Should US pilots be armed?

I think it's just semantics. Two the body, one to the head is the most effective way to stop the threat. I guess I'm trying to steer the conversation away from "pilots are given guns to kill people" to "pilots are given guns to stop a threat to the flight deck."

Oh Ok. I see where you're coming from on that.
 
As a cop I've had quite a bit of firearms training. First things first. You're only going to use deadly physical force (DPF) if it's being used against you or someone else. If someone actually made it in to the cockpit who wasn't supossed to be there, I'd say they're trying to use DPF against you and everyone on the plane. Maybe they have a weapon. In that case using DPF against them could be justified. When you shoot somone, you do so to STOP them from trying to use DPF on either you or someone else. That's why we're not trained to (as the media would like) to shoot the gun out of someone's hand, or shoot them in the leg. Try doing that when someone is trying to kill you. It's funny, well not really: but the hit accuracy of perps shooting at cops is pretty good. It's not as good the other way around. Also, perps often get shot in the torso and live to tell/ and sue about it later on. Cops get shot in the pinky and go into hypovolemic shock... j/k but you get the idea.

You don't bring a taser to a gun fight. We were always taught to defend ourselves using the same, or one level higher level of force. I'm not against the idea per se of a properly qualified, properly trained person/pilot/FFDO being armed. I'm just saying with the cockpit door secure, and assuming no one brought any explosives onto the plane..... thanks to the crack TSA staff ..........whatever happens in the back of the plane should have no bearing on the pilots opening the door. I do agree that there are a variety of operational issues that preclude them being mentiond here. Security itself dicates you don't let all your secrets out of the bag. I guess from a security standpoint, you have to consider all the possibilities that could happen. Joe Schmo in seat 17A who had too much to drink while in the terminal certainly might have to be dealt with, but that's not the kind of thing the pilots or even the FAM should be involved in. What about then a terrorist who has explosives and demands the plane be taken somewhere. Maybe that's just the ole' fashion type hijacking........ not the new fangled ones that spur this type of debate.
 
First off I don't have any problem with FFDOs. I own guns, enjoy shooting them, and am in the process of getting my CHL. I believe that our country would be a safer place if more of us took our personal safety into our own hands instead of hoping the police will make it in time.

What I do have a problem with is seeing a realistic scenerio in which I as a pilot might have to shoot someone after they destroyed the cockpit door.

The FFDO program is set up to thwart another 9/11 type hijacking. The problem with that line of thinking is that the 9/11 method of attack could only work once. Which is why they were forced to attempt a cordianted attack in 2001. The protocol at the time was to give the hijackers whatever they want including access to the cockpit (which was only protected by a plastic door designed more for privacy than security). It only worked in 3 of the 4 flights because on UA 93 the word had already gotten out and the pax took matters into their own hands.

However now that the general public understands what can be done if the hijackers get to the cockpit they likely would never make that far. If they did fend off the riot of up to a couple hundred passengers, they now have to break in to the cockpit. Pilots are now told to not open the door for any reason. The door itself is armored to resist attack for a much longer time (nothing is perfect).

Meanwhile our trusty FFDO has his hands full diverting to the nearest suitable runway, dealing with ATC, and a hundred other things. Instead of doing anything about the bad guy in back he has his plate completely full just landing the plane, which in the USA he should be able to do long before any breaks through the cockpit door. If by some crazy misfortune they land the plane and there is not a SWAT team already waiting for them, then the FFDO could draw his H&K and "deal with the bad guy" (who is most likely a bloody pulp stomped into the carpet by this point).

Between the fact that passengers will revolt if they think someone is going to endanger the aircraft (shoe bomber, underwear bomber, countless drunks), and the armored cockpit doors (you CAN break through, but it's not easy and it will take time) I just do not see another 9/11 ever happening again.
 
I don't know anyone in law enforcement or home defense who shoots to kill. I own firearms, and I don't plan on killing anyone. It's just an effective tool at stopping a threat. If someone broke into my house to do me harm, and I shot and injured them to the point they couldn't attack me any more, I'm not going to go "finish them off." That's ridiculous.

You'd be better off throwing your guns at an intruder...

The ONLY reason to brandish a weapon is during a life threatening event at which point in time, you'd better be ready to kill the aggressor..
 
You'd be better off throwing your guns at an intruder...

The ONLY reason to brandish a weapon is during a life threatening event at which point in time, you'd better be ready to kill the aggressor..

I think you are misunderstanding his point. He is not advocating trying anything stupid like sooting a gun out of someones hand, he is saying you have a moral and legal duty to stop shooting once the attacker is no longer a threat (dead, wounded, or soiled underware).

Nobody wants to kill an intruder, although if you own a gun you need to be prepared to do so. However if I wing a bad guy in the rib and he runs/limps away, then that is as far as I am willing to go. I was prepared to kill, but my bad aim under pressure resluted in a happier scenerio for all involved.

Furthermore, even if I was carrying, I wouldn't draw just to stop any crime. If a thief wants my wallet he can have it. I'm not shooting someone over 50 bucks and some maxed out credit cards.
 
You are very misinformed about the people that are selected to be FAMs, FFDOs, etc.
He may be more accurate than you think. Crew room gossip is just that, but I've definitely heard some scary stuff from FFDOs employed at my place about some of the folks who have been deputized.

Trev you are very naive about the threats to the aviation system and the amount of "stuff" that does and can get past TSA.

TSA isn't the answer to the threats for one. The things I'm allowed to know make me think that the security folks engage in large amounts of hyperbole when discussing them. I'm not concerned at all about passengers as a threat, and the training I've received leads me to believe that the focus lies solely on them (and the flight crews) as threats.
 
He may be more accurate than you think. Crew room gossip is just that, but I've definitely heard some scary stuff from FFDOs employed at my place about some of the folks who have been deputized.



TSA isn't the answer to the threats for one. The things I'm allowed to know make me think that the security folks engage in large amounts of hyperbole when discussing them. I'm not concerned at all about passengers as a threat, and the training I've received leads me to believe that the focus lies solely on them (and the flight crews) as threats.

If the FFDO's in question at your company are not behaving appropriately or professionally turn their ass in. There is no excuse for it and they do not need to be in the program. What DHS giveth, DHS can taketh away too.
 
However if I wing a bad guy in the rib and he runs/limps away, then that is as far as I am willing to go. I was prepared to kill, but my bad aim under pressure resluted in a happier scenerio for all involved.

Until he or his 'buddies' come back to your house to get revenge.
 
If the FFDO's in question at your company are not behaving appropriately or professionally turn their ass in. There is no excuse for it and they do not need to be in the program. What DHS giveth, DHS can taketh away too.

You misunderstood. They are saying that folks going through the program and who are making it scare them. Those particular scary folks don't work at our company, that I know of.

I did love the story of the guy denied acceptance into the program because of a divorce with his wife....
Meanwhile, said pilot used to be inaw enforcement and has kept his concealed carry current past retirement. Really? Someone trained previously in law enforcement denied because of divorce? Wow.

I don't have faith in the program personally. I even initially supported it.
 
Until he or his 'buddies' come back to your house to get revenge.

Then I'll shoot them again.

I am not a cop, it is not my job to enforce justice, or to chase bad guys. Once the bad guy runs/limps away the police can do what I pay them to do.

Even in Texas you are legally obligated to stop shooting when the bad guy is down. If you don't, you will be the one on trial for murder, it is a very fine line between self defense and murder even in states with strong laws supporting the homeowner. Shooting a man when he is one the ground or running away WILL get you arrested and possibly convicted.
 
Then I'll shoot them again.

I am not a cop, it is not my job to enforce justice, or to chase bad guys. Once the bad guy runs/limps away the police can do what I pay them to do.

Even in Texas you are legally obligated to stop shooting when the bad guy is down. If you don't, you will be the one on trial for murder, it is a very fine line between self defense and murder even in states with strong laws supporting the homeowner. Shooting a man when he is one the ground or running away WILL get you arrested and possibly convicted.

Shooting a man in the back, outside of your residence, of course will have you wishing you hadn't..

Plowing an unwanted intruder into the floor of your living room, is pretty much near 100% defendable with laws like the Castle Doctrine..

Texas is a Castle Doctrine state and you're not required to using deadly force until you feel the threat is over..

It gives a person the legal right to use deadly force to defend that place (his/her "castle"), and/or any other innocent persons legally inside it, from violent attack or an intrusion which may lead to violent attack..

For me that means when Mr. Intruder has breathed his last.
 
Well these are easy solutions;

1: Shoot bigger (or more) bullets. As in; 12 gauge buck shot. You should only need to use one.

and

2: "No sir, I have no idea how the blood trail started in my yard and his body ended up in my living room. Haven't a clue.... (whistles)"
 
<--- has a loaded Saiga 12 next to his bed.. All Mr. Intruder will hear is the bolt slam home..
 
Even in Texas you are legally obligated to stop shooting when the bad guy is down.

That's not exactly accurate - and as Tram pointed out, it's when there isn't a threat anymore. I don't know about you...but in a dark house... evaluating whether the bad guy was waved the white flag is well.... is probably easier said than done. Does he have a second weapon, is there a second person, motives, etc? As far as I'm concerned, the 'intruder' has made his decision prior to entering the house - I have an obligation to protect my family from any threat in that instance.

Even the whole "it's illegal to shoot them in the back".. depends on many different circumstances as well, it's not cut and dry. (unless you simply sprinkle some crack on them and leave) ;)
 
There are a lot of people who seem to think they live in the wild wild west on here. Owning a gun for protection is one thing...even a smart thing. But all the bravado talk is rather laughable.
 
I think you are misunderstanding his point. He is not advocating trying anything stupid like sooting a gun out of someones hand, he is saying you have a moral and legal duty to stop shooting once the attacker is no longer a threat (dead, wounded, or soiled underware).

Nobody wants to kill an intruder, although if you own a gun you need to be prepared to do so. However if I wing a bad guy in the rib and he runs/limps away, then that is as far as I am willing to go. I was prepared to kill, but my bad aim under pressure resluted in a happier scenerio for all involved.

Furthermore, even if I was carrying, I wouldn't draw just to stop any crime. If a thief wants my wallet he can have it. I'm not shooting someone over 50 bucks and some maxed out credit cards.

This is exactly what I was trying to say. Thanks.
 
This is exactly what I was trying to say. Thanks.

My pops and I were talking about this very thing today.. I took my carry weapon out and had it laying on a table and we started talking about when we'd use them.. I carry next to zero cash, I would have no issues giving a guy my wallet..
 
Back
Top