PPL Compensation Flying

N519AT

Ahh! This is how I change this!
Okay, Let me see if I can get this.

My Public School English Education is failing me entirely here (I'm having a hard time defining incidental..and yes I checked dictionary.com & I still don't get it)...So, let me begin.

FAR Sec. 61.113 Says this:
Private pilot privileges and limitations: Pilot in command.
(b) A private pilot may, for compensation or hire, act as pilot in command of an aircraft in connection with any business or employment if:
(1) The flight is only incidental to that business or employment; and
(2) The aircraft does not carry passengers or property for compensation or hire.

I work for my father who owns a car dealership here somewhere in town. We do a lot of business with another dealer about 70 nm North of here. Because we do a lot of business with them, we are up there at least 3 times a week and 2 hr car rides start sucking incredibly after you do it over and over again. The things we do are: Take cars there for service, sell cars through them (which requires movement of paperwork back & forth..including checks) and other things.

So, if I did the following:
Flew checks/paperwork back and fourth
Flew a driver there to pick up a car
Meet a driver at the airport and flew him home
Etc Etc.

Could that be counted as incidental to the business or would I have to put in my penny's to pay for it?
 
You cannot haul passengers for profit.

However, they can share the expense of the flight. So have them pay the costs of the flight (Rental, gas, etc....)
 
I think what it means is you personally have to fly somewhere to do something instead of drive, you can be reembursed for it.

Carrying stuff, however, would be 135.

I think...
 
If you're making a profit (or if the FAA's watching, even breaking even), I'd try to shy away from it. IMO, if you aren't getting paid for your services as a pilot (ie, the car dealership pays for the plane and gas but nothing else), I'd see that as incidental to the business. There's a couple of things you could do to be even more on the safe side. #1 talk the car dealership into buying a share of an airplane or #2 get your commercial license.

I've been wrong before, though.....

I don't see it as 135 b/c you're doing it for ONE customer, not holding out for multiple contracts.
 
The questions I asked when I was insuring airplanes:
1) Are you being reimbursed for the use of the plane?
(If Yes) 2) Is the reimbursement greather than the expenses of operating the aircraft?
(If Yes) You need a commercial policy.
(If No) We can insure you on your personal aviation policy.

Not exactly the same as FAR but I'd check with your insurance as well, it would suck if you totalled your plane and then the insurance company declined the claim due to unacceptable business use.
 
Also, if you're renting, check with the FBO. I know we had some guys renting airplanes for aerial photography on the flight school's insurance policy. If anything happened, the insurance company wouldn't pay up since it specifically says "no commercial operations not related to the flight school." If they were taking pictures for us, cool. But they weren't.
 
You legally could not (even with your commercial license) take checks up to the other business or fly another person up there, unless it just happens to be incidental. A weekly flight up there moving checks would definitely be a no-no in the FAA's eyes. All the commercial license allows is for aerial, banner towing, crop dusting and a few other non passenger/cargo carrying operations.
 
Care to elaborate?




You certainly can carry passengers/cargo for hire with a commercial ticket.

I'll elaborate...the pilot can carry the checks up there weekly, but they can't have anybody pay him for it.

With a Commercial Ticket, you cannot carry passengers for hire unless you work for a 121 op ( or 135)....Me as a commercial pilot, I can only carry passengers for hire if it's incidental to a trip. If I happen to be going to LA and Joe Blow asks to go with, I can then charge him what I want to take him.
 
Wow, those corporate flight depts are screwed, then. I bet they don't have a 135 operating cert.....

You certainly can fly pax and cargo for hire, IF it's for one (or even just a few) select customers. 135 covers charter and holding out. In this case, he would not be holding out to the general public, but working for one car dealership.
 
so if you are flying a scenic tour, what else do you need besides your commercial ticket??? hmmmm

You can do all the scenic tours you want with just a PPL, but the passengers can only pay their pro-rated share...you legally can't make money doing it unless you work for a company that has the legal status to carry passengers for hire.
 
Flew checks/paperwork back and fourth
Flew a driver there to pick up a car
Meet a driver at the airport and flew him home
Etc Etc.

Could that be counted as incidental to the business or would I have to put in my penny's to pay for it?

No, these activities are not incidental, and you need a commercial license to do this work if you are receiving any compensation for it. My rationale:

My American Heritage Dictionary defines incidental as "occuring or likely to occur as a minor consequence." As a practical example, incidental use might include an independent salesperson (1099 employee) who uses his/her airplane to travel to see clients.

In contrast, an employee using an airplane owned (or rented) by the business for the sole purpose of transporting people or cargo from one place to another does not seem like a "minor consequence." If the business owner did the flying, that might be incidental... but if he's paying somebody to fly, it's pretty obvious that we're talking about a commercial operation.

MusketeerMan said:
You legally could not (even with your commercial license) take checks up to the other business or fly another person up there, unless it just happens to be incidental. A weekly flight up there moving checks would definitely be a no-no in the FAA's eyes

Why would this be a no-no? You cannot "hold-out" to transport persons or cargo for hire without an operating certificate. But the case we are referring to seems like cut-and-dry part 91 operation.

That's like saying the flight departments of Wal-Mart and Coca-Cola require 121 or 135 operating certificates.
 
Wow, those corporate flight depts are screwed, then. I bet they don't have a 135 operating cert.....

You certainly can fly pax and cargo for hire, IF it's for one (or even just a few) select customers. 135 covers charter and holding out. In this case, he would not be holding out to the general public, but working for one car dealership.

Well...my DE must have not known what he was talking about then. I was told that a commercial pilot on their own can never carry passengers or cargo for hire. Sure, as a pilot you can transport someone or something to point B, but you can't get paid for it. Joe can pay me his share, but nothing more than that...correct?
 
Wow, those corporate flight depts are screwed, then. I bet they don't have a 135 operating cert.....

You certainly can fly pax and cargo for hire, IF it's for one (or even just a few) select customers. 135 covers charter and holding out. In this case, he would not be holding out to the general public, but working for one car dealership.


Hmmm.......I'll spend some time re-learning it......my DE was pretty cut & dry with me...
 
Well...my DE must have not known what he was talking about then. I was told that a commercial pilot on their own can never carry passengers or cargo for hire. Sure, as a pilot you can transport someone or something to point B, but you can't get paid for it. Joe can pay me his share, but nothing more than that...correct?

Not correct. As mentioned before, certain commercial operations (that means the pilot is getting paid) do not require 135 or 121 certificates. Skydiving, scenic tours, aeiral photography, agricultural flights, and others are on the list. Also corporate flight departments, such as a King Air owned by a group of attourneys. The pilot definately gets paid and the owners most likely do not have a 135 certificate.
 
Not correct. As mentioned before, certain commercial operations (that means the pilot is getting paid) do not require 135 or 121 certificates. Skydiving, scenic tours, aeiral photography, agricultural flights, and others are on the list. Also corporate flight departments, such as a King Air owned by a group of attourneys. The pilot definately gets paid and the owners most likely do not have a 135 certificate.

Good point...with this point, the group of attorneys would be paying him as a "clerk" of the company. If asked, they would have to show that they would be paying him the same to move file cabinets, make coffee, or fly the King Air for them
 
Back
Top