One list

[ QUOTE ]
I would define a bad apple as one who works with a reckless regard due to no appreciation of their job.

[/ QUOTE ]

Being non-union will not prevent this either.

If you come to networkJC, I'll tell you a story about a non-union airline that hired a "street captain" without experience in type and got numerous complaints from senior FO's about being dangerous and not up to speed with the operation. But since he was a very good pal of the chief pilot, there was no remedial action taken and the compaintants got put on 'double secret probation' and one was 'let go'.

Having a union wouldn't have prevented this either, for the most part, but being non-union isn't this bright sunny green meadow where employees and managers sit around and sing koobayah
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I think management has the best interest of the EMPLOYEES in mind.

[/ QUOTE ]

And I've got some swampland to sell you in Florida, and there is this really cool bridge in New York you need to see, and I know this guy in Sierra Leone who needs some help moving $100 million to the US.

[/ QUOTE ]

Sure, all the American managers are evil b@$+@rd$ but don't forget that one guy in New Zealand. He's OK.
smile.gif
 
I've never worked anywhere that has had a union nor have I had much exporsure to them. But one thing that I don't like about them is that it seems to take the accountability away from the employee and the employer. In both cases the tit for tat protocol of reaching agreements. Employees tend to take the attitude that they will not to anymore than what is in their agreement and if they are forced to they will tell their union rep. Employers tend to be reluctant to give anything to the employees feeling that it will be forced upon them in the next round of negotiations and they will have to cough it up then.

I really don't like the way most employees treat it though. In the case of an airline you have to see that if a company is making tons of money it will eventually benefit the pilots and all the other workers. Those benefits can sometimes be intangible though like not have to furlough people.

In the case of SkyWest, they are making tons of money right now. But I see that as future job security. Additionally they do give a lot to their pilots. Maybe it is not a lot in comparison to what pilots used to make at Legacies but for me, who never knew those days, it is fine. Am I happy about not being paid for training? Hell no, I think it is ludicrous. But I do think there a ton of ways the company could improve things. On the other hand I am sure they wish we pilots could improve our performance too. It goes hand in hand. This is not a perfect company, there is no such thing, but it really good and I don't think it would be well served by a union. My belief is that there is far too much potential for us to get what we need from management by way of voicing our needs.
 
[ QUOTE ]
I haven't seen a real world example of this in aviation.

[/ QUOTE ]

I have. Not in a pilot realm, but in the ramper world, it's all too common. I worked with too many guys that had the "it's not my job" attitude along with the guys that were always one sick call away from being fired. As soon as one absence rolled off, they felt they were again entitled to another day off with pay. These were also the same guys that wouldn't step in to help out if you were getting slammed with 220 bags on one flight. Since they weren't SPECIFICALLY assigned that SPECIFIC flight, they would sit in the break room and watch Jerry Springer for another 10 minutes. After all the bags were loaded, THEN they would trot out there and say "Oh, I guess you don't need me." We had guys that would SKIP flights altogether and play ping pong instead of doing their jobs. These were the guys that were masters of getting write ups thrown out on union technicalities. Unfortunately, I worked with more of these guys than I cared to. I'm not saying that ALL unions are like this, just pointing out that aviation isn't immune.

All things being equal, I think in aviation, given how quickly management looks at the labor assets for places to trim costs, I'd rather have a union. I'm glad Skywest has a good relationship between management and labor, but they are the lucky exception to the rule.
 
I think Russ (FL270 for ya'll that remember him) summed up unions at airlines about as well as you possibly can; every airline that has an airline on grounds has done something to the pilot group to deserve it. If the airline goes to screw over the pilots, they'll get a union. Until that time, it looks like at least two airlines (Skywest and Jetblue) don't need them. Why screw with a good formula that is producing results? At the same time, if managment goes to screw over their pilots, then screw managment, bring on the union.
 
[ QUOTE ]
My belief is that there is far too much potential for us to get what we need from management by way of voicing our needs.

[/ QUOTE ]

No offense but you guys seem to have voiced your opinions about no pay during training yet it still exists. And last I heard first year pilots there still don't make a living wage ... what around $18k or $20k isn't it? Last I looked trying to live on that anywhere (let alone the West Coast) is damned tough Not that union would fix these things but it's not like Skywest is the holy grail of all thing aviation, either.

Now before I get bashed into oblivion I still believe SkyWest is one of the better places to work at the regional level.
 
[ QUOTE ]
No offense but you guys seem to have voiced your opinions about no pay during training yet it still exists.

[/ QUOTE ]

Why would the ordinary on staff pilot want to change this? They went through with no pay. If management starts paying during training, then that is less money to go in their pockets... At least that is how I would see it. I would definately not waste all of what little pull I have on something for new hires. Obviously it isn't a problem for them to get people to take the job so why sweat it?
 
[ QUOTE ]
Obviously it isn't a problem for them to get people to take the job so why sweat it?

[/ QUOTE ]

Because it's not right? I know it's not popular to have a strong sense of right and wrong anymore but that's how I see it.
 
Well, I noticed that you didn't address the folks I brought up such as Ornstein, Kozlowski, Ebbers, Lay, et al. Sure, there are good managers -- Kelleher, Bethune and Buffett come to mind -- but you look at most of them and all they're doing is finding new ways to line their pockets.

Not finding ways to increase shareholder value, by the way, but finding ways to line their pockets. Now, if the execs are going to take that attitude, why shouldn't the rank and file?
 
I guess I just don't see how it "isn't right." Keep in mind, I am not employed as a pilot so maybe something would click if I were but the way I see it, we are all free to pursue employment on the terms available and that we want to agree with. No one is forced to work and go to training without being paid.

Now if you mean that what they are doing is detrimental to the profession as a whole, I would agree with you.

Tony, isn't Lay on his way to being someone's boyfriend soon? At least I hope he is.
 
I've got a friend who's been spending a LOT of time down in Houston helping the feds put together their case. He said they are being extra cautious, because they want to nail the SOB to the wall and make him someone's jailhouse beoatch.

And I do think that not paying for training is detrimental to the profession. Anything that drives down the pay of the employees is bad for the profession if you ask me. I think that if you're working for a company, even if they're training you, you should get paid.

But hey, that's my socialist attitude coming out.

Now, back to the union thing. Someone else I know works for CWA. He said that a lot of times what happens is that if the union doesn't get certified, the managers who were responsible for that unit get fired.

Why? Because the execs figure, man, if you had people so pissed that they were looking for a union, then you must have done something stupid!
 
Well if you can't see how not getting paid to copmplete a required task for employment isn't right ... well then nothing I can say is gonna change your view much.
wink.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I am highly frustrated, as our QOL keeps spinning around the drain and mgmt just thinks we are there to work at there whim.
argue.gif
banghead.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

I hate to break it to you, but you ARE there to work at their whim. That is the nature of being an employEE as opposed to an employER

[/ QUOTE ]

skydog: I understand what you are saying but when companies staff the bare min of crews and one sick call leads to cancellations and extensions that is not acceptable. Also, if mgmt can't answer there phone after hours or more importantly during business hours they can't expect their employees to answer calls on their days off. Also, cancelling pilots vacations after they have been awarded is BS too. When will mgmt learn the respect is earned and can't be demanded. If mgmt would act responsibly and treat the employees as people they might actually have employees who give a crap and might actually try to help the company out of jam. I for one will never ever answer my when not contractually obligated to. I learned the hard way on that one as I was forced onto a five day trip in the middle of substantial time off.
[end rant]
 
[ QUOTE ]
Yes, I'm sure that Dennis Kozlowski had the best interests of his employees in mind when he was buying $100K shower curtains. And I'm sure that Ken Lay was thinking about the employees when he told them to buy stock in a company that was unravelling. Bernie Ebbers had the best interests of his employees in mind, too, when he cooked the books.

In the airline industry, I'm sure that American's management had only the interests of their employees in mind when they put together bankruptcy proof pensions for the execs while threatening to dump the pensions of the rank and file.

Adding on, you know what Ornstein said at an industry conference? He was talking about the wages of US Airways employees, and he said why the hell were you paying them 50 percent more than you needed to? Nobody quit after the paycuts.

I'm sure someone like that only has the interests of his employees in mind.

And I've got some swampland to sell you in Florida, and there is this really cool bridge in New York you need to see, and I know this guy in Sierra Leone who needs some help moving $100 million to the US.

[/ QUOTE ]

Well of course they're are examples of bad management. You will find them in every industry, at all levels. But generally speaking it is my opinion that most people try to do the best they can with what they have, and they try to play by the rules. My management team at Air Wisconsin is certainly like that. With every thing that has happened to us in the last year, they have thought outside the box and positioned the company as best they could, while still honoring all their commitments (to labor and otherwise). It remains to be seen whether or not it will work, but if it doesn't, it is hardly from lack of trying. I certainly will not blame them.

My take on all this is that it doesn't matter what kind of union or contract that you have. What matters is what kind of person or people you have running the show. Mesa has a union and contract and most of their people hate it. Skywest doesn't, and most of their people are happy. Why is this? I think it is because the people running Skywest are decent, moral people who want to live up to their obligations. On the other hand, the people running Mesa view agreements and commitments as obstacles to what they want, and have no compunction whatsoever about violating them. Now THAT is bad management. No, that is EVIL management
 
[ QUOTE ]
Not finding ways to increase shareholder value, by the way, but finding ways to line their pockets. Now, if the execs are going to take that attitude, why shouldn't the rank and file?

[/ QUOTE ]

a) You way over do the whole executives are the devil, the devil!!!!!! You keep bringing up a few notorious cases who are in various stages of prosecution. They broke the law. There is no upside to their behavior. The majority of business executives of successful companies do not behave this way. And certainly the owners of small and medium size businesses don't behave that way.

b) The best course for anyone is high honesty and ethics. Unions have a responsibility, beyond just taking what they can blackmail out of their employers, to be good stewards of their industry and profession. If a union gets into a destructive, us vs them, mindset it hurts their members, not helps them. I think ALPA has done pretty well right now in trying to protect their members, their companies and their industry. It takes all of them to make a career.

c) The way you find solutions is by accurately identifying the components of the problem. (So you can use the proper checklist). By advancing the lie that "all managers are greedy and only looking out for themselves" which leads you to "just take what you can leverage in the short term" you close the door on real solutions.
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
My belief is that there is far too much potential for us to get what we need from management by way of voicing our needs.

[/ QUOTE ]

No offense but you guys seem to have voiced your opinions about no pay during training yet it still exists. And last I heard first year pilots there still don't make a living wage ... what around $18k or $20k isn't it? Last I looked trying to live on that anywhere (let alone the West Coast) is damned tough Not that union would fix these things but it's not like Skywest is the holy grail of all thing aviation, either.

Now before I get bashed into oblivion I still believe SkyWest is one of the better places to work at the regional level.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah, I have been wondering if there is a way to address the no pay during training thing. But I haven't really come up with a strategy. I think the problem lies in the historical pattern that has been set up in all airlines doing this and justifying it by saying they are recouping traininng costs. Additionally, all the pilots who understand how to make a difference, by virture of the fact they have been with the company for awhile, both see different battles to fight as well as fact that not paying junior pilots keeps labor costs down and increases the possibility of higher payrates for senior pilots.

The only way to deal with this would be a collective boycott by all perspective pilots. Judging by the stack of resumes that they have, there is no such boycott.
 
[ QUOTE ]
fact that not paying junior pilots keeps labor costs down and increases the possibility of higher payrates for senior pilots.

The only way to deal with this would be a collective boycott by all perspective pilots. Judging by the stack of resumes that they have, there is no such boycott.


[/ QUOTE ]

Not paying trainees a measley $2 or $3k is a cost savings? Come on. But here's an idea that my instructor (who flys for Skyewest) came up with: Bankroll the salary during training - if you pass they cut you a check for the total and if you don't pass they dont and, well, no harm no foul.

And they don't have my resume.
cool.gif
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
fact that not paying junior pilots keeps labor costs down and increases the possibility of higher payrates for senior pilots.

The only way to deal with this would be a collective boycott by all perspective pilots. Judging by the stack of resumes that they have, there is no such boycott.


[/ QUOTE ]

Not paying trainees a measley $2 or $3k is a cost savings? Come on. But here's an idea that my instructor (who flys for Skyewest) came up with: Bankroll the salary during training - if you pass they cut you a check for the total and if you don't pass they dont and, well, no harm no foul.

And they don't have my resume.
cool.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

That is exactly what they do for Customer Service people. Works fine
 
That goes to show you who will tolerate it and who won't. Pilots keep lining up for the job without pay. Sure there are a bunch that won't apply because if it but there is no shortage. CSA's wouldn't take the job if they didn't get paid for training.
 
Back
Top