Virgin- Zero time to A330 copilot!

I just read through this thread pretty quickly and may have missed what I think is one of the most important aspects of aviation...experience and judgement being discussed.

To @unclassified consider this: I am a low time pilot with a CMEL and CFI. I am confident that if you sent me to airbus 330 school, I could fly that bad boy just fine, under normal conditions. But I am lacking in a lot of real world flying experience so if something unusual/emergency comes up do you want me up front or do you want someone with umpteen thousand hours of real flying experience?

Someone referenced AF447. There are plenty of other examples.

Ok, but then when is one "good enough" ? Umpteen thousand isn't a real number, so at what hour mark is one good enough? For a RJ? For a A320? A330?
 
Ok, but then when is one "good enough" ? Umpteen thousand isn't a real number, so at what hour mark is one good enough? For a RJ? For a A320? A330?

I'm not sure when one is good enough or has enough experience. I was just trying to illustrate my point. In my opinion a zero hour to 330 pilot does not have the experience to handle out of the ordinary or emergency situations that may arise.
 
Hey everyone, let's all sing along.... (Apologies to Madonna)


I made it through the interview
Somehow I made it through
Even though I always get lost
But then I found you

I was beat, incomplete
I'd been had, their pay is sad and blue
But they made me feel
Yeah, they made me feel, shiny and new

I fly for Virgin. Piloting for the very first time
I fly at Virgin n n n. I got hired, at zero time.
Whoa oh ah ohh, whoa oh ah ohh....

Gonna give you all my money, Richard
Flight training spends it fast
Been saving it all for you
I hope that it will last

The job ain't fine, but it's mine
Makes me dumb, yeah, it makes me bold
Oh, hope I don't screw up
Yeah, hope I don't screw up
And live to get old

I fly for Virgin. Piloting for the very first time
I fly at Virgin n n n. I got hired, at zero time.
Whoa oh ah ohh, whoa oh ah ohh....

This job ain't fine, but it's mine
I'll be in debt 'til the end of time
'Cause you made me feel
Yeah, you made me feel
Like I've got no money to hide

I fly for Virgin. Piloting for the very first time
I fly at Virgin n n n. I got hired, at zero time.
Whoa oh ah ohh, whoa oh ah ohh....
Exciting opportunity. Hopefully the US majors will undertake a similar program.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/...-Virgin-pilots-with-no-flying-experience.html
 
I just read through this thread pretty quickly and may have missed what I think is one of the most important aspects of aviation...experience and judgement being discussed.

To @unclassified consider this: I am a low time pilot with a CMEL and CFI. I am confident that if you sent me to airbus 330 school, I could fly that bad boy just fine, under normal conditions. But I am lacking in a lot of real world flying experience so if something unusual/emergency comes up do you want me up front or do you want someone with umpteen thousand hours of real flying experience?

Someone referenced AF447. There are plenty of other examples.

Last I checked, you would not be flying that A330 single pilot.
 
Who did a PFT scheme like Virgin is wanting here.

He lied on the app and Colgan never caught it. He failed at literally every checkride, initial, recurrent, and upgrade opportunity and nothing was done about it. Colgan management even passed a letter around saying this guy was not ready for the Q, yet the seniority system ensured he got his chance.

No "guy like CA of 3407" will ever make it through VS's ab initio program.
 
I'm not sure when one is good enough or has enough experience. I was just trying to illustrate my point. In my opinion a zero hour to 330 pilot does not have the experience to handle out of the ordinary or emergency situations that may arise.

True. But top-notch quality airlines like Singapore have successfully used ab initios for decades with great safety records. It's still about the quality of the process, the quality of the training, the stringent selection process, and exposure to many scenarios in the sim. I've heard some of those airlines give lots of sim time that is specific to not just the usual takeoff/landing/V1 cut but also cruise flight scenarios which is ultimately what they do as relief officers.

As for AF447 the fact he just grabbed the stick and man-handled it shows 1. he had no clue 2. training never enforced the idea of smooth small corrections if handflying and 3. no CA ever caught him in time to correct it. I rest my arm on the armrest and the base of my hand on the bottom pad of the sidestick and basically fly with three fingers. If you have a firm grip on the sidestick while you are hand flying and cranking it, you are doing it all wrong.
 
Hey everyone, let's all sing along.... (Apologies to Madonna)


I made it through the interview
Somehow I made it through
Even though I always get lost
But then I found you

I was beat, incomplete
I'd been had, their pay is sad and blue
But they made me feel
Yeah, they made me feel, shiny and new

I fly for Virgin. Piloting for the very first time
I fly at Virgin n n n. I got hired, at zero time.
Whoa oh ah ohh, whoa oh ah ohh....

Gonna give you all my money, Richard
Flight training spends it fast
Been saving it all for you
I hope that it will last

The job ain't fine, but it's mine
Makes me dumb, yeah, it makes me bold
Oh, hope I don't screw up
Yeah, hope I don't screw up
And live to get old

I fly for Virgin. Piloting for the very first time
I fly at Virgin n n n. I got hired, at zero time.
Whoa oh ah ohh, whoa oh ah ohh....

This job ain't fine, but it's mine
I'll be in debt 'til the end of time
'Cause you made me feel
Yeah, you made me feel
Like I've got no money to hide

I fly for Virgin. Piloting for the very first time
I fly at Virgin n n n. I got hired, at zero time.
Whoa oh ah ohh, whoa oh ah ohh....

BOB HAS WON THE INTERNET! :)
 
He lied on the app and Colgan never caught it. He failed at literally every checkride, initial, recurrent, and upgrade opportunity and nothing was done about it. Colgan management even passed a letter around saying this guy was not ready for the Q, yet the seniority system ensured he got his chance.

No "guy like CA of 3407" will ever make it through VS's ab initio program.

Great job missing the point of my post.

Look at the crew of the Air France crew that stalled. One of them made it through an ab initio program.
 
Great job missing the point of my post.

Look at the crew of the Air France crew that stalled. One of them made it through an ab initio program.

Actually both FOs did. The CA was experienced from Air Inter but he was checked out the instant he decided the entire day would be spent in Rio without napping before the flight. He functioned on basically one hr of sleep. Anyway, you are correct about Air France's ab initio program. There's a reason I specifically left them out.
 
Actually both FOs did. The CA was experienced from Air Inter but he was checked out the instant he decided the entire day would be spent in Rio without napping before the flight. He functioned on basically one hr of sleep. Anyway, you are correct about Air France's ab initio program. There's a reason I specifically left them out.

Sooooo....Virgin's ab initio program won't be bad but Air France's was.

Got it.....
 
Then why don't you share the differences then between the Cathy/Singapore programs and Air France's?

From what I read, much more sim time in cruise phase and different scenarios presented (even before AF447). Arguably, one could say because Cathay and Singapore don't have narrowbodies and are only training cruise/relief pilots whereas AF trains abinitios to go to A320s as FOs, but still. It's the airlines job to train the candidate in all aspects of flight. And, the numbers speak for themselves. In the last decade (2000-2009) Cathay didn't have a single fatal hull loss, Singapore had one fatal loss, and Air France had 3. You can't blame Concord on training, but the YYZ accident (luckily not fatal but a full hull loss) was absolutely the fault of training. AF447 as well. I realize heavily pro-union folks such as yourself are against ab-initio programs, but the industry needs to look at some of the world's safest airlines (Emirates, Cathay, Singapore, and even Malaysia) for what they have done with their abinitio programs, some of which have existed for 3+ decades. If ab-initio has to happen, then the program should be modeled after some of the world's most safest airlines.
 
Back
Top