PPL Compensation Flying

So, if I did the following:
Flew checks/paperwork back and fourth
Flew a driver there to pick up a car
Meet a driver at the airport and flew him home
Etc Etc.

Could that be counted as incidental to the business or would I have to put in my penny's to pay for it?

Have your father add you as a shareholder (on paper) of the corporation and you would then eliminate the "employee" factor. That would make you an owner and thus relate these activities to "your" business.
 
Have your father add you as a shareholder (on paper) of the corporation and you would then eliminate the "employee" factor. That would make you an owner and thus relate these activities to "your" business.

Would still need his commercial to get paid...correct?
 
Yes, if he is being paid for his skills as a pilot, then yes you need a commercial. If he is an "owner" of the business, then the business can cover costs associated with the flight such as insurance, rental, fuel, etc. I've seen guys all the time rent 182s with PPLs, and write the trip off as a business expense since they were travelling to see clients.
 
One test for "incidental" is to determine if the trip would be made by the PILOT (and any accompanying persons or cargo) if flying is NOT an option. Alternatively, we might consider an "incidental" flight to be one in which the physical pressence of the pilot is required upon termination of the flight

From your statements, it appears that you are PERSONALLY making multiple trips and wish to replace driving with flying. Thus, because the trips would occur whether driving or flying, a flight could be considered "incidental."

Now, if your boss likes the flexibility and mobility of air transportation and requests that you make additional runs to reposition persons or cargo that you would not normally make (meaning your presence is not required; a courier could provide the same service), then the "incidental" test presented above is violated. Essentially, your job description would have been (practically) modified to include professional pilot services---a domain that requires commercial certificate privileges.
 
Let me clarify: I would not be paid for making the flight...Just the flight expenses (fuel, oil, aircraft rent) would be paid by the business.
 
If it's more than pro rata, I'd say you'd either have to be a part owner or have a commercial license. How many hours do you have? If you're close, it might be a worthy investment, and it would drop the premiums on any insurance your dad's company might have to cover on you.
 
The FAA could look at the timebuilding incentive your situation possess and yank your ticket. They have handed out violations in the past to guys in your exact situation. Time in a logbook (in the FAA's eyes) can be considered compensation to an aspiring professional pilot.

Your safest play is to not fly for any company anymore until you have your commercial. If you were to actually own the company with your father, then it wouldn't matter.
 
I dont really have much creditability (just a CFII) and i dont really feel like backing up anything i say with proof (too much work) but most of you guys are just wrong. This is part 91, so forget all the 135 rules. Also, its iffy (for some of the reasons stated) if he even needs a commercial since its his dad who owns the plane and his dad's business. He could be considered an extention of his father (as a legal dependant) and his dad can use his airplane is his own business for anything incidental. Flying stuff around in airplanes is not the dads business, nor does he directly profit from it.

The thing that makes him need his commercial is the fact that he is getting compensated for his flying in the form of free flight time. Alot of people try to get around needing a commercial ticket by saying they dont get paid, it doesnt work that way.

Saying stuff like I'm sure of it with no way to back it up is kinda fun...i wonder if this could come back and bite me in the future? nah
 
Flying stuff around in airplanes is not the dads business, nor does he directly profit from it.

But he DOES profit from either the checks being carried or the drivers being ferried. I agree that it's no where close to 135, and I also agree that the FAA would probably see the flight time as "compensation." Best bet is to get the commercial done, THEN do the flying.
 
Let me clarify: I would not be paid for making the flight...Just the flight expenses (fuel, oil, aircraft rent) would be paid by the business.
You're still being "compensated" in the form of free flight time, which the FAA is down on lately for some stupid reason. The FAA wants to see an out-of-pocket expense on your part for every tenth in your logbook.

Semi-related to this: Civil Air Patrol has an exemption from the FAA to reimburse private pilots for aircraft operating expenses related to Search and Rescue operations, which exempts a private pilot from the pro rata rule (which you and your employer are likely NOT exempt from), but in a recent opinion, they ruled that a private pilot volunteering with CAP can be reimbursed for the flight's expenses OR log the flight time--but not both, due to their flight-time-as-compensation stance. Given this, if you're not paying for any of the flight's expenses, and you're logging the time, the FAA will probably have a problem with it.

Here's a similar scenario I faced a few years ago: when I worked in San Diego, one of my coworkers and I had frequent meetings at a client's offices up in Torrance, about a 2 hr drive, if traffic was good. I could fly the both of us up there no sweat. He'd pay half of the flight expenses with the travel expenses he was authorized, as would I The flight was incidental to the business since it simply facilitated my getting to a meeting.

Now, suppose I didn't need to go to the meeting, but still flew my coworker up there. Probably not legal, as I am then performing a transportation function for my employer, and getting paid for it. Same as if I were to fly documents, parts, or any other cargo. Seems like the key is whether the flight is for the primary purpose of transporting myself or not. If it's primarily to transport someone or something else, then I probably need a commercial ticket.
 
This is part 91, so forget all the 135 rules. Also, its iffy (for some of the reasons stated) if he even needs a commercial since its his dad who owns the plane and his dad's business.

Saying stuff like I'm sure of it with no way to back it up is kinda fun...i wonder if this could come back and bite me in the future? nah

If it was a company owned plane, that might be the case. But the situation here says nothing about the company owning a plane, sounds like a rental to me.

Boils down to:

1) Private + rental = no reimbursement beyond actual costs and then only if the businessman/pilot had direct business interests in being at destination. Anybody who wants to come along can. If the businessman/pilot had no direct business at the destination, but was only going to carry pax/cargo then that's illegal.

2) Private + company owned plane = no reimbursement, pilot is not paying for plane anyway. Businessman/pilot can be paid for being a businessman, not for pilot services. Again, must have direct business interests at destination like in case 1 above.

3) Cmmcl + company owned plane = pilot is not paying for plane anyway, plus he can be paid a salary to fly wherever the boss wants with whatever cargo/pax the boss desires AS LONG AS it is for the business owners business. Start flying and carrying somebody elses pax/cargo, then you are into an illegal 135 operation.

4) Cmmcl + rental plane = illegal 135 operation. Very tricky situation to get around if you are getting paid or reimbursed for costs. Looks to FAA like you are running a charter outfit illegally unless you make it look strictly like case 1, above.
 
So, if I did the following:
Flew checks/paperwork back and fourth
Flew a driver there to pick up a car
Meet a driver at the airport and flew him home
Etc Etc.

Could that be counted as incidental to the business or would I have to put in my penny's to pay for it?

There isn't really enough information here to help you, but the answer is it's probably not. If you, as an employee of the company, have a legitimate need to be in the places you are flying to then incidental activites can also take place, like having people come with you, moving paperwork. But if the only reason you need to be there is to move the paperwork or to pickup the person then it's not incidental and a PPL won't work. Even if you split the costs of such flights I'd be VERY wary of doing it because it may well not standup to FAA scrutiny since your sole purpose is still moving paperwork picking up people and you, yourself, have no legitimate need to be in those places.

The other point about the plane's status if it's a rental should also be considered.

HOWEVER - if you are an employee of the company and the company has access to the appropriate plane (either by ownership or through a lease that may be exclusive or non-exclusive) and you have a COMMERCIAL certificate you can probably do the stuff you describe (I say probably because it looks like you can on the information you provide, but there are all sorts of ways to invalidate it).

You are basically then operating as a corporate flight department.
 
3) Cmmcl + company owned plane = pilot is not paying for plane anyway, plus he can be paid a salary to fly wherever the boss wants with whatever cargo/pax the boss desires AS LONG AS it is for the business owners business. Start flying and carrying somebody elses pax/cargo, then you are into an illegal 135 operation.

4) Cmmcl + rental plane = illegal 135 operation. Very tricky situation to get around if you are getting paid or reimbursed for costs. Looks to FAA like you are running a charter outfit illegally unless you make it look strictly like case 1, above.

I'd like to take issue with a couple of points here:

3) You can fly anything you want owned by anybody as long as there is no charge for that service. So if your company wants to fly people from the partner company and or cargo for that company it certainly can. However you can't charge for it, and if you do it too much the FAA is going to start looking pretty hard for a quid pro quo. But the occassional movement of stuff as a favor would be fine.

4) Corporations rent planes all the time, in fact it's probably fair to say most of them do. So you can certainly setup an environment where the pilot is an employee of the company and the corporation rents the plane and the plane is flown on company business. The i's need to be dotted and the t's crossed, so I'd make sure you engage an expert to advise you, but it certainly can be done.

This is different from me, Joe Schmo, walking into an FBO, renting a plane, flying my buddy to New York and charging him for it. That's a 135 operation and that doesn't work.
 
Let me clarify: I would not be paid for making the flight...Just the flight expenses (fuel, oil, aircraft rent) would be paid by the business.

Probably doesn't work, as others have pointed out the FAA has from time to time seen fit to determine that the receipt of flight time is compensation, and hence........
 
One test for "incidental" is to determine if the trip would be made by the PILOT (and any accompanying persons or cargo) if flying is NOT an option. Alternatively, we might consider an "incidental" flight to be one in which the physical pressence of the pilot is required upon termination of the flight

From your statements, it appears that you are PERSONALLY making multiple trips and wish to replace driving with flying. Thus, because the trips would occur whether driving or flying, a flight could be considered "incidental."

It's a bit more complicated than that. The "pilot" has to be required at the location, just saying "well I would have driven it anyway" isn't enough. So for example in the movement of paperwork, could the paperwork have been sent by courier? If the answer is yes then the "pilot" isn't needed and it's not incidental. With the movement of the driver, could they have taken a cab? If the answer is yes then the "pilot" isn't required and it's not incidental.
 
I'd like to take issue with a couple of points here:

3) You can fly anything you want owned by anybody as long as there is no charge for that service. So if your company wants to fly people from the partner company and or cargo for that company it certainly can. However you can't charge for it, and if you do it too much the FAA is going to start looking pretty hard for a quid pro quo. But the occassional movement of stuff as a favor would be fine.

4) Corporations rent planes all the time, in fact it's probably fair to say most of them do. So you can certainly setup an environment where the pilot is an employee of the company and the corporation rents the plane and the plane is flown on company business. The i's need to be dotted and the t's crossed, so I'd make sure you engage an expert to advise you, but it certainly can be done.

This is different from me, Joe Schmo, walking into an FBO, renting a plane, flying my buddy to New York and charging him for it. That's a 135 operation and that doesn't work.

Both points you make are valid, and perhaps more specialized cases of somthing I was trying to keep relatively simple.
 
Back
Top