Pilot Mistook Venus for Aircraft, Plunged Plane Towards Atlantic

TripSix

Well-Known Member
An Air Canada pilot mistook the planet Venus for another aircraft and plunged his plane towards the Atlantic Ocean to avoid a collision.
A report released Monday by the Transportation Safety Board of Canada found 16 people were injured after the Boeing 767 dropped 400 feet to avoid an imaginary crash with an oncoming US C-17 military cargo plane.
The report blamed pilot fatigue and breached rules over mid-flight napping for the January 2011 incident on a Toronto to Zurich flight.
An investigation by the safety board -- based in Gatineau, Quebec -- revealed the first officer had just woken from a "controlled rest" when the captain informed him a US cargo plane was flying towards them.
He "initially mistook the planet Venus for an aircraft," then thought an oncoming plane was descending from above and risked an "imminent collision."
The cargo plane was actually 1,000 feet below the Air Canada flight.
The report said, "Under the effects of significant sleep inertia (when awareness and performance are degraded after sleep), the first officer perceived the oncoming aircraft as being on a collision course and began a descent to avoid it."
Fourteen passengers and two crew members were injured during the incident. The passengers were all in economy class, and none were wearing seatbelts.
Air Canada spokesman Peter Fitzpatrick said, "We sincerely regret that some of our customers were injured, and we have taken measures to prevent a reoccurrence of this type of event."
Under Canadian regulations, pilots are permitted to take "controlled rest" naps of a maximum of 40 minutes during flights.


 
The guys in the C-17 were probably thinking, "ahhhh you can stop your descent at any moment".
 
Unfortunate for everyone involved but having just done my first transoceanic flight I can say that the fatigue on long haul flights is much different than anything I've experienced domestically including redeyes. Not to beat a dead horse but ALPA messed up bad on the augmented crew concessions.
 
Unfortunate for everyone involved but having just done my first transoceanic flight I can say that the fatigue on long haul flights is much different than anything I've experienced domestically including redeyes.

I would imagine long haul fatigue is a lot more along the lines of "holy crap I can't keep my eyes open." Wheras domestic 6 leg day fatigue is "I'm not about to fall asleep, but my brain is mush."
 
The real issue is that the pilot was so fatigued he wasn't able to maintain situational awareness for his entire flight. If he wasn't fatigued to the point of sleeping on the job this wouldn't have happened. "Controlled naps" are a bad joke.
 
The real issue is that the pilot was so fatigued he wasn't able to maintain situational awareness for his entire flight. If he wasn't fatigued to the point of sleeping on the job this wouldn't have happened. "Controlled naps" are a bad joke.

I don't know about that. That being said, napping at your duty station seems like a bad idea to me. Usually takes me a few minutes to be functional even after just a short nap.
 
The real issue is that the pilot was so fatigued he wasn't able to maintain situational awareness for his entire flight. If he wasn't fatigued to the point of sleeping on the job this wouldn't have happened. "Controlled naps" are a bad joke.

I think you misunderstand the rules in Canada.
Air Canada has approved OpSpecs allowing for "Crew Rest" Some of my Canadian homeboys might be able to chime in, however a crew member is limited to 30 minutes or so, but also must be woken up 30 minutes prior to reaching TOD.

He wasn't fatigued in the traditional sense, rather he was in "Sleep inertia" where his mind is still waking up.
 
Unfortunate for everyone involved but having just done my first transoceanic flight I can say that the fatigue on long haul flights is much different than anything I've experienced domestically including redeyes. Not to beat a dead horse but ALPA messed up bad on the augmented crew concessions.
We do midnight Caribbean turns out of JFK. While I'm sure it's a little different flying over the ocean to Europe, flying at 2-3am to Santiago or San Juan sucks big time. I have never been so tired in my life. My eyes played many tricks on me.
 
We do midnight Caribbean turns out of JFK. While I'm sure it's a little different flying over the ocean to Europe, flying at 2-3am to Santiago or San Juan sucks big time. I have never been so tired in my life. My eyes played many tricks on me.

I saw those trips on the board at JFK and thought that they have to be really challenging. I would think the threats are pretty much the same in many ways...late at night, fatigue, featureless terrain, quiet radios, foreign voices, challenging arrivals, non radar in some areas, etc. The only difference I can see is the addition of a relief pilot for some of our ops. For me it was a weird experience coming back from a break where I got marginal sleep only to find myself with sun directly in my face still in a bit of a haze with frozen tundra below, Russian voices on the radio, and the crew saying "ok we're probably 20 mins from TOD." Translation was you better get your SA back in a hurry because you're about to get REALLY busy.

Point being I can see how weird things like this happen to any fatigued crew no matter what the theater is or odd the scenario seems to us after the fact. If you've experienced autokinesis before you know that it can be hard to ignore especially if you are tired.
 
I would imagine long haul fatigue is a lot more along the lines of "holy crap I can't keep my eyes open." Wheras domestic 6 leg day fatigue is "I'm not about to fall asleep, but my brain is mush."

Could be but I honestly don't have the experience to say. Ask me after I've done more of it. What I do know is that the experience was a bit surreal and will take some getting used to. Having the relief pilot there to look over your shoulder and keep an eye on you, listen to the radios, and pretty much backup your every move when you're tired is an essential layer of safety imo. I've got a 2 man Dublin trip coming up that adds an obvious threat to the whole deal.
 
Could be but I honestly don't have the experience to say. Ask me after I've done more of it. What I do know is that the experience was a bit surreal and will take some getting used to. Having the relief pilot there to look over your shoulder and keep an eye on you, listen to the radios, and pretty much backup your every move when you're tired is an essential layer of safety imo. I've got a 2 man Dublin trip coming up that adds an obvious threat to the whole deal.

Can I ask which aircraft you're on now? I am guessing that they're not taking the DC-9 across the pond.
 
Haha nope that would be challenging. 75/76 now.

Awesome, congrats on the "upgrade." Hope it comes with much more QOL and days off.

Whenever someone makes the joke bout going somewhere overseas in the canuckjet I say "sure, but we'll have to swim most of the way!"
 
Awesome, congrats on the "upgrade." Hope it comes with much more QOL and days off.

Whenever someone makes the joke bout going somewhere overseas in the canuckjet I say "sure, but we'll have to swim most of the way!"

Thanks! Enjoying it so far.
 
+1 to Cav. Long-haul fatigue is the worst type I've encountered. Hope you're enjoying the "light twin." :)

By the way: I opt for the middle break as the PF... If I take the third break, I feel too groggy.
 
Back
Top