response.
Also, no flaps at all during the approach means easier to get set up on final at the same speed, same trim, starting the flare at the same position with the same elevator feel.

Then, when the student has the flaring sight picture under control with the longer slower flare/roundout, we add a notch of flaps on final to decrease the roundout time a bit.
After the student is able to apply the first flap setting, and increase the reaction time during the flare, then we go to the next notch, or setting at approximately half, and no more, usually until after solo. Then we get into the use of full flaps.
The main thing is that the student gets to use (use, not demo'ed) all flap settings in as many different wind conditions as possible during training.
 
And why UND's approach profile has us coming in on an ILS at 90 knots with 10 degrees of flaps. Flying that to DA pretty much guarantees that you'll use up at least half of our 7300' main runway :bang:
Nah, I disagree. Power back to just off idle at DH, pitch to follow the glideslope/VASI, and you'll be golden. At least that's the way I remember it, been forever since I flew an ILS.
 
Back
Top