IFR Comm failure question

Beechlover

Well-Known Member
Good morning and Happy Holidays everybody. I just passed my instrument check ride yesterday! Haven't had to study that hard in years, now I can relax and enjoy the holidays, whew. Here's a question that came up, and I'd like to see what your opinions are if you'd like to share them. Here's some background info to work from..,

You flight plan an IFR flight in a small general aviation twin engine prop for a 300 mile flight. The air field you are flying from is mid sized, towered, and is currently IFR in Class D airspace. (reporting Overcast 600 with 2 miles vis) Your route of flight utilizes victor routes, and your planned altitute is 6000. (the highest MEA for any route on this trip is 3000) You will pass through the middle of the busiest portion of a Class B airspace over flying a major city with a large and very busy international airport and several smaller "executive" airports. Your destination airport, is a large towered airport in class C airpace that services mostly domestic commercial traffic.

Weather enroute is mostly VMC but there is a large cold front moving (from the northwest) into your destination's area later in the day "potentially" around the time you plan to arrive there. As a note, this flight will be approaching the destination airport from the southeast. The weather is currently Marginal VFR there with light rain and is forecast to be IFR as the day (and the cold front progresses). Of course this cold front brings with it, heavy thunderstorm activity , moderate to heavy turbulence, wind shear etc.

Here's the question..,

You get in the plane, start up, pick up atis and contact grnd for your clearance. They pass.., "Cleared to your destination as filed, climb and maintain 2000, expect 3000 in ten minutes, contact departure on 132.6, squawk 1234. You taxi to runway 9, contact tower, who then says fly heading 090, cleared for takeoff. Your climbout quickly puts you into the overcast and you are in solid IMC. About 2 miles east of the field tower tells you to contact departure. When you make the switch both radios fail, and after a quick troubleshooting, you realize there is no getting them back.., what do you do?
 
First thing SQUAWK 6600. Start climbing to 6000 since it's the highest and being situatuinal aware of you're position fly direct to the VOR where your first portion of the flight or the DP begins or intercept the V airway (I'd have to see the chart). as soon as you encounter VMC find an appropriate airport and land, if you don't encountetr VMC continue as filed to your destination I'm sure you'll find VMC somewhere along 300NM!! if not and that cold front brought TS and restricted vis and I take it you didn't file for an alternate. then it depends on your type of ops 91.3 says you can deviate from any 91 rule if you think it's emergency I would... No Radio + solid IMC + lightening + turbulence + Not GPS equipped! I would turn away from it and navigate to an airport with better condition giving the ATC some time to coordinate with other airports.
 
First thing SQUAWK 6600. Start climbing to 6000 since it's the highest and being situatuinal aware of you're position fly direct to the VOR where your first portion of the flight or the DP begins or intercept the V airway (I'd have to see the chart). as soon as you encounter VMC find an appropriate airport and land, if you don't encountetr VMC continue as filed to your destination I'm sure you'll find VMC somewhere along 300NM!! if not and that cold front brought TS and restricted vis and I take it you didn't file for an alternate. then it depends on your type of ops 91.3 says you can deviate from any 91 rule if you think it's emergency I would... No Radio + solid IMC + lightening + turbulence + Not GPS equipped! I would turn away from it and navigate to an airport with better condition giving the ATC some time to coordinate with other airports.

I'd have to see some charts. However, I would not climb to 6000' until ten minutes has expired. Very likely though, that 2000' will be below most MEA's....so you may have to climb to the MEA. After ten minutes...climb to 6000'. That takes care of the altitude.

I like the way your examiner/inspector posed the scenario. It allows you to demonstrate a complete understanding of the rules. Too many times in training, we spout off the one liner of rules...not completely understanding how to do it for real.
 
Squawk 7600, maintain 2000 for 10 minutes or until you reach a point with an MEA of 3000, at which time you should maintain 3000. Continue on your route as filed.

If you get into VMC, go VFR to the nearest suitable airport and land.

If you don't get in to VMC and don't think you will get in to VMC in any reasonable amount of time (you do have a weather forecast with you, don't you?), you should return to the airport you departed from, set yourself up for the active approach there, and land.

This is all assuming the Class D airport you departed out of has you on radar. If it's a non-radar environment, I would continue the trip and *not* return.

The letter of the law says you should continue the trip as filed until reaching VMC or your destination, but I think that's dumb. There's no reason to screw up busy airspace (Class B and C) by continuing without radios when a quick, easy return is possible. Also, do you know what caused the radios to fail? How do you know nothing else is going to fail because of the same problem? I'd rather not be droning along in solid IMC for 300 miles with the possibility of more important equipment (VORs, GPS, transponder) failing.
 
Squawk 7600, maintain 2000 for 10 minutes or until you reach a point with an MEA of 3000, at which time you should maintain 3000. Continue on your route as filed.

If you get into VMC, go VFR to the nearest suitable airport and land.

If you don't get in to VMC and don't think you will get in to VMC in any reasonable amount of time (you do have a weather forecast with you, don't you?), you should return to the airport you departed from, set yourself up for the active approach there, and land.

This is all assuming the Class D airport you departed out of has you on radar. If it's a non-radar environment, I would continue the trip and *not* return.

The letter of the law says you should continue the trip as filed until reaching VMC or your destination, but I think that's dumb. There's no reason to screw up busy airspace (Class B and C) by continuing without radios when a quick, easy return is possible. Also, do you know what caused the radios to fail? How do you know nothing else is going to fail because of the same problem? I'd rather not be droning along in solid IMC for 300 miles with the possibility of more important equipment (VORs, GPS, transponder) failing.

I'd say if you're going to do that, an important point to mention would be, make sure you declare an emergency (ie: squawk 7700 at least momentarily) as you're now deviating from the FAR's.
 
Ops! Yeah I meant 7600,
But why wait 10min before continuing the climb? How often did we have to wait 10min? I think the sole purpose of that 10min delay is to keep you in class D till they can hand you off to the next controller when you leave their airspace, if you keep climbing out of 2500AGL then you're not in D airspace any longer! the rules say as expected but that's in terms of highet not time! so keep on climbing.
 
No, the reason for the 10 minute delay is for the exact scenario you just outlined. If you lose comms, the controller will know EXACTLY when to expect you to climb to your "expected" altitude. That is one of the reasons to start the chronograph when you start the takeoff roll.

And whoever said climb to 6000 should read 91.185 again:

2) Altitude. At the highest of the following altitudes or flight levels for the route segment being flown:
(i) The altitude or flight level assigned in the last ATC clearance received; (2,000 initially)
(ii) The minimum altitude (converted, if appropriate, to minimum flight level as prescribed in §91.121(c)) for IFR operations; or (3000 MEA on the route)
(iii) The altitude or flight level ATC has advised may be expected in a further clearance. (expect 3000 in 10 minutes)

Nothing there about 6000.
 
Couple things. You wait 10mins because thats what your clearence tells you to do. Remember if you follow your flight plan then ATC "knows" what you are doing. If you deviate and return to the airport you departed, you could just as easily screw something up there as you could at a busier airport. Some other things to consider however. You are approaching a cold front which usually brings with it a wind shift and rapidly changing weather conditions. Do you want to shoot an approach with no idea what weather your in because you cannot receive an ATIS? But since you said that the weather enroute is VMC as soon as you get there land at the nearest airport.
 
Baed on what understand from my fellow instructor who also is Tracon ATC. For the case you describe, You fly to your first fix on your route, climb to 2000 and squawk 7600, climb to 3000 10 minutes after your takeoff time. (Remember to write down your takeoff time, :)), ATC expect and will clear the airspace around and above you. Fly your filed route if the entire route in your filed flight plan is under IMC. If you can find VMC, that would be great. If not, try to arrive the destination airport as close your filed arrival time. ATC is more likely pay real close attention on your movement.

Just my 0.02
 
Forgot to this, if you are flying around the busy air space, ATL, LAX...etc. Try to turn away from those primary airports. ATC would really appreciate that. :) The moment you realize you lost comm, you ...

squawk 7700

Do that for about a minute or so, then squawk 7600. It would alert ATCs and the whole system about your situation.

Try to arrive your destination airport or IAF(initial approach fix) at your filed time arrival or close to it. ATC will clear out the airspace for you.
 
Forgot to this, if you are flying around the busy air space, ATL, LAX...etc. Try to turn away from those primary airports. ATC would really appreciate that. :) The moment you realize you lost comm, you ...



Do that for about a minute or so, then squawk 7600. It would alert ATCs and the whole system about your situation.

Try to arrive your destination airport or IAF(initial approach fix) at your filed time arrival or close to it. ATC will clear out the airspace for you.


Don't think so. If you're on an IFR plan and in actual, they don't want you "turning away" to avoid their airspace. You're gonna screw them up and they will have no clue what route you're on then.
 
Don't think so. If you're on an IFR plan and in actual, they don't want you "turning away" to avoid their airspace. You're gonna screw them up and they will have no clue what route you're on then.

Agreed. If you follow the regs, you will be just fine. The last thing you want to do is start making up your own rules causing a controller to vector 30 airplanes around where he "thinks" you are headed. You will definitely have some explaining to do and could get a violation.

Also, there is no need to sqwak 7700, as lost comms aren't an "emergency" and you are really in no harm. Do what you are supposed to and no metal will get bent.
 
I agree with the guy from ERAU. I would continue all the way to the destination at 3,000.

Unless of course, I get into VMC. Then I would land somewhere.

Returning would probably cause more headaches to the system. ATC wouldn't be expecting you to come back.

HS
 
Also, there is no need to sqwak 7700, as lost comms aren't an "emergency" and you are really in no harm. Do what you are supposed to and no metal will get bent.
:yeahthat:Squawking 7600 will alert ATC just as much as 7700, no sense creating an "emergency" when one does not exist.
 
:yeahthat:Squawking 7600 will alert ATC just as much as 7700, no sense creating an "emergency" when one does not exist.

I think I once read in some "learn to fly" type book that the suggested procedure was to squawk 7700 for one minute, and then 7600. This cycle was repeated every so often (it gave a time frame, but I don't recall). That was back in the mid-90s and could have been an old skool way of things. It could have been changed, so I won't be offended if someone cites proof that I'm wrong.
 
Back
Top