Why give up so much in such an environment, though? The LCP thing is a big give... but actually it doesn't cost much in the way of jobs. It does cost all of us money, which seems to be a big focus of yours. With 75% of the LCP trips removed, that is a large amount of pilots kicked back to reserve, and thus less white and green slip ability.
Unfortunately, you aren't going to get that great of an explanation. The committee chair explained it to me in detail... much to my dismay.
Historic movement historic movement historic movement. Why put such a damper on the historic movement with these major gives? Thousands a year gets cut back to 500 a year with enough work rule gives. Does that speak to you?
More long term viable large jets that don't have a very short expiration stamp on them unlike the 50's. That IS a give, no matter how you try to justify it. For me, it was tolerable in the gives this time, but it IS a give. I was very happy with the block hour ratio tightened up.
I don't think you understand that math is one of my things...