Weather Diversions / Backdoor

That was a nasty line down there yesterday. Why in the world would someone in a light plane try to get through that type of weather? Guess I shouldn't be surprised as it just seems to keep happening.
 
That was a nasty line down there yesterday. Why in the world would someone in a light plane try to get through that type of weather? Guess I shouldn't be surprised as it just seems to keep happening.
Agreed!
I'm still scratching my head about the PC-12 crash in mid-Florida a few years ago. Flies right into a huge storm, aircraft comes apart in flight, one child gets sucked out and the remainder of the airplane crashes later. Wait ten minutes and the storm would have passed.....WTH?
 
Agreed!
I'm still scratching my head about the PC-12 crash in mid-Florida a few years ago. Flies right into a huge storm, aircraft comes apart in flight, one child gets sucked out and the remainder of the airplane crashes later. Wait ten minutes and the storm would have passed.....WTH?

It wasn't even in ...that... bad weather. Pilot was disgustingly inexperienced, and when the autopilot kicked out he let it get into a nose-low unusual attitude, at estimated Vmo+100 (you read that right) he panic pulled.
 
Poor souls. Might underestimated the weather.

I just don't get how you underestimate the wx in today's day and age. All the available apps, foreflight, myradar, etc. If you have enough money and stature to afford a plane; you can afford an extra night in a hotel. An entire family died because somebody thought they could punch their way through a line that even the airliners were avoiding.
 
I just don't get how you underestimate the wx in today's day and age. All the available apps, foreflight, myradar, etc. If you have enough money and stature to afford a plane; you can afford an extra night in a hotel. An entire family died because somebody thought they could punch their way through a line that even the airliners were avoiding.

Remember Jessica Dubroff, who was "flying" cross country? Yeah, the CFI was actually doing it, but look how they died. Took off into a thunderstorm because they "wanted to beat the weather" and they were on a media timeline crunch.

http://www.avweb.com/news/safety/183036-1.html
 
Remember Jessica Dubroff, who was "flying" cross country? Yeah, the CFI was actually doing it, but look how they died. Took off into a thunderstorm because they "wanted to beat the weather" and they were on a media timeline crunch.

http://www.avweb.com/news/safety/183036-1.html
I remember that one well. I remember reading the NTSB report that mentions all the arm and leg fractures that the CFI had which all indicate that he was the pilot flying--not the little girl. In that crash, and probably this one too, there were lots of external pressures to complete the mission. But in both cases, there were ominous reasons to cancel or delay. Yet, otherwise presumably intelligent people blasted off into weather that was likely to kill them.

I don't know where the disconnect is between all of us looking at that weather and knowing that it's literally a killer, and that pilot wagering the lives of his entire family on his ability to punch through it. It can't be ignorance of the fact that the weather existed. If it is, that's a pathetic excuse given the cheap technology available to the GA community.

I don't fly GA any more and haven't in almost 15 years--but I've developed a very low tolerance for these guys that kill innocent and trusting passengers as a result of their arrogance. I fly a big, well equipped jet and have lots of experience picking my way through nasty weather. Yet, convective lines like the one in question scare me. I'm happy to admit that and I'm the first one to chicken out and find a way to avoid it completely. Based on flightaware, it appears that a 100 mile diversion would have put him north of the line and his kids would probably be getting ready for school as I type this. Unnecessarily tragic.
 
I remember that one well. I remember reading the NTSB report that mentions all the arm and leg fractures that the CFI had which all indicate that he was the pilot flying--not the little girl. In that crash, and probably this one too, there were lots of external pressures to complete the mission. But in both cases, there were ominous reasons to cancel or delay. Yet, otherwise presumably intelligent people blasted off into weather that was likely to kill them.

I don't know where the disconnect is between all of us looking at that weather and knowing that it's literally a killer, and that pilot wagering the lives of his entire family on his ability to punch through it. It can't be ignorance of the fact that the weather existed. If it is, that's a pathetic excuse given the cheap technology available to the GA community.

I don't fly GA any more and haven't in almost 15 years--but I've developed a very low tolerance for these guys that kill innocent and trusting passengers as a result of their arrogance. I fly a big, well equipped jet and have lots of experience picking my way through nasty weather. Yet, convective lines like the one in question scare me. I'm happy to admit that and I'm the first one to chicken out and find a way to avoid it completely. Based on flightaware, it appears that a 100 mile diversion would have put him north of the line and his kids would probably be getting ready for school as I type this. Unnecessarily tragic.


Agreed, I too am one of the first ones to give severe wx a wide berth. Twice in my career (early on as an FO) I ended up in weather I didn't want to be in, due to the PIC insisting it wouldn't be that bad and not wanting to burn the extra gas or waste the time cause it would cost the company $$$. I'm glad it was a well built transport category aircraft and beefed up for cargo use. I smaller plane may have come apart. I learned a lot those two nights, both about weather and what I didn't want to do as a PIC. When I finally made PIC I operated to the lowest comfort level in the cockpit. If the FE or FO didn't like plan A we worked on B or C to we all agreed on the course of action.



Now this is a generalization but it got the point home to the students I taught. What do you notice when the NTSB arrvies at a crash scene? It is usually a descent day wx wise. Simply waiting a few hours or a day and the wx will pass.
 
It wasn't even in ...that... bad weather. Pilot was disgustingly inexperienced, and when the autopilot kicked out he let it get into a nose-low unusual attitude, at estimated Vmo+100 (you read that right) he panic pulled.
Not going to argue about his experience but he flew right into the last 1/4 of a huge line of storms. The area that he penetrated was heavy in red and magenta on the RADAR returns. Can't be good!
 
Agreed!
I'm still scratching my head about the PC-12 crash in mid-Florida a few years ago. Flies right into a huge storm, aircraft comes apart in flight, one child gets sucked out and the remainder of the airplane crashes later. Wait ten minutes and the storm would have passed.....WTH?

Ok but that's not why that airplane crashed. It was an AP malfunction during a bank, and the pilot attempted to fix the autopilot instead of fixing the flight path problem. It ended up in an unusual attitude and the recovery for that was botched.
 
Ok but that's not why that airplane crashed. It was an AP malfunction during a bank, and the pilot attempted to fix the autopilot instead of fixing the flight path problem. It ended up in an unusual attitude and the recovery for that was botched.
Why did the AP disconnect?
I'm not stating that the storm destroyed the plane and the highly-qualified pilot couldn't control the plane. The thermal activity and severe turbulence of the storm he was trying to penetrate most likely caused the AP to disengage (never fully addressed)and THEN the inexperienced pilot trashed his plane. My original post here is that I don't understand why people with get anywhere near these storms when, in most cases, it's so easy to avoid. Sorry for the confusion....
 
Why did the AP disconnect?
I'm not stating that the storm destroyed the plane and the highly-qualified pilot couldn't control the plane. The thermal activity and severe turbulence of the storm he was trying to penetrate most likely caused the AP to disengage (never fully addressed)and THEN the inexperienced pilot trashed his plane. My original post here is that I don't understand why people with get anywhere near these storms when, in most cases, it's so easy to avoid. Sorry for the confusion....

Actually:


The Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite No. 13 (GOES 13) infrared image at 1232, at 2X magnification indicates the accident site location was on the eastern side of an area of enhanced cloud cover associated with high cirrus clouds potentially from anvil from cumulonimbus clouds located to the west depicted by the enhanced areas in blue to yellow. Also depicted were multiple layers of clouds producing a broken to overcast layer of clouds over the accident site. No defined cumulonimbus clouds were observed within 20 miles of the accident site; however, cumulonimbus clouds were observed to the west through northwest between Plant City and Ocala, Florida.

The closest Weather Surveillance Radar (WSR-88D), was located about 48 miles east of the accident site. The 4.3 degree elevation scan, which encompassed altitudes between 21,080 and 25,920 feet, at 1233, depicted reflectivity of 0 to 15 dBZ, which equates to light intensity echoes. Additionally, the 4.3 degree elevation scan for 1233 with the flight path overlaid depicts clear areas east and southeast of the accident site area before the flight encountered the light intensity echo.

The current icing product (CIP) which provides a forecast of icing conditions indicates that for 25,000 feet at 1200 and 1300 EDT, the chance for light to moderate icing existed. The NTSB Weather Factual report is contained in the NTSB public docket.

The pilot of a Beechcraft Corporation 400A that was determined to be located about 13 nautical miles southeast of the accident airplane and at Flight Level (FL) 290 about the time the accident airplane began a right descending turn, reported his on-board weather radar was not depicting any returns. He also reported encountering light rime ice at the top of FL260 while in a cloud layer climbing to his assigned altitude; the airplane was clear of icing conditions within seconds. He further reported the temperature at FL 260 was ISA plus 10 to ISA plus 15.

https://www.ntsb.gov/about/employme...ev_id=20120607X54234&ntsbno=ERA12FA385&akey=1





Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk Pro
 
also in GA in April 2006, Aviation legend Scott Crossfield. "A. Scott Crossfield, 84 ( AOPA 1043507), a test pilot who set the criteria that made the first manned space flights possible, died in the crash of his 1960 Cessna 210 Wednesday near convective weather over northern Georgia."
https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media...-scott-crossfield-dies-in-single-engine-crash

I believe on that one he was actually vectored right into a storm, but I cannot remember why I remember that.
 
I remember that one well. I remember reading the NTSB report that mentions all the arm and leg fractures that the CFI had which all indicate that he was the pilot flying--not the little girl. In that crash, and probably this one too, there were lots of external pressures to complete the mission. But in both cases, there were ominous reasons to cancel or delay. Yet, otherwise presumably intelligent people blasted off into weather that was likely to kill them.

I don't know where the disconnect is between all of us looking at that weather and knowing that it's literally a killer, and that pilot wagering the lives of his entire family on his ability to punch through it. It can't be ignorance of the fact that the weather existed. If it is, that's a pathetic excuse given the cheap technology available to the GA community.

I don't fly GA any more and haven't in almost 15 years--but I've developed a very low tolerance for these guys that kill innocent and trusting passengers as a result of their arrogance. I fly a big, well equipped jet and have lots of experience picking my way through nasty weather. Yet, convective lines like the one in question scare me. I'm happy to admit that and I'm the first one to chicken out and find a way to avoid it completely. Based on flightaware, it appears that a 100 mile diversion would have put him north of the line and his kids would probably be getting ready for school as I type this. Unnecessarily tragic.
That's what's great about being a captain; the willingness to say "no". I've had a client scream at me on a contract trip, profane enough where the FBO asked if the cops needed to be called, because I was causing what he saw to be unnesscairy delays. Scream all you want, but we aren't going until I deem the aircraft and flight to be safe. No sweat off my back.
 
I believe on that one he was actually vectored right into a storm, but I cannot remember why I remember that.
https://app.ntsb.gov/pdfgenerator/R...ID=20060501X00494&AKey=1&RType=Final&IType=MA
Analysis The airplane flew into an area of severe thunderstorms identified as a mesoscale convective system (or "MCS") with intense to extreme intensities during cruise flight at 11,000 feet then descended rapidly and impacted the terrain. The on-scene investigation revealed no preimpact mechanical malfunctions or anomalies that would have prevented the normal operation of the airplane or its systems.
The airplane entered the severe convective weather; the pilot then requested and received clearance from the air traffic controller to initiate a turn to escape the weather. The airplane was lost from radar about 30 seconds after the pilot initiated the turn. Before the airplane entered the weather, the controller's radar scope depicted a band of moderate to extreme weather along the accident airplane's projected flight path that was consistent with an embedded, heavy-precipitation, supercell-type thunderstorm; however, the controller did not provide the pilot with any severe weather advisories and did not advise the pilot of the weather depicted on his radar scope.
Although Federal Aviation Administration directives state that controllers should give first priority to separating aircraft and issuing safety alerts, the directives further state that controllers should use good judgment and first perform the action that is most critical from a safety standpoint. Review of air traffic communications and radar data identified no air traffic control (ATC) radar limitations, no excessive traffic, no radio frequency congestion, and no controller workload issues that would have prevented the controller from issuing pertinent weather information to the accident pilot. On the basis of the controller's workload and available resources, he should have recognized that the adverse weather represented an immediate safety hazard to the accident flight and should have provided appropriate advisories to the pilot.
The pilot obtained several weather briefings before departure. At that time, the current weather along the route of flight showed significant convective activity and a moving squall line, and the forecast predicted significant thunderstorm activity along the planned route of flight. The pilot also discussed the weather with an acquaintance, mentioning that he might need to work his Page 2 of 13 CHI06MA115 way around some weather. On the basis of the weather information obtained by the pilot and his comments regarding the weather, the pilot was aware before departure that he would likely encounter adverse weather along the planned route of flight; however, by the time the airplane encountered the weather, the pilot had been airborne for over an hour and had not requested any updated weather information from air traffic controllers. The airplane was equipped with a BF Goodrich WX-950 Stormscope, which has some ability to depict the location and frequency of lightning strikes in the vicinity of the airplane; however, the investigation could not determine if and how this equipment may have been used during the flight. The airplane was not configured to display satellite weather information on its global positioning systems.
In October 2006, the National Transportation Safety Board issued Safety Alert SA-11, "Thunderstorm Encounters," as a result of this accident and three other fatal accidents that involved in-flight encounters with severe weather. The safety alert addresses ATC involvement in these accidents. The alert also states that IFR pilots need to actively maintain awareness of severe weather along their route of flight, and it provides suggestions to assist pilots in avoiding involvement in similar accidents. The safety alert can be found at the Safety Board's Web site at http://www.ntsb.gov/alerts/SA_011.pdf.
Probable Cause and Findings The National Transportation Safety Board determines the probable cause(s) of this accident to be: The pilot's failure to obtain updated en route weather information, which resulted in his continued instrument flight into a widespread area of severe convective activity, and the air traffic controller's failure to provide adverse weather avoidance assistance, as required by Federal Aviation Administration directives, both of which led to the airplane's encounter with a severe thunderstorm and subsequent loss of control.
 
Last edited:
That's what's great about being a captain; the willingness to say "no". I've had a client scream at me on a contract trip, profane enough where the FBO asked if the cops needed to be called, because I was causing what he saw to be unnesscairy delays. Scream all you want, but we aren't going until I deem the aircraft and flight to be safe. No sweat off my back.

Been there before as well a couple of times. Never fun, and I agree the plane will move when I believe we can go safely.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Back
Top