ADS-B Mandate Modification

MidlifeFlyer

Well-Known Member
A friend of mine recently sent the FAA a Petition for Rulemaking to modify the current ADS-B mandate

To summarize, aircraft not equipped with ADS-B Out would be allowed to continue to operate withing the 30 mile Mode C veil, so long as they remain below 10,000 msl and outside of Class B and C airspace. The petition goes into a bit more detail but the thrust of the argument is (1) most Mode C veil areas outside of Class B and C limits are in rural areas with small airports with pilots who rarely, if ever have a need to head into Class C and B airspace and (2) requiring those pilots to upgrade to ADS-B Out is an unfair financial burden, and (3) there's no real benefit to air traffic control to offset the burden.

Please take a look at the Petition and, whatever your viewpoint of it, comment.
 
I do wish they would start junking the transponder requirement for adsb aircraft though (ie, allow adsb to substitute for transponder )
 
I do wish they would start junking the transponder requirement for adsb aircraft though (ie, allow adsb to substitute for transponder )
I agree but it won't work with the inevitable transition/exemptions period. The system won't instantly go from 100% terrestrial to 100% sat
 

The Luddites were 19th-century English textile artisans who protested against newly developed labour-replacing machinery from 1811 to 1817. The stocking frames, spinning frames and power looms introduced during the Industrial Revolution threatened to replace the artisans with less-skilled, low-wage labourers, leaving them without work.

Although the origin of the name Luddite (/ˈlʌd.aɪt/) is uncertain, a popular theory is that the movement was named after Ned Ludd, a youth who allegedly smashed two stocking frames in 1779, and whose name had become emblematic of machine destroyers.[1][2][3] The name evolved into the imaginary General Ludd or King Ludd, a figure who, like Robin Hood, was reputed to live in Sherwood Forest.[4][a]
 
Now back to the ADS-B conversation.

Midlife, I disagree with your friend. I believe that even folks who fly outside controlled airspace can benefit from ADS-B. If I am in class B airspace, I'm constantly given traffic seperation information, however, when I'm VFR on flight following between Houston and San Antonio (and back), I've passed other aircraft at 7500-8500' with not a word from ATC. I can't fault ATC on this because seperation is provided when they can. I've also been given a heds up by ATC about other aircraft, and never seen them. If we all had ADS-B, we could see each other and avoid = increased safety. Not to mention weather information that you have to pay XM for right now. As for the cost, it should come down to an affordable level by 2020, if not before.
 
I do wish they would start junking the transponder requirement for adsb aircraft though (ie, allow adsb to substitute for transponder )
And what happens when an aircraft loses its electrical system? Not only will they be unable to navigate, but ATC won't be able to see them either. Or what about someone who doesn't want to be detected switching off their ADS? Radar isn't going anywhere. I see ADS-B as a useful tool to aid in pilot situational awareness and to provide reduced separation in non-radar areas, but I don't see radar ever going away completely, especially in the ADIZ and busy terminals.

Edit: Just went back to the thread in the Pilot-Controller forum and saw you were a part of that one, too. I am not trying to get on a high horse, I just don't see ADS-B getting implementation the way the management thinks it will be implemented, at least not during my career. I do support rule changes for the ADS-B requirements, but I think the FAA will end up delaying and reevaluating them anyway.
 
Last edited:
I own an aircraft with an older electrical system. It will likely be somewhere between 30% to 50% to have ADS-B Out installed. An ADS-B in system with display screens is well off the table. Under the current proposal, I won't be allowed to fly my aircraft anywhere that a transponder is required. Additionally, the FAA won't allow portable options under the current scheme.
 
And what happens when an aircraft loses its electrical system? Not only will they be unable to navigate, but ATC won't be able to see them either. Or what about someone who doesn't want to be detected switching off their ADS? Radar isn't going anywhere. I see ADS-B as a useful tool to aid in pilot situational awareness and to provide reduced separation in non-radar areas, but I don't see radar ever going away completely, especially in the ADIZ and busy terminals.

A transponder is tied to that same electrical system, so a electrical failure would render both transponder and ADS-B useless. Unless there is secondary radar coverage ATC would not detect a transponder failed aircraft either. Also a transponder is just as easy to turn off as ADS-B. ADS-B also has greater accuracy and update speed than radar.


I do wish they would start junking the transponder requirement for adsb aircraft though (ie, allow adsb to substitute for transponder )

Talking to the one legged man about this, he provided this input. First the rest of the world will be on transponder based extended squitter ADS-B. Second getting into larger aircraft with integrated FMS/EFIS systems, the cost between getting a ES mod approved vs a UAT system that is only good in the States makes the ES transponder a no brainier. Also the transponder provides a terrestrial based backup system.
 
Oh yea ADS-B will be the savior of aviation just like TCAS at Uberlingen and TCAD on the Hudson !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
I own an aircraft with an older electrical system. It will likely be somewhere between 30% to 50% to have ADS-B Out installed. An ADS-B in system with display screens is well off the table. Under the current proposal, I won't be allowed to fly my aircraft anywhere that a transponder is required. Additionally, the FAA won't allow portable options under the current scheme.
Do you have a tablet? Bam, ADSB display.
 
A transponder is tied to that same electrical system, so a electrical failure would render both transponder and ADS-B useless. Unless there is secondary radar coverage ATC would not detect a transponder failed aircraft either. Also a transponder is just as easy to turn off as ADS-B. ADS-B also has greater accuracy and update speed than radar.




Talking to the one legged man about this, he provided this input. First the rest of the world will be on transponder based extended squitter ADS-B. Second getting into larger aircraft with integrated FMS/EFIS systems, the cost between getting a ES mod approved vs a UAT system that is only good in the States makes the ES transponder a no brainier. Also the transponder provides a terrestrial based backup system.
Yeah, the two bands really did complicate things.
 
Oh yea ADS-B will be the savior of aviation just like TCAS at Uberlingen and TCAD on the Hudson !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

We should junk all this ATC stuff and go back to basics.

UA 412, blue and white, 2 holes, passing St Johns east bound, FL370, 420 knots. Any traffic in the area please advise.

777_Cartoon_United_Airlines_by_audoman2607.jpg
 
Last edited:
Do you have a tablet? Bam, ADSB display.

Its funny, you can have an ADS-B in setup for less than $1000 all in, but the FAA seems tied to in-panel installation for ADS-B out. I think the recreational flying world would compromise on mandated dates if portable options are allowed.
 
Its funny, you can have an ADS-B in setup for less than $1000 all in, but the FAA seems tied to in-panel installation for ADS-B out. I think the recreational flying world would compromise on mandated dates if portable options are allowed.
How are you going to ensure that a portable system has adequate coverage and GPS reception? there's a huge amount of work that goes into making sure that something like this works right and proper installation is a critical component.
Not to mention I don't trust most owner/operators to configure the stuff right.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top