Cherokee_Cruiser
Bronteroc
I just read through this thread pretty quickly and may have missed what I think is one of the most important aspects of aviation...experience and judgement being discussed.
To @unclassified consider this: I am a low time pilot with a CMEL and CFI. I am confident that if you sent me to airbus 330 school, I could fly that bad boy just fine, under normal conditions. But I am lacking in a lot of real world flying experience so if something unusual/emergency comes up do you want me up front or do you want someone with umpteen thousand hours of real flying experience?
Someone referenced AF447. There are plenty of other examples.
Ok, but then when is one "good enough" ? Umpteen thousand isn't a real number, so at what hour mark is one good enough? For a RJ? For a A320? A330?