IFR Comm failure question

I dont have "proof", but it is my understanding that when the pilot squawks 7700, 7600, or 7500 the radar scope flashes that on the scope and the controller will know what is going on. Not that it would really be a big deal, but my instructor told me that squawking 7700 is the same as declaring an emergency over the radio and you may have to give explainations as to why you declared an emergency. If ATC clears traffic out of your way when they really didnt need to then they might get pissy about it.
 
I dont have "proof",

He's basically saying it used to be a recommended procedure. This was changed, however he doesn't know how long ago. I think MikeD even mentioned it - if I have my thoughts correct he also stated it's an old procedure and is no longer "recommended" any more.

Also, I might be wrong, but lost comm in IMC is an emergency to me. You just can't declare it to ATC.....because your radios don't work.
 
AIM 6-4-1 and 6-4-2 It just says 7600. I agree it would be a hairy situation to have no radios in IMC. I would have to fight the urge to declare an emergency
 
He's basically saying it used to be a recommended procedure. This was changed, however he doesn't know how long ago. I think MikeD even mentioned it - if I have my thoughts correct he also stated it's an old procedure and is no longer "recommended" any more.

Also, I might be wrong, but lost comm in IMC is an emergency to me. You just can't declare it to ATC.....because your radios don't work.
That makes sense
 
It just says 7600. I agree it would be a hairy situation to have no radios in IMC. I would have to fight the urge to declare an emergency
Using that same reasoning, a hijacking isn't an emergency. Is that how you feel?
 
The Regs say fly the highest of the altitudes for the route segment which is 3000 there is no need to delay the climb 10min, if you're flying a Jet at 250k, 10 min will put you 42NM out!! I couldn't find anything about it in the books but I appreciate the inputs guys, good stuff.

Before you make that your final answer, go ahead and READ THIS THREAD:

http://jetcareers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=25753

Notice, on the second page, I've posted a response from a controller. You might find what he says enlightening.

(just in case you decide to not click, he says DO NOT CLIMB until the time has expired)
 
Using that same reasoning, a hijacking isn't an emergency. Is that how you feel?
Not at all, I am just getting ready to take my instrument ride in two weeks and want to be sure I am on the right page. If I came across as smug or argumentative I apologize. When my instructor asked me a similar question a few weeks ago i said "squawk 7700" first and he made sure I understood that was not the correct procedure since it was not technically an "emergency"
 
When in doubt, declare an emergency. Never let the fear of ATC being put out, or getting "pissy" stop you from declaring. That's not the pilot's problem, and should never come into consideration. Don't worry about having to answer questions later, either. If you think that you have a situation that could benefit from getting some extra help, declare. You won't get busted for doing so, and the authorities would much rather have someone declare an emergency when things aren't very bad than the other way around.
 
When in doubt, declare an emergency. Never let the fear of ATC being put out, or getting "pissy" stop you from declaring. That's not the pilot's problem, and should never come into consideration. Don't worry about having to answer questions later, either. If you think that you have a situation that could benefit from getting some extra help, declare. You won't get busted for doing so, and the authorities would much rather have someone declare an emergency when things aren't very bad than the other way around.
That makes a lot more sense to me. I swear I learn way more here than I have in all the instruction I have recieved.
 
I think lost comm in IMC is an emergency. If I was filed into a high density area and knew I was flying over a podunk IFR airport, I'd just drop in there. You'd already be at min legal altitudes as your follow the lost comm procedure, so you don't need to worry about traffic below you. If ATC has you on radar and they see you heading for the podunk IFR airport, they won't release any departures from there and will clear the airspace for you.

Dial 7700 in the transponder declaring your emergency. 91.3 allows you to deviate from the lost comm reg if you think it's safer. Follow the course of action you find safest. Get on the ground safely. To me, that means quickly as I don't know why I lost comms. If my comm quit, do I have an unindicated alternator problem? Are my navs gonna quit next? Did the ATC facility get bombed and chaos reins in the sky with everyone flying around lost comm? You just don't know and the safest course of action might be to declare an emergency and land at the nearest suitable litte airport where you'll cause the minimum of heartache to the system.
 
If you're flying a jet plane, waiting 10min for higher at 250k will put you more than 40NM out, "expect 3,000 10min after departure" does not restrict you from an ealry climb if you lost your radio comm, in the given scenario I don't think the ATC would clear you to 3000 if you filed for 6000, they would consider a loss of comm after take-off and give you higher than that, especially when you're on a 300NM flight.
P.S don't forget to Tune and ID the VOR, there could be your clearnace for an approach back into your Departure airport yay.
 
If you're flying a jet plane, waiting 10min for higher at 250k will put you more than 40NM out, "expect 3,000 10min after departure" does not restrict you from an ealry climb if you lost your radio comm, in the given scenario I don't think the ATC would clear you to 3000 if you filed for 6000, they would consider a loss of comm after take-off and give you higher than that, especially when you're on a 300NM flight.
P.S don't forget to Tune and ID the VOR, there could be your clearnace for an approach back into your Departure airport yay.

YES IT DOES.

Seriously, did you even both reading the thread I posted a link to? Did you happen to read EatSleepFly's post, where he called a center controller and asked him what he thought? Did you read the post I forwarded from a controller in Hawaii about how the lost comm operations work?

Stop making up things. You're incorrect. It's people with attitudes like yours that end up killing others (not meant as a jab, sorry). Go read that thread, it could save your life and someone else's.
 
Why? If you are on a flightplan, recieved clearence, and following it then ATC wont have to provide any seperation that they would not provide were you to have your radios working fine.

Two scenarios:

#1 - You are departing IAD. You are cleared to destination (somewhere on the Chesapeake Bay) via the CAP5 departure (3000' initially as published), vectors to DAILY, then as filed, you are to expect 15,000 ten minutes after departure. You depart runway 30 at IAD. ATC's normal routine is to vector you north of IAD, turn you southeast, take you north of DCA, and somewhere near Andrews you finally get cleared direct to DAILY. After switching to departure, you receive clearance to climb to 7,000. Your comm radios go scratchy, and then dead. You squawk 7600, and ATC immediately expects you turn directly to DAILY to join the route along which you were cleared. A straight line from your current position to DAILY will take you across 3 different arrival streams, the BARIN1/COATT4 into IAD, the IRONS4/OJAAY1 into DCA and the OTT6 into BWI. As you climb from 3,000 to 7,000 and fly direct from the point of lost comms to DAILY, you cross the BARIN1/COATT4 arrivals that are descending on a northwesterly heading to join the 1L/R finals. After you wait your 10 minutes to elapse, you continue the climb to 15,000, and then cross the IRONS4/OJAAY1 streams, which are level over OJAAY at 10,000, and then on through the OTT6, which cross SABBI at 15,000 and descend on a northeasterly heading to cross OTT at 9,000.

SOMEWHERE along this line, airplanes will have to be moved out of the way.

#2 Same route, same clearance, same situation. You squawk 7700 for one minute, then squawk 7600, all the while making your turn to DAILY. Same thing, SOMEWHERE along this line, airplanes will have to be moved out of the way.

Thats what I mean by it'll happen regardless of what you choose to squawk.
 
Read the given scenario, If you stay at 2000 you're below MEA and you can't guarantee obstacle clearance or navigtional reception once you get back on route not to mention if you're flying at high speed ouch! but you would still maintain 2000 because thats what the controller likes you to do, NOW I'm not sure who is the one trying to kill himself here. if you are wondering what I would do.. I would maintain 2000 for 10min if I think I'll be safe and I know exactly where I am in terms of location and terrain proximity, and my equipment limitation. you are RIGHT, the controllers expect you to maintain it for 10min, I'm just referring to the given scenario. and please for future reference don't use that kind of language, keep it friendly.
 
Don't think so. If you're on an IFR plan and in actual, they don't want you "turning away" to avoid their airspace. You're gonna screw them up and they will have no clue what route you're on then.


Well, I was saying ATCs would appreciate if you can stay away from the regular arrival and departure route for big boys. This idea is a very scenario based. The airport where I instruct is very close one big airport OM. If you lost comm on approach, ATC will have to shut down the approach path for this "big" airport till you called in and cancel your IFR clearance. There will be some people who will be interesting talk to you. On the other hand, if you fly to your first fix in this airspace, you will cross some heavy traffic route. This idea is just me and one of my fellow instructors(Tracon ATC) talk about.
 
You wuss. :)

HS

well it would be a great time to finally use my backup radio lol

but all in seriousness if both radios fail, I would def consider turning back around... anytime something isnt right with the plane, i'd be worried... you never know what might fail next

am i the only one who thinks this?
 
SOMEWHERE along this line, airplanes will have to be moved out of the way.
I agree completely, what I am trying to figure out here is wouldn't ATC already be providing seperation if you are cleared on that route? Again I am not trying to prove myself right or wrong, I am wanting to be sure I know this before my ride in a few weeks. If you decided to deviate from the route and return to land then I would answer differently, but according to the AIM you would not squawk 7700. Like I said earlier my instructor made sure I understood the procedure as the FAA writes it for the checkride, not that you would necessarily follow that to the letter in a real situation. Just looking to learn more.:)
 
I'd personally turn around to the airport, shoot an approach and land (assuming the nav radios are working). I'm not going to fly an airplane with a know problem with a (most likely) unknown cause for hours on end when an airport's practically underneith me.

If everything died, I'm headed towards VFR.

From what I heard from a former ATC guy, they pretty much vector planes in away from you and just kinda wait to see where you're going to go.
 
Back
Top