PPL Compensation Flying

What you are considering is illegal in the eyes of the FAA. They have busted people in the past for it and will do it again. The following posts are spot on:

Pilot Hopeful said:
One test for "incidental" is to determine if the trip would be made by the PILOT (and any accompanying persons or cargo) if flying is NOT an option. Alternatively, we might consider an "incidental" flight to be one in which the physical pressence of the pilot is required upon termination of the flight

From your statements, it appears that you are PERSONALLY making multiple trips and wish to replace driving with flying. Thus, because the trips would occur whether driving or flying, a flight could be considered "incidental."
It's a bit more complicated than that. The "pilot" has to be required at the location, just saying "well I would have driven it anyway" isn't enough. So for example in the movement of paperwork, could the paperwork have been sent by courier? If the answer is yes then the "pilot" isn't needed and it's not incidental. With the movement of the driver, could they have taken a cab? If the answer is yes then the "pilot" isn't required and it's not incidental.

The purpose of your flights need to be for YOU (your personal gain). The FAA is trying to protect the general public. They don't want a private pilot acting as a commercial pilot in any way.

Get your commercial, then you can fly for your dad's company. They can pay for the plane, the fuel, the mx, and even pay you! :) You can start doing this the day you get your commercial.
 
Ok, so if that would be considered an illegal charter (let's say he has a commercial license), then how does a corporation legally compensate a coporate pilot with pay and allow them to log the flight time.

9AT mentioned that he would be transporting company people and some cargo. None of those people would be paying him or the company for the flight, because they are employees. I don't know of any private pilots that are coporate pilots, but I don't see it as more than a corporate flight operation as long as 9AT had a commercial license. In that case he'd be a corporate pilot, based on the information he's provided. That is, if the company owned the airplane.
 
N519AT said:
Let me clarify: I would not be paid for making the flight...Just the flight expenses (fuel, oil, aircraft rent) would be paid by the business.

Probably doesn't work, as others have pointed out the FAA has from time to time seen fit to determine that the receipt of flight time is compensation, and hence........
Besides, being paid for flight expenses =is= compensation. You don't have to get into flight time as comp issues.
 
Ok, so if that would be considered an illegal charter (let's say he has a commercial license), then how does a corporation legally compensate a coporate pilot with pay and allow them to log the flight time.

9AT mentioned that he would be transporting company people and some cargo. None of those people would be paying him or the company for the flight, because they are employees. I don't know of any private pilots that are coporate pilots, but I don't see it as more than a corporate flight operation as long as 9AT had a commercial license. In that case he'd be a corporate pilot, based on the information he's provided. That is, if the company owned the airplane.

It wouldn't be illegal. Corporate aircraft operate under part 91. As a commercial pilot you can fly someone's personal aircraft for compensation, period. It is when you start acting like an air carrier (flying for lots of people, anyone and everyone that comes knocking on your door) that you need to get special permission from the FAA.

I don't think that it matters who owns the aircraft... that isn't something the FAA is worried about. That restriction would be set by the insurance company. I am not positive about this part though.
 
I'd like to take issue with a couple of points here:

3) You can fly anything you want owned by anybody as long as there is no charge for that service. So if your company wants to fly people from the partner company and or cargo for that company it certainly can. However you can't charge for it, and if you do it too much the FAA is going to start looking pretty hard for a quid pro quo. But the occassional movement of stuff as a favor would be fine.

4) Corporations rent planes all the time, in fact it's probably fair to say most of them do. So you can certainly setup an environment where the pilot is an employee of the company and the corporation rents the plane and the plane is flown on company business. The i's need to be dotted and the t's crossed, so I'd make sure you engage an expert to advise you, but it certainly can be done.

This is different from me, Joe Schmo, walking into an FBO, renting a plane, flying my buddy to New York and charging him for it. That's a 135 operation and that doesn't work.

Except that the FAA has started to view fight time as "compensation." Note the word. It doesn't necessarily have to be money changing hands. I'd wager that if someone swapped tickets to a game for a trip in a 172, that would be viewed as compensation. You're not "charging" for it, but you are recieving something in return.

In exampe 3) and 4) above, I'm fairly certain that the FAA would see free flight time (even though there is no "charge") as "compensation." I'd wager the pilots that corporations use when they rent planes have commercial licenses or better.
 
Except that the FAA has started to view fight time as "compensation." Note the word. It doesn't necessarily have to be money changing hands. I'd wager that if someone swapped tickets to a game for a trip in a 172, that would be viewed as compensation. You're not "charging" for it, but you are recieving something in return.

In exampe 3) and 4) above, I'm fairly certain that the FAA would see free flight time (even though there is no "charge") as "compensation." I'd wager the pilots that corporations use when they rent planes have commercial licenses or better.

If you look back at the original post in cases 3 and 4 the pilot is assumed to have a commercial certificate and can be compensated via tickets, flight time, camel rental or good old folding money.
 
Back
Top