Where to post checkride experiences?

When was the last time the PTS was updated? It is a broad guide for examination but is it really pertinent for determining a good pilot?

They are updated every few years based on changes in technology and input from the field.

And examiners aren't supposed to ask anything outside of the PTS. Nowhere in a PTS does it say "anything the examiner feels is appropriate for the rating".
 
What????

Someone please tell me this is false.

If it is true please pass along to the DPEs that in the real world there is something known as "a gouge" and an outline of what to expect during a training program.
Yes. This ^
 
And examiners aren't supposed to ask anything outside of the PTS. Nowhere in a PTS does it say "anything the examiner feels is appropriate for the rating".

Actually it says exactly that when you read over the special emphasis areas (the very last one):

"Other areas deemed appropriate to any phase of the
practical test."

Now the intent of this is not for the examiner to go outside of the PTS, but it does open the door to allow them to use "discretion" when conducting any practical test to make sure the applicant is proficient enough to hold the rating sought.

Not all of the tasks in each area of operation have a hard tolerance, such as steep turns (+/- 100 feet, 10kts, etc...). Where you get into the gray areas are during the oral where the PTS states "to determine that the applicant exhibits satisfactory knowledge of the elements related to (specific task)..."
 
Last edited:
Actually it says exactly that when you read over the special emphasis areas (the very last one):

"Other areas deemed appropriate to any phase of the
practical test."
Correct!

Imagine a flight school located within (B)ravo airspace, with a high(er) profile monument nearby. The private oral here will likely focus on the airspace a little more than usual. It's all part of the PTS, but would a student from an untowered field in the middle of Kansas pass this oral and practical? Probably not. The examiner has the authority to vary orals from place to place and student to student. Whatever they deem necessary to the phase of flight.

On another side note, I know of an examiner that would NOT bust students on a private multi checkride for screwing up short field landings. The reason, they were enrolled in the "pro course" and the examiner understood that they would get proficient during instrument and commercial training and that they wouldn't just go buy a multi plane and fly around.
 
It is rumored that ATP flight school got fined or at least frowned on for students "briefing" other students on a check ride they just passed and the other student was about to take.

This was in sacramento when I was at ATP 2 years ago.
I was also at ATP in SAC about 2 years ago and that place seemed a little shady to me.
 
Last edited:
I've never heard of an actual regulation against it...but like I said, it's definitely frowned upon by DPE's.

I will say...when I went to aviator college to finish instrument and commercial, my instructor tried to pay me $20 to "brief" one of his other students after I passed my commercial multi. His other student failed it 3 times. I told him, "3 times?? Then he knows the DPE better than me, why does he need briefed?"

Failed 3 times? With Corcoran? Wow!
 
Failed 3 times? With Corcoran? Wow!
Ya! I was surprised to say the least. Personally, I think if you fail with Corcoran even once then you should probably take up another profession.

But I think he failed his third attempt with McColgan actually.
 
No one fails with McColgan. Not even JFK Jr. Just kidding. (What...too soon?)

I actually really enjoyed my check ride with Corcoran. It was fun, I learned some things, and he was a fair evaluator.
 
Back
Top