Where to post checkride experiences?

JFlighttt

Well-Known Member
As the title speaks, where would I post a checkride experience/gouge; if it is allowed? Interview Experiences?
 
It is rumored that ATP flight school got fined or at least frowned on for students "briefing" other students on a check ride they just passed and the other student was about to take.

This was in sacramento when I was at ATP 2 years ago.
 
I've never heard of an actual regulation against it...but like I said, it's definitely frowned upon by DPE's.

I will say...when I went to aviator college to finish instrument and commercial, my instructor tried to pay me $20 to "brief" one of his other students after I passed my commercial multi. His other student failed it 3 times. I told him, "3 times?? Then he knows the DPE better than me, why does he need briefed?"
 
Haha that's funny.

Yea no reg or anything and plus, hard for the DPE to be able to find out who you are from JC...not like my certificate or medical say "JFlighttt" on any of them LOL.
 
It is rumored that ATP flight school got fined or at least frowned on for students "briefing" other students on a check ride they just passed and the other student was about to take.

This was in sacramento when I was at ATP 2 years ago.
I never heard this when I was there. In fact our examiner would pretty much give away what we were doing. Was this mt?
 
My DPE for my PPL Multi Add on, CMEL, & CSEL (All via ATP in Chicago) is apparently a well known regional ball buster, but she's sharp as a tack. As the standard saying does, she's forgotten more about airplanes then I'll ever learn. That being said, she wanted her rides to be fair, yet to PTS standards. During both my Commercial rides, she had 2 newer CFI's to the location sit in on the oral so they knew EXACTLY what she covered...and people still failed.
 
My DPE for my PPL Multi Add on, CMEL, & CSEL (All via ATP in Chicago) is apparently a well known regional ball buster, but she's sharp as a tack. As the standard saying does, she's forgotten more about airplanes then I'll ever learn. That being said, she wanted her rides to be fair, yet to PTS standards. During both my Commercial rides, she had 2 newer CFI's to the location sit in on the oral so they knew EXACTLY what she covered...and people still failed.
Wasn't Leslie Henninger by any chance was it?
 
Indeed it was Leslie. A lot of people are intimidated by her for some reason...I think she's hilarious. (PS, bring her a diet coke and you score the brownie points ;) )
 
Yes! I have certainly heard good and bad points about her.

My first sign-off was a private going with her. She came in looking quite irritated and made it about a 2-3 hour oral with him.
Apparently he did great according to her!

She definitely is up to the PTS standards, very few exceptions to that, if any. She also does push a lot of smaller things that most DPEs will not push as hard.
 
It is rumored that ATP flight school got fined or at least frowned on for students "briefing" other students on a check ride they just passed and the other student was about to take.

This was in sacramento when I was at ATP 2 years ago.

I've never heard of an actual regulation against it...but like I said, it's definitely frowned upon by DPE's.

I will say...when I went to aviator college to finish instrument and commercial, my instructor tried to pay me $20 to "brief" one of his other students after I passed my commercial multi. His other student failed it 3 times. I told him, "3 times?? Then he knows the DPE better than me, why does he need briefed?"

What????

Someone please tell me this is false.

If it is true please pass along to the DPEs that in the real world there is something known as "a gouge" and an outline of what to expect during a training program.
 
Last edited:
When was the last time the PTS was updated? It is a broad guide for examination but is it really pertinent for determining a good pilot?
 
I've never heard of someone having a problem with it. In fact a good examiner/check airman should brief you ahead of time on exactly what will be done during the checkride. There should be no surprises other than something like when the engine failure or rejected takeoff occurs. Many airlines these days have training departments that publish what the checkride will be like prior to the student even showing up. I think its much more productive training if the person isn't scared or completely surprised when they get something.
 
When was the last time the PTS was updated? It is a broad guide for examination but is it really pertinent for determining a good pilot?

PTS are updated fairly regularly (tho not extensively), Most of the fixed wing ratings have been updated within the last few years, all my book copies are not upto date at this point.

http://www.faa.gov/training_testing/testing/test_standards/

^ FREE PTS EVERYONE ^

But I do agree a checkride is not a great way of determining if a pilot is good or not, just that he/she can meet standards. It would take multiple flights in different conditions to determine the true skill of a pilot, but this isn't feasible as it would take much more time and cost much much more. The PTS is as good as it gets, for now at least.
 
I never heard this when I was there. In fact our examiner would pretty much give away what we were doing. Was this mt?
Not mike troud. The other examiner. Can't remember his name. But he was upset that one student told another exactly when the emergency would be and where they were going to divert. The student also spent 3 hours "coaching" the other student about the oral and what to expect.

Of course a lot of DPEs are not secretive with that stuff and want the students to do good. So I guess it depends on what kind of "gouge" you mean. If you know the PTS then you know everything that should be done on the check ride.

What varies widely from each DPE is the oral and how they approach it. The "hypothetical" questions and what not.

Why do you think the instructor isn't supposed to be in the room for the oral??? Same reason you can't take notes when taking a written. They don't want those "cheat sheets" floating around.
 
Remember that the PTS does state that the examiner will ask about what's in the subject areas to be done AND...the catch...AND whatever the examiner feels like asking that is appropriate for the rating...

That statement there basically throws the PTS under the table.
 
Back
Top