ADS-B Mandate Modification

Now back to the ADS-B conversation.

Midlife, I disagree with your friend. I believe that even folks who fly outside controlled airspace can benefit from ADS-B. If I am in class B airspace, I'm constantly given traffic seperation information, however, when I'm VFR on flight following between Houston and San Antonio (and back), I've passed other aircraft at 7500-8500' with not a word from ATC. I can't fault ATC on this because seperation is provided when they can. I've also been given a heds up by ATC about other aircraft, and never seen them. If we all had ADS-B, we could see each other and avoid = increased safety. Not to mention weather information that you have to pay XM for right now. As for the cost, it should come down to an affordable level by 2020, if not before.
Just to make sure we're talking apples and apples.

1. What does free weather information without XM (which we have right now) have to do with the ADS-B Out mandate?

2. Looking at the chart, on your 167 NM KHOU-KSAT route at 7500-8000', the mandate under my friend's proposal would cover 36 NM (26 NM on the Class B end; 10 NM on the Class C end). As it exists right now, the mandate would cover 40 NM (30 NM on the Class B and and 10 NM on the Class C end; a net change of 4 NM).

And, of course, without the mandate, "folks who fly outside controlled airspace" who believe they "can benefit from" a $5,000-$6,000 ADS-B out installation would be welcome to get it.

You really think some guy flying a Cub in and out of Rosenberg and Westminster airparks is a threat to your safety until he gets 2 NM to the west of his home base?
 
Last edited:
Just to make sure we're talking apples and apples.

1. What does free weather information without XM (which we have right now) have to do with the ADS-B Out mandate?

2. Looking at the chart, on your 167 NM KHOU-KSAT route at 7500-8000', the mandate under my friend's proposal would cover 36 NM (26 NM on the Class B end; 10 NM on the Class C end). As it exists right now, the mandate would cover 40 NM (30 NM on the Class B and and 10 NM on the Class C end; a net change of 4 NM).

And, of course, without the mandate, "folks who fly outside controlled airspace" who believe they "can benefit from" a $5,000-$6,000 ADS-B out installation would be welcome to get it.

You really think some guy flying a Cub in and out of Rosenberg and Westminster airparks is a threat to your safety until he gets 2 NM to the west of his home base?

1. I was just commenting that it's nice to get the WX data with out paying XM for it.

2. I misunderstood the 2020 mandate. I was under the impression that if you wanted to be in the air after 2020, you needed ADS-B. I just re read the mandate and understand ADS-B will only be required in airspace that currently requires mode C.

How much hate mail would I get if I petioned the FAA to modify the mandate to require everyone, no matter the airspace, to have ADS-B after 2020?

I think (regardless of airspace) anyone flying near me is a threat, including "some guy flying a Cub". Are you saying people who fly small aircraft don't cause midair accidents?
 
I think (regardless of airspace) anyone flying near me is a threat, including "some guy flying a Cub". Are you saying people who fly small aircraft don't cause midair accidents?

So, how exactly is a non-electric plane going to be equipped with ADS-B?
 
How are you going to ensure that a portable system has adequate coverage and GPS reception? there's a huge amount of work that goes into making sure that something like this works right and proper installation is a critical component.
Not to mention I don't trust most owner/operators to configure the stuff right.

These are all good questions. Right now, it's not even possible to demonstrate a portable solution to the FAA. I think Garmin could easily make unit that's preconfigured so that it's an on/off system. I haven't heard any portable GPS users complain about adequate signal coverage.
 
These are all good questions. Right now, it's not even possible to demonstrate a portable solution to the FAA. I think Garmin could easily make unit that's preconfigured so that it's an on/off system. I haven't heard any portable GPS users complain about adequate signal coverage.
They also don't have to meet the accuracy requirements that ADS-B requires. Are you familiar with the terms NIC & NAC?
Bottom line is that there are too many variables with a portable system. Do you advocate letting people use a portable transponder too?
 
They also don't have to meet the accuracy requirements that ADS-B requires. Are you familiar with the terms NIC & NAC?

Don't you think that if the FAA said "We will accept portable solutions that meet the navigation standards in DO-260A," that industry would come up with solutions that better meet the needs of recreational aviation than the current offerings?

Right now, there are scores of airplane owners who are not going to invest in a high cost, low (perceived) value installation and everyone with ADS-B in will lose.
 
Don't you think that if the FAA said "We will accept portable solutions that meet the navigation standards in DO-260A," that industry would come up with solutions that better meet the needs of recreational aviation than the current offerings?

Right now, there are scores of airplane owners who are not going to invest in a high cost, low (perceived) value installation and everyone with ADS-B in will lose.
Like I said, way too many variables. Anything from the cigarette lighter coming unplugged to airframe shadowing making the plane drop off. In the end it will be just like the mode c rule-if you want to use the airspace, by the equipment.
 
Like I said, way too many variables. Anything from the cigarette lighter coming unplugged to airframe shadowing making the plane drop off. In the end it will be just like the mode c rule-if you want to use the airspace, by the equipment.

Thankfully, that's not the opinion of AOPA.

There's no way we could say to every car owner in America "Want to use your car after 2020? You're now required to spend $2000 on a nifty new-fangled GPS tracker." We allowed grandfather clauses for transponders, strobes, fire extinguishers, seat belts, and just about every other safety innovation.

Hopefully, this modification makes it.
 
Thankfully, that's not the opinion of AOPA.

There's no way we could say to every car owner in America "Want to use your car after 2020? You're now required to spend $2000 on a nifty new-fangled GPS tracker." We allowed grandfather clauses for transponders, strobes, fire extinguishers, seat belts, and just about every other safety innovation.

Hopefully, this modification makes it.
It's not every aircraft! It's essentially the same places as the mode c rule.
 
They also don't have to meet the accuracy requirements that ADS-B requires. Are you familiar with the terms NIC & NAC?
Bottom line is that there are too many variables with a portable system. Do you advocate letting people use a portable transponder too?

Oh oh, I know what those are..

Certified ADS-B out requires being connected to the ships altitude encoder and to a air switch tied into the pitot system (helo's will have it tied to the torque or oil pressure system). I don't see a portable system that ties into these aircraft systems. Now wireless encoder and torque system sensor could theoretically be developed but it would be more cost effective I would think to just go with the panel mounted system, let alone the cost of buying a yet to be developed portable TSO 145/146 WAAS system that could meet the Fault Detection and Exclusion requirements.
 
Oh oh, I know what those are..

Certified ADS-B out requires being connected to the ships altitude encoder and to a air switch tied into the pitot system (helo's will have it tied to the torque or oil pressure system). I don't see a portable system that ties into these aircraft systems. Now wireless encoder and torque system sensor could theoretically be developed but it would be more cost effective I would think to just go with the panel mounted system, let alone the cost of buying a yet to be developed portable TSO 145/146 WAAS system that could meet the Fault Detection and Exclusion requirements.
No requirement for pitot, just static. Aircraft that don't have an air switch are allowed to use GS from the GPS to activate air mode.
 
The same way that airplane deals with the mode c requirement.

Plus, there's lots of aircraft with no transponder that fly into Class C airports. They don't even give us a heads up they're coming, they just say they're 20 miles out with no transponder usually. As long as I get a primary radar target on the screen, that's good enough for me.
 
A transponder is tied to that same electrical system, so a electrical failure would render both transponder and ADS-B useless. Unless there is secondary radar coverage ATC would not detect a transponder failed aircraft either. Also a transponder is just as easy to turn off as ADS-B. ADS-B also has greater accuracy and update speed than radar.

Okay, a couple things wrong with this statement. First, it is primary radar that detects the reflection of the aircraft's hull, secondary is what interrogates the transponder. Most domestic radar coverage is both primary and secondary. If a transponder is lost nextgen and legacy systems can still track a primary target. Controllers can separate laterally from primary targets. If we rely solely on ADS-B, then a failed ads would result in zero tracking ability and anyone operating outside the system would be invisible. Currently a taylorcraft with no electrical system will still show up as a radar primary target. With no radar it won't show up at all.

Second, I can't speak for terminal, but an ERAM scope still updates every 12 seconds, regardless of whether it is receiving radar or ads position data, so it is not faster. I also happen to know first hand that reliability within the ATC system is not reliable enough currently for it to be the sole means of separation.

Also, someone mentioned cost...the transponder upgrade alone is about $6k, but it needs to be coupled to a TSO'd WAAS GPS, which is at least another $6k if you don't already have one. Now let's not even start talking about the privacy concerns.
 
I'd suggest a deviation be allowed for non-electric aircraft be allowed to use a portable system.
I don't think that's at all likely. One absolutely necessary component of ADS-B out (not required for ADSB-In) is system reliability. The airspace system needs to be able to rely on the information being produced. That means controlled installation showing no interference of certified equipment.
 
I don't think that's at all likely. One absolutely necessary component of ADS-B out (not required for ADSB-In) is system reliability. The airspace system needs to be able to rely on the information being produced. That means controlled installation showing no interference of certified equipment.

I understand that argument when it was made in the 1950's, or with airliners today who are flying the public around, but I don't understand it with a 172. I'd take the reliability of my iPad over any of the transponders and avionics I've used in GA aircraft. There are off the shell options for this problem that will have 99% of the reliability for a fraction of the cost.
 
I don't think that's at all likely. One absolutely necessary component of ADS-B out (not required for ADSB-In) is system reliability. The airspace system needs to be able to rely on the information being produced. That means controlled installation showing no interference of certified equipment.

My portable GPS is just as accurate as the IFR certified panel mounted GPS and more accurate than the VORs. I'd trust information coming into the system from a portable unit if it were from a small, slow moving target. I'd bet the signal error would be under 50' (just a guess). If you really had to have something mounted, you could mount an external antenna, then just plug the portable into the antenna wire.
 
In the marine world, their version of ADS-B is called AIS, and the prices are much more reasonable. The coast guard and other international agencies have created guidelines for manufacture of these devices, and then let the market determine the price. When I quickly look up AIS transponders, I get prices from $830-1200 (link: http://www.defender.com/category.jsp?path=-1|135|2028691&id=2028911). Most boat owners would consider this to be one boat "buck"; expensive but not unreasonable.

ADS-B transdponders, on the other hand, seem to start at $3000. One link as an example: http://sarasotaavionics.com/category/ads_b/ads_b-products

TN70

WAAS GPS Receiver & WAAS Antenna
Part #: 01381-00
The TN70 includes a certified WAAS GPS and companion WAAS GPS antenna, designed to enhance your aircraft via a simple install that will deliver excellent ADS-B Out performance.
$3,329.00

I see the same problem (for GA pilot-owners) occurring with Angle of attack indicators. $200 worth of electronics sells for upwards of $2000.00 (link: http://www.alphasystemsaoa.com/kits.html). Whatever the FAA is doing in terms of bureaucratic usurious "Certification" and "filing fees" for new gear, they are doing it wrong and they are creating an environment wherein items that are clearly helpful in terms of increasing safety are too painful, financially, to install for many pilot-owners.
 
Back
Top