How the Airlines Became Abusive Cartels

Absolute poppycock. Yes, service drops when prices drop. Duh. The simple fact of the matter is that airline travel has become infrastructure, like the national highway system. Why don't you try suing the state DOT when you're slowed down by the fact that, uh, you know, roads require maintenance? Are there inefficiencies in the system? I'm sure there are. But there absolutely is real competition, and real differentiation in the product one receives for a similar amount of money. It's all well and good to be eternally pissed off about everything, always, if you've no part in making the thing work in the first place. It's easy, and it tickles the Outrage Gene we've evidently all discovered in ourselves in the last 20 years or so. But with X aircraft, Y runways, Z gates, etc., our system moves more people faster and cheaper than anywhere else, past or present. If you just cannot possibly be delayed, charter an airplane for 10x the cost of a business class ticket. Then I'll get to be the lucky guy who tells you that, woops, sorry, the weather still applies, and we're going to Rifle. Have a nice drive to Aspen. At least you'll have catering.
 
Wait, did this author just state that airlines should emulate Amtrak as a business model, using it as an example of how it won't destroy the currently profitable airline model? Amtrak? As in the government subsidized company that has never made a profit?

I'm sure they'll get right on that.
 
The airline industry has never been better for both providers and customers. Don’t like the stupid rules of the Big 3? Fly Allegiant, Southwest, JetBlue, VA/Alaska, Hawaiian, etc. The unregulated bloodbath of the 90s wasn’t sustainable and the market corrected for that either through consolidation or through participants leaving the market.
 
Passengers want more from the airlines but yet a majority roll out of bed, don't shower, and travel in their pajamas???

If airlines were to say something about that in today's world people would explode.

Now that we're 15+ years past 9/11, people forget why the security is there. We're in a world now where people complain the WiFi isn't on below 10,000 feet. Seriously.

Perspective.
 
This is what happens when passengers want more for less.

It's also what happens when old Betty should have retired as a flight attendant 15 years ago.
 
My miles were about to expire on Frontier, so I decided to fly them to LAS. The ticket was $19.10, after tax, and the airfare was $0.98, the rest was taxes and fees. With 2017 inflation rates.

Yeah...in a world where that is happening, you get what you pay for. Even United was $50 each way that same day. Watch a few Low Fare Airline ads from the 80s on YouTube and you'll see things like "Mega Sale on AirCal, SFO-LAS for $49 each way!"...in 1984 money. And it was a deal at the time. When the masses want the cheapest price and compare online in seconds, that becomes the bottom line for all but the top-tier frequent flyers and premium cabin passengers as far as the airlines are concerned. Don't like it? Stay loyal to an airline and buy fullfare tickets and hope the masses do the same. But they won't.
 
My miles were about to expire on Frontier, so I decided to fly them to LAS. The ticket was $19.10, after tax, and the airfare was $0.98, the rest was taxes and fees. With 2017 inflation rates.

Yeah...in a world where that is happening, you get what you pay for. Even United was $50 each way that same day. Watch a few Low Fare Airline ads from the 80s on YouTube and you'll see things like "Mega Sale on AirCal, SFO-LAS for $49 each way!"...in 1984 money. And it was a deal at the time. When the masses want the cheapest price and compare online in seconds, that becomes the bottom line for all but the top-tier frequent flyers and premium cabin passengers as far as the airlines are concerned. Don't like it? Stay loyal to an airline and buy fullfare tickets and hope the masses do the same. But they won't.
$20 to fly SFO-LAS?

Jesus I really can't comprehend how the legacies are going to compete...I mean...I just can't even imagine paying that kind of money.

If that becomes the norm we can kiss $300k good bye. $50k FOs and $75k CAs on narrowbody equipment.

I'm banking my money now because this is, quite frankly, the best we'll ever see it as far as pay/QOL goes in the US. IMO.
 
It's also what happens when old Betty should have retired as a flight attendant 15 years ago.

Whatever. On my first trip off IOE I had an FA in her 60's who was also brand new, it was her third career.

Her first career was 20 years as a marine.

I doubt she'd have any problem keeping the cabin in line.

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk
 
$20 to fly SFO-LAS?

Jesus I really can't comprehend how the legacies are going to compete...I mean...I just can't even imagine paying that kind of money.

If that becomes the norm we can kiss $300k good bye. $50k FOs and $75k CAs on narrowbody equipment.

I'm banking my money now because this is, quite frankly, the best we'll ever see it as far as pay/QOL goes in the US. IMO.

The sky isn't falling. The ULCC's only sell a few seats at prices that low. Most of the profit is from the al a carte pricing on everything from bags to a can of soda to a seat assignment ahead of time.

Frontier and Spirit had 2 of the lowest CASM's and two of the highest profit margins through at least the first 9mos of 2016. I know one of them made $125m in 1 quarter with only 60-ish airplanes. The money is there and both pilot groups are working to improve their compensation packages.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tld
The sky isn't falling. The ULCC's only sell a few seats at prices that low. Most of the profit is from the al a carte pricing on everything from bags to a can of soda to a seat assignment ahead of time.
They actually sell A LOT of seats that low($20-60). But yes, they rely on people not understanding the fees. Didn't print your boarding pass? $20. Oh, you want to sit together? $50 each way. Oh that carry-on needs to go in the over head bin and you didn't pay in advance? $100. An assigned window seat would have cost me as much as the boarding pass. Actually come to think of it, I spent more on liquor on that flight than I did for the seat.

But people like me who buy a $20 last minute airfare to Vegas with nothing but a backpack aware of all the fees and play lottery with the seat assignment are a rarity in the grand scheme of things. When Frontier said "Oh, by the way, 2 weeks notice or you lose all your miles when you're less than 200 miles from a free roundtrip", they probably didn't expect that all I'd have to do to earn the roundtrip was throw them $0.98 and run up a little bar tab then non-rev home. If that was the case, these fares would go bye-bye. I'd be surprised if any less than 90% of pax have to pay some kind of fee on each leg either out of necessity or being unprepared. And of those, I'm curious how many pax could have saved money on Delta, Southwest, jetBlue, ect not having to pay for seats, carry-ons, boarding passes, ect.

Still, long haul is one thing because not everyone is willing to save $600 but sit upright in a plastic seat for 12 hours staring at the wall...but domestically, even though SFO-ORD-SFO on Frontier hurt my back for 2 days, $98 roundtrip vs $400+ on United that same weekend...it is hard to compete domestically with the leisure crowd who flock to ULCCs. Oddly enough, though SFO/SJC/OAK-LAX/BUR/SNA/ONT/LGB have some of the highest frequencies of any city/area pair in the world(peaks close to 400 daily flights at times), Spirit's 2-3 OAK-LAX flights each day are the only ULCC flights between them. The legacy carriers must be doing something right, maybe it is just the ability for them to win a fare war on these well-established route pairs. jetBlue already has SJC-LGB for $39 after tax often...
 
Last edited:
I love Frontier. I just got a non-stop round trip on Frontier from LAS to IAD for about $220. The added charges below.

Carry on: $30.00 - $60.00
1st checked bag: $25.00 - $40.00
2nd checked bag: $30.00 - $45.00
 
Wow, another *journalist* trying to cash in on the easy topic of the day.
Regardless of the persuasiveness of this writer's opinion to you, are you attempting to besmirch journalism, or do you really not understand the difference between a journalist and an opinion writer?

Despite 20 years of Fox's best attempts to dumb down the population into believing that editorial content and journalism are synonymous, THEY ARE NOT THE SAME THING.

The author of the OP-ED opinion piece cited in the original post is a professor of public policy. He is not a journalist.
Absolute poppycock. Yes, service drops when prices drop. Duh. The simple fact of the matter is that airline travel has become infrastructure, like the national highway system. Why don't you try suing the state DOT when you're slowed down by the fact that, uh, you know, roads require maintenance? Are there inefficiencies in the system? I'm sure there are. But there absolutely is real competition, and real differentiation in the product one receives for a similar amount of money. It's all well and good to be eternally pissed off about everything, always, if you've no part in making the thing work in the first place. It's easy, and it tickles the Outrage Gene we've evidently all discovered in ourselves in the last 20 years or so. But with X aircraft, Y runways, Z gates, etc., our system moves more people faster and cheaper than anywhere else, past or present. If you just cannot possibly be delayed, charter an airplane for 10x the cost of a business class ticket. Then I'll get to be the lucky guy who tells you that, woops, sorry, the weather still applies, and we're going to Rifle. Have a nice drive to Aspen. At least you'll have catering.

Wow, that's pretty absolute. Unexpected coming from you. Absolute poppycock? You sure? Which of his statements, specifically, are poppycock?

The only outrage genes I see expressing are some which are known to be activated by reaction genes here on this board. I noted no outrage in Kuttner's piece. He is certainly concerned at the level of service provided by US carriers, and as a customer of those service providers, I share his concern. Perhaps if I could just assimilate and become part of the consumer Borg, I might feel differently. In any case, he offers some specific remedies to specific maladies afflicting the system. I'm scratching my noggin trying to suss out if your stinging but somewhat rambling response* is aimed at his diagnoses or his proposed Rx. ??

As far as real competition goes... there is little among the big three. There is some from the minor majors like Southwest et al. Differentiation among the big three? I'll just say that as a guy who flies major airlines a fair amount, I don't see it. For me, the big three experience is almost always inconsistent, convoluted, uncertain, and stressful. Southwest sells essentially the same product, a seat. Yet, there is a huge difference in experience. Southwest, in particular, does many things in a far more straightforward and understandable fashion than the big three. While they sell the same mundane seat you could buy elsewhere, the experience is understandable, predicable and flexible. You know what you are buying, and you know that if your plans change, or if their plans change, you're not going to lose the value of what you already purchased. There are a lot of reasons for this, but I would argue that the primary driver behind all of them was Southwest's inception as an airline designed to serve markets underserved by the hub and spoke system. That service orientation infused the whole shebang right from the get go. Profit was always important to Southwest as well, but as a byproduct of service. And yes, even at Southwest, things are changing as they age farther and farther away from their initial conception. But at the big three, I feel like I've gone to Vegas. The vibe feels like "let's extract as much from consumers as possible while giving them back as little as possible, preferably nothing." Again, just my personal experience.

Internationally? US Airlines? No. That's where you see real differentiation. Europe? I'll buy the ticket through United, but I'll make damned sure it's the Lufthansa jet I fly on. South America? I'll buy the ticket through American, but I'll make damned sure it's the LAN Chile jet I fly on. - It's. Just. Not. Even. Close. I'm sorry if this annoys some of you who are working for US carriers. I wish it were otherwise, I really do. But as it stands now, as a customer, you'd have to be a dolt to choose to sit on a pay-per-breath, dirty, old plane with fang-bearing FAs when you could get to the same place and -even in coach- feel somewhat pampered for the same money.

Again, just my opinion, but I see most of the problems with the majors as "legacy" problems. That's not a pun, but probably the best way to describe the situation. These are companies with the complacency and "we've got ours" attitudes of legacy holders. They are more interested in protecting what they've got than in innovating to better serve and change. Legacy executives (in any industry) will almost always see innovation as risky and therefore eschew it overtly, but more insidiously, they eschew it unconsciously. They don't even know they're doing it. Sometimes their desire to protect earnings and share prices becomes so toxic they let core equipment fail to save on maintenance. Recall Ameritech letting Chicago metro telco switches drop while they "primped for the prom" (that's banker speak for making their numbers look good to maximize buyout price). The Baby Bells were a lot like the Legacy Airlines. They were the deregulated pieces of the former Ma Bell (ATT). As they predictably gobbled each other up post-deregulation breakup -just like the airlines- they rearranged themselves into the ultimate nightmare. The New ATT. A company beloved by consumers nationwide. A company where CSR means "Customer Shield Representative". A company that retains all the attitude and most of the scope of its former regulated monopoly self, but with none of the customer protections or regulations that formerly mitigated its behavior. Heck, that could be its motto: The New ATT. All the Attitude, None of the Regulation". They could have invested in new technology and recreated themselves into huge players in the networked computing age. But instead, they simply attempted to protect their legacy. Kodak is another example. Leading player in photography. Invented and patented most of the innovations that enabled digital photography. But never risked going after it because they were too afraid it would cannibalize their legacy film business. It did. But instead of Kodak cannibalizing it's own legacy business, others ate Kodak's children. In trying to protect it's legacy, Kodak lost sight of serving customers, accepting change and reifying its innovations. Kodak's managers weren't stupid. They pursued a wise, enlightened, conservative strategy to protect profits, avoid risks, and keep themselves fat and happy. Kodak went bankrupt and lost everything. I hope the US legacy carriers don't continue to pursue the same wise strategy.

*yah, ok. mine's a tad rambling too. ;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Whatever. On my first trip off IOE I had an FA in her 60's who was also brand new, it was her third career.

Her first career was 20 years as a marine.

I doubt she'd have any problem keeping the cabin in line.

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

It not necessarily about age. It's more about people who are in their upper 60's who have been doing it for 35+ years and a bitter and burnt out.
 
#triggered
IMG_3168.PNG
 
Back
Top