Who thinks IFR in a single engine is crazy?

Sure about that? ;)

You might want to fact check that one.

Perhaps I was over-generalizing; I was referring to 135.105, although that section doesn't appear limited to IFR operations. Never flew Part 135 so what the hell do I know? My point is that it's clearly more safe to have a second pilot on board. For those of you who want to build your proficiency at the "one man show" then more power to you, but what does that teach you about crew coordination?

===============================================

Section 135.105: Exception to second in command requirement: Approval for use of autopilot system.

(a) Except as provided in §§135.99 and 135.111, unless two pilots are required by this chapter for operations under VFR, a person may operate an aircraft without a second in command, if it is equipped with an operative approved autopilot system and the use of that system is authorized by appropriate operations specifications. No certificate holder may use any person, nor may any person serve, as a pilot in command under this section of an aircraft operated in a commuter operation, as defined in part 119 of this chapter unless that person has at least 100 hours pilot in command flight time in the make and model of aircraft to be flown and has met all other applicable requirements of this part.
(b) The certificate holder may apply for an amendment of its operations specifications to authorize the use of an autopilot system in place of a second in command.
(c) The Administrator issues an amendment to the operations specifications authorizing the use of an autopilot system, in place of a second in command, if—
(1) The autopilot is capable of operating the aircraft controls to maintain flight and maneuver it about the three axes; and
(2) The certificate holder shows, to the satisfaction of the Administrator, that operations using the autopilot system can be conducted safely and in compliance with this part.
The amendment contains any conditions or limitations on the use of the autopilot system that the Administrator determines are needed in the interest of safety.
 
Perhaps I was over-generalizing; I was referring to 135.105, although that section doesn't appear limited to IFR operations. Never flew Part 135 so what the hell do I know? My point is that it's clearly more safe to have a second pilot on board. For those of you who want to build your proficiency at the "one man show" then more power to you, but what does that teach you about crew coordination?

Take a look at 135.101 and you'll see a whole world of single pilot IFR ops open up.

As for crew-coordination, and for anyone moving from a single pilot to a multi-crew environment - with a little training crew-coordination is a very simple concept to learn. But looking at your profile, you should know that already!
 
What the h3LL does being "a man" have to do with it?

-mini
It doesn't. It takes just as much man to make the decision not to fly. But single engine IFR experience over mountains is invaluable (actually, it's about $130 an hour, but that's beside the point...).


That's like saying you're more likely to die in a car crash than die skydiving. If you don't jump at all, the odds are pretty low. If you're skydiving over mountains at night, the odds just went up.
However, the same can be said for the car - if the car's on a wet, curvy road and your tires are shot, the odds just went up. ;)
 
Right, what I'm getting at is this is a situation where considering the odds for the entire population is inaccurate. Accidents per hour or per mile would give a more telling story.
However, the same can be said for the car - if the car's on a wet, curvy road and your tires are shot, the odds just went up. ;)
 
* For those of you who want to build your proficiency at the "one man show" then more power to you, but what does that teach you about crew coordination?*


It teaches me no circle jerk when Im a "one man show"
ef'n rj driver
 
You're more likely to die in a car crash than dying because your only engine hit the john..

I don't know about you, but I take the car risk every day.

But seriously, as long as you're alert and you know what you're doing, I don't see why any mountain flying should be the least bit problematic. And if your engine does fail - well, shoot me in the face. ;)
I don't care about the odds

It simply adding an unnecessary risk to your flight. If I have to do it for my job then that is one thing, but I will not just plan to do that in the dark in a single. I plan my flights to avoid inescapable situations, give myself every alternative and option in case of emergencies. I can easily go around the mountains or like I said, follow the highway, that way I know I can see at least one decent place to land if I have to.

Like I said, it happens around here pretty regularly. Somebody wants to save 15 minutes on a flight plan so they cut a corner and go over the mountains at night and when they experience a problem (which does happen) they have no options.

I WILL NOT just plan on my engine never having trouble. I have too much to live for.

Ha ha.. Like the Uintah Mountains are "real mountains". King's Peak is only 13,500' MSL. ;)

How much you wanna bet I can throw a football over them mountains?
13,580 actually and yes, I bet you can throw a football clear over them mountains.

But if your single engine Cessna craps out in the dark can you glide out of them? Or work your way down a valley that you cannot see. Land in the flat bottom of a valley instead of colliding with a peak?
 
I don't know, i've had a bunch of vacuum pump failures in singles without a backup system. Plus turn coordinators don't last that long -brushes get dirty and they don't work a lick. In my opinion, a single turbine (which they pretty much all have a backup systems) is fine. Having a good AP doesn't mean much. Its the equipment that fails.. period.
 
I don't care about the odds

It simply adding an unnecessary risk to your flight. If I have to do it for my job then that is one thing, but I will not just plan to do that in the dark in a single. I plan my flights to avoid inescapable situations, give myself every alternative and option in case of emergencies. I can easily go around the mountains or like I said, follow the highway, that I know I can see at least one decent place to land if I have to. way

...

I WILL NOT just plan on my engine never having trouble. I have too much to live for.

But if your single engine Cessna craps out in the dark can you glide out of them? Or work your way down a valley that you cannot see. Land in the flat bottom of a valley instead of colliding with a peak?
...But the more experience you have in said mountain flying, the more likely you're gonna have developed the skills needed to get out alive.

We're both right, in our own senses. The more often you fly IFR single in mountains, the more experience you'll gain and the more skill you'll develop. However, the more you fly under the same circumstances, the more likely you are to have that one engine go out (however slim that chance might be).

Some are more willing to take the experience over the risk than others, and that's perfectly acceptable. As is the opposite.

As for me, I'll go for the experience. And that's not to say that my flights are any more/less dangerous than anyone else's - the only difference is the terrain I'm flying over. It's all the same air. ;)
 
DeltaAVL,

I have flown many many times where he's talking about. Candidly, it's out of reach for most GA single engine aircraft unless you are turbocharged, have oxygen, and anti/de-icing capabilities.

The terrain is very inhospitable. The mountain wave alone can be extreme. Hell, I've felt it going over the Uintah Mountains at FL350 while flying a jet. His point is very valid.

To be honest myself, I would have a difficult time flying in IMC over the terrain he's referring to unless it was in a pressurized, turbine single at FL300.
 
I flew IFR at night right out of my instrument training. During my training I did everything single IFR with little to no help form my Instructor. In the end you get used to the single pilot IFR environment right when you get your rating.
 
I'm pretty dissapointed with the replies that i've seen so far. A good question to ask yourself is how much do you value your life? Flying single engine piston airplanes IFR just isn't the best plan no matter how you look at it. I wish I had the time to type out everything I want to say here, but the lack of knowledge in this area really demonstrates the lack of knowledge and experience instructors these days have. I run across fairly new instrument pilots more often than I should that don't realize the dangers. The folks that mentioned 135 regs earlier were correct. IFR flying can be extremely challenging when things start going wrong. This is why to fly passengers IFR commercially requires 1200 hours and either an SIC or autopilot. Doing it in a multi requires an ATP. While many things the FAA has done are maybe "a little stupid", the hour and age requirements for ratings are not. It simply takes that much time and experience to learn what you need to in order to safely operate aircraft in certain conditions, to think like a captain. Folks, anytime you get in an airplane, think twice about the weather, and if there is any question in your mind, again, ask yourself "how much do I value my life vs. how bad do I need to get there?" Do we ever REALLY need to get there?
 
DeltaAVL,

I have flown many many times where he's talking about. Candidly, it's out of reach for most GA single engine aircraft unless you are turbocharged, have oxygen, and anti/de-icing capabilities.

The terrain is very inhospitable. The mountain wave alone can be extreme. Hell, I've felt it going over the Uintah Mountains at FL350 while flying a jet. His point is very valid.
Right, but we're not just talking about that particular region, are we? I though we were talking about mountain flying in general.

But yes, I realize that, in the odds of a failure, the survival chance would likely be slim to none. But you can't just look at it with the mindset that your engine IS going to fail, you've got to look at it from the other direction as well.

bdhill1979's point is valid, yes. But so is mine. If we've got the equipment, the ability, and the legality to fly IFR in the mountains safely, we might as well do it. The more varied experience a pilot has, the better he'll be in the long run.
 
Right, but we're not just talking about that particular region, are we? I though we were talking about mountain flying in general.

I think bdhill1979 (AKA Uncle Rico) was referring to the mountains specifically in his home state. But to add to our mountain flying discussion - I've flown over the mountains of Utah (10,000+') and had a little white knuckles doing such. I've also flown over some not so big mountains (3-5000') with much more confidence. Flying at 15-17,000', I have a few more options available to me over the smaller mountains that I do flying a few thousand feet above the MEA.

DeltaAVL said:
But yes, I realize that, in the odds of a failure, the survival chance would likely be slim to none. But you can't just look at it with the mindset that your engine IS going to fail, you've got to look at it from the other direction as well.

I personally teach my students to be prepared at any moment, for anything. This is that concept of staying ahead of the airplane. ;)

DeltaAVL said:
bdhill1979's point is valid, yes. But so is mine. If we've got the equipment, the ability, and the legality to fly IFR in the mountains safely, we might as well do it. The more varied experience a pilot has, the better he'll be in the long run.

Equipment, ability, and legality don't always equate to the best decision. I've seen this happen a dozen or so times in 121 flying where a MEL allows the plane to legally but the PIC decided for one reason or another, the flight shouldn't be done. Notice shouldn't, not couldn't.

This is any PIC's prerogative regardless of 91, 121, or 135 flying. I always try to emphasize to my students the responsibility of being the PIC of any aircraft. There is a little phrase I use that seems appropriate for this discussion... "Legality is sometimes just a little different than reality" ;)
 
Actually, they weren't.



It does? Reference please.

Oh boy, you're gonna make me work and dig in the FARs.... It's been a while. ok lets see here:

135.243
(a) No certificate holder may use a person, nor may any person serve, as pilot in command in passenger-carrying operations—
(1) Of a turbojet airplane, of an airplane having a passenger-seat configuration, excluding each crewmember seat, of 10 seats or more, or of a multiengine airplane in a commuter operation as defined in part 119 of this chapter, unless that person holds an airline transport pilot certificate with appropriate category and class ratings and, if required, an appropriate type rating for that airplane.
----------------------------------------------------------------------


(c) Except as provided in paragraph (a) of this section, no certificate holder may use a person, nor may any person serve, as pilot in command of an aircraft under IFR unless that person—
(1) Holds at least a commercial pilot certificate with appropriate category and class ratings and, if required, an appropriate type rating for that aircraft; and
(2) Has had at least 1,200 hours of flight time as a pilot, including 500 hours of cross country flight time, 100 hours of night flight time, and 75 hours of actual or simulated instrument time at least 50 hours of which were in actual flight; and
(3) For an airplane, holds an instrument rating or an airline transport pilot certificate with an airplane category rating; or
 
Dan208B said:
Oh boy, you're gonna make me work and dig in the FARs.... It's been a while. ok lets see here:

135.243

(a) No certificate holder may use a person, nor may any person serve, as pilot in command in passenger-carrying operations—
(1) Of a turbojet airplane, of an airplane having a passenger-seat configuration, excluding each crewmember seat, of 10 seats or more, or of a multiengine airplane in a commuter operation as defined in part 119 of this chapter, unless that person holds an airline transport pilot certificate with appropriate category and class ratings and, if required, an appropriate type rating for that airplane.

This deals specifically with turbojet commuter operations and aircraft with seating configurations of 10 or more seats. 119.3 defines commuter operations and ultimately has little or no applicability to freight an/or charter per se since they don't usually adhere to the route frequency stipulation the 9 seat configuration, or scheduled service. Hence, under part 135 a freight company flying a Beech 99 does not need an ATP in the left seat.

Plenty of exceptions to that rule.

Dan208B said:
(c) Except as provided in paragraph (a) of this section, no certificate holder may use a person, nor may any person serve, as pilot in command of an aircraft under IFR unless that person—
(1) Holds at least a commercial pilot certificate with appropriate category and class ratings and, if required, an appropriate type rating for that aircraft; and
(2) Has had at least 1,200 hours of flight time as a pilot, including 500 hours of cross country flight time, 100 hours of night flight time, and 75 hours of actual or simulated instrument time at least 50 hours of which were in actual flight; and
(3) For an airplane, holds an instrument rating or an airline transport pilot certificate with an airplane category rating; or

Never questioned that one.
 
You need an ATP to fly pax in the bigger stuff under 135....not to fly a Baron or Seneca or even freight in a lear.

I believe EOD requires an ATP for the PIC too.

-mini
 
This deals specifically with turbojet commuter operations as defined by 119.3 not freight or charter per se since they don't usually adhere to the route frequency stipulation and/or the 9 seat configuration. Hence, under part 135 a freight company flying a Beech 99 does not need an ATP in the left seat. Notice, it also says "passenger-carrying operations".

Plenty of exceptions to that rule.



Never questioned that one.

I am very familiar with that portion of the FARs, that's how companies such as Ameriflight and such can operate 99s, Metros, 1900s, etc single pilot without an ATP. If you look at my original post, I said "to fly passengers IFR commercially"....
 
Back
Top