How the Airlines Became Abusive Cartels

U.S. airline industry monopoly power as of 2015,

“Airlines aren’t going at each other like they used to,” said Mike Boyd, an aviation consultant frequently hired by airports. “They have their turf, and they very rarely go to the mattresses with one another.”

At 40 of the 100 largest U.S. airports, a single airline controls a majority of the market, as measured by the number of seats for sale, up from 34 airports a decade earlier.

At 93 of the top 100, one or two airlines control a majority of the seats, an increase from 78 airports, according to AP’s analysis of data from Diio LLC, an airline-schedule tracking service."
http://www.denverpost.com/2015/07/1...s-created-airport-monopolies-increased-fares/

Ex. Delta and its regional carriers make up close to 80 percent of the traffic at Atlanta.
 
Allegiant had $100 round trip Hawaii fares. They will get their money from you somehow in other fees. It's pretty rare someone travels with absolutely nothing, not even a carry on. Because that can cost you $50 at the airport, one way. Boom your $50 ticket becomes $200+ and now it's delayed/cancelled and you have no agreement to get rescheduled on another airline.

I'm not at all worried those $20-50 flights will make our pay go down. Clearly it hasn't changed anything for years.
 
#triggered

image.jpeg
 
I mean...I don't get the hate of "people want more for less!"

Of course people want more for less. Do you ever complain when you go to the grocery store and you can buy more cheese for less money? Hell no - you're stoked. Cheese manufacturers who can provide more cheese for less money have a competitive advantage over companies that can't.

Airlines in the post-deregulation world aren't all that different. When you provide a product that everyone can buy you make more money, you also get a small fraction of the people of Walmart per flight. Being indignant about that tends to miss the point.

In all fairness - the way the market is structured isn't exactly all that free, and the customer service on some carriers is atrocious, but to call then an abusive cartel is an insult to all of the other abusive cartels out there - I'm looking at you Sinaloa and OPEC, sorry to put you guys in the same league as American legacy airlines - you guys are way more ruthless and exploitative than that.

Cartel implies some sort of united (pun intended, sorry) vision to control pricing and costs that simply doesn't exist. The customer service is terrible at some companies - yeah, and the United debacle is a perfect example of that in the eyes of the public (by the way - of course JETcareers doesn't agree, we all have a vested interest in the ability to remove people without compunction, us cj-ing about how crappy passengers are is akin to doctors complaining about medical malpractice, or engineers complaining about unnecessary building codes - we aren't going to provide an unbiased opinion on the issue). And it's worth mentioning that there is somewhat of an oligopoly at play with regard to air travel in the country. That said, "an abusive cartel" it ain't.

As for us pilots - if we're shocked that people want to get more for less then we are idiots. If we're shocked that such an environment leads to the "walmartization" of air travel, then we're fools. I guess in short - shame on the public for being such filthy animals, but shame on us for expecting anything else when it's $199 to fly from SEA to ORD.

If you want to fly around rich, well dressed, people from the "higher" social orders who will feign the appropriate level of respect for such a "learned" professional as a pilot, then go fly corporate or charter. But you'll always be "the help" over there to most of them. Pilots need to by and large get over the idea that they are somehow all that different from the "unwashed masses" they have been flying around and be excited that the tattoo-to-tooth ratio is climbing in the back. The higher the TTR, the more customers you can potentially have, and the more money your company can theoretically make.
 
I mean...I don't get the hate of "people want more for less!"

Of course people want more for less. Do you ever complain when you go to the grocery store and you can buy more cheese for less money? Hell no - you're stoked. Cheese manufacturers who can provide more cheese for less money have a competitive advantage over companies that can't.

I actually am willing to pay more for real Sargento cheese over the store brand water/oil cheese substitute.
 
There's nothing intrinsically wrong with wanting more for less, that's basic capitalism.

However, demanding more for less and doing so through "passenger bill of rights" legislation and the "Yeah I bought a Z-class ticket, you wouldn't dare put me in a middle seat in the back of the airplane" is tiresome.

I wouldn't walk into Ruth's Chris and say, "$40? Yower rippin' me awf! The Sizzler is only $14 and it's probably from the same cow!"
 
I actually am willing to pay more for real Sargento cheese over the store brand water/oil cheese substitute.

Right - but you're able to. The people of Walmart aren't afforded that luxury, and typically the "Hoi Polloi" are buying their tickets on Travelocity for the lowest cost. This means you're going to get some "variation" in the income levels of air travelers. In fact, it'd be really interesting to see what the standard deviation and mean income levels were in the demographics of the "average" passenger - I'd suspect that the population is a lot more diverse economically than you'd suspect. So while the social class that you typically hang with might not be comfortable complaining about the quality of a Costco hotdog in relation to the price, many people are like this:

 
There's nothing intrinsically wrong with wanting more for less, that's basic capitalism.

However, demanding more for less and doing so through "passenger bill of rights" legislation and the "Yeah I bought a Z-class ticket, you wouldn't dare put me in a middle seat in the back of the airplane" is tiresome.

I wouldn't walk into Ruth's Chris and say, "$40? Yower rippin' me awf! The Sizzler is only $14 and it's probably from the same cow!"

But that’s not what is going on.

More or less everyone possesses an understanding that Sizzler and RC’s represent different market positioning and offer different quality experiences. Just as everyone understands that buying a first class ticket is going to cost more and provide a different experience than buying a coach ticket - vestigial marketing speak for a second class ticket. It’s precisely that understanding that would make your point correct and poignant if the restaurant scenario you posited ever happened.

But as much as we in the aviation industrial complex would like it to be otherwise, that same level of understanding of expectation does not apply in airline travel. When average travelers buy a ticket for a seat, they are buying a seat. Their expectation, especially once they’ve been seated in the position designated on their boarding pass, is that the seat is theirs. They paid for it; now they get to use it and go where they planned to go. Do some folks occasionally feel a little schadenfreude or invidious distinction when they know they paid $X more or less for the seat than the guy sitting next to them? Sure, many do. But do they understand why they paid more or less? Not really. To them, it’s the same seat. Despite our industry-insider howls of "differentiation", there is no expectation to a passenger that it would or could be different.

The vast majority of airline consumers have no idea what a Z fair is, or a Y fair, or an O fair, or a double secret probation fair. And I would argue rather strenuously that the airlines don’t want them to have any idea. If they did, the airlines would bullet point the differences, restrictions, and privileges clearly, obviously, and concisely.

At restaurants, there are no Z steaks and Y steaks. At the Sizzler the ribeye costs, let’s say, $14. You get what you paid for. But you can rest assured that every other diner who ordered that same ribeye is paying the same $14 and getting the same slab of meat. Similarly, at RC’s everyone who orders the ribeye is paying $40 and getting the same ribeye. But again, everyone knows that. So that’s not the comparison to what is going on with airline customers.

When you buy a steak, you buy a steak. There is no obfuscated, arcane, legal document dictating the terms and conditions of your steak purchase. If your steak sucks, you can send it back and get a different one, or get your money back. And finally, when you are sitting at your table at RC’s or Sizzler or any other restaurant, a waiter isn’t going to show up at your booth, serve you your hot juicy steak and then moments later, turn around, snatch it back and give it to someone other diner, let alone to some restaurant employee, ‘cause, you know, “we mis-ordered and have to feed the help”.

We in the industry understand the nuances of what’s going on, so to us the guy who refused to give up the seat he bought and had delivered to him might seem unwashed, unruly, and intransigent. But to the average traveller and to the public, he seems like the victim of fraud and abuse.

Demands for a Pax “Bill of Rights” could be quashed immediately if airlines would just be more forthright and transparent in their offerings. That which need not be complex should not be. Fine print is the province of the disingenuous, the fearful, and the cowering.

You often speak of an elevator speech for airline applicants. The same should apply for airline seats. If airlines -or anyone else- can’t explain clearly what they’re selling in bullet points on the back of the ticket, they’re doing it wrong, and no one is going to trust them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I actually am willing to pay more for real Sargento cheese over the store brand water/oil cheese substitute.
Same with hotels when I travel. $80-100 for a Hampton or Hilton property I have a reasonable assurance is going to be clean and have a nice bed, or $50 for a Motel 6. Both will probably get me the same result... but one I'm probably going to be shooing Johns away because they have the wrong door (true story) and feeling bugs crawling all over me which may or may not be there.
 
the ribeye costs, let’s say, $14. You get what you paid for. But you can rest assured that every other diner who ordered that same ribeye is paying the same $14
That steak (with a self life) price stays the same 24/7 at Sizzler until a corporate price menu change. Not so for that airline seat with a shelf life that expires every minute of every day. We all know the price of that seat is constantly moving $ set as we all know with dynamic pricing. http://www.easyjet.com/en/policy/dynamic-pricing What the pax expects is equal service in the traditionally three travel classes, which now are so varied within each class as to created confusion and conflict for staff and customer.
 
Back
Top