IFR Comm failure question

Also, there is no need to sqwak 7700, as lost comms aren't an "emergency" and you are really in no harm.
Adreamer is just living in the past a bit. The transponder piece of the lost comm procedure =used to= be to squawk 7700 for one minute and then switch to 7600. It was changed some years ago (I'm thinking around 10)
 
I agree completely, what I am trying to figure out here is wouldn't ATC already be providing seperation if you are cleared on that route? Again I am not trying to prove myself right or wrong, I am wanting to be sure I know this before my ride in a few weeks. If you decided to deviate from the route and return to land then I would answer differently, but according to the AIM you would not squawk 7700. Like I said earlier my instructor made sure I understood the procedure as the FAA writes it for the checkride, not that you would necessarily follow that to the letter in a real situation. Just looking to learn more.:)

I'm mostly assuming that this would happen in a radar environment. Non-radar would have a much greater impact on things from an ATC standpoint. Keep in mind that airways are 2-way streets, and also intersect with other 2-way airways. In a normal situation, you will be in a radar environment, maintaining 2-way communications with ATC. After departure, you may be climbed to an intermediate altitude. Not only are you held at an intermediate altitude for traffic, but also airspace sectorization. When ATC sees a space for you to climb to your final altitude, they will instruct you to do so. This instruction could come 2, 7, 10, 12, or any number of minutes after departure. If you are in radio communication, they would only allow you to climb when there were no conflicts. They can also instruct to "maintain visual separation, climb and maintain xxxx". In a lost comms situation, you will climb to your "expected" altitude exactly 10 minutes after departure. This may or may not put you into a potential conflict situation with oncoming traffic at altitudes through which you will be climbing. If there is a potential conflict, ATC will have to take action on the aircraft with which they still have communications; vectors off airway, descents before intented, etc. Also, they will have to take further steps for coordination with adjacent controllers who's airspace you will be transiting.

It sounds as though you may be thinking in terms of a non-radar environment. Unfortunately, even using radar, with airspace being as congested as it is today, it isn't as simple as "providing separation if you are cleared on that route".
 
If you stay at 2000 you're below MEA and you can't guarantee obstacle clearance or navigtional reception once you get back on route not to mention if you're flying at high speed ouch!

That was already covered. Again, all I wanted you to realize was that the expect time was a restriction. Obviously you wouldn't fly below a MORA/MEA, that is part of the Lost Comm procedures (highest of...).
 
No, the reason for the 10 minute delay is for the exact scenario you just outlined. If you lose comms, the controller will know EXACTLY when to expect you to climb to your "expected" altitude. That is one of the reasons to start the chronograph when you start the takeoff roll.

And whoever said climb to 6000 should read 91.185 again:

2) Altitude. At the highest of the following altitudes or flight levels for the route segment being flown:
(i) The altitude or flight level assigned in the last ATC clearance received; (2,000 initially)
(ii) The minimum altitude (converted, if appropriate, to minimum flight level as prescribed in §91.121(c)) for IFR operations; or (3000 MEA on the route)
(iii) The altitude or flight level ATC has advised may be expected in a further clearance. (expect 3000 in 10 minutes)

Nothing there about 6000.



You are exactly right. I think I said maintain 6000' feet after ten minutes, but you are only cleared to 3000'. No arguments there, 3000' it is.
 
I'm mostly assuming that this would happen in a radar environment. Non-radar would have a much greater impact on things from an ATC standpoint. Keep in mind that airways are 2-way streets, and also intersect with other 2-way airways. In a normal situation, you will be in a radar environment, maintaining 2-way communications with ATC. After departure, you may be climbed to an intermediate altitude. Not only are you held at an intermediate altitude for traffic, but also airspace sectorization. When ATC sees a space for you to climb to your final altitude, they will instruct you to do so. This instruction could come 2, 7, 10, 12, or any number of minutes after departure. If you are in radio communication, they would only allow you to climb when there were no conflicts. They can also instruct to "maintain visual separation, climb and maintain xxxx". In a lost comms situation, you will climb to your "expected" altitude exactly 10 minutes after departure. This may or may not put you into a potential conflict situation with oncoming traffic at altitudes through which you will be climbing. If there is a potential conflict, ATC will have to take action on the aircraft with which they still have communications; vectors off airway, descents before intented, etc. Also, they will have to take further steps for coordination with adjacent controllers who's airspace you will be transiting.

It sounds as though you may be thinking in terms of a non-radar environment. Unfortunately, even using radar, with airspace being as congested as it is today, it isn't as simple as "providing separation if you are cleared on that route".
That clears it up in my head a lot, thank you.
 
Baed on what understand from my fellow instructor who also is Tracon ATC. For the case you describe, You fly to your first fix on your route, climb to 2000 and squawk 7600, climb to 3000 10 minutes after your takeoff time. (Remember to write down your takeoff time, :)), ATC expect and will clear the airspace around and above you. Fly your filed route if the entire route in your filed flight plan is under IMC. If you can find VMC, that would be great. If not, try to arrive the destination airport as close your filed arrival time. ATC is more likely pay real close attention on your movement.

Just my 0.02

Thats EXACLTY what I would do, don't confused ATC with a guessing game of what you are going to do. Do it how your supposed to, by continuing sqwaking 7600 and using MEA and AVEF for altitude and route respectively, and do your flight. That way they know exactly what your doing and can keep you away from other aircraft.
 
It sounds as though you may be thinking in terms of a non-radar environment. Unfortunately, even using radar, with airspace being as congested as it is today, it isn't as simple as "providing separation if you are cleared on that route".

It may not be easy for ATC, but it's done all the time. We've probably all been vectored for a NORDO aircraft before.

The weirdest Lost-Comm scenario happen this last summer. I departed runway 12 @ CPS, at about 0445, IMC. I'd been cleared to MKC AF, Runway heading, maintain 2100, expect 6000 in 10 minutes. Got my void time, and launched. Flew runway heading (as instructed), and checked in with departure. He have me a right turn to 190 for traffic, and I complied. And, I flew that for about 6 minutes. It was really quiet, which was normal before 0500. However, it was REALLY quiet. I called approach, and had no answer at all. I tried every approach frequency that I knew, and all that I found in the plates. Nothing. However, I could still pick up the AWOS at CPS, and the ATIS at STL.

So, I squawked 7600 while I worked it out. I turned direct to my first fix, climbed to my expected altitude, and took a few minute to think it through. I thought it best to call the next facility along my route, and it worked. Mizzou Approach let me know that I was doing ok, and that STL's TRACON had suffered a total power loss - EVERYTHING!!!! No radar, no radios, nothing. They were down for the better part of any hour.

That was weird, but not scary.
 
Thanks for all the responses everyone. When I answered this question "at first" it wasn't correct in terms of what FAR 91.185 would have us do. My first priority was to return to my departure field and land squawking 7600.
Evaluator didn't like that answer.

So I modified by saying I would fly my flight plan out "until" I reached VFR conditions and THEN would land in VFR. He like that one better. As far as altitudes most of you were correct in that in cases like this we would fly based on the highest of either the published MEA, What was assigned, or what was expected.

In my case I would simply fly at 2000, get on my flight plan, then in 10 minutes climb to 3k for the rest of my flight. Since the MEA's for my entire route top out at 2400 I would remain at 3k.

In any case, without radios, I would not be comfortable flying into the possibility of severe weather without the ability to get updates in the air via EFAS/HIWAS/FSS or ATIS etc.

Thanks again and Happy Holidays
 
Back
Top