Windy days - flaps anyone?

Nah, I disagree. Power back to just off idle at DH, pitch to follow the glideslope/VASI, and you'll be golden. At least that's the way I remember it, been forever since I flew an ILS.

I must agree with Roger, we did the same at DWC. Granted if you take that to the extreme of lights and down to 100 without slowing down I'd imagine it would be tough. But at 200 feet you're .66 miles (agl/300 = distance in miles on 3 degree glide path) which is ~3500 feet. At 90 knots we are talking ~20 seconds if speed is maintained, which it isn't.

You'll find you have 30+ seconds to slow, stabilize, and land from 200' agl: Break out, chop the power, slow 85, dump flaps, and stabilize at 65. I never had an issue doing that while putting it on the stripes. Though I never tried it from 100 agl. Not sure I could, but looks like I found myself a new experiment.

Oh and we flew it at 90 ground speed. Still no issues dropping on the stripes while often at 100-105 indicated. Try it: VASI to 200 agl @ 90 ground w/10 degrees. See what happens when you chop, dump, stabilize, and land.

Side comment/fun game: This is great to help with management judgement. Fly it at 100 IAS on the VASI with 10 degrees and put it on the thousand foot markers at full stall. The game part of it is when do you chop & dump flaps to make that work perfectly. No slips, no s-turns, and no putting power back in unless it's to go around. A caution to the CFI's though, be sure you have a predetermined bottom line for your go around.
 
Nah, I disagree. Power back to just off idle at DH, pitch to follow the glideslope/VASI, and you'll be golden. At least that's the way I remember it, been forever since I flew an ILS.
Yeah, I was trying to figure out what was wrong with a 90-kt ILS in a 172 also (although I don't personally have much use for flaps during one)
 
I have found that 10 degrees in a 172 does help stabilize the airspeed. The airspeed doesn't acel/decel as quickly with minor slight pitch changes. Not as slippery. That's about the only good reason (operationaly) to have 10 degrees on the 172.
 
http://www.boundvortex.com/ReadArticle.aspx?ArticleID=54

Good old Tgray, for those that remember. A relatively non technical post by his standards.

I've recently conducted extensive research into stability/control for a presentation. Including specific work with flaps and their impact on stability/control. I'll post my findings in the next few days for those interested in the more technical side of this topic. (No math though! :) )
 
Them being scared. If your scared of it, you don't understand it.
Good for you going out and learning something, that while not required will make you a better stick and a far safer pilot.

of the folks who are scared of spins at the CFI level it usually breaks down to 3out of 10 don't understand it, 6 out of 10 their insurance companies would/do have them over a barrel and 1 poor bugger cause his/her student nearly did it to 'em in a pattern and they don't want to fill out paper work if the students kills or hurts themselves. although with a spin hurt themselves maybe overly optimistic.

as much as hate to suggest adding anything to the FARs (they're plenty long enough as is) it might be worth looking at requiring a spin endorsement for a Comm cert. Spins will scare people until you study them AND do them. Sure did for me.
 
90Kts in a 172 for the ILS is perfect. I cant stand people that take 20 minutes to get to DH from the FAF because they are flying the whole way down in a landing flare configuration.

As far as spinning goes, if you own the plane then spin away, but if you're working for a flight school how can you blame them for not teaching them? There is liability involved and it is horrible for the gyros.
 
As far as spinning goes, if you own the plane then spin away, but if you're working for a flight school how can you blame them for not teaching them? There is liability involved and it is horrible for the gyros.
I blame them specifically because they are Schools.
Schools are charges with the responsibility of teaching the students of whatever the chool is about.
Flight Schools are about teaching people who don't know anything about flying, how to fly.

The "How to Fly" subject would include spins and more, if the Flight Schools had not degraded themselves to merely and only teaching the minimum federal government standards.

Flight Schools, as well as each individual Flight Instructor, have the responsibility to provide adequate training machines; an old 150 or something that can be the "spinner", or whatever.

Liability? ...of course there's Liability! We're teaching people to FLY, after all. The liability lies in NOT teaching good pilot skills, which includes responding to spin-inducing situations.

Notice how I said "spin-inducing situations"? That's what I'm really talking about.

As a life-time flight instructor, I know we don't hafta really teach full blown spins- but what we do need to teach is recovering from an 'almost-spin' - where you get over 90 degrees and recover. That's what kills most folks - it isn't really a spin. But it is as close to upside down as most untrained pilots get, and they freeze.

So, yes, I blame the schools who let this happen. Years ago.
 
Nosehair,

I agree with your entire post .

Teaching a 18 year old who thinks he is a invincible top gun can be a volatile situation though. I remember when there was not really a no spin policy at the flight school I work at and during the 100 hours the mechanics would find a lot of evidence from repeated spinning.
 
Even as an aerobatic pilot and someone who teaches spins I am ambiguous about enforced spin training. As it is I have seen CFIs who received poor spin training, don't understand stalls/spins, some even received spin endorsements without actually spinning an airplane. As it is the majority of spin accidents have... a CFI on board. The one group of pilots who must have spin training are involved in most spin accidents.:(
I'm not sure what the solution is to this.
As for flying the approach at 90 kts, go for it. However, IAW the Terminal Procedures, "However, if it is necessary to operate at a speed in excess of the upper limit of the speed range for an aircraft's category, the minimums for the category for that speed shall be used..." Then gives examples, such as a helicopter operating at 130 KIAS must use the CAT C minimums.
My favorite on instrument stage checks is to give the pilot an approach at an airport with CAT B N/A. PTS says you must maintain the desired speed +- 10 KTS. But, if you are conducting the approach in excess of 90 KTS you are a no go. Nine times out of ten the pilot will be consistently in excess of 90 knots- usually between 95-100 knots. Since the approach is not applicable for CAT B they have busted minimums. I even had one pilot where the conversation went like this:
Me: "What speed are we flying the approach."
"100 KIAS".
"What approach category are you at 100 knots?"
"Category B."
"What are the category B minimums?"
"It's N/A for category B."
No change in airspeed.
 
As it is I have seen CFIs who received poor spin training, don't understand stalls/spins, some even received spin endorsements without actually spinning an airplane. As it is the majority of spin accidents have... a CFI on board. The one group of pilots who must have spin training are involved in most spin accidents.:(
I'm not sure what the solution is to this.
Oh, yeah! If there was suddenly a regulation requiring actual spins in pre-solo, or pre-private training, with no Checkrides that require the safe skilled proficient demonstration of these spins, then the slaughter and increased lies in the logbook would continue.

The simple (relatively simple) solution is to require spin recovery demonstration on a CFI checkride.

The actual training of spins stopped (began stopping) when the FAA wrote the regulation allowing the spin training requirement and CFI endorsement to be sufficient evidence of his/her spin proficiency.

So, all the spin proficiency has been lost because, well, no one checked their work. What do you expect?
I don't blame the schools, or instructors, they're only human. They have evoIved to a new mis-understanding of the need to know and be in control of an upside down airplane.

Actually, the chances of getting turned over 90 degrees is much greater than an engine failure.

The FAA dropped the ball (their responsibility) when they stopped doing actual spins on checkrides.
 
Me: "What speed are we flying the approach."
"100 KIAS".
"What approach category are you at 100 knots?"
"Category B."
"What are the category B minimums?"
"It's N/A for category B."
No change in airspeed.

LOL.

Most of mine go like this:

Me: "What speed are we flying the approach?"
"90kts" (Airspeed showing nearly 120)
"Little fast, aren't we?"
No change in airspeed.
 
Oh, yeah! If there was suddenly a regulation requiring actual spins in pre-solo, or pre-private training, with no Checkrides that require the safe skilled proficient demonstration of these spins, then the slaughter and increased lies in the logbook would continue.

The simple (relatively simple) solution is to require spin recovery demonstration on a CFI checkride.

The actual training of spins stopped (began stopping) when the FAA wrote the regulation allowing the spin training requirement and CFI endorsement to be sufficient evidence of his/her spin proficiency.

So, all the spin proficiency has been lost because, well, no one checked their work. What do you expect?
I don't blame the schools, or instructors, they're only human. They have evoIved to a new mis-understanding of the need to know and be in control of an upside down airplane.

Actually, the chances of getting turned over 90 degrees is much greater than an engine failure.

The FAA dropped the ball (their responsibility) when they stopped doing actual spins on checkrides.
I agree with demonstrating proficiency either on the check ride (I think many FAA Inspectors would not enjoy this), or with a designated aerobatic school. I do agree something more is needed. I'm not sure right now what. I think back then there was a knowledge base on spins, but it has been lost.
I do give ALL my students the option of spin training and strongly encourage it.
Funny, I was giving an HP check out yesterday in a 182 to someone who desires to be a CFI in the future (in a 182). He was apparently warned ahead of time by other CFIs that I was a little more "aggressive" in stall demonstrations than was normal as I teach aerobatics.
 
LOL.

Most of mine go like this:

Me: "What speed are we flying the approach?"
"90kts" (Airspeed showing nearly 120)
"Little fast, aren't we?"
No change in airspeed.
Yep. Had that as well. Another memorable one was the instrument student who, after his first lesson, used all 8400' of runway to land a 172. I told him we needed to work on some basics before we started instrument training. He ended up being a very good student and went through commercial MEL with me... he had just been taught very poorly for his private SEL (he actually failed landing on his first go).
 
Isn't the failure that is being addressed here? Candidates for CFI should be going through spin training no matter what school they are training at.
The actual wording is to demonsatrate instructional knowledge of spins. I've often found that the person giving the training maybe has one or two spins more than the student and there is often little if any ground.
 
Yep. Had that as well. Another memorable one was the instrument student who, after his first lesson, used all 8400' of runway to land a 172. I told him we needed to work on some basics before we started instrument training. He ended up being a very good student and went through commercial MEL with me... he had just been taught very poorly for his private SEL (he actually failed landing on his first go).
Yikes...Airspeed control anyone?
 
IMO the pilot should be taught to land with no, partial and full flaps. In whatever wind conditions. Unless there is some limitation, the wind and it's velocity an d direction is irrelevant and strictly a matter of preference. In a 172, the only one I avoid in practice is no flaps because I just don,t personally like the view out the window with the more nose up attitude required to maintain proper final approach speed.

This.


During private training, I teach them to avoid using full flaps in strong winds or at least winds that are at their personal limits. As they gain experience however, they should be able to land in any configuration. This avoiding flaps in the wind stuff is an instructors insurance policy for when the student is out solo.
 
The actual wording is to demonsatrate instructional knowledge of spins. I've often found that the person giving the training maybe has one or two spins more than the student and there is often little if any ground.

Exactly, and probably why it is no longer a requirement. A good thing IMO. Learning spins is a wonderful thing. Learning spins from a guy/gal with an hour spin training is down right dangerous. Not only do you learn very little, but the actual lesson itself is high risk.

I support what the FAA has done. CFI's should encourage students to get spin training from qualified instructors. Not go up and say "here is a spin" when they've done 12 in their career. :rolleyes:
 
Exactly, and probably why it is no longer a requirement. A good thing IMO. Learning spins is a wonderful thing. Learning spins from a guy/gal with an hour spin training is down right dangerous. Not only do you learn very little, but the actual lesson itself is high risk.

I support what the FAA has done. CFI's should encourage students to get spin training from qualified instructors. Not go up and say "here is a spin" when they've done 12 in their career. :rolleyes:
That was Bill Kershner's thoughts. He ran a school that specialized in spin training, wrote flight training and spin books, yet was against further spin requirements. His logic was that requiring more spin training would force pilots to take spin training from instructors who were not qualified to teach spins which would probably result I more stall/spin accidents than would be prevented by the training. Not sure if this would be the case, but it is worth investigating before calling the government action. Often such calls appeal to emotions but the actions taken by the government do more harm overall than good.
 
That was Bill Kershner's thoughts. He ran a school that specialized in spin training, wrote flight training and spin books, yet was against further spin requirements. His logic was that requiring more spin training would force pilots to take spin training from instructors who were not qualified to teach spins which would probably result I more stall/spin accidents than would be prevented by the training. Not sure if this would be the case, but it is worth investigating before calling the government action. Often such calls appeal to emotions but the actions taken by the government do more harm overall than good.
If you're interested, you won't have to go very far in a search to find that the FAA investigated it before removing the spin training requirement that existed years ago. The stated reason for the removal was the number of stall/spin accidents that occurred during training.

It's old enough that it's no longer available from the government publication website, but this is from the 1991 rule revision that re-introduced spin training as a CFI requirement:

==============================
NPRM No. 89-14 included three proposals regarding stall/spin training for pilots and stall/spin training and testing for flight instructors of airplanes and gliders. The spin, a controlled or uncontrolled maneuver or performance in which the glider or airplane descends in a helical path while flying at an angle of attack greater than the angle of maximum lift, was a required training maneuver for pilot certification until 1949. It was deleted from the pilot certification requirements based on the high number of fatal stall and spin accidents, most of which occurred during training. The FAA has since placed greater emphasis on spin avoidance, particularly on training in the avoidance of unintentional stalls or unwanted unusual attitudes. This shift in training requirements resulted in a significant decrease in the number of stall/spin accidents since 1949. NTSB statistics indicate that stall/spin accidents fell from 48 percent of fatal general aviation accidents during the period 1945-48, to 22 percent during 1967-69, and to 12 or 13 percent in the 1970's. The stall/spin proposals in NPRM No. 89-14 constitute an effort to further reduce the already declining incidence of spin-related accidents in general aviation. The amendments contained in this rule will broaden stall and spin awareness training by emphasizing avoidance of unintentional stalls in addition to what is currently the more common procedure of practicing recovery from intentional stalls.

****


Stall awareness training is effective. After the United States dropped the spin training requirement in June 1949 in favor of increased stall training, stall/spin accidents dropped dramatically. Although other factors such as improved stall warning devices undoubtedly contributed to this decrease, several studies indicate that the revised training approach was a main factor in reducing stall/spin accidents. In the 4 year period from 1945 to 1948, stall/spin accidents accounted for 48 percent of all fatal accidents. This proportion dropped to 27 percent from 1965 to 1968. The NTSB conducted a study of the period from 1967 to 1969, and found that stall/spin accidents caused 22 percent of all "fatal occurrences." That study, the Special Study General Aviation Stall/Spin Accidents, 1967 - 1969 (National Transportation Safety Board AAS-72-8, September 13, 1972), examined the 1,261 stall/spin accidents recorded for the period and noted that, while they accounted for only 8 percent of the total number of accidents, they caused 23 percent of the fatalities or serious injuries.
==============================
 
Back
Top