One list

"If you elect to upgrade to Captain and you don't cut the mustard, you are fired."

Holy Guacamole. That's harsh. Right there is a reason for a union. I've known a couple of really good pilots who busted out of upgrade (maybe that's why it chaps my hide that CAPT gives big jet type ratings to 300 hour guys). Sometimes the timing is wrong and personal distractions come up causing you to not be at your best. We have a few PFO's at my company who have tried and failed to move up. I don't think they deserve to be fired.

"union wages, union politics, union vs. company battles, union beauracracy"

Welcome to the biz. It's not really all that bad. But if you really don't think a union will improve your lot then you shouldn't vote for it. What other regional pilot groups don't have a union?
 
[ QUOTE ]
Welcome to the biz. It's not really all that bad. But if you really don't think a union will improve your lot then you shouldn't vote for it. What other regional pilot groups don't have a union?

[/ QUOTE ]

I'm on the outside looking in here, but let's keep in mind that union does not equal bad labor relations, losing money, and so on.

Southwest is the most unionized airline out there, and they're making money, operate efficiently, and have good labor relations.
 
"The training dept really wants pilots to succeed and will not let them go without a fight"

That's a good thing. It's nice to know that they will work with you. I'm still glad to have my union, contract, and IPA training committe backing me. Perhaps that reduces the stress. I can't imagine the stress of entering upgrade training knowing if I don't pass I don't have a job.
 
I KNOW! could you imagine the amount of sweat the janitorial people would have to mop while your at recurrent... whew!!
 
[ QUOTE ]
What other regional pilot groups don't have a union?

[/ QUOTE ]

Doesn't matter - It is a unique situation. I seem to recall from day one (granted I am a Ramper) them saying flat out that OO is non-union. There is a whole page on it in the company packet, on the website, and it is frequently discussed.

I am very happy with the SAFA part of the company. We just elected a new person for the Southeast portion, and the director of SAFA is ALWAYS in touch. After the Regional director came out and saw the operation in Nashville, pay went up instantly.

I think the pilots are just getting a bad shake from SAPA. Reforms are definitely needed, but I don't know about going against the company's original non-union foundation. SkyWest is a really close group of people. (Closer then any other Airline I have seen, including WN.) Wouldn't a union just drive everyone further apart?
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
they will do whats in their best interest to please the shareholders and maximize profits.

[/ QUOTE ]

Which actually puts more money in our pockets with our financial performance based bonuses! The way the company is operating right now, I've got an extra $5-6000 coming to me this year.

[/ QUOTE ]

I was just looking at that today. In December when I qualify for the financial reward part of it, my bonus will turn out to give me about a $2/hr raise. I think thats about a 7.4% raise if I stay in the bro the 2nd year and a 5.7% raise if I go to the jet. I think where a lot of peoples grief with that is its not guaranteed and out of our hands. ie mishandled bags, customer service issues etc. I think this company is still one of the top places to work for in the regional sector, I'm just worried of what it will be like in the next 2 years when we start receiving bigger planes and I'm a reserve captain!
crazy.gif


I remember you being on reserve quite a while in SLC right Chris? Did you find it tough or not so bad? I bet living in SLC helped though.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Unions wouldn't be necessary if management had the pilot groups best interests in mind. Managements job is to get maximum value for themselves and the stockholders and to give as little to the employees as possible. Pilot groups form unions to get the best possible deal for themselves. There are very few non-union airlines and there is a good reason for that. Personally, I think you guys would be better off if you voted in an indepentent union.

[/ QUOTE ]

I don't think the problem is management. It's a problem of perspective. Pilot unions have the luxury of looking at the company from their perspective only. Therefore anything that management does that does not put more $ in their pocket or more time off on their schedule is seen negatively.

On the other hand, management does not have the luxury of taking such a narrow view of the company. They have to look at the company as a whole. They have to run a safe, profitable, and successful company that works for all employee groups, the shareholders, and themselves. If they don't then the company eventually goes out of business, and that is bad for EVERYONE.

I think management has the best interest of the EMPLOYEES in mind. Since a pilot is an employee, then it follows that management has the best interest of the pilots in mind as well.
 
[ QUOTE ]
I am highly frustrated, as our QOL keeps spinning around the drain and mgmt just thinks we are there to work at there whim.
argue.gif
banghead.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

I hate to break it to you, but you ARE there to work at their whim. That is the nature of being an employEE as opposed to an employER
 
[ QUOTE ]
I think management has the best interest of the EMPLOYEES in mind.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes, I'm sure that Dennis Kozlowski had the best interests of his employees in mind when he was buying $100K shower curtains. And I'm sure that Ken Lay was thinking about the employees when he told them to buy stock in a company that was unravelling. Bernie Ebbers had the best interests of his employees in mind, too, when he cooked the books.

In the airline industry, I'm sure that American's management had only the interests of their employees in mind when they put together bankruptcy proof pensions for the execs while threatening to dump the pensions of the rank and file.

Adding on, you know what Ornstein said at an industry conference? He was talking about the wages of US Airways employees, and he said why the hell were you paying them 50 percent more than you needed to? Nobody quit after the paycuts.

I'm sure someone like that only has the interests of his employees in mind.

And I've got some swampland to sell you in Florida, and there is this really cool bridge in New York you need to see, and I know this guy in Sierra Leone who needs some help moving $100 million to the US.
 
[ QUOTE ]
and I know this guy in Sierra Leone who needs some help moving $100 million to the US.

[/ QUOTE ]
you know that guy too???
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
and I know this guy in Sierra Leone who needs some help moving $100 million to the US.

[/ QUOTE ]
you know that guy too???

[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah, and he's a real SOB. Keeps on bugging me even though I've never replied to him.
 
[ QUOTE ]

Adding on, you know what Ornstein said at an industry conference? He was talking about the wages of US Airways employees, and he said why the hell were you paying them 50 percent more than you needed to? Nobody quit after the paycuts.


[/ QUOTE ]

Even more evidence that SkyWest's corporate culture is FAAARRRRR different from Mesa's. FAAAARRRRRRR (Thank Goodness)
 
[ QUOTE ]
"If you elect to upgrade to Captain and you don't cut the mustard, you are fired."


[/ QUOTE ]

...Which opens up interjecting politics into the flight training department.

I know a guy at a formerly non-union carrier that wasn't in the good graces of a couple of check airmen that suprisingly didn't fare well during training one year and was fired, years after probation. He had a family situation, had a bad training module and the check airmen decided that "Well, he's probably not going to do well during the evaluation phase so let's cut the line before it costs the company any additional money".

True story! It wasn't Skyway, so don't ask.

Everyone thinks they don't need a union until the moment they break an airplane, bust a medical or get 'called to the carpet' for a bogus reason.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Everyone thinks they don't need a union until the moment they break an airplane, bust a medical or get 'called to the carpet' for a bogus reason.


[/ QUOTE ]

And this the exact reason why the excuse of paying union dues is SOOOOOOO lame. Dues are what, $60 to $100, maybe $200 a month? You'll blow through that in eating out in only a few meals but for that same money you have VERY cheap JOB insurance.
 
And it's deductable.

People will gleefully cough out phat dollars to insure their beloved automobile, but coughing out a single cent for a package of legal representation, a world reknown flight safety/accident department and representation in Washington DC is absolutely preposterous.
 
[ QUOTE ]
And it's deductable.

People will gleefully cough out phat dollars to insure their beloved automobile, but coughing out a single cent for a package of legal representation, a world reknown flight safety/accident department and representation in Washington DC is absolutely preposterous.

[/ QUOTE ]

Sure, but it is also a good way of keeping bad apples around, yes? Too often bad people hide behind their unions.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Sure, but it is also a good way of keeping bad apples around, yes? Too often bad people hide behind their unions.

[/ QUOTE ]

I haven't seen a real world example of this in aviation.

Any company can still fire a pilot covered by a collective bargaining agreement. They'll be given a hearing, and if company policy was indeed broken, punished and/or terminated.
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Sure, but it is also a good way of keeping bad apples around, yes? Too often bad people hide behind their unions.

[/ QUOTE ]

I haven't seen a real world example of this in aviation.

Any company can still fire a pilot covered by a collective bargaining agreement. They'll be given a hearing, and if company policy was indeed broken, punished and/or terminated.

[/ QUOTE ]

Well, there is something Aviation has going for it!
grin.gif


My wife's company is struggling with about a whole factory of employees who have been causing trouble and hiding behind a union. It is so irritating.
 
"Sure, but it is also a good way of keeping bad apples around, yes?"

How do you define bad apple? An F/O who busts a Capt upgrade on an RJ after 5 years as an F/O on the 120 (maybe he liked being number one in PDX) How about the weak F/O who decides to give the upgrade a try and doesn't make it but is perfectly capable of being a PFO (professional F/O...my term for an F/O who will never be a Capt).

In most cases, I don't think the company is out to get you, either, but it's nice to have the union to back you up. If you are the right person, I CAN see the company being out to get you. Maybe that person is outspoken or pissed off someone in management. They aren't necessarily bad apples but could be made to look like it in the sim.

I've personally known two people who got fired and both had bad attitudes which fits my defination of a "bad apple". Had nothing to do with training.
 
[ QUOTE ]
"Sure, but it is also a good way of keeping bad apples around, yes?"

How do you define bad apple? An F/O who busts a Capt upgrade on an RJ after 5 years as an F/O on the 120 (maybe he liked being number one in PDX) How about the weak F/O who decides to give the upgrade a try and doesn't make it but is perfectly capable of being a PFO (professional F/O...my term for an F/O who will never be a Capt).

In most cases, I don't think the company is out to get you, either, but it's nice to have the union to back you up. If you are the right person, I CAN see the company being out to get you. Maybe that person is outspoken or pissed off someone in management. They aren't necessarily bad apples but could be made to look like it in the sim.

I've personally known two people who got fired and both had bad attitudes which fits my defination of a "bad apple". Had nothing to do with training.

[/ QUOTE ]

I would define a bad apple as one who works with a reckless regard due to no appreciation of their job. The situations mentioned earlier are certainly NOT bad pilots, and are also not grounds for termination. (In my opinion) You can't forget what was said earlier about the Training Department giving multiple chances.
 
Back
Top