Should US pilots be armed?

Guns never do any positive things it seems. They are more harm then good. I don't think they should be on airplanes. What if the pilot has an undocumented mental health problem? Why not just carry a taser and handcuffs? Usually when you carry a gun your not shooting someone to injure them your shooting to kill them.

Tasers are only really useful against drunks and 6'7" 275 lb guys who provide a large target. If you understand the mechanics and the drawbacks of the taser system, it's definitely not an effective tool for defending an airplane. It's nice that it's been added as a tool for police officers to use, but somehow it's become that a taser is a sort of non-lethal gun to be used in deadly force encounters, when a gun and taser are two separate animals.

I don't know anyone in law enforcement or home defense who shoots to kill. I own firearms, and I don't plan on killing anyone. It's just an effective tool at stopping a threat. If someone broke into my house to do me harm, and I shot and injured them to the point they couldn't attack me any more, I'm not going to go "finish them off." That's ridiculous.
 
Don't get me wrong, I definitely feel that there are people who though they can legally own a gun, probably shouldn't. Like here in AZ. Being from here, I'm used to seeing pistols open-carried on belts, etc. Its common and no surprise. But when I see Billy Bob wearing his pistol on hip (again, perfectly legal), then he gets into his pickup truck with the bumper or window stickers on the back that say things like "Heavily Armed, Easily Pissed" or "Got a problem? Dial 3-5-7"; Ive gotta wonder whether that person really should be packing in public......

I totally agree. It's nutjobs like that who ruin it for the law abiding citizens who own firearms. It's also people like that who are probably going to shoot themselves in the leg, because they're "too good" for safe firearms practices.
 
I don't know anyone in law enforcement or home defense who shoots to kill. I own firearms, and I don't plan on killing anyone. It's just an effective tool at stopping a threat. If someone broke into my house to do me harm, and I shot and injured them to the point they couldn't attack me any more, I'm not going to go "finish them off." That's ridiculous.

You're missing the point. It's not "finish them off". There's a reason its two to the chest, one to the head. There's a reason its deadly force. If you're at that stage, and you're not prepared to kill, then you shouldn't be at that stage. If the guy ends up wounded only, then so be it....no one is saying "finish him off", nor should there be implication of that. But one better be in the kill mindset if things have escalated to that level or they have zero business being an LEO, both for their own safety as well as that of their cohorts.
 
To answer the original question, yes I think US pilots should be able to carry guns. I also think pilots from other countries where it is deemed that there is a hijack risk should also be allowed to carry guns.
 
Operational items like this aren't likely to be revealed on a public forum for security reasons.

I guess what I'm getting at is with all of the security screening already in place it should never happen that someone gets anything lethal on an airplane, but as we know TSA is human and misses a lot of things. I have a friend who's mom is a detective and she recently took a trip to background check a new officer and she used her work bag to bring her clothes in and forgot a fully loaded clip that was in there. She carried it on and didn't realize she had it till she got to her hotel. Talk about a security lapse.
 
I don't know. I think the reality of pilots carrying weapons would be hard for the pilots that chose not to carry. For example not only do you have to deal with Johnny D-bag for X number of overnights but now he is carrying a gun. To the hotel, the crew van, starbucks etc. If the guy was an OK sort it wouldn't matter but if he were "one of those guys" well it would matter, a lot.

I know enough about pilots that the kind of pilot who volunteers to carry a gun is probably the one who shouldn't be... just sayin'.
 
Hey guys, look at the Snowman I made. :D

DSC00122.JPG
 
"What Would the Founders Do?" Richard Brookhiser

The backstory of the founders' thoughts on the politics of gun ownership begins with the politics of England, one hundred years earlier.

...Protestant Englishmen feared that they would be disarmed b the Catholic king and bullied by his large professional army and its Catholic officer corps. That is indeed what James planned. His Protestant subjects forestalled him by chasing him from the throne in 1688, with the Dutch. One consequence of the Glorious Revolution was the English Bill of Rights, banning standing armies in England in peacetime and guaranteeing Protestants the right to bear arms "for their defense".

Furthermore, William Blackstone, explained the right of "having arms" as a firewall, a "barrier... to pretect and maintain" other rights when ordinary protections had crumbled.

The fifth and last auxiliary right of the subject, that I shall at present mention, is that of having arms for their defence, suitable to their condition and degree, and such as are allowed by law. Which is also declared by the same statute I W. & M. st. 2. c. 2. and is indeed a public allowance, under due restrictions, of the natural right of resistance and self-preservation, when the sanctions of society and laws are found insufficient to restrain the violence of oppression.
 
I guess what I'm getting at is with all of the security screening already in place it should never happen that someone gets anything lethal on an airplane, but as we know TSA is human and misses a lot of things. I have a friend who's mom is a detective and she recently took a trip to background check a new officer and she used her work bag to bring her clothes in and forgot a fully loaded clip that was in there. She carried it on and didn't realize she had it till she got to her hotel. Talk about a security lapse.

So you are making our argument for us?
 
I think it's up to the pilot. If they feel comfortable having one then let them.

I can't for the life of me understand how a person can handle the risk of flight and yet deem a weapon too risky. Are you going to stop guns from getting into the hands of criminals? No that will never happen. Can you stop crazy people? No that will never happen. So basically you will only punish sane law abiding people. It's illogical when you think about it in earnest.

Do you really think you can ever stop the manufacturing or importation of firearms or weapons? It will never ever happen.
 
So you are making our argument for us?

It's an endless debate. There is no winner here. There will always be a logical argument for each side. I was just stating that the TSA does make mistakes and giving an example. That's not good enough for me to warrant a firearm in the cockpit. If the TSA was continuously missing assault rifles or handguns in carry ons then I'd feel a little more concerned. For me personally I wouldn't want the responsibility of carrying a firearm around with me everywhere. If someone is going to try to break into the cockpit and hijack me I'll use other creative ways to stop the person. 1 man with a box cutter or with some powder in his panties against a whole plane of people shouldn't be able to breach a cockpit.
 
I don't know. I think the reality of pilots carrying weapons would be hard for the pilots that chose not to carry. For example not only do you have to deal with Johnny D-bag for X number of overnights but now he is carrying a gun. To the hotel, the crew van, starbucks etc. If the guy was an OK sort it wouldn't matter but if he were "one of those guys" well it would matter, a lot.

I know enough about pilots that the kind of pilot who volunteers to carry a gun is probably the one who shouldn't be... just sayin'.

Experiences vary. We've got one GIANT d-bag here who is company famous (nearly media famous). Off the top of my head I can think of 2 others who are a very normal sort who don't mind the added responsibility. With that said it would be 3 if he hadn't gone back to Airtran, and yet another who screwed up a procedure with the gun thing (somewhat accidentally) and deeply regrets it who no longer works here. It's a BIG profession.

With all that said, we trust them to fly airplanes with people in the back, complete with crash axes.
 
It's an endless debate. There is no winner here. There will always be a logical argument for each side. I was just stating that the TSA does make mistakes and giving an example. That's not good enough for me to warrant a firearm in the cockpit. If the TSA was continuously missing assault rifles or handguns in carry ons then I'd feel a little more concerned. For me personally I wouldn't want the responsibility of carrying a firearm around with me everywhere. If someone is going to try to break into the cockpit and hijack me I'll use other creative ways to stop the person. 1 man with a box cutter or with some powder in his panties against a whole plane of people shouldn't be able to breach a cockpit.

If someone breaks in, you'd want some pretty serious training. There's a course in New Mexico sponsored by NRA and ALPA who will help you out. It's a two week course or something like that. Guns, cockpit tactics, all kinds of important stuff. Anyone know what I'm talking about? Got a link?
 
You're missing the point. It's not "finish them off". There's a reason its two to the chest, one to the head. There's a reason its deadly force. If you're at that stage, and you're not prepared to kill, then you shouldn't be at that stage. If the guy ends up wounded only, then so be it....no one is saying "finish him off", nor should there be implication of that. But one better be in the kill mindset if things have escalated to that level or they have zero business being an LEO, both for their own safety as well as that of their cohorts.

Yes, it's deadly force. However, my point is that law enforcement, FFDO, FAMs, or whoever, are not shooting specifically to kill. They are shooting to stop a threat. Yes, the threat may be stopped by killing someone, which guns are designed to do. But the DHS/TSA is not issuing guns to pilots to kill people. They are issuing them to defend the flight deck, and having a firearm on board is more effective at stopping that threat (with deadly force if required) than a taser, knife, etc...

I think it's just semantics. Two the body, one to the head is the most effective way to stop the threat. I guess I'm trying to steer the conversation away from "pilots are given guns to kill people" to "pilots are given guns to stop a threat to the flight deck."
 
Yes, it's deadly force. However, my point is that law enforcement, FFDO, FAMs, or whoever, are not shooting specifically to kill. They are shooting to stop a threat. Yes, the threat may be stopped by killing someone, which guns are designed to do. But the DHS/TSA is not issuing guns to pilots to kill people. They are issuing them to defend the flight deck, and having a firearm on board is more effective at stopping that threat (with deadly force if required) than a taser, knife, etc...

I think it's just semantics. Two the body, one to the head is the most effective way to stop the threat. I guess I'm trying to steer the conversation away from "pilots are given guns to kill people" to "pilots are given guns to stop a threat to the flight deck."

Eh, speaking of semantics. That's a lot of double speak. :)
 
Yes, it's deadly force. However, my point is that law enforcement, FFDO, FAMs, or whoever, are not shooting specifically to kill. They are shooting to stop a threat. Yes, the threat may be stopped by killing someone, which guns are designed to do. But the DHS/TSA is not issuing guns to pilots to kill people. They are issuing them to defend the flight deck, and having a firearm on board is more effective at stopping that threat (with deadly force if required) than a taser, knife, etc...

I think it's just semantics. Two the body, one to the head is the most effective way to stop the threat. I guess I'm trying to steer the conversation away from "pilots are given guns to kill people" to "pilots are given guns to stop a threat to the flight deck."

IMHO, I hope they kill them. If the individual did something to warrant being shot by the crewmembers of the plane, then they're guilty in my book. You don't just accidentally get shot multiple times by the pilots on an airplane because you got up to go to the bathroom. If you manage to get past the citizens, flight attendants, then past the flight door, your gonnna die.

Plus, it saves the American tax payers MILLIONS of dollars worth of trials, lawsuits, and years and years worth of "Prison" and whatever else would come out of the deal if the individual was simply just tasered, or shot and subdued.

Don't waste my time and money. Shoot to kill.
 
Tasers are only really useful against drunks and 6'7" 275 lb guys who provide a large target. If you understand the mechanics and the drawbacks of the taser system, it's definitely not an effective tool for defending an airplane. It's nice that it's been added as a tool for police officers to use, but somehow it's become that a taser is a sort of non-lethal gun to be used in deadly force encounters, when a gun and taser are two separate animals.

I don't know anyone in law enforcement or home defense who shoots to kill. I own firearms, and I don't plan on killing anyone. It's just an effective tool at stopping a threat. If someone broke into my house to do me harm, and I shot and injured them to the point they couldn't attack me any more, I'm not going to go "finish them off." That's ridiculous.

I don't know which LEO's you have been talking to but all the ones I know don't shoot to wound someone. A leg, a shoulder, arm are too easy to miss. The LEO's that I know are all trained to shoot center mass, it is the easiest part of the body to hit. If the criminal lives it is by luck alone. Two + rounds to the chest from .45acp, 9mm, or .40sw usually won't just wound someone. TASERs fail and I have seen many cases where they are ineffective and just wouldn't work for defending an aircraft nor do they act as a deterrent.


I don't know. I think the reality of pilots carrying weapons would be hard for the pilots that chose not to carry. For example not only do you have to deal with Johnny D-bag for X number of overnights but now he is carrying a gun. To the hotel, the crew van, starbucks etc. If the guy was an OK sort it wouldn't matter but if he were "one of those guys" well it would matter, a lot.

I know enough about pilots that the kind of pilot who volunteers to carry a gun is probably the one who shouldn't be... just sayin'.

You are very misinformed about the people that are selected to be FAMs, FFDOs, etc.


It's an endless debate. There is no winner here. There will always be a logical argument for each side. I was just stating that the TSA does make mistakes and giving an example. That's not good enough for me to warrant a firearm in the cockpit. If the TSA was continuously missing assault rifles or handguns in carry ons then I'd feel a little more concerned. For me personally I wouldn't want the responsibility of carrying a firearm around with me everywhere. If someone is going to try to break into the cockpit and hijack me I'll use other creative ways to stop the person. 1 man with a box cutter or with some powder in his panties against a whole plane of people shouldn't be able to breach a cockpit.

Trev you are very naive about the threats to the aviation system and the amount of "stuff" that does and can get past TSA.
 
Back
Top