ADS-B Mandate Modification

No one ever said anything about a pieced together system from scrap parts. Avionics manufacturers (ie, Garmin) would have to be involved to build the system.
Are you talking about certified systems or not? I have a bit of difficultly with the concept of "no certification" but with only "approved manufacturers" allowed to participate.

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on reality. (You'll notice I haven't stated a position on the proposal itself).
 
Reality is that the FAA is extremely risk adverse. You're right in what you're saying, I just don't agree with the position that the faa will take.
 
Are you talking about certified systems or not? I have a bit of difficultly with the concept of "no certification" but with only "approved manufacturers" allowed to participate.

I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on reality. (You'll notice I haven't stated a position on the proposal itself).

We can agree to disagree, but your reality may change in the next few years. Take a look at the article hook posted. It adds to our conversation.
 
The problem with the portable idea is there is no way to tie it into the static system to acquire baro altitude. Vertical separation would be next to impossible with aircraft using to different altitude metrics. The technology exists to sniff the transponder and take the beacon code, mode S data and baro altitude and import it into the ADS-B box. Coming up with a portable box that can do that would be much harder to argue against.
 
The problem with the portable idea is there is no way to tie it into the static system to acquire baro altitude. Vertical separation would be next to impossible with aircraft using to different altitude metrics. The technology exists to sniff the transponder and take the beacon code, mode S data and baro altitude and import it into the ADS-B box. Coming up with a portable box that can do that would be much harder to argue against.

Easy, digital altimeter.

As a backup you can do the mode S data trick you mention (Zaon PCAS). You can also do a GPS data feed in with altitude (assuming you have enough satellites).
 
Easy, digital altimeter.

As a backup you can do the mode S data trick you mention (Zaon PCAS). You can also do a GPS data feed in with altitude (assuming you have enough satellites).

I thought GPS altitude was inherently inaccurate, but I cannot remember why I believe this.
 
I thought GPS altitude was inherently inaccurate, but I cannot remember why I believe this.

A number of things can effect the accuracy of GPS. Not having enough satellites would be a biggie. I remember reading there is an inherent error where the vertical error is 1.5x the horizontal error (can't remember why). So if you had up to a 50' horizontal error, you could have up to a 75' vertical error. But with WAAS that potential error is pretty small. The last thing I can think of is the WGS84 ellipsoid, but I thought the known errors with that had been corrected.
 
Here's the craziness I face: I own a Champ (without an electrical system or transponder) that's based at a rural airport with low traffic and a Citabria that's based at a busy field under class B. If this ADS-B thing isn't sorted out in a way that's cost-effective, I'm considering swapping the two so that the no-transponder Champ is on the busy field under the Bravo. I'm pretty sure that makes the flying public less safe, but the flying public isn't exactly offering to subsidize my avionics install either.
 
Here's the craziness I face: I own a Champ (without an electrical system or transponder) that's based at a rural airport with low traffic and a Citabria that's based at a busy field under class B. If this ADS-B thing isn't sorted out in a way that's cost-effective, I'm considering swapping the two so that the no-transponder Champ is on the busy field under the Bravo. I'm pretty sure that makes the flying public less safe, but the flying public isn't exactly offering to subsidize my avionics install either.

This. Pilots are smart guys and gals, and they WILL game out the least cost method.

$5k is nuts for $20 worth of gear.

RIchman
 
Back
Top