ADS-B Mandate Modification

Second, I can't speak for terminal, but an ERAM scope still updates every 12 seconds, regardless of whether it is receiving radar or ads position data, so it is not faster. I also happen to know first hand that reliability within the ATC system is not reliable enough currently for it to be the sole means of separation.

Just to add to Greg's outstanding information here: ELP TRACON has STARS. That STARS has one short-range ASR-9 feed with 4.8-second update, two long-range ARSR-4 feeds with about 12 second updates, and three ADS/B feeds giving one-second updates. Within STARS all six feeds are combined, or "FUSED" in something called FUSION Mode. FUSION analyzes all six data feeds and then predicts where the target will be before the next data "hit" from one of these sensors. Since implementation of FUSION El Paso has gone from 12 updates per minute when using ASR-9 or five updates per minute when using ARSR-4 to one-second "updates" utilizing predicted target location. A huge improvement. Not only that, but because ADS/B gives ELP one-second updates on Mode C, ELP can continue to use automated altitude readout for separation as opposed to obtaining pilot reports even when ASR-9 fails or is taken out of service.

As for ADS/B alone it's my understanding that it's not yet certified for "radar" separation, so ELP is still required to have a radar source to supply longitudinal and lateral separation. I have my doubts that ELP STARS is even receiving ADS/B position data as a result, but I don't know that for a fact. I do know that FUSION works even if ADS/B data is not being received, utilizing ARSR-4 and ASR-9 data alone. That means ELP controllers still get the one-second position updates based solely upon the predicted target location from the FUSION tracker even when receiving only radar data.

At some point I believe ADS/B position data is supposed to eventually be certified for "radar" separation and vectoring service, but I've no idea what that timeline may be.
 
Last edited:
I understand that argument when it was made in the 1950's, or with airliners today who are flying the public around, but I don't understand it with a 172. I'd take the reliability of my iPad over any of the transponders and avionics I've used in GA aircraft. There are off the shell options for this problem that will have 99% of the reliability for a fraction of the cost.
Maybe if you're talking iron gyros and KT76s. Modern transponders like the GTX330 are way reliable. The first gen ADSB transceivers, the GDL90, were less reliable but those were designed and built almost 10 years ago and Garmin at least has had lots of experience building and supporting the stuff.
The other thing that has to be dealt with on any portable system, and what will kill the idea IMHO, is how in the world are you going to get a reliable signal when your transmitter is inside a metal cage? Even with an external antenna we've found that you run into airframe masking during some maneuvers, depending on altitude and where the ground station is, if you are running with only one antenna. Put your antenna inside a 172 and good luck.
 
Maybe if you're talking iron gyros and KT76s. Modern transponders like the GTX330 are way reliable. The first gen ADSB transceivers, the GDL90, were less reliable but those were designed and built almost 10 years ago and Garmin at least has had lots of experience building and supporting the stuff.
The other thing that has to be dealt with on any portable system, and what will kill the idea IMHO, is how in the world are you going to get a reliable signal when your transmitter is inside a metal cage? Even with an external antenna we've found that you run into airframe masking during some maneuvers, depending on altitude and where the ground station is, if you are running with only one antenna. Put your antenna inside a 172 and good luck.

An external antenna with a coax cable running to to a place where you can plug it into a portable transceiver seems like a reasonable idea.

Like I said, I get the idea of backups upon backups upon backups when you're talking about carrying the public. But Steve in his Cessna down the road who is going to skirt the class B anyway beacuse he's afraid of talking to controllers? I'd rather have SOMETHING installed in that airplane to tell the world where it is than NOTHING. And I think that most folks will choose nothing if it's too expensive.
 
An external antenna with a coax cable running to to a place where you can plug it into a portable transceiver seems like a reasonable idea.

Like I said, I get the idea of backups upon backups upon backups when you're talking about carrying the public. But Steve in his Cessna down the road who is going to skirt the class B anyway beacuse he's afraid of talking to controllers? I'd rather have SOMETHING installed in that airplane to tell the world where it is than NOTHING. And I think that most folks will choose nothing if it's too expensive.
Thing is, by the time you do that you're halfway to a permanent install. I've put one of these in and unless you're integrating it with a whole spit load of other avionics there isn't much to it. They need to build a fully panel mount unit to drive install costs down, right now half the price of getting compliant is building a shelf and running wires to the back of the plane for a remote box. Mount all of that in the panel and you can get away with 2 coax cables and a power wire. Oh and hardware cost needs to come down, but with companies needing to recoup expenses for getting this crap certified I don't know how much that is likely to happen. This would be a good topic to hear from @jynxyjoe on, as he has some experience in the electronics cert and testing world (though the big ADSB push may have been after his day.
 
My portable GPS is just as accurate as the IFR certified panel mounted GPS and more accurate than the VORs. I'd trust information coming into the system from a portable unit if it were from a small, slow moving target. I'd bet the signal error would be under 50' (just a guess). If you really had to have something mounted, you could mount an external antenna, then just plug the portable into the antenna wire.

jtrain609 said:
I understand that argument when it was made in the 1950's, or with airliners today who are flying the public around, but I don't understand it with a 172. I'd take the reliability of my iPad over any of the transponders and avionics I've used in GA aircraft. There are off the shell options for this problem that will have 99% of the reliability for a fraction of the cost.

Me too. But the issue is ADS-B Out, not In. your and my trust in the information isn't the issue. It's whether the FAA is willing to bet the lives of other people on what you or I trust.
 
Just to add to Greg's outstanding information here: ELP TRACON has STARS. That STARS has one short-range ASR-9 feed with 4.8-second update, two long-range ARSR-4 feeds with about 12 second updates, and three ADS/B feeds giving one-second updates. Within STARS all six feeds are combined, or "FUSED" in something called FUSION Mode. FUSION analyzes all six data feeds and then predicts where the target will be before the next data "hit" from one of these sensors. Since implementation of FUSION El Paso has gone from 12 updates per minute when using ASR-9 or five updates per minute when using ARSR-4 to one-second "updates" utilizing predicted target location. A huge improvement. Not only that, but because ADS/B gives ELP one-second updates on Mode C, ELP can continue to use automated altitude readout for separation as opposed to obtaining pilot reports even when ASR-9 fails or is taken out of service.

As for ADS/B alone it's my understanding that it's not yet certified for "radar" separation, so ELP is still required to have a radar source to supply longitudinal and lateral separation. I have my doubts that ELP STARS is even receiving ADS/B position data as a result, but I don't know that for a fact. I do know that FUSION works even if ADS/B data is not being received, utilizing ARSR-4 and ASR-9 data alone. That means ELP controllers still get the one-second position updates based solely upon the predicted target location from the FUSION tracker even when receiving only radar data.

At some point I believe ADS/B position data is supposed to eventually be certified for "radar" separation and vectoring service, but I've no idea what that timeline may be.

Anchorage Center has been certified for stand alone ADS-B separation for several years now. Though it is a one-off Micro EARTS build that was used for the ADS-B testing. They can do separation between all target modes, ADS-B, primary radar and wide area multilateration. A friend involved with the ATC integration said one of the biggest headaches has been that there are so many variations in ATC software builds that ringing the bugs borders on being unique to each facility.
 
Me too. But the issue is ADS-B Out, not In. your and my trust in the information isn't the issue. It's whether the FAA is willing to bet the lives of other people on what you or I trust.

I'm willing to bet that the FAA will trust the ADS-B OUT from a portable unit where the antenna is hard mounted... specifically from small non-electric aircraft like a Piper J3 Cub (the PA18's and Cessna 172's I've seen have an electrical system so I can see the FAA sticking with the hard mounted for a/c with electrical systems), mainly because of what jtrain said, "I'd rather have SOMETHING installed in that airplane to tell the world where it is than NOTHING."... and I think the FAA would rather have something than nothing as well.
 
I'm willing to bet that the FAA will trust the ADS-B OUT from a portable unit where the antenna is hard mounted... specifically from small non-electric aircraft like a Piper J3 Cub (the PA18's and Cessna 172's I've seen have an electrical system so I can see the FAA sticking with the hard mounted for a/c with electrical systems), mainly because of what jtrain said, "I'd rather have SOMETHING installed in that airplane to tell the world where it is than NOTHING."... and I think the FAA would rather have something than nothing as well.
It would be nice if you are right. But I would expect to see official sanction for handheld GPS for IFR use long before I would expect to see Joe's garage sale ADS-B Out made from scrap parts approved.
 
Anchorage Center has been certified for stand alone ADS-B separation for several years now.

Good to know. I believe there may be a couple of other sites using ADS-B separation as well. Isn't it used in western Colorado and in the Gulf of Mexico? I thought I read about that somewhere.
 
Between this forum and another one I frequent, one thing that is clear is that the ADS-B rule is evoking some rather strong reactions as the date approaches.
 
A friend of mine recently sent the FAA a Petition for Rulemaking to modify the current ADS-B mandate

To summarize, aircraft not equipped with ADS-B Out would be allowed to continue to operate withing the 30 mile Mode C veil, so long as they remain below 10,000 msl and outside of Class B and C airspace. The petition goes into a bit more detail but the thrust of the argument is (1) most Mode C veil areas outside of Class B and C limits are in rural areas with small airports with pilots who rarely, if ever have a need to head into Class C and B airspace and (2) requiring those pilots to upgrade to ADS-B Out is an unfair financial burden, and (3) there's no real benefit to air traffic control to offset the burden.

Please take a look at the Petition and, whatever your viewpoint of it, comment.
As a 121 pilot, the issue I see is that there are arrivals, and maybe few departures that have airliners below 10,000 outside the mode c veil. At least that's the case in the NYC and PHL area. I've been vectored many times for an aircraft that was unknowingly smack in the middle of a busy arrival route. Not that it's any fault of the GA pilot. That info is extremely hard to find anywhere except a TAC, which is vague at best. I've always wondered why there isn't better guidance from the FAA on how to avoid those areas. JMHO
 
It would be nice if you are right. But I would expect to see official sanction for handheld GPS for IFR use long before I would expect to see Joe's garage sale ADS-B Out made from scrap parts approved.

No one ever said anything about a pieced together system from scrap parts. Avionics manufacturers (ie, Garmin) would have to be involved to build the system.
 
My guess is the big push for ADSB Out is NOT for what it seems. Air Carriers soak up the vast majority of ATC services at "congested airports". Most other places you can see the tumbleweeds blow across the runways.

UAT WX services is a lure. 1090/UAT Traffic only to ADS-B out equipped aircraft is a lure (the system is capable of broadcasting all traffic to everyone).

What's prize they want to reel in? User fees. A couple lines of code, and your ADS-B out box becomes a cash register that they only need to ring the bell. The long standing, and valid, argument against user fees has been the method of collection. ADS-B makes it easy peasy.

Richman
 
What's prize they want to reel in? User fees. A couple lines of code, and your ADS-B out box becomes a cash register that they only need to ring the bell. The long standing, and valid, argument against user fees has been the method of collection. ADS-B makes it easy peasy.

See, that is a separate argument all together. If the government wants to charge "use fees", then they need to get rid of the fuel taxes that currently fund the AIP. For 100LL we currently pay 19.4 cents a gallon and you kerosene burners get to pay 21.9 cents per gallon, unless you are the airlines or a charter company, then you pay 4.4 cents a gallon. This is what goes to the AIP, localities may place additional taxes (or fuel flowage fees, taxes by another name) on to your fuel bill.
 
My guess is the big push for ADSB Out is NOT for what it seems. Air Carriers soak up the vast majority of ATC services at "congested airports". Most other places you can see the tumbleweeds blow across the runways.

UAT WX services is a lure. 1090/UAT Traffic only to ADS-B out equipped aircraft is a lure (the system is capable of broadcasting all traffic to everyone).

What's prize they want to reel in? User fees. A couple lines of code, and your ADS-B out box becomes a cash register that they only need to ring the bell. The long standing, and valid, argument against user fees has been the method of collection. ADS-B makes it easy peasy.

Richman
I don't *think* that's the case but you could be right.
 
Good to know. I believe there may be a couple of other sites using ADS-B separation as well. Isn't it used in western Colorado and in the Gulf of Mexico? I thought I read about that somewhere.

I think Colorado had a ADS-B/WAM test site, an the gulf had ADS-B ground stations installed out on the oil rigs for low level IFR coverage for the helo fleet. The helicopter separation went from 20 mile to 5 mile lateral separation.

The info I got today from my guy is that they are only 1/3 of the way getting ADS-B certified on the glass in the lower 48. They have to go to each facility and do all the airborne testing for the coverage area and do training with the tec-ops guys and controllers.
 
No requirement for pitot, just static. Aircraft that don't have an air switch are allowed to use GS from the GPS to activate air mode.

Talked with JW today, the air switch is still in the FAA tech requirements, but Freeflight's STC made it through the ACO with out it somehow. He was gonna check into Garmin's and see if they got around it also.
 
The info I got today from my guy is that they are only 1/3 of the way getting ADS-B certified on the glass in the lower 48. They have to go to each facility and do all the airborne testing for the coverage area and do training with the tec-ops guys and controllers.

Thanks. That's good to know.
 
Back
Top