Windy days - flaps anyone?

If you're interested, you won't have to go very far in a search to find that the FAA investigated it before removing the spin training requirement that existed years ago.

And since then the studies have continued, though not as much on the government front. AOPA and the current guru's in spin training over at APS offer some wonderful reading on the subject. Here is one facinating snippet:

The most foreboding aspect of the Veillette study, however, involved the hands-on spin experience of flight instructors. Ninety-eight percent noted that their formal spin training consisted of no ground instruction and a mere two spins--one in each direction. Nonetheless, these instructors readily received logbook endorsements certifying that they were competent to teach spins.

This comes from: http://www.apstraining.com/2003/review-of-new-aopa-stall-spin-study/

AOPA's article can be found here: http://www.aopa.org/asf/ntsb/stall_spin.html

The governments 1972 study that Midlife's post refers to: http://libraryonline.erau.edu/online-full-text/ntsb/aviation-special-studies/AAS72-08.pdf

Finally, the annual GA accident review in 2002 devotes a section to stall/spin: http://libraryonline.erau.edu/online-full-text/ntsb/aircraft-accident-data/ARG06-02.pdf



I think bringing spins back with the more forgiving airplanes of today has the potential to be beneficial. That said, the process would take many years and likely a great deal of unnecessary deaths before it started to show benefit; if it ever did. So I conclude that the risk is great and the reward may or may not be worth it.
 
Keep in mind that spin training ended as a requirement in the 1940's. So the data of too many accidents comes from days that some look back on as the good old days when pilots really knew how to fly and instructors really knew how to teach...
 
The NTSB conducted a study of the period from 1967 to 1969, and found that stall/spin accidents caused 22 percent of all "fatal occurrences."
22% ? That's the important take-away from this study.
Find a way to get competent training so that you reduce your chances down from 22%.
 
22% ? That's the important take-away from this study.
Find a way to get competent training so that you reduce your chances down from 22%.

Actually, if you look at my final link of the 2002 statistics it's even lower. From 93-02 it varied between 10-13 percent of all accidents involved a stall. Not even necessarily a spin, just a stall.

Then again, the argument to this, ~25 percent of fatal accidents are stall related. Still. So it would seem we've plateaued. Was it the change in training requirements or the improvement in aircraft design?

Who knows, but with current training regimes for CFI's it would be reckless to bring back the required spin training for private pilots. Just my 02 though.
 
While the "22% of all fatal accidents are stall related" is an interesting and ominous statistic, it seems to me that it would only be a part of the story. The other piece of the puzzle is to learn if the total number of fatal accidents (expressed as # per hours flown, or a similar exposure based metric) has been increasing or decreasing.
 
While the "22% of all fatal accidents are stall related" is an interesting and ominous statistic, it seems to me that it would only be a part of the story. The other piece of the puzzle is to learn if the total number of fatal accidents (expressed as # per hours flown, or a similar exposure based metric) has been increasing or decreasing.

I wonder if this might be helpful Steve:

In 2002, accident-related deaths per flight hour were 2.3 fatalities
per 100,000 hours flown. This is slightly higher than the recent low
of 2.1 per 100,000 hours flown in 1999 and 2000 but noticeably
lower than the highest annual fatality-per-hour rate for the period
in 1993 and 1994 (3.3 deaths per 100,000 hours flown).

The above gives us between 2.1-3.3: call it 2.5 for a mean. Using the stats I gave in a previous post, about 25% of all fatal accidents are stall related.

Result: 0.625 fatalities per 100,000 hours.

I'm not a statistics guy, so please correct my analysis if its wrong.

Source: Annual Review of Accidents 2002 Page 8 & 41.


Edit: Interesting info from page 46 of the above source: 79 of the 175 stall accidents analyzed were pilots with more than 1000 hours. or ~45%.
 
Back
Top