Who thinks IFR in a single engine is crazy?

meritflyer

Well-Known Member
I remember Doug once saying that flying IFR in a single engine aircraft is crazy. Personally, I fly a newer 182 with glass and a good AP so, I have zero problem navigating the weather or flying in the soup in a SE piston. Old skool 172 may be a different story.

(Sorry Doug, I sold you out).

I thought I'd see what the community thinks.
 
<popcorn machine=on>

(Ambiguous question + a crazy number of variables) X opinionated pilots X limited poll = long thread + good show

:yar::yar::yar:
 
<popcorn machine=on>

(Ambiguous question + a crazy number of variables) X opinionated pilots X limited poll = long thread + good show

:yar::yar::yar:
Sorry to be the :yeahthat: guy, but...

:yeahthat:
 
wherethisthreadgoing.jpg
 
If you are certified as an instrument rated pilot, and you have your own personal minimums, and you are comfortable with your instrument abilities, AND the aircraft is certified IFR (w/ or w/o autopilot, w/ or w/o radar, or any other "benefit") then no, I do not think SE IFR is crazy.

If done right.
 
Over the plains, no problem. SE IFR at night, or over mountains at anytime...not what I would want to do. I am talking about SE piston, not turbine.
 
I think it builds character, skill, and hones decision-making and task management abilities as well. I think IFR single-engine, single-pilot is an outstanding idea, and I am grateful to have all that experience under my belt. But then again, maybe I'm just a crazy former freight dawg who is lucky to be alive after all the stupid stuff I've done!
 
I remember Doug once saying that flying IFR in a single engine aircraft is crazy. Personally, I fly a newer 182 with glass and a good AP so, I have zero problem navigating the weather or flying in the soup in a SE piston. Old skool 172 may be a different story.

(Sorry Doug, I sold you out).

I thought I'd see what the community thinks.

I'm thinking you are putting words in Doug's mouth, and there is a possibility that even if he said something along those lines that it was stated within a particular context. A context that you have left out of your statement here. I'd be willing to place a wager that he did not say that all single engine IFR is crazy, which is exactly what you are implying here. Then again, maybe he did say that, I don't know.

You might want to do some research and see if you can find where he said what you are claiming that he said. Not because I'd think that Doug would get PO'ed one way or the other, but just to be fair to the guy, eh?

:)
 
I wouldn't call it crazy - just a lack of skill and experience. Hence personal minimums.

I would LOVE to go fly hard IFR with any IFR certified SE Piston airplane.
 
Over the plains, no problem. SE IFR at night, or over mountains at anytime...not what I would want to do.

Night flight in mountains is crazy regardless of whether it's VFR or IFR.

IFR in an SE piston can be perfectly safe in the right conditions. In areas where low coastal stratus is a regular fixture, an instrument ticket is durn near essential if you want to get any utility out of your license.
 
I've said it before and I'll say it again,

"the most unreiable part of the airplane is the nut in the left seat"


IMHO, the number of engines matters far less than the number of pilots (in this case "George" counts).

So I'll continue flying behind my PT-6 with george's help with no serious worries. Obviously I would like two eingines, but it's not a deal breaker 99% of the time.
 
Single engine IFR in all weather in a single piston that's older than you are? That's crazytalk. Witness the fact that the southeast is positively littered with the still smouldering hulks of Ram, FLX, safewing, etc. At least ten of the hundreds single engine piston freight haulers flying crash every night! The humanity! No wonder those guys make so much money! It's a suicide mission! :rolleyes:
 
I'm thinking you are putting words in Doug's mouth, and there is a possibility that even if he said something along those lines that it was stated within a particular context. A context that you have left out of your statement here. I'd be willing to place a wager that he did not say that all single engine IFR is crazy, which is exactly what you are implying here. Then again, maybe he did say that, I don't know.

You might want to do some research and see if you can find where he said what you are claiming that he said. Not because I'd think that Doug would get PO'ed one way or the other, but just to be fair to the guy, eh?

:)


Here you go Steve...

Doug Taylor April 13 said:
Maybe I'm weird but non-commercial single-pilot IFR is nuts, single-pilot single-engine IFR is even crazier. So what's the point of the glass?
 
MAMMOTH YOSEMITE AIRPORT, Big Bear Airport = CA
Reno, NV Pitkin County, CO and sure some of you can think of others.
Winter in these places are fun.
 
Back
Top