There's nothing intrinsically wrong with wanting more for less, that's basic capitalism.
However, demanding more for less and doing so through "passenger bill of rights" legislation and the "Yeah I bought a Z-class ticket, you wouldn't dare put me in a middle seat in the back of the airplane" is tiresome.
I wouldn't walk into Ruth's Chris and say, "$40? Yower rippin' me awf! The Sizzler is only $14 and it's probably from the same cow!"
But that’s not what is going on.
More or less everyone possesses an understanding that Sizzler and RC’s represent different market positioning and offer different quality experiences. Just as everyone understands that buying a first class ticket is going to cost more and provide a different experience than buying a coach ticket - vestigial marketing speak for a second class ticket. It’s precisely that understanding that would make your point correct and poignant if the restaurant scenario you posited ever happened.
But as much as we in the aviation industrial complex would like it to be otherwise, that same level of understanding of expectation does not apply in airline travel. When average travelers buy a ticket for a seat, they are buying a seat. Their expectation, especially once they’ve been seated in the position designated on their boarding pass, is that the seat is theirs. They paid for it; now they get to use it and go where they planned to go. Do some folks occasionally feel a little schadenfreude or invidious distinction when they know they paid $X more or less for the seat than the guy sitting next to them? Sure, many do. But do they understand why they paid more or less? Not really. To them, it’s the same seat. Despite our industry-insider howls of "differentiation", there is no expectation to a passenger that it would or could be different.
The vast majority of airline consumers have no idea what a Z fair is, or a Y fair, or an O fair, or a double secret probation fair. And I would argue rather strenuously that the airlines don’t want them to have any idea. If they did, the airlines would bullet point the differences, restrictions, and privileges clearly, obviously, and concisely.
At restaurants, there are no Z steaks and Y steaks. At the Sizzler the ribeye costs, let’s say, $14. You get what you paid for. But you can rest assured that every other diner who ordered that same ribeye is paying the same $14 and getting the same slab of meat. Similarly, at RC’s everyone who orders the ribeye is paying $40 and getting the same ribeye. But again, everyone knows that. So that’s not the comparison to what is going on with airline customers.
When you buy a steak, you buy a steak. There is no obfuscated, arcane, legal document dictating the terms and conditions of your steak purchase. If your steak sucks, you can send it back and get a different one, or get your money back. And finally, when you are sitting at your table at RC’s or Sizzler or any other restaurant, a waiter isn’t going to show up at your booth, serve you your hot juicy steak and then moments later, turn around, snatch it back and give it to someone other diner, let alone to some restaurant employee, ‘cause, you know, “we mis-ordered and have to feed the help”.
We in the industry understand the nuances of what’s going on, so to us the guy who refused to give up the seat he bought and had delivered to him might seem unwashed, unruly, and intransigent. But to the average traveller and to the public, he seems like the victim of fraud and abuse.
Demands for a Pax “Bill of Rights” could be quashed immediately if airlines would just be more forthright and transparent in their offerings. That which need not be complex should not be. Fine print is the province of the disingenuous, the fearful, and the cowering.
You often speak of an elevator speech for airline applicants. The same should apply for airline seats. If airlines -or anyone else- can’t explain clearly what they’re selling in bullet points on the back of the ticket, they’re doing it wrong, and no one is going to trust them.