Stop Flying in MOAs

It has already been said, but I feel that knowing when MOAs are hot and the associated altitudes is really the ticket, instead of a blanket ban. The problem is that those GA pilots you are probably talking about, they probably don't know where to find those times (even though it is printed right on the sectional).
---
Sometimes it is really not practical to go around a MOA that is the size of a small state. See and avoid.

----

We have Victor airways through MOAs here.
Some of the Victor airways are hashed so they disappear and no longer exist when the MOA is active, others make no mention of disappearing.
I know the MOA activity here is nothing compared to what is like down south.
 
It has already been said, but I feel that knowing when MOAs are hot and the associated altitudes is really the ticket, instead of a blanket ban. The problem is that those GA pilots you are probably talking about, they probably don't know where to find those times (even though it is printed right on the sectional).
---
Sometimes it is really not practical to go around a MOA that is the size of a small state. See and avoid.

----

I agree. Just knowing the altitude is really key. We normally flew all over the areas covered by the MOA's. You sort of have to around GTR, but the thing is we were always below them. Times help too, but even if they are hot a little GA plane can usually fly under them. That isn't always the case, but as you mentioned, it is worth checking out the sectional. :)
 
:yeahthat:

when i flew GA before i started military flying i was ignorant and didn't really think too much of it.....now, i'd never do it

This is exactly why I started this thread.

I can't figure it out, so mods are cleared hot to edit the thread title to "Stop Flying in MOAs (when hot)."

About knowing the altitudes of MOAs - be vigilant if you're in a corridor type space between the MOA or within a few thousand feet as well. Chances are pretty good that the high volume of military traffic in said MOAs is using the same airspace to transit the area.

Final note: At least talk to someone if you are flying through a hot MOA. If you aren't cleared through it's probably for a good reason. If you are in contact with the controlling agency then they will let me know about you long before my crappy TCAS - wannabe equipment in the T-6 tells me you're a few hundred feet below me at the bottom of a loop...
 
I don't see why you should avoid an MOA that's NOT active. However, if you fly through one which is active, then you're playing with fire.

You may not get burnt but it's not a good idea.

I can only imagine what it's like for a guy training in an F-15 at high speed to have to avoid a slow flying Cessna that's flying around fat, dumb, and happy.
 
I don't see why you should avoid an MOA that's NOT active. However, if you fly through one which is active, then you're playing with fire.

You may not get burnt but it's not a good idea.

I can only imagine what it's like for a guy training in an F-15 at high speed to have to avoid a slow flying Cessna that's flying around fat, dumb, and happy.

And that's exactly the hazard. You've got (generally speaking) the civilian plane cruising through, who probably....if he's vigilantly scanning at all....has limited field of view ahead and either high or low.

You have high speed tactical traffic that....even though they're supposed to be seeing and avoiding too......due to the specific operations (formation maneuvering, air-air combat, etc), their ability to see and avoid other traffic that they're not directly working with, is pretty limited. Combine that with the fact that they're likely maneuvering not only in the hoizontal, but the vertical at high speeds; and as you can see, the risk factors keep going up and up.

I do know that roughly 95% of the time, any GA traffic I did spot while in the MOA was by pure chance due to the fact that I just happened to be looking in that particular piece of sky because the other aircraft I was working with was there.....so I happen to spot the Cessna a mile or two beyond him, or the Piper 1000' or more below. I think it was only once or twice that I actually picked up traffic in the MOA visually because I actually had the time to scan and look for traffic. Myself and those in my flight are busy with what we're doing.....essentially distracted from classic see and avoid, combined with we were single-seat aircraft, and the recipe for disaster was only by chance that we didn't hit the aircraft we happened to see.

I still wonder how many other planes I never did see, and likely didn't see me. When we were operating medium altitude, the ghost-grey paint job of ours blended us into the sky, and we flew too low to con, so someone seeing us was likely by the same happenstance, taking into account their own limitations combined with their degree of attention span, or not.

Hell, when our Hogs were still green camo, at least we made a good contrast to the sky.

Oddly enough, my closest call ever was down in the Tombstone MOA in southern AZ. Working night medium altitude air-ground on NVG. So I already have a very limited field of view, combined with all the aforementioned distractions. Still, in the back of my mind, I'm working at 2230ish, so what's the chance some GA plane is tooling around here in the dark anyway? As I'm checking the target through my NVGs while simulataneously reading the attack clearance to my assigned fighters (I was the FAC plane....single ship, single pilot)......remember, I'm on NVGs, so I have a very limited field of view........all of a sudden, two US Customs Cessna Citation jets in a close-route formation instantly appear in my NVGs crossing from left to right, not more than 200' or less below me......me at their 4'oclock and slightly higher, our angle-off about 60 degrees and both of us in shallow left turns. And I had been varying my altitude, since my block contract with the other flight I was working with was 9000' and below (I had them 10k and above). No radio call, no nothing from the two Citations. Just a near-collision that I never even had the time to react to insofar as maneuvering my jet since it happened so quick; and a quick knock-it-off call for the rest of my flight until they could clear.
 
Before I joined the military, I would have told you to pound sand. Now that I've seen both sides of it, I can tell you that you won't find me flying GA aircraft VFR in an active MOA.

This needs to be written in big, bright shining lights.

That's exactly how I felt as a GA pilot (or, more importantly, how I was *taught* to feel by other GA pilots I flew with an CFIs who instructed me), and how I later felt after flying for Uncle Sam.

It's mostly ignorance that leads to this attitude. Some of it is a kind of false bravado, but most of it is that GA pilots simply don't know what is going on inside those MOAs, nor do they know how much non-participating traffic passing through the MOA can completely destroy the fast-paced training going on in there.

I bet if I took a GA pilot up on a standard T-38 aerobatic or formation sortie and he saw what type of activity was going on in that MOA, he'd feel differently. Most guys don't understand how much altitude and real estate fast jet training uses, and they seem to have this bizarre idea that military jets all have some kind of magic radar that can keep them aware of non-participating traffic.

In one of those MOAs that is "the size of a state", there may be 10 or 15 aircraft that are all participating in a highly planned and carefully orchestrated plan, and one GA airplane flying through the MOA makes all of them have to STOP doing what they're doing. That's a lot of time, money, and opportunity wasted.

I agree that awareness is also the answer. Go find out when MOAs are hot, and by all means when they're cold go through there. When they're hot, though, don't think you're standing up for your GA rights by flying through there. You're really exposing yourself to needless risk and crapping on military training.
 
How would you ever get anywhere in Florida if you didn't?

:D Area 1 and Area 2 in the panhandle area certainly is an example. Not so much fast jet traffic as T-34's and some T-6's. The Texan's operate mainly above 10k with the 34's from the surface to 10k or so. I had quite a few see and avoid situations but being in the mighty, slow but manueverable T-34, not too much of a problem...if seen of course.
 
I know what you mean, I generally have each of my students call up to find out if the MOA near our practice area is "hot" or not. I always feel stupid when I am on a cross country with a student, and an MOA is hot and I have them go either over,under, or around it, and then I hear over the radio with ATC talking with a flight of F16's that there are multiple VFR targets in different quadrants of the MOA flying around. Then my students look over at me as if I am being to anal retentive about flying into hot MOA's, kind of backing me into a corner if you will.
 
Then my students look over at me as if I am being to anal retentive about flying into hot MOA's, kind of backing me into a corner if you will.

That's an opportunity for you to educate your student.

More importantly..."backing me into a corner"? Seriously?

Which one of you is the instructor? Which one of you knows what they are doing and which one does not? Which one of you is in charge of the safe conduct of the flight?

If that student were mine, they'd either heed what I was teaching them -- and respect where it was coming from -- or they'd find a new instructor.
 
Alright bad choice of words there, what I mean to say is I often get the question of well if their flying through active MOA's then why can I not? because it keeps me from flying all the way around sometimes if you cant get over or under, well I tell him it is safer that way(so we don't end up food for an F16), and I get "whatever will do it my way when I get my license", thats what I meant, kind of an indifferent attitude from the student.
 
Alright bad choice of words there, what I mean to say is I often get the question of well if their flying through active MOA's then why can I not? because it keeps me from flying all the way around sometimes if you cant get over or under, well I tell him it is safer that way(so we don't end up food for an F16), and I get "whatever will do it my way when I get my license", thats what I meant, kind of an indifferent attitude from the student.

try telling him the importance of what you are doing...like other people in the thread have said just because it's legal doesn't mean it's safe
 
Alright bad choice of words there, what I mean to say is I often get the question of well if their flying through active MOA's then why can I not? because it keeps me from flying all the way around sometimes if you cant get over or under, well I tell him it is safer that way(so we don't end up food for an F16), and I get "whatever will do it my way when I get my license", thats what I meant, kind of an indifferent attitude from the student.

Here is a picture that you can paint for your student. I'm out there in the MOA, a student on a solo in a jet that is very hard to see from a distance, in a break turn nose low descending down to our training hard deck (10k) at 400+ KIAS, pulling 6-7 G's, looking through a soda straw of vision grunting through the G's and spending most of my time looking over my shoulder at the guy trying to take a shot at me. He does, and while still looking at him, I reverse almost pure vertical, still watching him, and we start weaving vertically up to nearly the top of the MOA (we gain 5-6k almost instantly in this maneuver before we start slowing down). I see another opportunity to get away, and piroutte right back into him and go shooting back down to the deck. Meanwhile I have really never once stopped watching him, and have certainly not scanned the area for traffic. Did I mention that we don't have TCAS or radar? Did I mention that we are covering many square miles a minute and essentially using the entire area of the MOA (both vertically and laterally) to do this? If that doesn't paint a clear picture to him of what goes on, then I guess nothing will.....or he just has a death wish.
 
:D Area 1 and Area 2 in the panhandle area certainly is an example. Not so much fast jet traffic as T-34's and some T-6's. The Texan's operate mainly above 10k with the 34's from the surface to 10k or so. I had quite a few see and avoid situations but being in the mighty, slow but manueverable T-34, not too much of a problem...if seen of course.

Yeah, I have the hardest time trying to plan a route up there. Oh well - I like a free air show from time to time :)
 
Here is a picture that you can paint for your student. I'm out there in the MOA, a student on a solo in a jet that is very hard to see from a distance, in a break turn nose low descending down to our training hard deck (10k) at 400+ KIAS, pulling 6-7 G's, looking through a soda straw of vision grunting through the G's and spending most of my time looking over my shoulder at the guy trying to take a shot at me. He does, and while still looking at him, I reverse almost pure vertical, still watching him, and we start weaving vertically up to nearly the top of the MOA (we gain 5-6k almost instantly in this maneuver before we start slowing down). I see another opportunity to get away, and piroutte right back into him and go shooting back down to the deck. Meanwhile I have really never once stopped watching him, and have certainly not scanned the area for traffic. Did I mention that we don't have TCAS or radar? Did I mention that we are covering many square miles a minute and essentially using the entire area of the MOA (both vertically and laterally) to do this? If that doesn't paint a clear picture to him of what goes on, then I guess nothing will.....or he just has a death wish.
on another note, i miss the ice cream and thai food
 
Tell you're student to look closer.......:D

That's my old stomping grounds, and the airway doesn't run through it. The V66 airway is capped at 13,000. Tombstone C starts at 14,500 (IIRC) because it was the high airbridge between Tombstone's A and B. Tombstone's A and B went down to 500AGL, because those were both A-10 MOAs we used to use often, but C existed in order to cross between the two, OR to do high air-air work and have one continuous MOA, yet STILL allow for aircraft to go IFR out of Douglas to the northeast underneath.

:D I just wanted to make sure you were looking!
 
If you want to go from North Texas to South Texas (Laredo, McAllen) you either have to go through a MOA, or fly many extra miles to the coast or border to find a hole. I am not flying hundreds of miles out my way if the rules say I can go through them. It is just as much your responsibility as mine to avoid each other.

That being said, I typically will also find a way to not fly through a MOA if it is hot and their are not expensive alternatives. When I do fly through a MOA, I am always on flight following. Nowadays, I am almost always on an IFR flight plan so it is pretty much moot. I would cancel and go VFR if it meant tons of extra miles though. Hate me for it. I don't care.
 
Back
Top