One list

mrivc211

Well-Known Member
I don't know much about unions. There seems to be a vote coming up at the airline I work for. So rather than go on another website I know of and pose the question and get nothing but insults I'll post it here.

First off:

Are you in favor of a union? Why or Why not?

It has been discussed in the past about having one list of pilots throughout the country. Many have said it would never work. Some thoughts on this.

Whats been your experiences with unions? Good and bad.

And lastly, more of a comment. I live in Socal, next to the port of Long Beach. A couple of years ago, the long shoreman there hada work stopage (strike) it literally was costing the economy (I heard a billion dollars per day) millions per day for not moving goods. IMO, this is an effective union if there ever was one. These longshoreman make $100K+ per year as a salary. Do you think they would be making that much if it wasn't for a union?

I'm not saying a union is the answer, but just giving a good example of one I'm familar with making a big effect.
 
Interesting that the pilot group over there is starting to look to a union. I've heard things are still good but not *as* good as they once were. As far as unions go, I only have experience dealing with them from the managment side. (I know, that's not a good thing to take into an interview ever
laugh.gif
) To fully understand unions you need to take a look at how they really got started and take them in a historical context. In an airline context... Unions solidify a pilot group into one face. Whether or not it is a face that you agree with or not varies from place to place/pilot to pilot, but the union is able to put MORE pressure on managment because all the pilots on the company list feel the same way as the union, at least as far as collective bargaining goes. As far as actually getting the consessions (spelled the wrong way I think) that the pilots want out of managment, a union is no better then a motivated pilot group with a good contract to start with (you know who I am talking about here). So, I guess my thought on unions is this. If the there is a good agreement in place and a pilot group that is willing to stick to it's ideals and put pressure on the company as needed, a union doesn't really serve a purpose. However, if there is a contract that needs large scale changes and a pilot group that isn't willing to put the pressure on, then a union can add the motivation/backing to make progress (and yes, I am talking about a certain PHX based airline.)

That said, it's just my thoughts. I'm fairly certain I'll be at a airline at somepoint that has a union, and I'm sure for the most part I will be happy about it.

Oh, and the single list... I don't like it. Not to pick on Eagle, but if I work for an a regional and upgrade in 3 years get my PIC and move on to an LCC or somethingI would hate to be 4 years junior to a guy in my new hire class just because he was right seat for 7 years.
 
Omar, I've got a friend who works in ALPA's communications department. If you want me to give you his contact information, PM me.

Now, my feelings on unions? I think that they're needed in these days of management running amuck. Everyone says that unions are bad for business. I have one word for those people -- Southwest.
 
interesting.

Would it be possible if there was one list for unions which set a standard rate for pay in a certain type of aircraft. In other words, regardless if you fly for southwest, united, delta, etc your gonna make the same wage flying a B737. If one airline decides against it, all pilots stand behind each other. Sounds too good to be true.
 
Omar, in the last 6 months I have gone from a non-union persuasion to a union supporter for a variety of reasons which can be sum up by an increasing lack of respect from management.

As for one list, nice in theory but never happen…
 
One list will never happen. To hard to implement.

Unions wouldn't be necessary if management had the pilot groups best interests in mind. Managements job is to get maximum value for themselves and the stockholders and to give as little to the employees as possible. Pilot groups form unions to get the best possible deal for themselves. There are very few non-union airlines and there is a good reason for that. Personally, I think you guys would be better off if you voted in an indepentent union.
 
[ QUOTE ]
In other words, regardless if you fly for southwest, united, delta, etc your gonna make the same wage flying a B737. If one airline decides against it, all pilots stand behind each other. Sounds too good to be true.

[/ QUOTE ]If you think about it.. that's what happens now. regardless of who you fly for, if your union and another unionized company has to "stand up and be noticed", a lot of the other union guys - regardless of what airline they work for.. will come out and support the other unionized company... it's seen just like any fraternity/brotherhood...

as far as i understand it and have seen some pilots in action...

for example, when one airline's union has to do an informational line picket, sometimes doug will go down there and help them out - or - if anything, he offers cuz he knows that the union (overall) has to stick together.

one list would just never happen.. it'd be a war over "whose top chicken" and all that
 
I'm not informed enough to speak all that intelligently about it, but I do see a huge conflict of interest in ALPA "representing" both mainline and regional carrier pilot groups. ALPA knows where its bread is buttered and I think it has and will continue to sell out to the interests of mainline pilots over their "small jet" brethren. Now, as all the growth in the industry is happening at the regional level, mainline pilots are telling regional guys they're only cutting their own throats and banishing themselves to a career at the regional level. Maybe so, but it's ALPA's fault for letting the "small jet" genie out of the bottle in the first place. It's gonna get real interesting as more EMB 170/190s and the new Canadair 100+ seaters hit the line.
 
Doug is right one list just would never happen there is just too much BS to hammer out about seniority. I would like to see 3 main unions and that is it. I would like ot see a commuter union, regional union, and a major union. Right now we have too many unions and they aren't strong enough to make a real point.

My company was just aquired by another for its operating certificate. The company not must create one master pilots list and merge two unions. It is a total nightmare and the two unions are fighting over who has jurisdiction over the merger and who will get the dues (the real reason for the fight).

I am highly frustrated, as our QOL keeps spinning around the drain and mgmt just thinks we are there to work at there whim.
argue.gif
banghead.gif
 
So what's AmWest and USAir going to do with their pilot list? Smooth work, or bloody mess?

Agree with Aloft on the representation pickle ALPA puts themself in regards regional/mainline representation. Tough conflict of interest to support both equally, it seems. Scope may or may not have helped this situation.
 
[ QUOTE ]
If the there is a good agreement in place and a pilot group that is willing to stick to it's ideals and put pressure on the company as needed, a union doesn't really serve a purpose.

[/ QUOTE ]

It's generally not the pilot group that ends up wanting to change or flat out violating a "good contract." Why would they - it's a "good contract." So, the question then becomes who is left that could possibly want to change things up? Management. And at the end of the day (even with a union) management are the one that hold the majority of power and thus can do what they want.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Smooth work, or bloody mess?

[/ QUOTE ]

Well seeingas how a) I lived through a merger with my father and saw the results close to first hand and b) the presiding judge has ruled that the unions have no say in the merger (which is complete and utter horsesh*t) I'm voting <font color="red">bloody mess</font>.

Oh and as a side note Skywest may be a great airline (and I honest believe it is from what I hear and from the people I know who work for them) but the whole no pay throughout training and their so-called "up and out" policy is well, frankly, insulting.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Well seeingas how a) I lived through a merger with my father and saw the results close to first hand and b) the presiding judge has ruled that the unions have no say in the merger (which is complete and utter horsesh*t) I'm voting <font color="red">bloody mess</font>.

[/ QUOTE ]

Ozark pilots got one of the biggest screw jobs in airline merger history. USAir/AmWest will be a bloody stinking mess. Wouldn't be surprised to see gunplay.
bandit.gif
argue.gif


Scope is a hopeless conflict of interest for ALPA.

Single list. Ain't gonna happen.

Skywest will vote in-house union if at all. Probably a good move in current environment. (See "hopeless conflict of interest" above.)
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
so-called "up and out" policy

[/ QUOTE ]

Can you please briefly describe this policy. Thanks

[/ QUOTE ]

If you elect to upgrade to Captain and you don't cut the mustard, you are fired. It doesn't matter if you've been with the company for 15 years. That is the way they do it.


I dunno about the union and SKW. I think the pilot group would be shooting themselves in the foot right now. Granted, SAPA, our own pilot representatives, don't really represent the pilots well because they work for the company but if we go union it could be some serious strife. The short sighted view is better wages and better ability to address QOL of life issues. But the reality will be union wages, union politics, union vs. company battles, union beauracracy and a generally more difficult time and drawn out battle to achieve the wants and needs of the pilots. If we go union things will dramatically change. And the fact is that SKW is filled with great people and working solution from where we are today. What we need is a greater say in SAPA and an elected body to represent us, not people appointed by management.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Oh and as a side note Skywest may be a great airline (and I honest believe it is from what I hear and from the people I know who work for them) but the whole no pay throughout training and their so-called "up and out" policy is well, frankly, insulting.


[/ QUOTE ]

The pilots are fighting hard to change that. Thats not something we obviously like. It's management. And without being legally represented, we have no say. I am suprised when I hear people always poking about something we can't control. When your an "at will" employee, you have no say. It's not like we can walk into SGU headquarters and demand this or that. Or demand different pay rates for the 50 and 70 seaters. Yes there was a pilot vote about it years ago. If they would have rejected it, would SGU have said ok, since you guys who are "non-union" have rejected the same rate pay scale, we'll do it that way. Heck no. Mgmt is gonna do what ever they feel like doing. And as someone previously posted on this thread, they will do whats in their best interest to please the shareholders and maximize profits.
It will be interesting to watch when the 70-99 seaters roll into SKYW, the pay rates for those aircraft are the same as the 50 seater as well. If theres no union by then, you can bet nothing will change. If you think it won't be like that, your a fool thats still drinking the kool aid.
 
I agree, no pay during training is not fair. And honestly I think we're missing out on a whole group of pilots who just can't afford to come to Skywest for that reason. It's disappointing. The industry has sure changed quite a bit in the last few years- when I went through, I did not get paid during training. I didn't even get a paid hotel room. But that was a time when my peers were paying $10-15,000 to get their jobs at Comair and Chautaqua- I think even CoEx charged for their training. Not a rationalization, just showing how a change in perspective has taken place and not everyone has come around. Skywest did pay during training until 9/11. They nixed it when our code-share partners started putting the squeeze on their regionals. That and 10% of management's pay, freeze on pilot wages, disappearing snack baskets, and no more comped liquor! Regional flying is competetive out there- just ask Air Wisconsin, SKYW IAH pilots, and soon-to-be Mesa.


Up or Out Policy:

I think it's fair. If you can't pass your training, then you have no business flying the airplane. It's the same for newhires. However, you must understand that Skywest is not in the business of failing people and firing them just for the fun of it. The training dept really wants pilots to succeed and will not let them go without a fight. I have a friend who took his capt. sim ride THREE times before he passed. I think that last one would have been it for him had he not passed. THREE times, though. That's not a flippant "oh well, you failed, have a nice life." Is it any different at other "performance-based" industries?
 
[ QUOTE ]
they will do whats in their best interest to please the shareholders and maximize profits.

[/ QUOTE ]

Which actually puts more money in our pockets with our financial performance based bonuses! The way the company is operating right now, I've got an extra $5-6000 coming to me this year.
 
Back
Top