I particularly liked the FO's attitude that she was more than willing to spend a winter in the right seat in the Northeast because she had next to no experience flying in icing conditions. That attitude alone tells me that she had a chance of being one hell of a good Captain at some point.
As for the New York Post....it's a bottom-feeding gossip rag that has no business being taken seriously. It's really unfortunate that they decided to set their sights on 3407. That cartoon was definitely unwarranted and inappropriate. Their journalism just bolsters my opinion that the media will twist anything to sensationalize a story. What's worse, the readers who can't read in between the lines and believe that rubbish have the right to vote, have a driver's license, and reproduce.