Should US pilots be armed?

Just to play devil's advocate here, if owning any gun as a civilian were illegal, would it be harder to obtain one illegally? It would seem like it would more difficult, a there would be no reason for a gun to even be around unless it belonged to police/military. Yes/no?

Its not what you think, illegalizing guns would not make that much of a difference. Theres to many already out there and if you live in a neighborhood like mine you would understand that if your not part of the gang your an outsider and your pretty much either hated and lashed out against or ignored (like me so far). The idea of authority, law, and many basic moral values that most people have are non existent and therefore the breaking the law is pretty much a guiltless act. Having an illegal weapon or selling drugs morally is a non issue, the same way most people stop by Starbucks every morning.

That said, people are crafty and if criminals in prison can make shanks and blow darts with toilet paper rolls and plastic spoons, or if Taliban/Al Queda engineers in Pakistani caves can machine AK-47s just as good as the Russian made ones imagine what thugs and criminals in the US with access to tons of resources and the internet can come up with?

Simply illegalizing firearms just wouldn't work (even if it wasn't unconstitutional).
 
I"m not an airline pilot but my understanding is the cockpit doors have been re enforced so the only way someone is getting in there is if the flight deck crew opens it. Correct me if I'm wrong there. Now what happens in the cabin is another matter. So, if a terrorist demanded the door be open so he could get in there and threatens, or maybe even kills passengers or flight attendants, the question becomes, are you going to open the door? My hostage negotiation training is kicking in now. If you let them in, then the worry becomes the plane being turned into a missle and flies right into a building. So now there's people in the ground that are dead in addition to those on the plane. On the other hand, you don't open the door, the terrorist carries out his threat to kill people but at the very least, the plane will be on a runway and in once piece. Either way you're posed with two options: both bad.

WIll having a FFDO on the plane change that? I don't know. You may end up having a bunch of people on the plane shot and the plane still being flown into a building.
Anyone remember the movie the Onion Fields? It was about two cops in I think either CA or AZ that were taken hostage. It was back in the early 70s maybe. One cop is held with a gun against him while the perp demands the other cop give up his gun. The cop gives up his gun. His partner ends up being killed.

That situation and a terrorist on a plane demanding you open the door or else bear some similarities. I"m not sure having a FFDO on board is going to save the day. I do have experience as a hostage negotiator but not as a part 121 pilot so granted, I don't know everything. We haven't even addressed the fact that there might be Federal Air Marshalls on board too.

Just food for thought.
 
Just to play devil's advocate here, if owning any gun as a civilian were illegal, would it be harder to obtain one illegally? It would seem like it would more difficult, a there would be no reason for a gun to even be around unless it belonged to police/military. Yes/no?

Do you mean like in countries like Jamacia, were violent crime is "low"?

FYI Jamacia has a near total ban on civilian ownership of guns, yet has plenty of gun violence. "Where there is a will, there is a weapon".


Mexico also has VERY strict gun control laws. How's that working out?



OTOH, in Switzerland their militia (their national guard) is issued an "assault rifle" and keeps it in his home. The Swiss have the highest rate of gun ownership in the world. Shockingly there is very little gun violence there.
 
So, if a terrorist demanded the door be open so he could get in there and threatens, or maybe even kills passengers or flight attendants, the question becomes, are you going to open the door?

Unless it is a VERY empty flight of old grandmothers, long before it would even come to the perp getting near the cockpit door he'd be killed by the passengers. It happened on Southwest a year ago and there have been several instances were people have been seriously injured by other passengers because they started acting up.

Also, I'm guessing just about every FA out there knows that even if they are being physically threatened, they are on there own and we can't come back and help. Just the way it is.
 
Probably not helpful, but here are some great ones.

1- "The very atmosphere of firearms everywhere restrains evil interference; they deserve a place of honor with all that's good."
~ George Washington.

2- "The best we can hope for concerning the people at large is that they be properly armed."
~ Alexander Hamilton .

3- "Arms discourage and keep the invader and plunderer in awe, and preserve order in the world as well as property."
~ Thomas Paine.

4- "Americans need not fear the federal government because they enjoy the advantage of being armed, which you possess over the people of almost every other nation."
~ James Madison.

5- "Games played with the ball and others of that nature, are too violent for the body and stamp no character on the mind. Let your gun therefore be the constant companion of your walks."
~ Thomas Jefferson.

6- "The great object is that every man be armed. Everyone who is able may have a gun."
~ Patrick Henry.

7- "Laws that forbid the carrying of arms... disarm only those who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes"
~ Thomas Jefferson quoting Cesare Beccaria.

8- "To disarm the people is the best and most effectual way to enslave them."
~ George Mason.

9- "The said Constitution be never construed... to prevent the people of the United States who are peaceable citizens from keeping their own arms."
~ Samuel Adams.

10- "As nightfall does not come all at once, neither does oppression. In both instances, there is a twilight when everything remains seemingly unchanged. And it is in such a twilight that we all must be aware of change in the air -- however slight -- lest we become unwilling victims of the darkness.”
~ Justice William O Douglas

11- "The Constitution is not neutral. It was designed to take the government off the backs of the people ...”
~ Justice William O Douglas


12- "This country, with its institutions, belongs to the people who inhabit it. Whenever they shall grow weary of the existing Government, they can exercise their constitutional right of amending it or their revolutionary right to dismember or overthrow it.”
~ Abraham Lincoln - March 4 1861

This

I wish dueling was a cultural norm as well. People would be a lot more polite if by being an you risked being shot at ten paces.
 
Two things to consider:
1% of accidental deaths in US are gun accidents (not talking about murders). About 70 children per day get shot in stupid accidents.
Per capita, there are roughly 10-20 times more crimes in US than in other western countries (Spain for instance, where civilians can't posses weapons). Most murders are commited w/ guns.

Y

As I said, it's my personal opinion and I respect other's as well.
Cite sources for your numbers please.

Most murders are also committed by people the victim knows.
Also, most air crashes occur with white males as Captain. Conclusion. Stay away from people you know and never fly on airplanes flown by white males.
 
I'm not a police officer but have carried and been responsible for firearms in the military and after the badassness (which is badass) wears off... its just one more thing to be responsible for and if your not getting paid for it or given any other benefits its not worth it from an employee point of view. As a pilot shooting and ILS down to Cat IIIc mins in JFK down to minimums the last thing I want to have to worry about is to make sure my weapon is on safe... just saying.
CAT IIIs are a walk in the park. Triple autopilot and highly defined airport, crew and environmental conditions. Not a big deal until you try to taxi. And no, the weapon is not on safety so there is no reason to worry about that.
And in this day of the volunteer force, I hope the only reason you served was not for the pay and benefits. I know those were not the reasons I served.
 
And in this day of the volunteer force, I hope the only reason you served was not for the pay and benefits. I know those were not the reasons I served.

Isn't it funny how people interpret different things from the same exact sentence? Silly internet. I did not see one little thing in what he wrote that would lead me to even wonder if he served only for the pay and benefits. When he spoke of an employee point of view that made it pretty clear to me he had transitioned to speaking of carrying a firearm as a civilian. The ellipse between clauses is what makes me think that. I could be wrong, but I tend towards the positive when it comes to our service-members. That may just be me, though.
 
Taliban/Al Queda engineers in Pakistani caves can machine AK-47s just as good as the Russian made ones imagine what thugs and criminals in the US with access to tons of resources and the internet can come up with?

You mean like these?

AFGHANISTAN5.jpg


AFGHANISTAN6.jpg


dcpj6.jpg
 
Maybe... Just MAYBE... It would be nice for the evil terrorists to realize if they tried to get in the cockpit and use the airplane as a guided missile, there was 100-something (SSI) grain hollow point that would say, "nuh uh, not today." Go try another way to wreak havoc on our Nation.

You can argue all the ups and downs of guns until you are blue in the face. "WHAT IF!?" it to death. The fact is, having a deadly defense mechanism to defeat a known threat is better than trying to be politically correct any day.
 
Isn't it funny how people interpret different things from the same exact sentence?

The comment was if there were no benefits and no pay, why do it? And you are right. Maybe the format creates the error but I saw nothing to indicate a different attitude at different times. And thus I made the point.

I was a FFDO and the FFDOs I knew did it because they believed in the deterrent. The mad Maxes were quickly flushed from the program (and yes I know a few slipped through the cracks). There was no swagger and no 'new marshal in town' guys.
 
You can argue all the ups and downs of guns until you are blue in the face. "WHAT IF!?" it to death. The fact is, having a deadly defense mechanism to defeat a known threat is better than trying to be politically correct any day.

Don't get me wrong, I definitely feel that there are people who though they can legally own a gun, probably shouldn't. Like here in AZ. Being from here, I'm used to seeing pistols open-carried on belts, etc. Its common and no surprise. But when I see Billy Bob wearing his pistol on hip (again, perfectly legal), then he gets into his pickup truck with the bumper or window stickers on the back that say things like "Heavily Armed, Easily Pissed" or "Got a problem? Dial 3-5-7"; Ive gotta wonder whether that person really should be packing in public......
 
Guns never do any positive things it seems. They are more harm then good. I don't think they should be on airplanes. What if the pilot has an undocumented mental health problem? Why not just carry a taser and handcuffs? Usually when you carry a gun your not shooting someone to injure them your shooting to kill them.
 
Don't get me wrong, I definitely feel that there are people who though they can legally own a gun, probably shouldn't. Like here in AZ. Being from here, I'm used to seeing pistols open-carried on belts, etc. Its common and no surprise. But when I see Billy Bob wearing his pistol on hip (again, perfectly legal), then he gets into his pickup truck with the bumper or window stickers on the back that say things like "Heavily Armed, Easily Pissed" or "Got a problem? Dial 3-5-7"; Ive gotta wonder whether that person really should be packing in public......

If they have truck-nuts that really seals the deal.
 
Guns never do any positive things it seems. They are more harm then good. I don't think they should be on airplanes. What if the pilot has an undocumented mental health problem? Why not just carry a taser and handcuffs? Usually when you carry a gun your not shooting someone to injure them your shooting to kill them.
You are uninformed about the process to qualify for the FFDO program. It does not consist of just wanting to carry and going to a shooting range.

As for guns never doing anything positive, define positive, please. If they have no deterrent value, no effect on safety or crime, why do banks have armed guards?
 
Guns never do any positive things it seems. They are more harm then good. I don't think they should be on airplanes. What if the pilot has an undocumented mental health problem?

Thats only on Egypt Air.......

Why not just carry a taser and handcuffs? Usually when you carry a gun your not shooting someone to injure them your shooting to kill them.

If you're drawing a weapon to use, you're always shooting to kill. Shooting to injure is a fallacy, hence why deadly force is a last resort.
 
So what is the criteria for pulling your firearm out? If the cockpit door is locked from the inside and no terrorist can get in why carry a gun?
 
So what is the criteria for pulling your firearm out? If the cockpit door is locked from the inside and no terrorist can get in why carry a gun?

Operational items like this aren't likely to be revealed on a public forum for security reasons.
 
Guns never do any positive things it seems. They are more harm then good. I don't think they should be on airplanes. What if the pilot has an undocumented mental health problem? Why not just carry a taser and handcuffs? Usually when you carry a gun your not shooting someone to injure them your shooting to kill them.

I would extend that to always. Guns are lethal, as is their application.

It may seem to you that "Guns never do any positive things", however that is not true. It appears that you hear or read a lot of bad news about guns, or a few events have capitalized your view of them. I lived in MA for a while so I understand the anti-gun sentiment and it's arguments.

Guns are tools to be used, but both sides have turned even that bit of logic into either, "armed citizen is his own master, and unarmed citizens are slaves" or "If you want a gun you are unstable". I have guns, I don't use them much anymore. Owning them is a responsibility, using them even moreso. Nothing is inherently good or bad about guns, nor is there with my torch, hammer, box cutter, wrench, etc... . I shoot straight, I'm safe, if I'm empowered having it I don't feel it, nor do I feel like a slave without it.
 
Back
Top