Weather Diversions / Backdoor

I don't know why some people play games with the WX. When I was at ZMP, I've see guys blast off into solid IFR then try to pick up a clearance on the air. I've had to move a enroute planes a couple of times because giving the clearance would of immediately resulted in a loss of separation. Stupid...
 
Actually:


The Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite No. 13 (GOES 13) infrared image at 1232, at 2X magnification indicates the accident site location was on the eastern side of an area of enhanced cloud cover associated with high cirrus clouds potentially from anvil from cumulonimbus clouds located to the west depicted by the enhanced areas in blue to yellow. Also depicted were multiple layers of clouds producing a broken to overcast layer of clouds over the accident site. No defined cumulonimbus clouds were observed within 20 miles of the accident site; however, cumulonimbus clouds were observed to the west through northwest between Plant City and Ocala, Florida.

The closest Weather Surveillance Radar (WSR-88D), was located about 48 miles east of the accident site. The 4.3 degree elevation scan, which encompassed altitudes between 21,080 and 25,920 feet, at 1233, depicted reflectivity of 0 to 15 dBZ, which equates to light intensity echoes. Additionally, the 4.3 degree elevation scan for 1233 with the flight path overlaid depicts clear areas east and southeast of the accident site area before the flight encountered the light intensity echo.

The current icing product (CIP) which provides a forecast of icing conditions indicates that for 25,000 feet at 1200 and 1300 EDT, the chance for light to moderate icing existed. The NTSB Weather Factual report is contained in the NTSB public docket.

The pilot of a Beechcraft Corporation 400A that was determined to be located about 13 nautical miles southeast of the accident airplane and at Flight Level (FL) 290 about the time the accident airplane began a right descending turn, reported his on-board weather radar was not depicting any returns. He also reported encountering light rime ice at the top of FL260 while in a cloud layer climbing to his assigned altitude; the airplane was clear of icing conditions within seconds. He further reported the temperature at FL 260 was ISA plus 10 to ISA plus 15.

https://www.ntsb.gov/about/employme...ev_id=20120607X54234&ntsbno=ERA12FA385&akey=1





Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
Thanks!
My understanding was that he got caught up in the gust front on the leading edge of the long line of storms that were in the area. The RADAR depicted indicating his flight route put him right between two areas of red. As for the Beeccraft, the storm was a long line situated SW to NE and moving NE so his clear weather report from the SE doesn't surprise me. The PC-12 continued on a flight path that carried it (at a pretty good speed) farther west of the line so the distance between the crash site and the storm isn't surprising.
 
I don't know why some people play games with the WX. When I was at ZMP, I've see guys blast off into solid IFR then try to pick up a clearance on the air. I've had to move a enroute planes a couple of times because giving the clearance would of immediately resulted in a loss of separation. Stupid...

I can't stand those guys that decide to depart VFR because they're worried about being delayed on the ground waiting for a release. Especially when their filed plan doesn't match the route we have to give them at all. I had a guy try that out of LDJ (which is right under EWR 4 final) when ceilings were 1100 just a couple days ago. I was way too busy to be messing with giving him a freaking full route IFR clearance at that time, especially directly under a final that was descending out of 3000. Especially since we couldn't even find it in the system. Then they get all pissy when we can't accomadate them right away. Those phone numbers to clearance delivery are there for a reason.
 
Why did the AP disconnect?
I'm not stating that the storm destroyed the plane and the highly-qualified pilot couldn't control the plane. The thermal activity and severe turbulence of the storm he was trying to penetrate most likely caused the AP to disengage (never fully addressed)and THEN the inexperienced pilot trashed his plane. My original post here is that I don't understand why people with get anywhere near these storms when, in most cases, it's so easy to avoid. Sorry for the confusion....

IIRC, the AP disconnected because of a fault in the system. Not because of weather. He tried to reset the AP with a certain reset method for that airplane. In this timeframe, the bank angle continued to worsen.
 
IIRC, the AP disconnected because of a fault in the system. Not because of weather. He tried to reset the AP with a certain reset method for that airplane. In this timeframe, the bank angle continued to worsen.
I paraphrase here but the words from the Pilatus team were something along the lines of.......flight conditions exceeded the parameters of the Auto Pilot system causing it to disengage. No anomlies were noted or identifed that would support a fault. [now they did not specify that it was external flight conditions, it may very well have been a pilot induced disconnect]

Still major suckage!! He was in way over his head......
 
I paraphrase here but the words from the Pilatus team were something along the lines of.......flight conditions exceeded the parameters of the Auto Pilot system causing it to disengage. No anomlies were noted or identifed that would support a fault. [now they did not specify that it was external flight conditions, it may very well have been a pilot induced disconnect]

Still major suckage!! He was in way over his head......

Or a jolt of turbulence. I've had it give up once or twice in moderate.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
 
Back
Top